C
Coder
Guest
Hi hecd2,
The Church speaks with authority from God. God created the universe and humans. This is not like the commonly held understanding that the earth was at the center of the solar system or universe. That was not Church doctrine. Here we are talking about a key doctrine of the faith and I think it is the category of teaching that is unchangeable and cannot be in error. If so, differing claims are incorrect.
I trust what the Church teaches regardless, however even from a purely scientific perspective:
The article I linked to clearly indicates that a previous assertion that has been made regarding a number of humans in history was unreliable and that other factors must be considered. This seems to show that these “conclusions” are shaky/debatable and this is a work in progress. Even if one claim is now 10,000 what makes this any more reliable? If scientists can go from 100,000 to 10,000 then they can go from 10,000 to 2. They are heading in the right direction.
Alleles are codes. Codes can form from many combinations of things in ways that make it impossible to determine the original state. In software engineering this is called “information loss”. For example if you receive the number 16 in binary and are told that this was formed from two factors, you cannot say definitively what the factors were. They may have been 4 x 4, 8 x 2 or 16 x 1. I am not a geneticist (I am a software engineer with a degree in electrical engineering) but perhaps this or similar principals could apply to genetic codes.
Alec:
The Church speaks with authority from God. God created the universe and humans. This is not like the commonly held understanding that the earth was at the center of the solar system or universe. That was not Church doctrine. Here we are talking about a key doctrine of the faith and I think it is the category of teaching that is unchangeable and cannot be in error. If so, differing claims are incorrect.
I trust what the Church teaches regardless, however even from a purely scientific perspective:
The article I linked to clearly indicates that a previous assertion that has been made regarding a number of humans in history was unreliable and that other factors must be considered. This seems to show that these “conclusions” are shaky/debatable and this is a work in progress. Even if one claim is now 10,000 what makes this any more reliable? If scientists can go from 100,000 to 10,000 then they can go from 10,000 to 2. They are heading in the right direction.
Again even from a purely scientific prespective I think this may be just one current theory among others.Meanwhile, a huge body of work on genetic information covering mitochondrial DNA, the NRY of the Y-chromosome, the X-chromosome, various autosomal genes, various tracts on noncoding autosomal DNA, ALU-insertions, linkage disequilibrium, and microsatellites all agrees that the effective population size in the lineage leading to extant humans was at least 10,000