$1.1bn wasted on solar power

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
MORE than $1 billion of taxpayers’ money was wasted on subsidies for household solar roof panels that favoured the rich and did little to reduce Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions, a scathing review has found.–Tom Arup, The Age, 11 November 2010

Despite a $535 million loan guarantee from the federal government, Solyndra, a maker of solar panels in the southeast San Francisco Bay Area city of Fremont, will close one of its manufacturing plants, lay off 40 permanent and 150 contract workers, delay expansion plans of a new plant largely financed with the government-guaranteed loan and scale back production capacity more than 50 percent. Despite the hype and tax money, Solyndra seems unable to compete with Chinese manufacturers, whose prices are lower. This is the latest bad news for the company touted by Mr. Schwarzenegger and President Barack Obama as one of the green industry’s supposed shining lights. – Editorial, The Orange County Register, 11 November 2010
Trying to encourage greater use of solar power and competing with Chinese prices are two separate issues. There are plenty of energy wasteful industries going off-shore as well. Until such time as wages in the West (including that of the incredibly greedy CEO’s) show restraint, nothing will change in relation to the burgeoning Chinese economy. The Communist Party in China will continue to run their nation as they see fit, and I doubt very much if returning manufacturing industries to the West is high on their agenda. It’s probably on the bottom.

About the only hope for the West is for China to float their currency, faced by nternational punitive action if they don’t. And if the Chinese workers themselves get fed up with being exploited by their own government. Until then there can only be one continuing result.

We are a very wasteful society, not very far behind the US. In fact we now have, on average, the world’s biggest homes, and probably the world’s biggest waistlines to boot. A home that is twice as big as another requires approximately twice as much energy to build.

If something can be done to reduce the consumption of fossil fuels, well and good. But the policies need more thought before they are rushed into practice. It’s pointless trying to generate home based manufacturing industries of any sort if we know that they are going to run into the brick wall of much lower labour costs overseas.
 
Also as an engineer, what is amazing to me is the amount of low hanging efficiency fruit still out there waiting to be plucked. I was at a NEW industrial facility last week where I say about an 80 gallon resin tank for the water softening system. Upon closer look, this water softener utilized a timer based recharge cycle so it recharged once a week. The system was sized by the number of fixtures in the building, which included showers due to code, but those are virtually never used. The system disposes of 900 gallons of recharge water per week by this setup. The total other water use at the facility consists of 1,000 gallons a week (basically employee restrooms). What a stupid waste of energy, water and salt (which overloaded the septic system). For about $100 more in initial cost they could have controlled the recharge basis by flow meter and programmed hardness so that it only recharged when the resin was saturated. Would have paid for itself in salt in 6 months. Timer based softener recharge systems were obsolete in about 1985.

What’s this got to do with the topic? This was a LEED gold rated facility (prestigious green building certification)! They spent thousands on “green roofs” (grass), rainwater recycling systems for irrigation and a myriad of other foofy things and ignored the basics because it wasn’t on the LEED list. Humans are weird critters.
 
Sorry , his bills ranged from 1600 to 2 thousand.
If one could really Pay for these units with as little as two months utility savings everybody in the country would have one. I suspect something is got lost in translation here because I know of no home solar units in the $5000 range that would generate $1620 in electricity in a given month.
 
If one could really Pay for these units with as little as two months utility savings everybody in the country would have one. I suspect something is got lost in translation here because I know of no home solar units in the $5000 range that would generate $1620 in electricity in a given month.
I think he’s talking annual electric bill. I’d drop dead of heart attack if I got a $1,600 electric bill for ONE month!!!
 
manualman - isn’t it amazing how many systems like this are just running with no body even aware? The de-ionized water system at the “green” plant that I was at also had timer-based brine tank type recharge system. Half the plant was no longer in operation but both systems continued to run, washing countless pounds of salt down the drain. Water waste, salt waste/cost, etc. My concerns fell upon deaf ears.

The fact that was also a green facility (that I worked for) always itched at me. Both from an engineering and just plain common sense perspective. Lots of other wasteful practices. Too many contradictions to mention.
 
MORE than $1 billion of taxpayers’ money was wasted on subsidies for household solar roof panels that favoured the rich and did little to reduce Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions, a scathing review has found.–Tom Arup, The Age, 11 November 2010

Despite a $535 million loan guarantee from the federal government, Solyndra, a maker of solar panels in the southeast San Francisco Bay Area city of Fremont, will close one of its manufacturing plants, lay off 40 permanent and 150 contract workers, delay expansion plans of a new plant largely financed with the government-guaranteed loan and scale back production capacity more than 50 percent. Despite the hype and tax money, Solyndra seems unable to compete with Chinese manufacturers, whose prices are lower. This is the latest bad news for the company touted by Mr. Schwarzenegger and President Barack Obama as one of the green industry’s supposed shining lights. – Editorial, The Orange County Register, 11 November 2010
Unfortunately the search for sustainable living is bound to have some fits and starts. In truth $1B is a very small % of the annual US budget and well worth the money to prove or disprove potential solutions to the day’s problems.
 
Honestly I wouldn’t call an investment in solar technology a waste. True it isn’t much benefit at the moment, but the more money that goes into the market the better the technology will get. A lot of research is being done on this stuff now because the market is starting to become somewhat lucrative and in 20 years this stuff could really pay off. Better our tax dollars go to budding industries with promise then bailing out companies because they are “Too big to fail”
 
I still remember a field trip me and my class took in elementary school. I don’t remember where we went but this was probably 20 years or more ago. Anyway, I do remember one thing that we saw. This building was supposedly energy efficient. Well, they kept it heated by letting sunlight in through huge windows. When it became cloudy or if they needed to cool the place off, big vacuum things filled the inside of the windows with Styrofoam beads or something to prevent light from coming through. This had the effect of keeping the warm air from escaping in the winter and it also kept warm air out in the summer. It was pretty interesting at the time but I really have no idea just how much they saved in energy costs or anything.
 
Who wants an entire garage full of batteries and a yard covered in panels? Again I’m illustrating an application to drive a large load…perhaps even an entire house. Such an example is not affordable by the average person. Most solar “systems” pick up load from intermittent loads, and can shed usage from the grid at times. They do save customers some money on their utility bill.
My solar system for the hot water uses no batteries. When ever the sun is shinning. (about 90% of the time here) Its heats the water. I have a house hold of seven. we get our two showers a day. (there of the seven are teenage girls. So that’s some idea of how much hot water gets used lol). On over cast days, we click a switch and it draws off the main grid. But those times are few and far between. Our annual bill, has dropped by 30 %. As for the old man down the roads setup. I’ll have to ask him about his battery set up. The solar panels do not take up that much space. About 6 x 8/9 feet squared. Could be more, but not much. I’ll need to check that out as well. There are four adults living in that house.He has had to draw off of the main grid, a few times. I’m not saying the solar technology we have today, will see us 100% free of the grid. But there is a lot of savings to be made. If… You live in the right climate.
 
If one could really Pay for these units with as little as two months utility savings everybody in the country would have one. I suspect something is got lost in translation here because I know of no home solar units in the $5000 range that would generate $1620 in electricity in a given month.
LOl yeah. It is a annual bill. If that was our quarterly bill, I’ll be doing all my cooking,heating etc, around a camp fire in the back yard.
 
“My solar system for the hot water uses no batteries”

Ah, ok on hot water only. I’m familiar with that kind of system too, in those residential applications they can work well to offset hot water heating expenses. I’m assuming there is an insulated storage tank, etc.

Solar panels to generate electricity is another application, but the dynamics are different. Hot water usage is intermittent, whereas electrical usage is constant. It is the solar electric generation that gets over-played.

"A lot of research is being done on this stuff now because the market is starting to become somewhat lucrative and in 20 years this stuff could really pay off. Better our tax dollars go to budding industries with promise then bailing out companies because they are “Too big to fail” "

I used to think so also. Truly I had fun in the industry. It’s fascinating to work on new technologies, being on the cutting edge. But it will be more than 20 yrs I’m afraid. We’ll still be using oil well beyond that point too.

There needs to be “bridge” technologies, things that transition from fossil fuels to “x”. I worked in the fuel cell industry, which uses hydrogen. It makes electricity (DC) much like a perpetual battery. But that technology is still decades away from being viable. But what needs to be done is to bring the cost of H2 down. Some automakers have built prototypes to actually BURN the H2, in a modified IC (internal combustion) engine. This is a great idea in my opinion. You take a established working platform and modifiy it slightly (somewhat similar to IC’s that burn propane or LNG). Creating the refueling infrastructure is where the capital investments will be. BUt once there are refueling capabilities, and H2 production costs reduced, you have the platform for a good fuel alternative. Then that will make technologies such as fuel cells a good investement again. Perhaps that generation will carry that past the goal posts this time.

But honestly I won’t see it. If God blesses me I have perhaps 20-25 yrs left to work, we’ll still be dependant on fossil fuels and similar power generation. But maybe my grandkids will.
 
Actually I had some hope that we might see financially viable grid tied solar for home use fairly soon. You don’t think so?

I had heard that some of the shingle companies were working on integrating solar into their roofing products. Seems like if the installation occurred simultaneously (new construction or a re-roofing needed anyways) with roofing the install cost would come down. Seems like I read that they thought they were just a few years out from $1/watt output at retail cost level.

My house would be great for that, with a large roof expanse angled due south and no shade on it. My peak use would still draw from the grid, but the beauty of a tied solar system is that the meter essentially flows backwards during the day when I’m at work and the panels are feeding juice back into the grid. Instantaneous generation shortages become a moot point if the net monthly average use is zero, or at least much lower (since bills come monthly). You don’t see that being a reality any time soon?
 
Engineering and science are always moving forward, but perhaps not as fast as people want.

It will take a lot of solar panels (assuming in an optimum solar location) to “run a house” so to speak. Shedding load is one thing, but in order to pick up hard inductive loads like air conditioning would take more active area of solar panels than most people have property for. That (a/c) is one of the hardest electrical loads, and most people do not want to live without.

But again things are improving. I’ve seen great improvments in the area of electronics for example; better power handling devices (MOSFETS, IGBT’s, etc) that have made inverters/power conversion more efficent. 20 yrs ago 85% was the best, now we can get at least 90%, maybe a few ticks more. That is a big deal when it comes to PFC and hard loads.

Personally I think energy storage (batteries) technology is going to have to improve if any of these “alternatives” are to succeed. Most all of them (solar, wind, fuel cells, etc) require batteries to support load either at peaks, or during down times (no sun, no wind, etc). Most systems currently are limited by their battery storage. That technology needs to move simultaneously if any of the “green” altenatives are to be used.
 
But grid tied solar arrays don’t NEED to be sized for peak loads. The idea isn’t to size for peak demand, but AVERAGE demand on a monthly basis. A certain amount of centralized nuclear base generating capacity, a regional electrical grid and some fast responding gas peaking plants to cover peak days and shady days (i.e. most days they are big paperweights) would seem to offer a very flexible and efficient system.

I’m with you that the home solar off-grid technology is not really viable for US lifestyles. But tied into the grid opens a whole other universe.

In my area, the electric companies are begging people to sign up for centralling coordinated AC management. Even on the hottest day, most AC systems don’t run constantly. When thier cycling is random, it’s possible that upt to 80% of the compressors could be running in one 15 minute interval and as low as 30% of them in another 15 minute interval. That makes things tough on the power producers. They want the ability to centrally control AC starts to even out power demand and avoid peak demands that strain the grid. Cool idea, but people have been slow to trust them. Folks worry that the powerCo will simply turn their AC OFF when it gets dicey on hot days, and don’t want that.
 
That’s true, solar will not handle peaks. It’s true for most of all the current (sorry for the pun!) alternatives (solar, wind, fuel cells, etc). Peaks tend to lean hard on the system batteries. Solar can’t ramp up so usually the grid ties are switched in. Fuel cells try to “ramp up” and during that period the grid takes over, then are synched back to the grid. We always designed for the ever-reliable grid.

I know that most commercial AC systems (rooftops) run constantly in the summers. Perhaps residential units operate more efficient (smaller structure, better insulated, less opening of doors, etc). But rooftop units of most anything else but residential is a massive load in summer.

At the “green” co I worked for, we participated in a NYS “energy reduction” program, where if notified, we would voluntarily shed load in order to help keep demand down in the grid. In terms of techy, it was a fun project to be involved in. Instrumenting the switchgear for 3 bldgs and understanding the load profiles was fun, and educational. We had lab systems, production facility, machine shop, and offices. Lots of high draw stuff in labs (electric heaters, pumps, etc), MFG had similar, lighting loads thruout the plant…but the A/C load was the absolute biggest.

Drafting and starting this project occured in the winter (cool) months of course. Predictably the “green” folks all thought it was a fantastic idea. Getting “paid” (really just more state subsidies…not real “money”) for reducing demand and helping the environment, etc, etc. But when summer arrived…and this past summer was blistering even for us Yankees…reality was harder to accept.

I think the Fed limit for A/C is something like 78degF, but like most facilities we all “cheat” and because of personnel complaints it’s most always lower (73 - 75 depening on complaints, sometimes lower). Also predictable, the biggest complaints come from executives pushing the green agenda the most…but I digress. Just keeping the entire 3 bldgs systems at 78 was a hard sell…even to the greenies.

But the best was when we actually did a “drill” before the summer season. We needed to know just exactly what we could shed during a real event, and of course we got “paid” for this too. Taking down processes (MFG, lab, etc) revealed little in terms of energy usage, it was important, but had the most impact in terms of company productivity. A facility paying employees but not actually producing anything was apparent. Did the subsidy make up for the lost revenue…of course not. The “real” load shedding events truly increased the discomfort level…nobody really cares about money savings or being green in the summer…they just want to be comfortable.

I realize that “peak” load shedding is not a regular occurence. It is not something the grid or any system experiences often.But what I’m trying to get at with the long dissertation is that our energy policies are often unrealistic. The answer is not to turn off stuff, but to seriously look at increasing production. Conservation and increasing efficiency are also important to work on in a parallel path. But there is a bottom limit that we, as a society are willing to accept. It’s counterintuitive to shut down MFG and productive activity, we as a nation should be thinking in terms of productivity. If the answer is to shut down productive activities and just hang out because we don’t have enough power, then I’m afraid that’s a lazy man’s philosophy. Of course if you throw around gov’t subsidies to in essence pay people to sit around (which truly never covers the cost) then that is a poor plan. But people like it, it’s called green and sustainable. These are the buzzwords that are part of our strategies now.

Perhaps it’s more of a psychological effort (rather than science or engineering) to get people back to reality, that we need to make an effort to increase power production. Or…we regress and do with less in the interest of using less energy. In a time of terrible unemployment…one should see the potential. Improving the grid, improving and building more electrical production facilities (power plants). Drilling for natural resources here too. There will need to be a “bridge” effort in parallel with whatever “green” technologies (solar, etc) to keep the US productive. I know it sounds counter-intuitive to extract “old fashioned” energy while chasing new alternatives, but the chasm is still too great to adopt a “all green or nothing” attitude.
 
If you install a solar panel in your house, you are tapping into this massive source of free energy, and slashing your fuel bills. There are also great environmental benefits to solar energy, as it produces no pollution.
Florida solar panels
 
MORE than $1 billion of taxpayers’ money was wasted on subsidies for household solar roof panels that favoured the rich and did little to reduce Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions, a scathing review has found.
There seem to be two points in that story.

One is that rooftop solar units are not a cost effective way for a government to lower its country’s greenhouse emissions. I don’t think that is particularly surprising, considering that rooftop units are not necessarily situated in high sunshine locations and are not necessarily angled for optimum solar collection. Solar is most effective in a location with high amount of sunshine (say, a desert) and when the solar collectors can be angled, and then pivot, for maximum energy collection.

The second point is that Chinese industry ate the lunch of the Australian solar industry. Perhaps this is not surprising, either. China seems to be doing that in many industries.
Despite a $535 million loan guarantee from the federal government, Solyndra, a maker of solar panels in the southeast San Francisco Bay Area city of Fremont, will close one of its manufacturing plants, lay off 40 permanent and 150 contract workers
Again, it seems a case of Chinese industry undercutting domestic industry. Its a problem which the US, as well as Australia faces, and not just in solar energy panels.

I’m not sure what the solution is, but subsidizing an industry which is fundamentally uncompetitive seems misguided. I think both Australian and American governments assumed that China would not be able to ramp up production with the same level of technological sophistication. And perhaps they were right in that assumption. However, they seem to have forgotten the fate of Betamax.

Betamax, as oldtimers might remember, was a videotape standard developed by Sony. It was a superior technology, providing better image quality, compared to the videotape standard of VHS. For a few years, Betamax machines and videotapes were marketed in competition with those using VHS. However, the significantly cheaper VHS eventually won the competition for market domination.

The lesson of Betamax: superior technology sometimes is an economic loser to cheaper technology. Solyndra seems to be another example of that.
 
Gilliam: Looks as if the rich lost too. We will never be able to compete when a country pays its employees much less than American workers are paid.We’ll compete only when countries like China subscribe to fair labor practices.If its employee’s were paid fairly instead of profits geing to the corporation or the state we could level the playing field.As states (countries) reap more of the profits they become more powerful and build and purchase more military goods.
 
Gilliam: Looks as if the rich lost too. We will never be able to compete when a country pays its employees much less than American workers are paid.We’ll compete only when countries like China subscribe to fair labor practices.If its employee’s were paid fairly instead of profits geing to the corporation or the state we could level the playing field.As states (countries) reap more of the profits they become more powerful and build and purchase more military goods.
Import tax.

China taxes our exports-into their Country.

God Bless you.
+Jesus, I Trust In You!
Love, Dawn
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top