Adam and Eve

  • Thread starter Thread starter brierpatch1974
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
OK - explanation accepted and I withdraw that specific criticism.
Its pre-existence and the fact that it is a core teaching are irrelevant to its accuracy.
Well, yes it is made up, on the basis of a ancient myth.
It is impossible to underestimate God’s power.
Well, I should say that Big Bang plus inflation is a strong hypothesis with quite a lot of evidence in support of it. Which represents considerably more insight than any non-scientific explanation for how the universe began.
Yes, I agree, but it does have the answer to this specific question, which is that it is inconceivable that modern humans descend from just two parents. Sorry that that cuts across what the very ancient myth says, but that’s the way it is.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
You have made dogmatic statements. Please do not attempt to spread your atheism here. It is clear that your goal is to say “the Church is wrong” as often as possible, not to present your interpretations of what you claim to be facts.

Peace,
Ed
 
I respectfully disagree that scientists currently claim this. It may be a lesser-addressed and a subconscious assumption, but I don’t see anyone claiming that in their opinion it is ruled out.
As I have said - you find me a single paper or a single population geneticist who accepts that two is a viable number, and you will have the bare beginnings of a case. As it is, you have none
I accept (yes on faith and I fully expect science to follow) that the current genetic variation started with two original humans. On what basis do you claim that this is not possible? I don’t plan to spend a lot of time studying genetics so break it down for us as to why you claim this is not possible.
I have already done so. One, amongst other, reasons is that the number of allelic families in extant humans that coalesce before the divergence of human/chimp lineages exceeds the number of alleles in two people(ie four in the autosomal genome).
Remember, you are the one promoting this here.
Nice attempt to shift the burden of proof - but you are the one making the positive assertion that extant humans descend from two people. The burden of proof is on you - I am merely pointing out that the evidence precludes that assertion. I think I am going to have to give you that long list of references, but that will have to wait for another time.

One last comment - no-one is claiming that we know exactly how narrow the minimum bottleneck in the human lineage was - there is a degree of uncertainty around this as there is around many other scientific conclusions - that is the meaning of confidence intervals. No-one is claiming that we cannot improve out conclusions by doing more work. That does not mean that all options are tenable. We can say with certainty that the minimum bottleneck was larger than two as two falls outside a credible range.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Eyre-Walker: Indication that we need more research on recombination.
Oh - and I spent some time explaining in detail where things stand on that matter - which you have ignored; you have merely brought up the objection (which I have shown is no objection) again. I am sorry that you are so wedded to what you believe that you will grasp at straws, but that’s how it comes over. And this is a very slender straw.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
You have made dogmatic statements.
No. I have made statements based on evidence.
. It is clear that your goal is to say “the Church is wrong” as often as possible, not to present your interpretations of what you claim to be facts.
My goal is to present the evidence. If one concludes from that that the Church, or the Pope, or its cardinals or you, Ed, are wrong, well that’s just the way it is.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
One, amongst other, reasons is that the number of allelic families in extant humans that coalesce before the divergence of human/chimp lineages exceeds the number of alleles in two people(ie four in the autosomal genome).
Hi hecd, that’s a good example of something that you could break down for us better.

Also, for one thing that seems to assume evolution and even a particular timing of evolution. I accept that there is evidence of evolution but with or without evolution I think scientists are still trying to piece together the actual timing and location of the first appearance of us humans - true? So that seems to imply other possibilities for your statement here. Also are there possible other explanations? For example, if mtDNA recombined could this affect the number of alleles?

But at least please do further break down your statement. How many alleles do two people have?
 
I think this is irrelevant to the teaching regarding Adam and Eve.

All humans alive today have inherited DNA from this human or pre-human female. This does not mean that she is the only ancestor of all people living today. Some but not all people living today may have descended from others living in her time.

The fact that we have a common ancestor through our mothers at a point in history does not mean that we don’t have an only pair of parents at either an earlier or later date. This also applies to the common male ancestor discovered.

I ask whether this or similar reasoning is possible as an explanation:
The species was pre-human and declined and there were only two left. The offspring of these pre-humans were given a soul by God at conception and became the first true humans (Adam and Eve). Because Eve had genetic material from the female pre-human and we all descend from her then we all also have inherited from this pre-human.

I also propose this as a possible explanation:
Adam and Eve predated this other woman from whom we all inherit through our mothers.

I think people can mistakenly relate inherited genetic material from a common “ancestor” to our first parents. I don’t think the two concepts are directly related as I have illustrated above.
Please read “The Seven Daughters of Eve” by Bryan Sykes. Dr. Sykes is a world-renown geneticist who lays out the genetic story as to who we originated from. It’s a fascinating read.
 
Phil,

Interesting. There is a dentist that caims that Neanderthals were the first humans. He had a video clip. I will try to find it.
We know that Neanderthals were not homo sapien but were a separate subgroup of humans that did not survive. Homo sapiens did not evolve or descend or develop from the Neanderthal line which ran parallel to the homo sapien line. In fact, from what we know now, there were several human subgroups that became extinct leaving only the homo sapien line.
 
No. I have made statements based on evidence.

My goal is to present the evidence. If one concludes from that that the Church, or the Pope, or its cardinals or you, Ed, are wrong, well that’s just the way it is.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
You reject God. Think about that.

Peace,
Ed
 
40.png
hecd2:
One, amongst other, reasons is that the number of allelic families in extant humans that coalesce before the divergence of human/chimp lineages exceeds the number of alleles in two people(ie four in the autosomal genome).
Hi hecd, that’s a good example of something that you could break down for us better.
Sorry, I’ve been busy on other things. What more do you want to know about this? Alleles evolve in phylogenetic families, rather like taxa in organisms. By analysing the differences between one allele and another we can assign an individual allele to one family or another by using the same sort of technique as is used to analyse the relationships between organisms. Families of alleles coalesce as we go back in time just as taxa of organisms do. Many families of alleles are shared by chimps and humans - ie their coalescence pre-dates the divergence of chimp and human lineages. At some loci there are more allelic families shared by chimp and humans than can be transmitted through a couple of people (for each locus, two healthy people carry a maximum of four alleles in their autosomal genome, three alleles on the X-chromosome of which the woman has two and the man has one, one allele of heritable mtDNA carried by the woman, and one allele in the non recombining portion of the Y-chromosome). This is just one bit of evidence against a literal Adam and Eve - there are others.
Also, for one thing that seems to assume evolution and even a particular timing of evolution. I accept that there is evidence of evolution but with or without evolution I think scientists are still trying to piece together the actual timing and location of the first appearance of us humans - true?
Well, of course the fact of evolution is a premise. My argument makes no sense for young earth creationists and their fellow travellers, but only for those who accept the huge quantity of evidence for evolution and common ancestry. As for the timing of emergence of humans - anatomically modern humans (but with distinct anatomical differences from living humans) appear in the Levant about 190K BP, presumably from a African source a few 10s of K earlier; but there is little evidence of fully human behaviour until after 50K BP. So yes, there is uncertainty, but that doesn’t matter in this case as we can be certain that humans emerged a long time after the divergence of the human and chimpanzee lineages.
So that seems to imply other possibilities for your statement here.
Such as?
Also are there possible other explanations? For example, if mtDNA recombined could this affect the number of alleles?
No, not even in the heritable mtDNA and certainly not in the nuclear genome.
But at least please do further break down your statement. How many alleles do two people have?
See above.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Originally Posted by hecd2
OK - explanation accepted and I withdraw that specific criticism.
Its pre-existence and the fact that it is a core teaching are irrelevant to its accuracy.
Well, yes it is made up, on the basis of a ancient myth.
It is impossible to underestimate God’s power.
Well, I should say that Big Bang plus inflation is a strong hypothesis with quite a lot of evidence in support of it. Which represents considerably more insight than any non-scientific explanation for how the universe began.
Yes, I agree, but it does have the answer to this specific question, which is that it is inconceivable that modern humans descend from just two parents. Sorry that that cuts across what the very ancient myth says, but that’s the way it is.

**Myth? You want to know what a myth is? That the universe started with a p(name removed by moderator)rick of light and then “blew up” like an expanding balloon until we have infinity. Wow…talk about a fairy tale!! **:rotfl:
 
OK - so I promised a set of references that refute the concept that humans descend from just two parents. This evidence is molecular and is obtained by analysis of variations (alleles) in the human genome at many loci:

The MHC complex:
Ayala, The myth of Eve, Molecular biology and human origins, *Science *270, 1930 - 1936

Bergstrom et al, Recent Origin of DRB1 alleles and implications for human evolution,* Nature Genetics* 18, 237 (1998),

Screuder et al in The HLA Dictionary*, Tissue Antigens* 65, 1 - 55

Gyllensten, Sundvall and Ehrlich, Allelic diversity is generated by intraexon sequence exchange at the DRB1 locus of primates, PNAS 88, 3686 – 3690 (1991)

Beta-globin:
Harding et al, ‘Archaic African and Asian lineages in the genetic ancestry of modern humans’, Am J Hum Genet 60, 772 - 789

Apolipoprotein C II:
Xiong et al, ‘No severe bottleneck during human evolution; evidence from two apolipoprotein C II alleles’, Am J Hum Genet 48, 383 -389
**
Nuclear genome**:
Rogers and Jorde, ‘Genetic evidence on the origin of modern humans’, Hum Biol 67, 1 - 36, show that a modest bottleneck of 10,000 individuals is consistent with the data.

Takahata et al, ‘Diversion time and population size in the lineage leading to modern humans’, Theor Popul Biol 48, 198 - 221

Zhao et al, Worldwide DNA sequence variation in a 10 kilo-base noncoding region on human chromosome 22, PNAS 97, 11354 – 11358 (2000)

mtDNA:
Takahata, ‘Allelic genealogy and human evolution’, Mol Biol Evol 10, 2 - 22;

Y-chromosome data:
Hammer, ’ A recent common ancestry for human Y-chromosomes’, *Nature *378, 376 - 378

Pritchard et al, Population growth of Human Y Chromosomes: A Study of Y Chromosome Microsatellites, Mol Biol Evol 16,1791 – 1798 (1999)

LD:
Tanesa et al, Recent human effective population size estimated from linkage disequilibrium, Genome Res 17, 520 – 526 (2007)

Hayes et al, Novel multilocus measures of linkage disequilibrium to estimate past effective population size, *Genome Res *13, 635 – 643 (2003)

X-chromosome:

Yu, Fu and Li, DNA polymorphism in a worldwide sample of human X-chromosomes, Mol Biol Evol 19, 2131 – 2141 (2002)

Microsatellites:

Zhivotsky et al, Features of evolution and expansion of modern humans, inferred from genomewide microsatellite markers, Am J Hum Gen 5, 1171 – 1176 (2003)
**
General studies**:

Cavalli-Sforza and Feldman, The application of molecular genetic approaches to the study of human evolution, Nature Genetics 33, 266 – 275 (2003)

Jorde, Bamshad and Rogers, Using mitochondrial and nuclear DNA markers to reconstruct human evolution, Bioessays 20, 126 – 136 (1998)

Liu et al, A geographically explicit model of worldwide human settlement history, Am J Hum Gen 79, 230 – 237 (2006)

J D Wall, Estimating ancestral population sizes and divergence times, Genetics 163, 395 – 404 (2003)

Hawks et al, Population bottlenecks and Pleistocene human evolution, *Mol Bio Evol *17, 2 – 22 (2000)

Harpending et al, Genetic traces of ancient demography, PNAS 95, 1961 – 1967 (1998)

Takahata and Satta, Evolution of the primate lineage leading to modern humans: Phylogenetic and demographic inferences from DNA sequences, PNAS 94, 4811- 4815 (1997)

Yu et al, Low nucleotide diversity in chimpanzees and bonobos, Genetics 164, 1511 – 1518 (2003)

There are many more, but this should be enough to be going on with. Every single one of these support a minimum effective population in the human lineage way, way above two. There is no scientific hypothesis of a bottleneck of two in the human lineage, because the evidence precludes it.

I will be utterly astonished if anyone can refer to a single scientific paper that states that it is possible that humans descend from just two biological parents.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
I agree. The truth of the Big Bang is stranger and more magnificent and more awe inspiring than the little creation myth one can find in Genesis.

By the way, do you know where you **bold **key is?

Alec
I have told posters that I have to use the bold key as it is difficult for me to see the print. sorry.
 
At some loci there are more allelic families shared by chimp and humans
By the way, I don’t think that the fact that we share natural codes with chimps should be surprising from the prespective of faith. Before genetics, we knew that we share chemical elements, water, need for physical food, and even physical similarities with creatures. The faithful understand that we are creatures and even have some things in common with other creatures. Maybe this is good to humble us. However, God also tells us that we have a spiritual and eternal soul able to share His life that other creatures do not have. This is by His decision.
Many families of alleles are shared by chimps and humans - ie their coalescence pre-dates the divergence of chimp and human lineages.
I have seen the formula for coalescence. It seems a simple formula and I don’t think it is meant to have p(name removed by moderator)oint accuracy without considering other factors. I think there is still more research being done. On what basis do you claim the p(name removed by moderator)oint accuracy of the coalescent formula or that it is reliable in reagrds to monogenism?
At some loci there are more allelic families shared by chimp and humans than can be transmitted through a couple of people
What about the time factor? Doesn’t time also affect genetic diversity? That’s why I question this when scientists admittedly aren’t sure about when humans actually emerged.
Well, of course the fact of evolution is a premise. My argument makes no sense for young earth creationists and their fellow travellers, but only for those who accept the huge quantity of evidence for evolution and common ancestry.
One does not have to be an a-scientific “creationist” to point out that even the current theory of evolution apparently still has holes and again fails to p(name removed by moderator)oint the timing and location of the first humans.

You are claiming the impossibility of monogenism,yet scientists admit that they are not sure when humans emerged and where, nor how many. Even the coalescense formula seems to need work. I don’t see how you can even claim to know a minumum number of humans that existed yet still not be able to determine these other facts. I’m still interested in learning more and scientists still have work to do. I don’t see these scientific claims as final (i.e. not like “the moon is 240K miles away”). What I see is a.) evidence that we evolved from previous forms (I can accept that but still want to see more research.) and b.) crude/varied estimates of timing and location of when humans emerged.

As for scientists that accept the possibility of two, I will see what I can find. It’s a fascinating field but most importantly, see the hand of God in the mysteries and wonder of creation. Remember God is the author, we are merely the readers of the book, whether it be alleles or anything else in creation. This is one concept that I encourage you to grasp, Have an open mind and an open heart and respect the Word of God. Genesis uses figurative language but its wisdom is profound. It is inspired by the Holy Spirit and it is to be respected.

“Genesis”, “Genetics” Interesting.
 
By the way, I don’t think that the fact that we share natural codes with chimps should be surprising from the prespective of faith. Before genetics, we knew that we share chemical elements, water, need for physical food, and even physical similarities with creatures. The faithful understand that we are creatures and even have some things in common with other creatures. Maybe this is good to humble us. However, God also tells us that we have a spiritual and eternal soul able to share His life that other creatures do not have. This is by His decision.
I think all this is rather irrelevant. Are you trying to say that the evidence does NOT point to common ancestry of humans and other animals? If so, say so and then we can end this debate, because once you believe in the miraculous creation of the human body, then you part company with science and you can believe whatever fancy takes you. But then, you would also have to explain why chimps and humans share retrotransposons, the L-gulano-γ-lactone oxidase gene and the ACYL3 gene broken identically. You would have to explain why humans have a chromosome 2 that is clearly the fusion of great ape chromosomes. But you accept (as far as I can tell from this thread) common ancestry, so what is your point?
I have seen the formula for coalescence. It seems a simple formula and I don’t think it is meant to have p(name removed by moderator)oint accuracy without considering other factors.
What formula have you seen? Where?
I think there is still more research being done. On what basis do you claim the p(name removed by moderator)oint accuracy of the coalescent formula or that it is reliable in reagrds to monogenism?
It doesn’t need to have p(name removed by moderator)oint accuracy, because it’s a gross question. Since you have seen the formula, perhaps you could tell us in how many generations we expect coalescence to an MRCA in a population of two for a diploid gene? If you have more than four lineages shared with chimps in a diploid gene, the population CANNOT have passed through a bottleneck of 2.
What about the time factor? Doesn’t time also affect genetic diversity? That’s why I question this when scientists admittedly aren’t sure about when humans actually emerged.
It’s irrelevant as we know that humans cannot possibly have emerged before the divergence of chimp and human lineages.
One does not have to be an a-scientific “creationist” to point out that even the current theory of evolution apparently still has holes
Such as? Are they relevant to this question?
You are claiming the impossibility of monogenism,yet scientists admit that they are not sure when humans emerged and where, nor how many.
Well humans emerged in the last 500K years to give it a wide margin of tolerance, at least 4.5 million years after the critical divergence of humans and chimps, so the question of ‘when’ is irrelevant. ‘Where’ is Africa. And ‘how many’ is considerably more than two in every single informed estimate. Two is not in the credible range.
Even the coalescense formula seems to need work.
In what way precisely?
I don’t see how you can even claim to know a minumum number of humans that existed yet still not be able to determine these other facts.
We know modern humans arose in Africa between 280K and 200K BP, and that human lineage has never dropped to two individuals. That is sufficient for the purposes of this thread.
As for scientists that accept the possibility of two, I will see what I can find.
Good luck. You’ll need it.

Now I think we have gone as far as we can with this. You are, of course, free to believe whatever myth you like, but the fact is that humans cannot be descended from two parents. You are wedded to the myth, so there is no evidence that will convince you otherwise and that means you will not acknowledge the fact that multiple studies on multiple parts of the genome support a minimum population on the human lineage way above two - I have given you a number of references. - and none, not ONE support an ancestry of a single couple. If you are determined to believe that fairies exist or that humans descend from a literal Adam and Eve, I can’t persuade you otherwise and we are going round in circles. Good luck.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Why do you continue with your atheism here? What does it get you?

Peace,
Ed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top