Am I being too sensitive about my weight?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lone_Catholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
Princess_Abby:
So are you going back to counseling, LC, or what’s the plan? 🙂
Awww. Thank you for asking Princess Abby.

I guess I really don’t have a plan right now. I’m going to start looking for a counselor, although dh has made me feel quite silly about the whole thing by now, like I’m making a big deal out of nothing. But I do know things are not ok right now. He has always been willing to go to counseling before, so I’m sure he will now, although we have some financial concerns (that is putting it mildly actually!) that might keep us from pursuing counseling right now.

Any ideas of how to find a good Catholic counselor?
 
Lone Catholic:
Awww. Thank you for asking Princess Abby.

I guess I really don’t have a plan right now. I’m going to start looking for a counselor, although dh has made me feel quite silly about the whole thing by now, like I’m making a big deal out of nothing. But I do know things are not ok right now. He has always been willing to go to counseling before, so I’m sure he will now, although we have some financial concerns (that is putting it mildly actually!) that might keep us from pursuing counseling right now.

Any ideas of how to find a good Catholic counselor?
Yes, I do have some suggestions about how to find a good Catholic counselor. One, there is catholictherapists.com which is a database of counselors/therapists/psychologists who are faithful to the Church’s teachings. You can search by state and see if anyone is listed in your area.

Two, you can call your diocese’s Catholic Charities who have trained Catholic therapists, and also on a sliding scale. Simply do a google search for Catholic Charities and your diocese or geographic area.

Please don’t ignore how this is affecting you and ultimately your marriage, whether or not your husband chooses to acknowledge his behavior and your feelings as being legitimately of concern. Perhaps in counseling you will hear the terms “aggressing,” “countering” and “minimizing.” Aggressing is when a person uses help as a guise to demean and belittle, ultimately because they want to control a situation or person. (“I just want you be the pretty wife I once married. You need to try harder to lose weight and 125 is really the goal you should be seeking. Ten pounds of baby weight is too much on your body. My secretary is your height and her goal weight is 127.”) Countering is when a person denies any viewpoint that differs from their own. (Such as, “I deserve a hot wife even if you tell me you’ve had four babies and therefore won’t look the same as you used to. That means you aren’t trying hard enough.”) Minimizing is a form of denial and invalidating your feelings. (“You’re being too sensitive. I’m surprised this is still an issue when we already discussed it.”)

Just don’t start making your husband’s excuses for him. 🙂 Your feelings ARE valid and you deserve to be respected in the body that you have sacrificed for the sake of your four beautiful children. You have offered new life to this world and borne the children your husband helped make. HIS expectations are off, not yours!
 
I agree with Princess Abby…your feelings are valid. However, remember, your feelings do not have to dictate your actions. This is a mistake I often make…I feel a certain way therefore I am entitled to act a certain way. Nope. Not true. That is for babies. I am not a baby. I am a woman of grace and dignity. I am a sober woman of grace and dignity. Yes I am and if you do not believe me I just might run you over with my minivan of a body.

Ok, just kidding.

Seriously though, your feelings about his insensitive remarks and goofy way of putting things are valid. You still need to be sure that your actions are those of a woman of grace, that you are walking the path that Our Lady would have you walk, one that leads towards Christ her Son.

I do not pretend, when I write this stuff, that it is easy. One of my favorite quotes from Blessed Theresa of Calcutta is “I know that God will never give me more than I can handle, but sometimes I wish He did not think so highly of me.”
 
I have gotten kind of irritated reading this thread. I know we should all try to act more like Christ. I think the husband is being overly critical. I am 5’5" and weigh almost 240. While I realize that I am obese, I find it offensive for people to say that a woman must work on herself in order to stay attractive to her husband. I find this offensive because it implies that looks have a big impact on marriage. Someone once commented to me that my husband would love me if I was 800 lbs, purple, and had horns. I thought that was silly but my husband has lived up to it. As I said, I am obese but being critical does nothing to help the situation. I often get upset about my weight but my husband just encourages me to continue to try to exercise and eat better. When I mention the whole attractive thing, he states that I still “feel” the same on the inside. My outward appearance may have changed but my inner self is still the same. If anybody says you are the one with the problem, I would be hard pressed to agree. I think your husband is the one with the problem and he is just trying to use your weight as an excuse to let him off the hook. If you like your weight, then tell him too bad, in a Christian manner of course.
 
Sweet bejus…

Where else can you read about a woman smacking her kid around because she can and a woman with 3 kids with one in the oven getting abused by her hubby because she does not look like Ms. America… (btw - what kind of shape is he in?)

“he sent me an email that was 5 pages long telling me that I wasn’t trying hard enough and that I owed it to him to be “hot” because that is what he married, and he founda marriage book that says a man has the NEED to have an attractive spouse”

All along I have been thinking that these kind of men were extinct…

I think you need to show your ever-loving hubby who follows you into the shower with a measuring tape your state’s divorce laws and child support calculation sheets… Once he sees how much he would have to pay I bet he will start treating you like the most gorgeous creature God ever put on this planet… probably buy you a nice big box of bon bon’s too…

Good Luck,

Ronin
 
After my 3rd child I was carrying some extra weight… my husband would make “jokes” and it used to upset me sooooo much. Mostly because in my heart of hearts I knew he was right… I was letting myself go. I think it bothered ME way more than it ever bothered him. So I decided enough was enough… it was MY body… I controlled what I fed it… I controlled how often I moved it and I was going to get in shape. I started walking… then running & I lost 40 pounds. I felt great. My husband thought I looked great also but he’s admited that he didn’t REALLY mind when I was heavy either… but the truth is I feel better… sooooooo much better about myself.

You are preganant now and there isn’t much you can do… it takes alot of calories to make a baby & lets face it… excercise & preganancy - especially in the last few months don’t really mix. So put it all on the back burner for awhile… give yourself time to heal after you’ve had the baby & then get busy. Eat healthy - and EXERCISE. You’ll feel better about yourself & your husband’s comments won’t matter so much. Do I think he’s being a jerk? Yep. But he’s your husband… for better or worse… so forgive him and move on.
 
Maybe your husband should read ‘Good News About Sex and Marriage’ by Christopher West to counter balance that other book.
 
carol marie:
After my 3rd child I was carrying some extra weight… my husband would make “jokes” and it used to upset me sooooo much. Mostly because in my heart of hearts I knew he was right… I was letting myself go.
I don’t care how right your husband is. Joking about weight is off limits. Reading this thread makes it evident why so many girls (and guys) end up with eating disorders. If you have children, you had better remember that they hear and absorb everything. Focusing so much on body image definitely sends a message to your children that appearances are everything.
carol marie:
Do I think he’s being a jerk? Yep. But he’s your husband… for better or worse… so forgive him and move on.
Forgiveness IS important but it is really difficult to forgive when he makes no effort to stop the offensive behavior. Why is it that women are supposed to allow the husband to do whatever he wants, forgive him, and move on. I am not suggesting that you dwell on it but you must not just sit back and just let him be. That kind of behavior leads to more abuse. In my book, his nattering about your weight is nothing but abuse!!! If a man hits a woman, she doesn’t just sit around and forgive him. She makes sure the abuse is stopped. Verbal abuse is the same. I have been in a verbally abusive relationship and it is impossible to just suck it up and move on. It really does something to your psyche, your self-esteem, and your overall ability to exist.
 
40.png
ConcernCatholic:
Forgiveness IS important but it is really difficult to forgive when he makes no effort to stop the offensive behavior. Why is it that women are supposed to allow the husband to do whatever he wants, forgive him, and move on. I am not suggesting that you dwell on it but you must not just sit back and just let him be. That kind of behavior leads to more abuse. In my book, his nattering about your weight is nothing but abuse!!! If a man hits a woman, she doesn’t just sit around and forgive him. She makes sure the abuse is stopped. Verbal abuse is the same. I have been in a verbally abusive relationship and it is impossible to just suck it up and move on. It really does something to your psyche, your self-esteem, and your overall ability to exist.
How would she go about making him stop his abusive behavior? I can’t make my husband do anthing he doesn’t WANT to do. Her husband doesn’t see it as a problem - it sounds like he’s just that kind of guy who comments on women’s bodies. She’s told him repeatedly that it bothers her & he doesn’t stop. So what’s she supposed to do? Stop talking to him? Stop cleaning the house? Stop cooking for him? Stop having sex with him? Fight with him all the time? Yuck. What a crappy life that would make… for her & her chidren. Better to just try to ignore the comments - pray that he’ll have a change of heart and move on. Surely there are lots of wonderful traits he has - wouldn’t it be better to fix her mind on those?

And regarding her body image… my point was if she felt good about herself, she wouldn’t be so bothered when he pointed out other women’s bodies. She may feel good about herself at 140 pounds - or 200 pounds… that’s totally up to her. If she feels like she needs to drop some pounds to feel better (after the baby is born) - it’s within her power to do so. Being a healthy weight, eating right & excercising is good advice for EVERYONE and doesn’t cause eating disorders.
 
Lone Catholic:
…when I was complaining about not losing weight fast enough and he sent me an email that was 5 pages long telling me that I wasn’t trying hard enough and that I owed it to him to be “hot” because that is what he married, and he founda marriage book that says a man has the NEED to have an attractive spouse. Needless to say, this didn’t do much for our marriage. In counseling, he never really said he should not have said these things, he basically thought he was right and had the right to voice his opinion. He did apologize for hurting me though. I got through it by offering it up and trying to see my losing weight as a ministry to him and to try to love him unconditionally and forgive him for the hurt. I guess I feel that it wasn’t truly resolved. I did work on letting it go, but those words are burned forever in my memory.

…So where do I go from here? And am I over-reacting?
You are clearly a much finer person than I because had that been my husband he would **still **be explaining the dent in his skull that came from me bouncing that marital advice book he quoted off his forehead!!

I have to admit it is a HUGE pet pieve of mine when men even suggest, hint or in any way insinuate their wives are less attractive/overweight, etc. while in the midst of bearing their children. My husband, perhaps responding to the instinct of self-preservation, was a model husband during my pregnancies–full of compliments and attention. He even gained weight right along with me. I went from 115 to 160lbs.–so I know what you’re talking about when you say you put on weight–and it *will *come off again, in time and with a little effort.

I can’t tell if you husband is heading down that path with his recent comments, but clearly he needs a bit of sensitivity training–and 2x4 right between the eyes might be just the ticket–and that’s just to get his attention 😉 !! May God bless you with a healthy pregnancy–even if it means a few extra pounds. Nature knows what the babies need and provides accordingly. Go with the flow and worry about “your figure” once you’re off the nest!!
 
carol marie:
How would she go about making him stop his abusive behavior? I can’t make my husband do anthing he doesn’t WANT to do. Her husband doesn’t see it as a problem - it sounds like he’s just that kind of guy who comments on women’s bodies. She’s told him repeatedly that it bothers her & he doesn’t stop. So what’s she supposed to do? Stop talking to him? Stop cleaning the house? Stop cooking for him? Stop having sex with him? Fight with him all the time? Yuck. What a crappy life that would make… for her & her chidren. .
Having a mom that is bothered because Dad is constantly bugging her is a good thing? Sometimes telling somebody isn’t enough. You have to DO something to really get the point across. I am not suggesting that a person fight or anything else. I just think too many women sit back and take whatever is given to them from the husband. None of my Catholic teachings have ever said anywhere that a wife is supposed to take abuse from a spouse. I know some of you may not see this as abuse but it can be the beginning of a potentially bad situation. It is OK to bug her about her weight, oh then what about hair color, oh, wait, I don’t like your voice. When does a person stop and say that is enough??? I don’t have the answer as to how to make him stop but something has to be done. Ignoring it so it will go away just does not work!!!
carol marie:
And regarding her body image… my point was if she felt good about herself, she wouldn’t be so bothered when he pointed out other women’s bodies. She may feel good about herself at 140 pounds - or 200 pounds… that’s totally up to her. If she feels like she needs to drop some pounds to feel better (after the baby is born) - it’s within her power to do so. Being a healthy weight, eating right & excercising is good advice for EVERYONE and doesn’t cause eating disorders.
You missed my point completely!!! If dad is going around commenting and pointing out other women’s bodies, then what are the children learning. It is not about being bothered as to whether or not your husband is pointing out other women’s bodies. It is a matter of pure respect. This is a tasteless thing to do and it shows a lack of respect on the part of the husband. I agree that it is up to the woman if she wants to change her body. But, when children hear parents nitpicking each other over weight (or any other issue) it sends a bad message to the kids. Kids see the weight issues everywhere they look. Home should be a place where ALL family members are accepted no matter what!!! Mom shouldn’t constantly be put down or compared to other women.

BTW, she is pregnant. Who doesn’t have size issues when they are pregnant? I am 3 months along and feel like the good year blimp. (Maybe that is why this issue bugs me so much 🙂 )

You are in my prayers!
 
40.png
ConcernCatholic:
Having a mom that is bothered because Dad is constantly bugging her is a good thing? Sometimes telling somebody isn’t enough. You have to DO something to really get the point across. I am not suggesting that a person fight or anything else. I just think too many women sit back and take whatever is given to them from the husband. None of my Catholic teachings have ever said anywhere that a wife is supposed to take abuse from a spouse. I know some of you may not see this as abuse but it can be the beginning of a potentially bad situation. It is OK to bug her about her weight, oh then what about hair color, oh, wait, I don’t like your voice. When does a person stop and say that is enough??? I don’t have the answer as to how to make him stop but something has to be done. Ignoring it so it will go away just does not work!!!

You missed my point completely!!! If dad is going around commenting and pointing out other women’s bodies, then what are the children learning. It is not about being bothered as to whether or not your husband is pointing out other women’s bodies. It is a matter of pure respect. This is a tasteless thing to do and it shows a lack of respect on the part of the husband. I agree that it is up to the woman if she wants to change her body. But, when children hear parents nitpicking each other over weight (or any other issue) it sends a bad message to the kids. Kids see the weight issues everywhere they look. Home should be a place where ALL family members are accepted no matter what!!! Mom shouldn’t constantly be put down or compared to other women.

BTW, she is pregnant. Who doesn’t have size issues when they are pregnant? I am 3 months along and feel like the good year blimp. (Maybe that is why this issue bugs me so much 🙂 )

You are in my prayers!
Concern Catholic,
I am 8 months along and quite blimpy myself !!! 🙂

You make some valid points. I didn’t consider that the children may be hearing their father’s comments about the other women’s bodies… you are right… that isn’t a good thing. 😦

I’m just not sure what she can do about it? I think it’s a serious character flaw on his part - maybe he has issues about getting older - gaining weight himself etc… isn’t feeling so stud-like and he’s thinking that a thin wife on his arm would make HIM look better? Or maybe he’s just imature with a bad sense of humor and knows that it bugs her so like a bratty kid - he pushes her buttons? Who knows… but she did say he had other wonderful qualities and I’m just thinking since she stuck with him - for better or for worse - maybe she should just think about those… rather than this (obnoxious) part of him she can’t do a thing about?

She sounds like a very mature, nice person so maybe she can take the high road for the sake of peace in the family. It takes two to fight… and fighting takes alot of effort & makes everyone miserable. So if I were her… I’d give it over to God and wait on Him to help her husband appreciate that his comments are mean.

Blessings to all,
CM
 
How about this…every time her DH makes a comment about another woman looking FABULOUS she says out loud…'OK, THERE’S ANOTHER PACKAGE OF OREO COOKIES I’M GOING TO BUY TOMORROW!!! gee, honey, maybe you should look into the name of the parent company and buy some stock…at the rate you’re going, we’ll be able to afford that BEACH HOUSE IN MALIBU for our RETIREMENT HOME"…then start LAUGHING at the top of her lungs…

well, it’s a thought…😉
 
40.png
LSK:
How about this…every time her DH makes a comment about another woman looking FABULOUS she says out loud…'OK, THERE’S ANOTHER PACKAGE OF OREO COOKIES I’M GOING TO BUY TOMORROW!!! gee, honey, maybe you should look into the name of the parent company and buy some stock…at the rate you’re going, we’ll be able to afford that BEACH HOUSE IN MALIBU for our RETIREMENT HOME"…then start LAUGHING at the top of her lungs…

well, it’s a thought…😉
Hey, I like the way you think…OK, a bit juvenile but it sure sounds fun 😛

CM: I see your points. I guess I am just too unwilling to compromise on some things and this is one of them. I was in an abusive relationship and it started out something like this. I know how hurtful this can be and even though he has great qualities, it is sometimes difficult to get past depending on the frequency. I know that I used to get hopping mad when people would tell me to suck it up and move on. All I wanted was someone to validate my feelings. Making excuses for him only made me feel worse. (ie…That’s just the way he is…it is a character flaw…etc…)
 
40.png
Ronin:
I think you need to show your ever-loving hubby who follows you into the shower with a measuring tape your state’s divorce laws and child support calculation sheets… Once he sees how much he would have to pay I bet he will start treating you like the most gorgeous creature God ever put on this planet… probably buy you a nice big box of bon bon’s too…
I’m not interested in a divorce, and I don’t want my husband to act like he loves me because he’s scared of the financial difficulties of a divorce!!!

I’m here looking for advice on how to HELP my marriage, not to leave it.
 
As for the discussion about what to do when someone is treating us with a remarkable lack of courtesy, I firmly believe that we TEACH people how to treat us. When we excuse criticism and thinly-veiled rude remarks as “jokes,” we’re teaching the other person that behaving in that way is appropriate. A minor protest only once in awhile, plenty of silence or the worst–laughing along with the antagonist, simply reinforces the other person to believe that they are totally within their rights to continue speaking that way to us.

If someone says something that is extremely offensive or insensitive to me, then I address it immediately. I don’t care if it’s a child or a friend or a parent or a stranger or a peer or a co-worker. I expect courtesy and there are plenty of ways to set that expectation in a kind but firm way. Fortunately those times have been few and far between, but people generally feel entitled to express their opinion and some are more skilled at tact then others. However, I am also blessed with a very sensitive husband who doesn’t have an unkind or judgemental bone in his body. I can’t imagine having these sort of comments to deal with in my very own home.

I don’t buy that a husband who truly is seeking to love his wife will absolutely refuse to cease his unkind behavior when confronted again and again with the result of his comments–his wife’s protests, hurt feelings, frustration and dislike. But, if we laugh along with him or don’t let him know how we feel each and every time it happens, we’re just encouraging him to belittle us. If he claims that’s not his intention–great, but that still doesn’t change how his behavior is perceived and he should respect his wife’s feelings about comments he chooses to make specifically about her, to her.

I don’t think it’s necessary to stop doing laundry, having sex, making dinner, etc. 🙂 But when a husband is continuing to make extraordinarily insensitive comments, then at some point he’ll notice that it’s destroying intimacy, affection and trust–not even consciously, perhaps, on the part of the wife–but by the very nature of his behavior. If a woman is told she’s fat all the time, how much is she really going to want to get naked with her husband? How many of us want to feel judged by those who share our very flesh? As for the husband’s end of it–if he truly loves his wife, he wants to be a source of encouragement and not detraction. Motivating someone to lose weight is usually best done with love and care, not judgement, jokes and rude assessments. However, wives have to let him know each and every time a joke or rude remark is made that it is NOT acceptable. Preferrably in the moment.
 
40.png
Princess_Abby:
As for the discussion about what to do when someone is treating us with a remarkable lack of courtesy, I firmly believe that we TEACH people how to treat us. When we excuse criticism and thinly-veiled rude remarks as “jokes,” we’re teaching the other person that behaving in that way is appropriate. A minor protest only once in awhile, plenty of silence or the worst–laughing along with the antagonist, simply reinforces the other person to believe that they are totally within their rights to continue speaking that way to us.

If someone says something that is extremely offensive or insensitive to me, then I address it immediately. I don’t care if it’s a child or a friend or a parent or a stranger or a peer or a co-worker. I expect courtesy and there are plenty of ways to set that expectation in a kind but firm way. Fortunately those times have been few and far between, but people generally feel entitled to express their opinion and some are more skilled at tact then others. However, I am also blessed with a very sensitive husband who doesn’t have an unkind or judgemental bone in his body. I can’t imagine having these sort of comments to deal with in my very own home.

I don’t buy that a husband who truly is seeking to love his wife will absolutely refuse to cease his unkind behavior when confronted again and again with the result of his comments–his wife’s protests, hurt feelings, frustration and dislike. But, if we laugh along with him or don’t let him know how we feel each and every time it happens, we’re just encouraging him to belittle us. If he claims that’s not his intention–great, but that still doesn’t change how his behavior is perceived and he should respect his wife’s feelings about comments he chooses to make specifically about her, to her.

I don’t think it’s necessary to stop doing laundry, having sex, making dinner, etc. 🙂 But when a husband is continuing to make extraordinarily insensitive comments, then at some point he’ll notice that it’s destroying intimacy, affection and trust–not even consciously, perhaps, on the part of the wife–but by the very nature of his behavior. If a woman is told she’s fat all the time, how much is she really going to want to get naked with her husband? How many of us want to feel judged by those who share our very flesh? As for the husband’s end of it–if he truly loves his wife, he wants to be a source of encouragement and not detraction. Motivating someone to lose weight is usually best done with love and care, not judgement, jokes and rude assessments. However, wives have to let him know each and every time a joke or rude remark is made that it is NOT acceptable. Preferrably in the moment.
Princess Abby–You have a way of striking a perfect balance! ConcernCatholic and Carol Marie–You both make some very good points, and I can see where you are both coming from.

I think Princess Abby shows that there is a middle ground between your two seemingly conflicting advices. It is hard for me to know the middle ground. What is just “taking it” and what is putting up an unnecessary fight? I have felt like I have done both sometimes.

By the way, dh did say he would stop with any comments. He really has not said anything about me needing to lose weight since our little altercation back last February that sent us to counseling. I think he knows not to come out and say anything. My problem is that I KNOW he still feels those things. He still will readily admit that it is a NEED of his, to have an attractive spouse, and he will not apologize for saying he needs this or for encouraging me to look my “best”. But having him never relent on these feelings, following by the gaping at VS commercials, talking about other women’s bodies, little comments… each little thing, which in and of itself would not be THAT big of a deal… just sends me spiraling down.

And about refusing to have sex-- This is a HUGE issue to me. The LAST thing I want to right now is to be intimate with him. ugh. It is not to me a way of punishing him, I just can’t bear the thought of it right now.
 
Tell him you can lose weight but he can’t change the size of something else 😉 Just kidding …

Anyway, your husband has a very shallow attitude. He hasn’t carried your children and hasn’t had to experience the physical changes that brings. It would be one thing if he were concerned for your health, if there was enough weight to give him cause to be, but for his own pleasure, that’s just rude. Does he have huge muscles? Is he balding? Abs of steel? I’m willing to bet he’s not perfect.

What’s 10 lbs anyway, really? It’s a shame he doesn’t value you for who you are rather than what you can give him.
 
I am very sorry you’ve had to endure these comments from the one person who should cherish you more then any other person on the planet. I wish I had some good advise for you but I don’t. I really do not understand men (or women) that are fixated on personal appearance.

I am the same height as you and I would have to starve myself to maintain a weight of 125. I was a size 5 when I met my hubby but I was also 16 years old at the time. Now I am a 12 with only having one child. I do need to loose weight, because of major heart condition I have it is better for my heart to be slim. I did get down to 130 a couple of years ago after alot of work but we’ve had some big finacial stress over the last year and I’ve gain back all the weight I’ve lost.

I would be crushed if my hubby sent me a 5 page email about deserving a hot wife. Medication I’m on is making my hair fall out. The one thing I’ve always loved is having long beautiful hair and now it’s short and thin. Without my husband’s reasurrances about me being beautiful him I would find this whole trial with my health so much more difficult. I would recommend a Marriage Encounter weekend, if nothing else it will help your husband’s communication skills and probably his undersatnding of how hurtful he is being.

The only thing I can think of is that your husband hasn’t had many trials in life. Was he spoiled as a kid? Did his parents give him everything he wanted? My husband knows I have a 50% chance of dying within the next 5 years (I’m only 33), trust me my waist line is the least of his concerns. You hubby has a healthy wife, who’s given him 4 wonderful children. Do you know what my husband would give for me to healthy, for me to be able to have the large family that I always wanted. You husband has a treasure before him and he’s so blinded by society’s twisted values that he can’t even see it.

My prayers are with you. God Bless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top