Adam and Eve

  • Thread starter Thread starter brierpatch1974
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi hecd2,

The Church speaks with authority from God. God created the universe and humans. This is not like the commonly held understanding that the earth was at the center of the solar system or universe. That was not Church doctrine. Here we are talking about a key doctrine of the faith and I think it is the category of teaching that is unchangeable and cannot be in error. If so, differing claims are incorrect.

I trust what the Church teaches regardless, however even from a purely scientific perspective:
The article I linked to clearly indicates that a previous assertion that has been made regarding a number of humans in history was unreliable and that other factors must be considered. This seems to show that these “conclusions” are shaky/debatable and this is a work in progress. Even if one claim is now 10,000 what makes this any more reliable? If scientists can go from 100,000 to 10,000 then they can go from 10,000 to 2. They are heading in the right direction. 🙂 Alleles are codes. Codes can form from many combinations of things in ways that make it impossible to determine the original state. In software engineering this is called “information loss”. For example if you receive the number 16 in binary and are told that this was formed from two factors, you cannot say definitively what the factors were. They may have been 4 x 4, 8 x 2 or 16 x 1. I am not a geneticist (I am a software engineer with a degree in electrical engineering) but perhaps this or similar principals could apply to genetic codes.
40.png
Alec:
Meanwhile, a huge body of work on genetic information covering mitochondrial DNA, the NRY of the Y-chromosome, the X-chromosome, various autosomal genes, various tracts on noncoding autosomal DNA, ALU-insertions, linkage disequilibrium, and microsatellites all agrees that the effective population size in the lineage leading to extant humans was at least 10,000
Again even from a purely scientific prespective I think this may be just one current theory among others.
 
Hi hecd2,

The Church speaks with authority from God. God created the universe and humans. This is not like the commonly held understanding that the earth was at the center of the solar system or universe. That was not Church doctrine.
Really? That’s not what history records.
Here we are talking about a key doctrine of the faith and I think it is the category of teaching that is unchangeable and cannot be in error. If so, differing claims are incorrect.
Not according to most people. The fact that it is a key doctrine of the faith compels a more desperate defence in traditionalists (I note that there are catholic theologians who are quite content to accept that there never were a literal Adam and Eve), but scientists will proclaim what they find regardless of whose sacred ideas they contradict. If you are determined to stick with a literal Adam and Eve, you are on a certain loser.
I trust what the Church teaches regardless, however even from a purely scientific perspective:
Good for you. However, the facts do not support the assertion that there ever was a literal Adam and Eve and I will go with the facts ahead of magical thinking every time.
The article I linked to clearly indicates that a previous assertion that has been made regarding a number of humans in history was unreliable and that other factors must be considered. This seems to show that these “conclusions” are shaky/debatable and this is a work in progress. Even if one claim is now 10,000 what makes this any more reliable? If scientists can go from 100,000 to 10,000 then they can go from 10,000 to 2. They are heading in the right direction.
Not so. It is quite inconceivable that a bottleneck of 2 individuals existed and it is disingenuous or ignorant of you to suggest or claim that a disagreement between 100,000 and 10,000, now settled to be be between 10,000 and 15,000 could ever support a conclusion of 2. It doesn’t.
Alleles are codes. Codes can form from many combinations of things in ways that make it impossible to determine the original state. In software engineering this is called “information loss”. For example if you receive the number 16 in binary and are told that this was formed from two factors, you cannot say definitively what the factors were. They may have been 4 x 4, 8 x 2 or 16 x 1. I am not a geneticist (I am a software engineer with a degree in electrical engineering) but perhaps this or similar principals could apply to genetic codes.
These principles (note spelling) do not apply to genetics. If you want to discuss these matters you should learn about genetics rather than making rather limp analogies that do not hold water. When you have read and absorbed an undergraduate text in genetics you will be ready to discuss this. Remember to get a good grounding in the coalescent, in phylogenetic analysis and in Bayesian statistics.

Did you ever get round to reading the article by Hickson and Cann?

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Did you ever get round to reading the article by Hickson and Cann?

Alec
evolutionpages.com
Oh, and by the way, with regard to your question about using mtDNA to determine past population size, the answer is that it is derived in exactly the same way as for autosomal loci using coalescent theory and phylogenetics. You might find a recent paper interesting: Atkinson, Gray and Drummond, mtDNA Variation Predicts Population Size in Humans and Reveals a Major Southern Asian Chapter in Human Prehistory, Mol Biol Evol 25, 468 - 474 (2008)

Unsurprisingly, the answer is not 2. Do read the paper, not just the abstract.

Try this blog as well, for an introduction to why we know that humans have not passed through a severe bottleneck based on mtDNA data (John Hawks is an expert researcher on these matters - you could hardly get a more knowledgeable guide):
johnhawks.net/weblog/reviews/genetics/mtdna_migrations/sub-saharan-africa-population-size-behar-2008.html

See also Hawks et al, Population bottlenecks and Pleistocene human evolution, Mol Biol Evol 17, 2 - 22 (2000)

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Try this blog as well, for an introduction to why we know that humans have not passed through a severe bottleneck based on mtDNA data (John Hawks is an expert researcher on these matters - you could hardly get a more knowledgeable guide):
johnhawks.net/weblog/reviews/genetics/mtdna_migrations/sub-saharan-africa-population-size-behar-2008.html
It does not say that we “know” anything. There are no claims of solid facts. This is a quote from that link: “The estimates here depend on the mutation model employed by Behar et al. That model could be wrong.”

Anyone can do a bit of searching on the internet including the links you posted, wikipedia, etc and see very easily that scientists do not claim that their quest is anywhere near settled. One concensus is that humans all come from East Africa. This does not contradict the teaching about Adam and Eve. There are other current and viable claims that there were a small number of humans in East Africa. This does not contradict the teaching about Adam and Eve. No scientists are claiming in concensus that the population was never two, or that it was one thousand or ten thousand. The only thing that is clear is that estimates are just that - *estimates - *and that scientists plan to do much more research.

If anything the current claims that even resemble a scientific concensus i.e. that we come from an inconclusive and perhaps small number of humans in East Africa and that we have remarkably similar DNA for a species, agree with the teaching regarding Adam and Eve.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recent_African_origin_of_modern_humans#cite_note-0

We inherited pride and rebellion from Adam and Eve. This attempt to prove that religion is wrong because of our teaching about Adam and Eve is ironically itself proof that we indeed descend from Adam.
 
Hi hecd2,

The Church speaks with authority from God. God created the universe and humans. This is not like the commonly held understanding that the earth was at the center of the solar system or universe. That was not Church doctrine. Here we are talking about a key doctrine of the faith and I think it is the category of teaching that is unchangeable and cannot be in error. If so, differing claims are incorrect.

I trust what the Church teaches regardless, however even from a purely scientific perspective:The article I linked to clearly indicates that a previous assertion that has been made regarding a number of humans in history was unreliable and that other factors must be considered. This seems to show that these “conclusions” are shaky/debatable and this is a work in progress. Even if one claim is now 10,000 what makes this any more reliable? If scientists can go from 100,000 to 10,000 then they can go from 10,000 to 2. They are heading in the right direction. 🙂 Alleles are codes. Codes can form from many combinations of things in ways that make it impossible to determine the original state. In software engineering this is called “information loss”. For example if you receive the number 16 in binary and are told that this was formed from two factors, you cannot say definitively what the factors were. They may have been 4 x 4, 8 x 2 or 16 x 1. I am not a geneticist (I am a software engineer with a degree in electrical engineering) but perhaps this or similar principals could apply to genetic codes.

Again even from a purely scientific prespective I think this may be just one current theory among others.
It is interesting to note a few things:

Man is at the center of the biggest and smallest distances.

Some scientists are claiming that the universe consists of concentric shells and that we are in the center.

This is worth noting: (from the Altenberg 16)

Meanwhile, Kauffman’s had a breathtaking career, beginning as a medical doctor, honored as a MacArthur Fellow (genius) and has worked with Nobel prize winner Murray Gell-Mann at the Santa Fe Institute where he first studied self-organization. Looking at simple forms like the snowflake, he noted that its “delicate sixfold symmetry tells us that order can arise without the benefit of natural selection”. Kauffman says natural selection is about competition for resources and snowflakes are not alive – they don’t need it. But he reminded me in our phone conversation that Darwin doesn’t explain how life begins, “Darwin starts with life. He doesn’t get you to life.”
Thus the scramble at Altenberg for a new theory of evolution.
Kauffman also describes genes as “utterly dead”. However, he says there are some genes that turn the rest of the genes and one another on and off. Certain chemical reactions happen. Enzymes are produced, etc. And that while we only have 25,000 to 30,000 genes, there are many combinations of activity.
Here’s what he told me over the phone:
“Well there’s 25,000 genes, so each could be on or off. So there’s 2x2x2x25,000 times. Well that’s 2 to the 25,000th. Right? Which is something like 10 to the 7,000th . Okay? There’s only 10 to the 80th particles in the whole universe. Are you stunned?”
 
Apparently mtDNA may recombine and it has not been proven one way or another. So it seems one cannot claim accuracy of population numbers based on mtDNA.
pubmedcentral.nih.gov/picrender.fcgi?artid=1692889&blobtype=pdf
You really should stop referencing articles that you stumbled over in google search where you clearly fail to understand both the content and the consequences for our discussion. You completely misrepresented the Hickson and Cann paper (have you read it yet, by the way?), and here you are at it again.

The point in question is whether extant humans are descended from two parents and this paper does not affect the conclusion.

Here’s why:
  1. Many scientists disagree with the conclusion that Eyre-Walker and colleagues draw. For example, the following researchers published direct challenges to the Eyre-Walker conclusions (published in another paper in Science with his colleagues Awadalla and Maynard Smith):
Toomas Kivisild and Richard Villems: “In sum, likely errors in the sequence data used by Awadalla et al. and the possibility that straightforward phylogenetic explanations can explain the observed correlations make the conclusions drawn [in the reference below] weaker than such an exceptionally important problem deserves”

LB Jorde and M Bamshad: “The possibility of recombination in mtDNA is intriguing and deserves further evaluation. Six of the eight mtDNA data sets examined here fail to show a significant decline of LD with physical distance using the r2 statistic, however, and none show a decline using the more appropriate D’ statistic. Thus, LD patterns provide little support for the hypothesis of mtDNA recombination”

Sudhir Kumar, Philip Hedrick, Thomas Dowling and Mark Stoneking: “Our reanalysis thus contradicts the contention by Awadalla et al. (1) that recombination is occurring in human mtDNA. Extensive family studies have likewise failed to find any exceptions to strict maternal clonal inheritance of human mtDNA (9-12). There is no need to reconsider inferences about human or mtDNA evolution that have assumed that recombination does not occur in human mtDNA.”

Thomas J. Parsons and Jodi A. Irwin: “In light of that finding, it seems unlikely that our understanding of the pattern and relative rates of sequence evolution within the mtDNA CR will require substantial revision based on the Awadalla et al. report. Our analysis also suggests that mtDNA forensic testing will be negligibly impacted by recombination; forensic applications already deal successfully with intergenerational mutation [in the references below], clearly a far more significant effect.”

All of these were published in Science 288 p1931. These conclusions have been vindicated, as the community of population geneticists have reached a cosensus that the problem is non-existent or insignificant - there have been many papers published since 2000 that use mtDNA data.
  1. If there is recombination it is very rare and its effects are tiny - for example it has not been directly observed at all in any healthy reproducing human
  2. Even if recombination occurred freely and every human being carried half their mtDNA from their father (which is clearly not the case - far, far from it) then the consequence for the conclusions on effective population size is limited. I’ll leave it to you to see if you can figure out how much effect it would have - but I’ll give you a hint - the correction would not get you very far in your quest to attempt to show that an ancestry for humans of two people is genetically credible.
Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Anyone can do a bit of searching on the internet including the links you posted, wikipedia, etc and see very easily that scientists do not claim that their quest is anywhere near settled.
The problem is that you need to understand what you are reading which, if history is anything to go by, you don’t on this subject.
No scientists are claiming in concensus that the population was never two, or that it was one thousand or ten thousand. The only thing that is clear is that estimates are just that - *estimates - *and that scientists plan to do much more research
Of course there is a consensus that population was not two, because nobody comes close to suggesting that it was. All population geneticists accept, based on the genetic data, that the worldwide human population has not passed through a bottleneck of two people. If that’s not a consensus, I don’t know what is. I’ll be surprised of you can find even one working population geneticist who is prepared to say that the human lineage could have passed through a bottleneck of a single breeding pair in the last 2 million years. Human beings have narrow genetic diversity, but not *that *narrow. All the analysis (for which I could post many different references) of many different aspects of the human genome agree that the number is nothing like 2 or 20 or even 100. Would you like the references? Would you get them and read them?
We inherited pride and rebellion from Adam and Eve. This attempt to prove that religion is wrong because of our teaching about Adam and Eve is ironically itself proof that we indeed descend from Adam.
Nice argumentum ad hominem there.

To summarise, the genetic data is such that it is not credible that the human population passed through a bottleneck of two individuals. There was no such thing as a literal Adam and Eve.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Of course there is a consensus that population was not two,
Scientists claim only rough unsure estimates - I see 1,000, 10,000, 100,000 etc. and I see no concensus specifically claiming that it cannot possibly have been two.
 
She has been wrong about many things and she is wrong about this. You seem to have created a new cult for the infallibility of the Church as defined by a papal encyclical (which infallibility, by the way, is not claimed by the Church Herself). Anyone with the least superficial knowledge of history can point to things that the Church (as represented by the opinions and teaching of a pope) has been wrong about. This is one of them. The Church makes pronouncements about matters that impinge on science (ie matters that can be settled be reference to physical evidence) at Her peril. You would think that She would have learned better by now.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
Alec,
I think you’re right. The encyclical in question says that polygenism is not up for discussion at this time. It doesn’t rule it out absolutely. And as you said, it isn’t infallible either.

Catholics should be obedient to what it says, but it doesn’t mean we have to look for unlikely scientific theories to back it up.
 
Catholics should be obedient to what it says, but it doesn’t mean we have to look for unlikely scientific theories to back it up.
The science on this is speculative at this point and I don’t see any concensus or scientists claiming reliable accurate answers. As I pointed out before, this is not about the solar system which was never an essential element of the faith. I think the teaching about Adam and Eve is an essential element of the faith that cannot be in error.

Some people seem to promote the idea that scientific claims automatically cast doubt on related Church teaching. This is based on so-called mistakes of the past - which may have been accepted thinking (by society as a whole by the way including scientists) but was not official doctrine. This is easily used as leverage to cast doubt on the teaching regarding Adam and Eve and even Catholics now seem to cower and readily accept science that is in a rough unsure phase.

I have seen no scientific claim of conclusive evidence that humanity did not start with two. I see no claim that the current genetic variation could not have started with two.
 
In case you think that is what is my statements are about they’re not. The science on this is speculative at this point and I don’t see any concensus or scientists claiming reliable accurate answers. As I pointed out before, this is not about the solar system which was never an essential element of the faith. I think the teaching about Adam and Eve is an essential element of the faith that cannot be in error.
If science ever does prove conclusively that there were not a first man and woman who we are all descended from, I have no doubt that this could be reconciled with the dogma of original sin. I think the Church is right to move slowly though, and wait to see what science finds. I’m not saying that your science is wrong, I’m just saying I don’t think there are religious reasons to worry about what science finds, one way or the other.
 
I’m just saying I don’t think there are religious reasons to worry about what science finds, one way or the other.
Hi Neil, I agree that there is absolutely no reason to fear science and I embrace science. However my point is that this is actually an example of a case where we are talking about an essential doctrine. In this case I expect the progression of science to align with the Church teaching. I’m pointing out that I think the past may be used to attempt to pull the wool over people’s eyes regarding this Church teaching. We can be fooled and quickly listen to another voice just as Adam and Eve did.
 
All population geneticists accept, based on the genetic data, that the worldwide human population has not passed through a bottleneck of two people.
First of all it does not have to be “bottleneck”. God can create two people from the earth if it His will. Don’t ignore the “evidence” that we are speaking about the Being who has limitless power. Look out your window at the stars. Let’s be humble, you and I are floating on a planet around a nuclear furnace (sun). We were put here by Him who created us. That’s “evidence”. 🙂 We have some fossils and some genetic codes and we’re trying to piece together the number of humans that existed perhaps some tens/hundreds of thousands of years ago! Good luck! Can you genetically calculate the color of the hair of each of your ancestors from just five generations ago? It’s shaky science at this point - you don’t have to be an expert to see that.
 
Scientists claim only rough unsure estimates - I see 1,000, 10,000, 100,000 etc. and I see no concensus specifically claiming that it cannot possibly have been two.
The reason that you don’t see two being discussed in formal scientific work is that the evidence precludes the possibility of a bottleneck of two parents. The question of relevance here is not whether it was 1,000, or 10,000 but whether it was ever precisely two. Two is so far outside the possible range that it is not a matter for discussion amongst population geneticists. One reason for this (amongst others) is that the number of allelic families that coalesce at a number of loci before the divergence of human and chimpanzee lineages exceeds the number that can pass through a bottleneck of two people. This is a settled question. If you can find a single reference or a single population geneticist who is willing to entertain the discredited hypothesis of a literal Adam and Eve then you might have the beginning of a case. Such a person is non-existent or extremely rare. That’s a consensus (note spelling).

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
First of all it does not have to be “bottleneck”. God can create two people from the earth if it His will.
So here we go - the ultimate card played by believers when forced to confront the fact that their beliefs are incompatible with the facts. Of course this sort of argument is irrefutable, just as the Gosse Omphalos argument is. One can always fall back on the miraculous to attempt to explain away inconvenient facts.

The irony is that in this case it doesn’t help you that much - the genetic signature of a population originating with two created individuals is indistinguishable from that of a bottleneck of two - and in either case, a population of two is insufficient to transmit the genetic diversity we see in modern humans.

However, if God created “two people from the Earth”, why would they have a L-gulonolactone oxidase gene broken in exactly the same way as other primates? Why would they share multiple ancestral pseudogenes? Why would remnants of the chimp 2p and 2q chromosome centromeres and telomeres be found on human chromosome 2? Why do we share endogenous retroviruses with other primates, particularly the great apes?
Don’t ignore the “evidence” that we are speaking about the Being who has limitless power. Look out your window at the stars. Let’s be humble, you and I are floating on a planet around a nuclear furnace (sun). We were put here by Him who created us. That’s “evidence”.
That’s not evidence - that’s faith.
It’s shaky science at this point - you don’t have to be an expert to see that.
It’s not so shaky, and the answer cannot possibly be two.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
I hope my questions come out clear but its kinda confusing myself thinking about it lol. But here goes…

If Adam and Eve where the first two humans created does it mean they where the only two “created” the same way. Could there have been others created like them at a later date?

And if they where the only two created then wouldn’t this prove God also created the process of evolution? I don’t mean the theory of man came from monkeys. But that people did evolve do to their enviroments. How else could we have the differant races of man? Skin color for example and other physical differances.

I hope this is clear and you understand what I am trying to ask. Thanks again for all the help. Everyone has been very patient and understanding with the many questions I have. lol And I promise there will be many mroe to come as I conitue to search and learn:)

BP
**I ran across speculation that the reason there are two creation stories in Genesis was to explain the creation of humankind as well as the beginnings of God’s Chosen People.

Genesis 1 gives a synopsis of Creation as a refutation of pagan creation stories, and specifies that it is GOD Who does this, the Supreme Being, and not other gods. Then, in Genesis 1:26-30, the author(s) explain the creation of humankind in general.

Genesis 2 begins the ‘genesis’ or beginnings of the ancestry of the Chosen People, beginning with Adam & Eve specifically.**
 
So here we go - the ultimate card played by believers when forced to confront the fact that their beliefs are incompatible with the facts.
Hi hecd, no, that’s not the way I meant it. This is not some cult where we blindly and stubbornly deny scientific evidence. I also embrace the evidence for the theory that we have evolved from previous forms. On your part, don’t underestimate God’s power or jump to conclusions about what He has done. Science doesn’t know how the universe started and we will never understand from science alone why we are here and what existence really even is. Every answered question in science leads to more questions. Science does not have the ultimate answers.

Also, that we have two original parents is a core teaching of the faith and it has preexisted these recent scientific theories. The teaching that our two parents were created directly by God is not central (as far as I know) but this belief has also preexisted these recent theories.
 
Hi hecd, no, that’s not the way I meant it.
OK - explanation accepted and I withdraw that specific criticism.
This is not some cult where we blindly and stubbornly deny scientific evidence. That we have two original parents is a core teaching of the faith and it has preexisted these recent scientific theories.
Its pre-existence and the fact that it is a core teaching are irrelevant to its accuracy.
Therefore the story of Adam and Eve and the idea that God created them directly is not some made up response.
Well, yes it is made up, on the basis of a ancient myth.
I also embrace the evidence for the theory that we have evolved from previous forms. On your part, don’t underestimate God’s power or jump to conclusions about what He has done.
It is impossible to underestimate God’s power.
Science doesn’t know how the universe started
Well, I should say that Big Bang plus inflation is a strong hypothesis with quite a lot of evidence in support of it. Which represents considerably more insight than any non-scientific explanation for how the universe began.
and we will never understand from science alone why we are here and what existence really even is. Every answered question in science leads to more questions. Science does not have the ultimate answers.
Yes, I agree, but it does have the answer to this specific question, which is that it is inconceivable that modern humans descend from just two parents. Sorry that that cuts across what the very ancient myth says, but that’s the way it is.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
The reason that you don’t see two being discussed in formal scientific work is that the evidence precludes the possibility of a bottleneck of two parents.
I respectfully disagree that scientists currently claim this. It may be a lesser-addressed and a subconscious assumption, but I don’t see anyone claiming that in their opinion it is ruled out. In three papers two of which you actually pointed me to, I find this:

Eyre-Walker: Indication that we need more research on recombination.

John Hawks: My numbers are based on a theory that could be wrong.

Dr. Drummond et al: recommend other papers with other theories.

I accept (yes on faith and I fully expect science to follow) that the current genetic variation started with two original humans. On what basis do you claim that this is not possible? I don’t plan to spend a lot of time studying genetics so break it down for us as to why you claim this is not possible. Remember, you are the one promoting this here.🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top