According to Islam, there were more than 125000 Prophets.

  • Thread starter Thread starter wwolverine
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

wwolverine

Guest
If there were 125000 Prophets sent by Allah, than why only names of those who are mentioned in Holy Bible?

If so many Prophets were sent by Allah, than why do Muslims only consider Jews, and Christians as people of the book? What about all other people?

If all the prophets were sent all over the world, than why only Jewish and Christian woman dont have to convert to marry a muslim man, and all others have to first become muslims and than marry?
 
QUOTE=wwolverine;5696973]If there were 125000 Prophets sent by Allah, than why only names of those who are mentioned in Holy Bible?
The 124,000 prophets of islam are not named but only about 25 of them are. However, to islam Adam was a prophet whereas in Jewish & Christian, Adam is not a prophet.

As as as the other 123975 prophets of islam, they are not named nor do they know who they are.

Here is something from islam on line:

List of the Prophets’ Names

Question
As-Salamu `Alaykum. I have been wondering about this question for a long time.
I have heard that the number of Prophets is 124,000.
Where does that number come from and also are there any Prophets we believe in who are not mentioned in the Qur’an?
Where can I get a complete list of the names of all Prophets?
Answer
… ~ snip ~ …
However, the Qur’an did not give us the names and stories of all the Messengers and Prophets who were sent by Allah to various nations and groups.
We have only 25 Prophets and Messengers who are mentioned in the Qur’an by name.
About other Prophets and Messengers Allah Almighty says, “And messengers We have mentioned unto thee before and messengers We have not mentioned unto thee …” (An-Nisaa’: 164)
… ~ snip ~ …
In his Musnad, Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal has stated that Allah sent 124, 000 Prophets, and from among them 315 were Messengers.
It seems that on the basis of what Imam Ahmad mentioned in his Musnad, we have this number circulated in Islamic literature.
However, there is no list of names of all the Prophets and Messengers available.
… ~ snip ~ …
Source link provide for further reading:
If so many Prophets were sent by Allah, than why do Muslims only consider Jews, and Christians as people of the book? What about all other people?
🤷
If all the prophets were sent all over the world, than why only Jewish and Christian woman dont have to convert to marry a muslim man, and all others have to first become muslims and than marry?
Don’t quite understand.

A Jewish/Christian women who is to marry a muslim man must convert to islam, unless the guy is not religious and does not care about faith. That’s how I understand it.

Perhaps our muslim posters can help better with this thread.
 
If there were 125000 Prophets sent by Allah, than why only names of those who are mentioned in Holy Bible?
in the Bible, especially in the Old Testament, the lives of the prophets were gravely distorted. Lies were told about them to such an extent that they were no longer examples of righteousness but examples of corruption!

For example, Prophet Lot is portrayed as having become drunk with his daughters and committing incest with them! Prophet David is portrayed as lusting after a man’s wife, committing adultery with her and sending her husband off to the front lines of the battle to be killed! As for Prophet Solomon, he is portrayed as worshipping idols in his old age!!!
If so many Prophets were sent by Allah, than why do Muslims only consider Jews, and Christians as people of the book? What about all other people?
because we believe that jews and chrristians received scriptures which were revealed to them by God before the time of Muhammad, most notably . The generally accepted interpretation is that the pre-Islamic revealed texts are the Tawrat, Zabur and the Injil. They are roughly equivalent to the Jewish Torah, the Book of Psalms, and the Injeel respectively.
If all the prophets were sent all over the world, than why only Jewish and Christian woman dont have to convert to marry a muslim man, and all others have to first become muslims and than marry?
i’m not sure if your bible talked about this issue !!! , i hope if you can help me
 
A Jewish/Christian women who is to marry a muslim man must convert to islam, unless the guy is not religious and does not care about faith. That’s how I understand it.

Perhaps our muslim posters can help better with this thread.
no it’s okey for christian women to keep her religion while she marry to muslm

i think you misunderstand the qustion

he asking about why muslim women can’t marry nonmuslim in islam , while in christianity it’s okey for women to marry from other faiths
 
i’m not sure if your bible talked about this issue !!! , i hope if you can help me
I’d be happy too. 😉
in the Bible, especially in the Old Testament, the lives of the prophets were gravely distorted. Lies were told about them to such an extent that they were no longer examples of righteousness but examples of corruption!
I’m sorry, but there is no evidence of this. Any where. Not until the coming of Muslim apologetics does any one even conceive of this notion. No one offers anything different in rabbinical tradition, unwritten Jewish tradition, as well as the apostles of Christ (who I must remind everyone, once again, never accused the Jews of tarnishing scripture).
For example, Prophet Lot is portrayed as having become drunk with his daughters and committing incest with them! Prophet David is portrayed as lusting after a man’s wife, committing adultery with her and sending her husband off to the front lines of the battle to be killed! As for Prophet Solomon, he is portrayed as worshipping idols in his old age!!!
None of those men are, or ever were, prophets. Lot was merely family to Abraham, whereas David and Solomon were kings. The Bible is consistent in differentiating between prophets, judges, kings, etc. I think this is why it is often difficult to discuss Biblical passages or stories with Muslims, because the Muslim (through no personal fault of their own) comes to the Bible with preconceived notions implanted in them by the Koran; namely the confusion as to regards of who a “prophet” is.

In regards to flawed men in the service of God, such as David (who later repented, by the way), it is true that they had flaws. The fact is, we all have flaws. I understand that it is a Muslim belief that all prophets were in the perfect relationship with God and were spiritual “supermen,” but this is far from the case. The prophets, kings and judges were all normal individuals like us. Yes, they were spiritually and theologically sound, but that doesn’t mean they did not have struggles. Even Elijah, one of the greatest of the prophets, at one point felt that he was the last faithful man in all of Israel (1 Kings 19).

For evidence of these struggles, read the Psalms, many of which were written by David himself: they are full of times when the faithful person feels a lack of faith, or feels that God has completely isolated Himself from the people. These are prayers for the faithful at such times. They are meant to give strength. In fact, they are evidence of holy men feeling, at times, temptation and despair.

And thank God for it, for it is far more fitting and commendable that God would allow common men with imperfections to do His bidding. This means that God can even use us to be tools for His will. This is what is so beautiful about moments in the Bible such as where Isaiah, coming in the presence of the Lord, immediately said, “Woe is me, for I am undone! Because I am a man of unclean lips” (Isaiah 6:5), or the moment where St. Peter witnesses the miracle of the fishnets and immediately says to Christ, “Depart from me, for I am a sinful man, O Lord!” (Luke 5:8). God uses us for His love despite our sins, and loves us despite our occasional lack of faith. The prophets are examples of this that remind us that we are never really alone. If they were 100% perfect individuals, they would be no source of inspiration.
 
in the Bible, especially in the Old Testament, the lives of the prophets were gravely distorted. Lies were told about them to such an extent that they were no longer examples of righteousness but examples of corruption!

For example, Prophet Lot is portrayed as having become drunk with his daughters and committing incest with them! Prophet David is portrayed as lusting after a man’s wife, committing adultery with her and sending her husband off to the front lines of the battle to be killed! As for Prophet Solomon, he is portrayed as worshipping idols in his old age!!!

YOu have to read and understand the story from the bible by urself. Lot has chosen not to
stick with Abraham, nor did he chose the land in Canaan that God had promised Abraham, but he chose to live with the perverts and all the wicked man in Sodom Gomorrah. He is a potrait of a man of worrying about the sustenance of himself with his own strength and his environment. He is a potrait of different character of Abraham who chose to stay faithful to God where as Lot lived in a city where business flourished from the wickedness of its people. U have to see the contrast of this, the Jews really understand that Lot is not prophet!

As for David, he had already been chastised by God. Is it not
a beautiful account that God had taken people from all walks of life with their flaw and their own tendency of sinning (being a king with super power, he had shown a classical example of how this position could make people misused the power) to still taket part in God’s plan and salvation because as Jesus said: only sick people needs medication. we are all sinners, we need examples how God reconcile with sinners.

As for Solomon, he had married so many wives even from the idol worshippers, he was led astray by them. What can’t be expected in such situation. What u have to learn is that when God is not the priority in ur life again, the kingdom became divided and broken to pieces.
It’s part of the history of the Jew, why do u complain about it?u want to rewrite their history?

because we believe that jews and chrristians received scriptures which were revealed to them by God before the time of Muhammad, most notably . The generally accepted histinterpretation is that the pre-Islamic revealed texts are the Tawrat, Zabur and the Injil. They are roughly equivalent to the Jewish Torah, the Book of Psalms, and the Injeel respectively.

i’m not sure if your bible talked about this issue !!! , i hope if you can help me

We do have this issue in our bible.
Read the letter from Paul; he addressed people who married non christian to stay in the marriage so that the non christian would be sanctified by the marriage.
 
i’m not in the argument to proof which stories is the correct , i just answering the question from muslims prespective why our quran talked about prophets of the bible

whether you believe quran or not it isn’t my case actually in this subject
We do have this issue in our bible.
Read the letter from Paul; he addressed people who married non christian to stay in the marriage so that the non christian would be sanctified by the marriage.
what about teaching of jesus ?
actually the question are forwarded to muslims as they believe that jesus and mosas are prophets from the same God of mohammed , then why these prophets didn’t prohibit women to marry from another religions while mohammed (pbuh) did

my question was very clear , did the these prophets mentioned such issue in thier teaching in first place , because if it wasn’t mentioned , then the question not valid
 
i’m not in the argument to proof which stories is the correct , i just answering the question from muslims prespective why our quran talked about prophets of the bible

whether you believe quran or not it isn’t my case actually in this subject

then we havo to see the logic and choose the correct one right?especially the one that holds the history that is part of themselves and history that doesn’t polish the dirt but exposed the truth eventhough it seems humiliating. would u deliberately let urself fooled by false teachings for the sake of pride and identity?

what about teaching of jesus ?
actually the question are forwarded to muslims as they believe that jesus and mosas are prophets from the same God of mohammed , then why these prophets didn’t prohibit women to marry from another religions while mohammed (pbuh) did

Just now u just mentioned about the bible…and now u’re not satisfied? Why…can’t u accept the truth? is it hard for u to accept that the bible is more accurate in addressing this matter. The bible see through the matter of what men and women are capable . Not like ur Koran which was much-much influenced by culture

my question was very clear , did the these prophets mentioned such issue in thier teaching in first place , because if it wasn’t mentioned , then the question not valid

It’s clear that Muhammad had no knowledge of the real truth!/QUOTE]
 
… ~ snip ~ …

For example, Prophet Lot

… ~ snip ~ …
Elwill, I know you received a reply regarding your post, but I would like to send this link your way for review and understanding of Jewish Prophets.

jewfaq.org/prophet.htm

I know in islam Lot (et al) are classified as Prophets, but not according to Jewish scripture and history which as you know is at least 2000 years prior to islam.
 
actually the question are forwarded to muslims as they believe that jesus and mosas are prophets from the same God of mohammed , then why these prophets didn’t prohibit women to marry from another religions while mohammed (pbuh) did
Actually, Moses did, or at least he passed down a law from God that did.

“When the LORD your God brings you into the land which you go to possess, and has cast out many nations before you, the Hittites and the Girgashites and the Amorites and the Canaanites and the Perizzites and the Hivites and the Jebusites…You shall make no covenant with them nor show mercy to them. Nor shall you make marriages with them. You shall not give your daughter to their son, nor take their daughter for your son.” [Deuteronomy 7:1-3; emphasis mine]

Of course this was back when salvation was solely of the Jews, but when Christ came and instituted the Great Commission to make disciples of all nations, it was no longer necessary to restrict marriage within a select people.
 
Actually, Moses did, or at least he passed down a law from God that did.

“When the LORD your God brings you into the land which you go to possess, and has cast out many nations before you, the Hittites and the Girgashites and the Amorites and the Canaanites and the Perizzites and the Hivites and the Jebusites…You shall make no covenant with them nor show mercy to them. Nor shall you make marriages with them. You shall not give your daughter to their son, nor take their daughter for your son.” [Deuteronomy 7:1-3; emphasis mine]

Of course this was back when salvation was solely of the Jews, but when Christ came and instituted the Great Commission to make disciples of all nations, it was no longer necessary to restrict marriage within a select people.
thank you B.W

actually in islam i think it’s okey to marry from people of the book only , it’s not allowed for exanple to marry pagans or athiests

so what was the religion of the Hittites and the Girgashites and the Amorites and the Canaanites and the Perizzites and the Hivites and the Jebusites ? did they worshiped God in the heavin ?
 
Elwill, I know you received a reply regarding your post, but I would like to send this link your way for review and understanding of Jewish Prophets.

jewfaq.org/prophet.htm

I know in islam Lot (et al) are classified as Prophets, but not according to Jewish scripture and history which as you know is at least 2000 years prior to islam.
thank you for the link

anyway , i have no problem if you didn’t consider him prophet , and i hope if you have no problem either if i believed he was 🙂
 
thank you for the link

anyway , i have no problem if you didn’t consider him prophet , and i hope if you have no problem either if i believed he was 🙂
Hi elwill,

You believe he (Lot) was a prophet because he is classified as such in islam.

Once again the question needs to be asked.

Why would God do this?

Lot was not His prophet under Judaism, why would God deceive 2000 years of Biblical books and all of the sudden, under islam Lot is a prophet?
 
Hi elwill,

You believe he (Lot) was a prophet because he is classified as such in islam.

Once again the question needs to be asked.

Why would God do this?

Lot was not His prophet under Judaism, why would God deceive 2000 years of Biblical books and all of the sudden, under islam Lot is a prophet?
well , it’s kind of faith for me
i believe he was a prophet because my scipture said so
you believe he wasn’t becuse your scipture was silent about his nature
whither he was prohet or not , what is the benefits for you or for me ?

by the way , do you have any proofs from your bible that he wasn’t prophet ?
because i think he was prophet and not normal man from the story of the bible either

the story of lot in the bible have no contradictions with beliefs of muslims about him to be prophet , why you insist he wasn’t ?
 
well , it’s kind of faith for me
i believe he was a prophet because my scipture said so
you believe he wasn’t becuse your scipture was silent about his nature
whither he was prohet or not , what is the benefits for you or for me ?

by the way , do you have any proofs from your bible that he wasn’t prophet ?
because i think he was prophet and not normal man from the story of the bible either

the story of lot in the bible have no contradictions with beliefs of muslims about him to be prophet , why you insist he wasn’t ?
Your scripture also says the Trinity is God, Jesus, and Mary. Which is not true.

Do you see where we’re going with this?
 
QUOTE=elwill;5701917]well , it’s kind of faith for me
Yes, under islam which is your faith Lot is classifed as a prophet, therefore that is what you believe.
i believe he was a prophet because my scipture said so
Yes, indeed, but your scripture was written 2000+ years after Lot’s time. Why would God do this?
you believe he wasn’t becuse your scipture was silent about his nature
Elwill, you are missing the point. It is under Judaism that Lot was not a prophet and was carried in that manner under Christianity since we use the 5 Books of Moses.
whither he was prohet or not , what is the benefits for you or for me ?
:confused:

I don’t get your inquiry.
by the way , do you have any proofs from your bible that he wasn’t prophet ?
For the Love of God!!!

In Genesis, Lot is never classified as a prophet of God from.

He was only Abrahams nephew.
because i think he was prophet and not normal man from the story of the bible either
How is that? :confused:
the story of lot in the bible have no contradictions with beliefs of muslims about him to be prophet , why you insist he wasn’t ?
I’m sorry my dear, I know English is not your first lauguage, but I’m having a difficult time understanding your question. :confused:
 
Your scripture also says the Trinity is God, Jesus, and Mary. Which is not true.

Do you see where we’re going with this?
no muslims believe that quran said so , it’s the interpretation of nonmuslims , not muslims themselfs , and i think we discussed this issue in another thread
 
Yes, indeed, but your scripture was written 2000+ years after Lot’s time. Why would God do this?
do what ?
quran didn’t mentioned lot in quran to tell us he was prophet then full stop .
that’s why i feel that your questions not worth for the discussion

Thus, the Qur’an relayed the basic message of all prophets, in the most simple and clear terms: Worship God alone and do not worship false gods. It should also be noted that the Qur’an only mentions the key points of the lives of the prophets, wherein there are moral lessons to be learned. So their stories in the holy Qur’an focus on the spiritual message and do not get bogged down with unnecessary details.
Elwill, you are missing the point. It is under Judaism that Lot was not a prophet and was carried in that manner under Christianity since we use the 5 Books of Moses.
i have no problem with that , you can consider him just rightious man
I don’t get your inquiry.
i jsut can’t understand the benefits from this discussion : whiher he was prophet or rightious man
For the Love of God!!!
In Genesis, Lot is never classified as a prophet of God from.
He was only Abrahams nephew.
more details are missing
he was Abrahams nephew and he was prophet either according to islam
 
do what ?
quran didn’t mentioned lot in quran to tell us he was prophet then full stop .
that’s why i feel that your questions not worth for the discussion

… ~ snip ~ …
I hope I’m reading your statement right. This is what I understand of what you wrote above.

The koran **does not **say that Lot (Lut) is a prophet, is that correct?

And BTW ~ the topic of discussion based on the thread header is about islam and prophets.

If you do not wish to engage in discussion well then, it’s your prerogative.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top