Animal Biotechnology and Guided Evolution

  • Thread starter Thread starter Camron
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I will start with your last reply and work backwards …
Ok, that’s ok, but I’m going to be interjecting at a few points from in between the posts…
Well, I think we should look again at the title of this thread. We’re talking about “Guided Evolution” (among other things) and that poses a problem because it suggests that there could be “Unguided Evolution” also.
True, but I think this addresses a larger problem with detecting intelligence.
Unguided evolution would be a matter of “the natural laws create everything”. This is like an avalanche – some rocks roll down the mountain due to natural laws. This is an “unguided process”.
But exactly how “unguided” is the landslide?

Remember the example of Satan and Job and the windstorm that devastated Job’s family?

In reference to the windstorm that devastated Job’s family in Job 1:18-19, when I illustrated that it may even be that the rebellious angels caused turmoil within the laws themselves, leaving them so that they appear to be randomly acting out brutally mindless carnages, you said that you find this to be very good also.

If so then how would one use scientific principles to adduce the intelligence that guided the windstorm, if indeed this is the case?
If when the rocks reached the bottom they formed themselves into a statue of the Pieta – then we’d have reason to think that the process was “guided” somehow.
True, but we don’t even have to have to have an outstanding arrangement of rocks to think that the process was guided somehow. Even if the rocks were haphazardly strewn about, it could still be the case that someone caused the landslide to fall according to a particular purpose.

In the negative sense, it may be a case of someone detonating an explosive device to sabotage an area to cause damage to their enemy.

Or, in the positive sense, it may be a case of someone detonating an explosive device to create a crudely formed bridge to pass over troubled waters.

The pile of rubble does not need to have miraculously formed themselves into a statue of the Pieta in order for someone to infer that an intelligent agent was responsible for the rocks falling. And, if this is the case, it can certainly be said that God could likewise use these same types of events and happenings to bring about His will too.
 
Because normally, the natural laws don’t create specified complex objects like a sublime work of figurative art (although evolutionary theory would say it is “possible” that rocks could do that – so where are the limits to what science, natural law or evolution can produce?).
But, over time, and given many overlapping periods of formation, they most certainly could create specified complex objects like a sublime work of figurative art.

Here’s one example…

http://news.cnet.com/i/ne/p/2008/123marsmanclose550x404.jpg

And here’s another…

http://www.alienzoo.com/images/marsface.gif

What the…? :confused:

Ok, so it may be that we don’t see this happening often. But given that all the events could hypothetically work this way, we should be cautious before saying that it’s impossible.

Consequently, I don’t think that the various examples given by the ID movement have been successfully linked with a sublime work of figurative art, not from a scientific perspective anyway. The examples given by the ID movement can be explained by biological evolutionary factors, even if we don’t have conclusive evidence that these are strictly the results of these evolutionary pressures.
Again, I don’t think you’re following my example. One does not normally think that an avalanche is a “guided” process.
The Bible portrayed the windstorm in Job 1:18-19 as being a “guided process”.

The Bible also says that the Lord’s way is the whirlwind and the storm – and clouds are the dust of his feet, according to Nahum 1:3.

Clearly these are, in a sense, poetic statements meant to convey the sovereignty of God’s influence and is not meant to be taken literally. And yet, according to the Divine Inspiration of the Bible, it is also clear that these events have been brought about according to God’s will working through nature, something which is His creation.
It’s merely the function of natural laws.
So was the windstorm in Job 1:18-19, and yet the Bible attributes this to a spiritual factors which science cannot prove.

The same could be said of the wind rustling in the tree-tops that was regarded as an angel according to 2 Samuel 5:23-24 and 1 Chronicles 14:14, 15.

As the Catholic Encyclopedia indicates, something like this is more explicitly stated with regard to the pool of Probatica according John 5:1-4. Although there is some doubt about the text, in that passage the disturbance of the water is said to be due to the periodic visits of an angel.

The Jewish people clearly felt that all the orderly harmony of the universe, as well as interruptions of that harmony, were due to God as their originator, but were carried out by His ministers. I have no problem with this. I just don’t think that science has the capacity to prove that these events were triggered by an angel’s presence.
Additionally, we do not think it is evidence of intelligent design because rocks can roll down a mountain due to explainable laws. The micro-machines found in a cell, however, are inexplicable by evolutionary theory, and that kind of specified complexity is only the product of intelligent causes as far as we know. Therefore, that should be the proposed cause of such things until proven otherwise.
Hmmm, before I go further, could you explain how the micro-machines found in a cell are inexplicable by evolutionary theory?

I don’t believe this to be true. It may be that it is unknown how this happened, and even this much I honestly doubt (because there are explanations available). Nonetheless, I think it’s misleading to claim that the micro-machines found in a cell are “inexplicable” by evolutionary theory. It may be difficult to explain. But it’s not impossible.

Since this word can be used in two sensea, I have to ask which sense are you using the word inexplicable when saying that the micro-machines found in a cell are “inexplicable” by evolutionary theory?
But a wind storm causing a tree to fall is accidental. It is also “blind” because it just falls due to the natural law. If the tree acted in some manner that could not be explained by natural laws, then we would question if it was accidental.
What about the examples I gave above regarding Job 1:18-19, 2 Samuel 5:23-24,and John 5:1-4?

How would we use science to determine these events were miraculously caused?
 
Yes, micromachines found in a cell are inexplicable by evolutionary theory. A flagellum needs energy to operate, which the cell needs to provide. It needs a motor to operate, which must be constructed. The usefulness of the flagellum to propel the cell must take into account the cell’s environment. It cannot operate indiscrimantly but be used to propel the cell to a useful goal. The flagellum turns at thousands of RPMs. The notion that the flagellum existed as some floating independent part before attaching itself to some random cell is not logical. Even if it could, it would have to integrate itself into the cell’s existing machinery and the cell would need some way to add instructions to build it to its own genetic code, so it can reproduce with the flagellum included.

Peace,
Ed
 
Yes, micromachines found in a cell are blah, blah, blah…
Actually, I’m still waiting for an explanation as to whether you were replying to my post when you said, “This view is false and inconsistent with the truths of the Bible”.

Who exactly were you talking to?

And if you were talking to me, then a) why didn’t you address me and b) why didn’t you explain exactly why you felt this.

No offence, but you’ve basically accused me of maligning God, claiming that I’ve said God is not the creator, which is not true.

God is all good and He is our creator.

Now please answer the questions I’ve asked you without making your usual innuendo or else just shut up already.

Peace.
Cameron
 
Yes, micromachines found in a cell are inexplicable by evolutionary theory.
This is incorrect. Your creationist sources are misleading you. See Evolution of the Flagellum.

See also Evolution of Flagella (yes, there is more than one type of flagellum)

Flagella are explicable by evolutionary theory, your creationist sources were wrong.
A flagellum needs energy to operate, which the cell needs to provide.
A cell needs energy to operate many of its processes, all of which it provides using the standard ATP <-> ADP system.
It needs a motor to operate,
All motion in cells and in higher organisms is provided by molecular motors of one sort or another - our muscles use one sort of motor, the different types of flagella use different types of motor. Motors of one sort or another can evolve very easily.
which must be constructed.
Every part of a cell must be constructed. That is what the DNA → RNA → protein system is there for, producing the correct proteins for cell construction.
The usefulness of the flagellum to propel the cell must take into account the cell’s environment. It cannot operate indiscrimantly but be used to propel the cell to a useful goal.
Why? Sometimes movement on its own is useful. If a bacterium is using up local resources then movement to any new locality is useful. You are making the system appear more complex than it needs to be.
The flagellum turns at thousands of RPMs.
Some flagella do, others do not. Remember there is more than one type of flagellum.
The notion that the flagellum existed as some floating independent part before attaching itself to some random cell is not logical.
Not a whole bacterial flagellum, but the individual bits of a flagellum could. There are bacteria with non-rotating spines which resemble the long filament of the flagellum. The type three secretory system resembles the mechanism which builds the filament from the base of the flagellum. The motor resembles other motors used elsewhere in the cell. The great majority of essential proteins used in the construction of the bacterial flagellum have analogues elsewhere in the cell. See here for details of the protein homologies.
Even if it could, it would have to integrate itself into the cell’s existing machinery and the cell would need some way to add instructions to build it to its own genetic code, so it can reproduce with the flagellum included.
Much of the machinery and/or proteins was already present for other purposes and was adapted for use in the bacterial flagellum.

There is enough evidence to show that the evolution of the bacterial flagellum is possible using standard evolutionary mechanisms.

rossum
 
But, over time, and given many overlapping periods of formation, they most certainly could create specified complex objects like a sublime work of figurative art.

Here’s one example…

http://news.cnet.com/i/ne/p/2008/123marsmanclose550x404.jpg

And here’s another…
Certainly, one can propose that certain aspects of nature meet a criterion of specificity and complexity – but that’s Intelligent Design science at work. Some definition of design can be developed and then aspects of nature can be evalutated by it. If a natural cause can be found, then the idea is falsified.
The Bible portrayed the windstorm in Job 1:18-19 as being a “guided process”.
The Bible also says that the Lord’s way is the whirlwind and the storm – and clouds are the dust of his feet, according to Nahum 1:3.
I’m very glad to consider these examples, but I’ll say that our conversation will take a radically different direction at that point. If we want to use the Holy Scriptures to determine what God created, how He created it, and how He influenced the development of nature – then I can’t see how Darwinian theory could survive (considering that you’re accepting some literal truth to the Bible stories, as you do here). The Holy Scriptures give ample evidence for Intelligent Design theory – as you’ve done in other instances. Catholic scientists must accept some aspect of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous.
And yet, according to the Divine Inspiration of the Bible, it is also clear that these events have been brought about according to God’s will working through nature, something which is His creation.
Is the working of God in nature something that we can observe and detect? If so, then it is possible that it can be defined.
So was the windstorm in Job 1:18-19, and yet the Bible attributes this to a spiritual factors which science cannot prove.
The same could be said of the wind rustling in the tree-tops that was regarded as an angel according to 2 Samuel 5:23-24 and 1 Chronicles 14:14, 15.
I’m willing to accept that angels move the tree-tops and also that God parted the Red Sea, caused manna to come down from the sky, and caused people to rise up to heaven body and soul. These are all events that can be observed and which cannot be explained by natural laws.
As the Catholic Encyclopedia indicates, something like this is more explicitly stated with regard to the pool of Probatica according John 5:1-4. Although there is some doubt about the text, in that passage the disturbance of the water is said to be due to the periodic visits of an angel.
If the Prophet teaches us that the angel stirred the water, then we have to believe his word, because we have no other evidence. The same is not true of the parting of the Sea, for example. One could observe that an unusual action had taken place.
I just don’t think that science has the capacity to prove that these events were triggered by an angel’s presence.
Nor can science prove that any species evolved from another species. But this doesn’t stop scientists from saying that this is our “best explanation at present”. Therefore, when science encounters St. Pio and his many miracles, science can affirm that he exhibited qualities that go beyond the natural laws and that one should take his word for the action of God present in his life (and not consider him insane or deluded until proven otherwise). But, unfortunately, materialist philosophy does not permit this.
Hmmm, before I go further, could you explain how the micro-machines found in a cell are inexplicable by evolutionary theory?
By “inexplicable” I mean that no evolutionary path has been demonstrated. Of course, everything in nature – including all of the things we have never seen before, are “explicable” by evolutionary theory. One merely needs to say that something “could have evolved” in any vast number of ways.
This renders evolutionary hypotheses useless and frivolous (see the case of the peacock’s feathers). One can imagine any sort of scenario. In some cases, where no evolutionary evidence can be found, it is claimed that the object in question is a “remnant” of past evolutionary processes.
One does not need to have any facts to offer “explanations” about what evolution “could have done”.
But in the case of cellular micro-machines, there is no evidence to show how these organisms developed through evolutionary processes.
Nonetheless, I think it’s misleading to claim that the micro-machines found in a cell are “inexplicable” by evolutionary theory. It may be difficult to explain. But it’s not impossible.
I also think it’s misleading to claim that unfounded speculations, which are pure fiction, are “explanations” for how micro-machines evolved (or if they evolved at all).
 
What about the examples I gave above regarding Job 1:18-19, 2 Samuel 5:23-24,and John 5:1-4?
How would we use science to determine these events were miraculously caused?
I think it’s simple enough to approach this with the limits of what science can determine.
In the case of St. Job, we have this:
18While he was still speaking, another also came and said, “Your sons and your daughters were eating and drinking wine in their oldest brother’s house,
19and behold, a great wind came from across the wilderness and struck the four corners of the house, and it fell on the young people and they died, and I alone have escaped to tell you.”
Now we want to use science to determine if this was a miracle.
Ok, first we have to determine whether Job existed or not.
How would science do that?
First, by checking every bit of evidence that one can find to figure out when and where Job lived and what records we have about him. Then, we need to determine where his oldest son’s house was. We could then check the weather for that particular time. If it was shown that there was zero wind anywhere in the area on that day, and that no other properties suffered wind damage except for that house which suddently was blown to the ground (we investigate how strongly the house was built also), and we observe that there were no other natural or human forces or causes that could have resulted in the four corners of the house collapsing … then, we add the claims of St. Job, an honest and honorable man, known as a Prophet of God, and as Catholic scientists we conclude: “there is no scientific explanation for the sudden collapse of that house. There was no wind recorded anywhere in the near vicinity that day, no storms, nothing of the strength and power needed to collapse a stone house. St. Job stated it was a miracle. As scientsts we can see no reason why this event was not a miracle and we assert that it was until other evidence can be shown otherwise.”

We can proceed with the next one:
23When David inquired of the LORD, He said, “You shall not go directly up; circle around behind them and come at them in front of the balsam trees.
24"It shall be, when you hear the sound of marching in the tops of the balsam trees, then you shall act promptly, for then the LORD will have gone out before you to strike the army of the Philistines.”
This is certainly more difficult and more subtle. Here we have “the sound of marching” in the tops of the trees.
For science to evaluate this, we’d need more corroborating evidence – statements from other people, etc.
Obviously, science has severe limits when trying to determine the cause of transitory events in the past.
Again, this doesn’t stop evolutionists from making all sorts of claims about what “could have happened”.
In this case, though, we have no snapshot in time to determine if there was the sound of marching in the trees.
If we had the testimony of 20,000 people who could be validated somehow … then a miraculous event would be “the best explanation we have so far”.

This is true of more recent events. Certainly, the Fatima miracles, the story of St. Bernadette, as I mentioned — St. Pio, and others.

Evolution teaches that we are in competition with others and this is the sole driver of development and growth.
But Our Blessed Lord gave us a radically different teaching:
Matt. 6: 28-30
Why are you anxious about clothes? Learn from the way the wild flowers grow. They do not work or spin.
But I tell you that not even Solomon in all his splendor was clothed like one of them.
If God so clothes the grass of the field, which grows today and is thrown into the oven tomorrow, will he not much more provide for you, O you of little faith?
So do not worry and say, ‘What are we to eat?’ or ‘What are we to drink?’ or ‘What are we to wear?’
God has “clothed” the lilies of the field. We are to “learn from” the wild flowers. They are clothed in a splendor which is greater than what Solomon ever had.

This is a clear refutation of Darwinian theory. The flowers are clothed by God – not by mutations. We are to thank God – for his creation. To claim that flowers are accidental by-products of mutations and physical laws, is to deny these words of Jesus. He is directing us to see God’s creative power – His design, in the clothing of flowers.
 
Not a whole bacterial flagellum, but the individual bits of a flagellum could.
They would have to assemble themselves as if mapped to a plan for their future. There is no known process that could put those parts together in such a complex and precise mechanism.
The pressures that supposedly move natural selection are not present at the molecular level.
 
Certainly, one can propose that certain aspects of nature meet a criterion of specificity and complexity – but that’s Intelligent Design science at work.
I accept that there are forensic sciences and anthropological humanities within archaeology that can reasonably determine that an intelligent cause has occurred. But when one starts to talk about analyzing nature itself in that way this leads to a big mess of problems. I’m not saying they are insurmountable. But they are exceedingly difficult to determine without the eyes of faith, which is mostly my point. I don’t think we can psychoanalyze nature in order to determine God’s will.
Some definition of design can be developed and then aspects of nature can be evalutated by it. If a natural cause can be found, then the idea is falsified.
For the record I wouldn’t say they are falsified. It only demonstrates that a natural explanation could be the reason behind the event happening.
I’m very glad to consider these examples, but I’ll say that our conversation will take a radically different direction at that point. If we want to use the Holy Scriptures to determine what God created, how He created it, and how He influenced the development of nature – then I can’t see how Darwinian theory could survive (considering that you’re accepting some literal truth to the Bible stories, as you do here).
Again, I simply don’t see why it has to be an either/or proposition. God could have used evolutionary methods to bring about the various species. And I don’t see any solid reason why He could not have done this.
The Holy Scriptures give ample evidence for Intelligent Design theory – as you’ve done in other instances. Catholic scientists must accept some aspect of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous.
I think that’s true only to an extent.

Catholic scientists, if they are indeed true to their faith, must accept only the possibility of some aspects of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous, but only insofar that they are not permitted to outright say that it’s impossible for God to have directly intervened. Clearly, according to the Biblical record, there are ample examples of ways by which God could have acted on His creation in the past. But, on the other side of the argument, Catholic scientists, if they are indeed true to their faith, must also accept the possibility of some aspects of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous not applying in the degree that science can directly measure His presence.
Is the working of God in nature something that we can observe and detect? If so, then it is possible that it can be defined.
I think that reason and revelation can detect this. I do not think that science can do this though.
I’m willing to accept that angels move the tree-tops and also that God parted the Red Sea, caused manna to come down from the sky, and caused people to rise up to heaven body and soul. These are all events that can be observed and which cannot be explained by natural laws.
I think the moving of the tree-tops can be explained by natural events, such as the wind for example.

The parting of the Red Sea, although much less likely so, could also have a natural explanation to, as I’m sure you’re aware. Myself, since the Bible describes the parting as follows…
By the blast of your nostrils the waters piled up. The surging waters stood firm like a wall; the deep waters congealed in the heart of the sea.
Exodus 15:8​
…I’m less inclined to accept that this is simply a windstorm blowing the waters back. But I think you understand what I mean.

Manna literally means “What is this?” And it could also have a natural explanation too.

For example, angel’s hair is a wispy and flakey edible thing which has been observed to fall from the sky and quickly dissipate (some times it’s justfound on the ground. Of course, people who have observed this angel’s hair still don’t know exactly what it is (some think it is spider’s web), which reminds me of the Jewish people encountering the Manna.

Some think it could be from Tamarisk trees (particularly Tamarix Gallica), which were once comparatively extensive throughout the southern parts of the Sinai Peninsula. Their resin is similar to wax, melts in the sun, is sweet and aromatic (like honey), and has a dirty-yellow colour, fitting somewhat with the biblical descriptions of manna.

Still others think it could be a kind of fungi, since most of characteristics of manna are similar to that of psilocybe cubensis.

I’m not saying that these are the cases. It could be something totally new created literally from nothing, something that specifically attests to God’s creative power. I’m only saying that there are natural events recorded in history which could conceivably explain these events without recourse to the miraculous.

Finally, regarding the raising from the dead, I totally agree with you. This miracle, unlike the other miracles noted above, could not have a natural explanation.
 
If the Prophet teaches us that the angel stirred the water, then we have to believe his word, because we have no other evidence.
I think it’s possible that the Prophet may have taught us what the people believed and that the Prophet themselves may not have actually believed it. In other words, it is a matter of dogma to believe that Jesus literally rose from the dead, and I believe this. I do not think, however, that it is a matter of dogma to believe that an angel stirred the water in the pool.
The same is not true of the parting of the Sea, for example. One could observe that an unusual action had taken place.
True, but I’ve honestly never heard of water standing firm like a wall for the duration it took the Israelites to cross the Red Sea.
Nor can science prove that any species evolved from another species.
But science can reasonably infer that many species gradually evolved other species via the fossil record alone, which is what science is supposed to do. It can also match up the genetic paths along the DNA from species to species to effectively p(name removed by moderator)oint how various species are indeed distantly related, just as some do when a paternity test is done. We can also see the development of species along certain biomes within the geological history of the world, noting how they respond to changes to some extent. This is some powerful inference Reggie. People who do not believe in God are not going to abandon the theory of evolution based on a few anomalous details which don’t quite fit into the theory.
But this doesn’t stop scientists from saying that this is our “best explanation at present”.
Correction: It’s the "best natural explanation at present”.

Barring supernatural intervention, what other explanation even comes close to the explanatory power of the theory of evolution?

Nothing. Therefore, it really is the best natural explanation at present. It doesn’t automatically mean this makes it correct. Only that, using totally natural means, the theory of evolution is really the best natural explanation at present.
Therefore, when science encounters St. Pio and his many miracles, science can affirm that he exhibited qualities that go beyond the natural laws and that one should take his word for the action of God present in his life (and not consider him insane or deluded until proven otherwise). But, unfortunately, materialist philosophy does not permit this.
Yes, but then we’re not talking about good science. We’re now talking about bad philosophy.
 
They would have to assemble themselves as if mapped to a plan for their future. There is no known process that could put those parts together in such a complex and precise mechanism.
There is such a process and it is called evolution. The original bacterial flagellum would have been woefully inefficient compared with the current version, but since it was the original it would have had an advantage over everything else which had no flagellum at all. The improvements came later. Think of a Ford Model T compared with modern cars.
The pressures that supposedly move natural selection are not present at the molecular level.
You are sadly misinformed here. Antibiotics are molecules and act at the molecular level. Natural selection works perfectly well at the molecular level as we see bacteria evolving immunily to antibiotics. DDT is a molecule and we see insects evolving immunity to DDT. Your point here fails.

rossum
 
To rossum -

In storytelling, I can create a plausible sounding scenario to explain virtually anything. Those involved in the evolution story suggest that an unknown process created a part or device for an unknown purpose and further, that this part somehow knew it could connect itself to another object to perform a useful function. This is based on the idea that given enough time and enough chemical reactions, literally anything can happen.

What is not addressed are all the steps necessary to get from point A to point B. Assuming that the first flagellum was primitive, how did it construct itself? Where and how did it get the information to build a motor for itself? And what was it doing prior to figuring out it could connect itself to a cell? Just sort of swimming around? Where did its energy come from? Its motor energy? The biggest problem would be attaching to a cell and then, through some unknown process, transferring its reproduction instructions into the cell’s machinery. How does the cell know how to control the motor?

All of the above gives ‘nature’ an intelligence that everyone swears it does not have. Random mutation and natural selection are not enough. Evolution is not goal oriented, as science will tell you. Science says we are the product of a cold, uncaring universe that did not have us in mind. So clearly, none of this could be attributed to God. Unless, of course, His divine providence is made part of it, as the Church teaches.

But science, we are told, can never do this.

Peace,
Ed
 
In storytelling, I can create a plausible sounding scenario to explain virtually anything.
Agreed. Science calls these stories hypotheses. Science also provides a method of testing those hypotheses and eliminating the ones that do not correspond to relity. The hypotheses that survive the testing become theories. Evolution has survivrd 150 years of testing and is now a well established theory.
Those involved in the evolution story suggest that an unknown process created a part or device for an unknown purpose and further,
The process known, not unknown: random mutation, natural selection, genetic drift, founder effect and the other known and observed mechanisms.
that this part somehow knew
Does oxygen “know” that it has to connect to two hydrogen atoms to make water? Your use of anthropomorphic imagery here is inaccurate. Biological chemicals link together using the standard known chemical bonds.
it could connect itself to another object to perform a useful function.
It connected using chemistry. The resulting object could have a neutral function, a bad function or a useful function. Neutral functions would be subject to genetic drift. Bad functions would be eliminated by natural selection and useful functions would be amplified by natural selection. Evolution is not a random process. Natural selection picks up the useful functions and amplifies them by increasing their presence in the next generation.
This is based on the idea that given enough time and enough chemical reactions, literally anything can happen.
Again, you are leaving out the effects of natural selection. What you are talking about is not evolution but a strawman.
What is not addressed are all the steps necessary to get from point A to point B. Assuming that the first flagellum was primitive, how did it construct itself?
Read Evolution in (Brownian) space: a model for the origin of the bacterial flagellum for one current hypothesis.
Where and how did it get the information to build a motor for itself?
Molecular motors are present for many functions inside a cell, it probably adapted an existing motor. There are analogues for most of the motor proteins elsewhere in the cell. Indeed there are analogues for most of the flagellar proteins elsewhere in the cell. The parts needed were already present doing other functions.

For example if I wanted to evolve a motor car, I could start with a child’s pedal car and attach a lawn mower engine to it. Both have existing and different function - a toy and cutting grass - but in combination they have a new function. The flagellum arose in a similar way, by taking existing useful pieces of cell machinery and putting them together in a new way.
And what was it doing prior to figuring out it could connect itself to a cell?
All parts of the bacterial flagellum are found separately in bacteria. There are motors separate from the flagellum. There are (passive) filaments separate from the flagellum. There are secretory systems (that build the filament) separate from the flagellum. All of these have their own functions, which destroys the concept of Irreducible Complexity of the flagellum - the separate parts have a function apart from the flagellum.
Where did its energy come from? Its motor energy?
Cells already have a perfectly well functioning energy system using ATP and ADP. Are you really so ignorant of biology that you do not know that cells produce enercy from the chemicals they absorb?
The biggest problem would be attaching to a cell and then, through some unknown process, transferring its reproduction instructions into the cell’s machinery. How does the cell know how to control the motor?
Oh, you really are that ignorant of biology. You would do well to learn more before proceeding, that way you will not make so many obvious errors. The DNA to build all the components was already present in the cell for other purposes: motors, motor control systems, energy, secretory system and filament. They came together inside the cell, not outside it. Flagella are not known in the earliest bacteria, they evolved later.
All of the above gives ‘nature’ an intelligence that everyone swears it does not have. Random mutation and natural selection are not enough. Evolution is not goal oriented, as science will tell you. Science says we are the product of a cold, uncaring universe that did not have us in mind. So clearly, none of this could be attributed to God. Unless, of course, His divine providence is made part of it, as the Church teaches.
Your personal opinion would have more weight if you had studied more biology. Evolution is a process, and processes do not have a goal. It is God, who uses the process, who has the goal. A carpenter uses a saw to make some shelves. The purpose belongs to the carpenter, not to the saw. It is correct to say the evolution has no purpose, just as it is correct to say that a saw has no purpose.

rossum
 
It is quite right to mention God but He is missing from the science. Yes, I understand how cell energy works. What you appear to be missing is that plugging in a new component adds to the cell’s energy output, requiring a greater energy intake.

In reviewing the article you provided a link for, I see the same evidence of storytelling. While interesting, it was not conclusive. It relied on the old Darwinian, well, if it had a light sensing organ, even if a crude one, etc. Not convincing. It makes no sense to assume that some crude antecedant to the modern or complex flagellum existed in the first place.

And once again, there is the problem of a cell without a flagellum acquiring one. Before the addition, it reproduced itself, now it has to reproduce not only itself but its new add-on part. How does it code for this new chemical addition?

Yes, I also understand the non-random part, but it assumes a nearly infinite number of parts of all sizes, shapes and descriptions were being spit out. If I had a Volvo engine and needed a particular bolt, and assuming I had a pile of millions of bolts to choose from, I still have no idea if the correct size and shape and length of bolt I need is in that pile. Evolution assumes it is. In fact, it posits it must be.

I could write a story about 400 aliens who landed in Egypt thousands of years ago, built the pyramids, and left. It would contain lots of detail, and it would be based on the assumption that, well, the pyramids do exist and primitive Egyptians with their copper tools and tube drills were literally not up to the task. The aliens, by the way, become part of Egyptian mythology and are depicted as gods. The aliens used their antigravity technology and particle beams to precisely cut the rock and move it into place, while some Egyptians tried to do it the old-fashioned way, or at least helped out in some way.

Peace,
Ed
 
It is quite right to mention God but He is missing from the science.
And correctly so. God is missing from Geography and French Language in schools as well. You do not seem to have a problem with that.
Yes, I understand how cell energy works. What you appear to be missing is that plugging in a new component adds to the cell’s energy output, requiring a greater energy intake.
How much greater? You can take a bacterium without a flagellum and compare it with another bacterium that has a flagellum. Work out the energy difference. If the difference is 1% then your point is not a good one, if the difference is 50% then you have a point. It is up to you to do the experiment and to provide the evidence to support your point.
In reviewing the article you provided a link for, I see the same evidence of storytelling. While interesting, it was not conclusive.
So what is your story? How did -]God/-] the designer actually arrange the DNA in the correct form to produce the bacterial flagellum? You do not find my story convincing but I cannot find your story at all. Do you even have a story? Give us at least as much detail of your story as I have of mine. Refer to the ID sites where the mechanisms used by the designer are explained. Show as much evidence on your side as I have shown on the evolution side please.
It relied on the old Darwinian, well, if it had a light sensing organ, even if a crude one, etc. Not convincing.
Why is it not convincing? We can see crude light sensing organs in current species. We can observe them and see that they are useful to those organisms that possess them. If we look back down the line of descent from very primitive organisms to us we see eyes that get progressively simpler as they get further away from us. Again we have some evidence. What do you have to put in its place? How did the designer make the DNA that codes for our eyes?
It makes no sense to assume that some crude antecedant to the modern or complex flagellum existed in the first place.
We can see antecedents for all the pieces that go to make up the flagellum in existing non-flagellar bacteria. We can see analogues of the great majority of flagellar proteins being used elsewhere in bacteria. There is ample evidence to show that the bacterial flagellum is not irreducibly complex - if you remove a part that part is still useful separately.
And once again, there is the problem of a cell without a flagellum acquiring one. Before the addition, it reproduced itself, now it has to reproduce not only itself but its new add-on part. How does it code for this new chemical addition?
All flagellar proteins are coded for in DNA. The proteins have analogues that are also coded for in DNA. Simple gene duplication followed by mutation of one copy is sufficient.
Yes, I also understand the non-random part, but it assumes a nearly infinite number of parts of all sizes, shapes and descriptions were being spit out. If I had a Volvo engine and needed a particular bolt, and assuming I had a pile of millions of bolts to choose from, I still have no idea if the correct size and shape and length of bolt I need is in that pile. Evolution assumes it is. In fact, it posits it must be.
The new part need not be “correct”, it just needs to be “good enough”. There are many ways to make any protein; both humans and sunflowers have Cytochrome C, but we have a different version from sunflowers. Evolution is not looking for one target it is looking for any one of a a large number of targets. It has been calculated that there are 2 x 10[sup]93[/sup] ways to make a working Cytochrome C (Yockey 1992) - evolution only needs to find one of them.
I could write a story
Please do, only make it a story about how the designer reached into the world to arrange bacterial DNA in such a way as to produce the flagellum. That is what you say happened, so please tell us how it happened. Evolution has some of the details, though not yet a complete story. Now it is your turn to tell us your side of the story.

rossum
 
But when one starts to talk about analyzing nature itself in that way this leads to a big mess of problems. I’m not saying they are insurmountable. But they are exceedingly difficult to determine without the eyes of faith, which is mostly my point.
This is an excellent point (I added emphasis).
In my view, everything except for sin and death is difficult without the eyes of faith. Catholic spiritual teachers have always referred to the loss of faith (especially atheism) as blindness. I don’t think we should underestimate that. Catholic scientists should not try to view the world through the eyes of materialist-philosophy, but rather with the profound truths of revelation guiding them.
Certainly, developing a precise definition of “designed things in nature” is a very difficult task and there are a mess of problems. But as I see it, Darwinian theory comes with its own mess of problems and some scientists believe that they are insurmountable. (The following link gives an idea about the challenge that evolutionists face, and it does seem impossible as I read it).

boston.com/news/globe/health_science/articles/2007/09/24/dna_unraveled/
Again, I simply don’t see why it has to be an either/or proposition. God could have used evolutionary methods to bring about the various species. And I don’t see any solid reason why He could not have done this.
Well, it depends on how you define “evolutionary processes”. If these are natural laws that work on random mutations and random environmental factors, then it’s difficult to say that “God used this” since these things (supposedly) can be demonstrated in a laboratory. To say that “God created ice to form on the water when it got cold” is a problem when a scientist causes ice to form on water in his lab (or in his kitchen refridgerator). This is not saying anything about God’s “creative power”. Or, if it is saying that this is what it means to call God “the Creator”, then we really have an imaginary God who doesn’t create anything that the natural laws themselves can’t create on their own.
This is the problem with Darwinian theory. It is built on materialist philosophy which asserts that all things in nature are explainable by natural laws.
I believe, as Catholics, we have to reject that notion. The natural laws themselves cannot explain all of nature – nor can science ever explain the development of all of nature. This goes against the claims of evolutionary science.
If God affected nature somehow, what did He do?
Catholic scientists, if they are indeed true to their faith, must accept only the possibility of some aspects of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous, but only insofar that they are not permitted to outright say that it’s impossible for God to have directly intervened.
Here I think you’ve conceded too much to materialist philosophy. You seem to be saying that, as Catholics, we must say that it’s possible that God is not our creator and that the miraculous does not exist.
We profess at Mass every Sunday that God created “all things seen and unseen”. So we have to accept some aspect of creationism. God created something – and certainly has intervened in nature in ways that were observed (miracles). There’s no way we can deny that and maintain our faith.
But, on the other side of the argument, Catholic scientists, if they are indeed true to their faith, must also accept the possibility of some aspects of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous not applying in the degree that science can directly measure His presence.
Ok, I think it’s possible, but I don’t think it’s likely. I don’t think the centuries of support given to the teleological argument can simply be dismissed as incorrect. On the contrary, I believe we should know more about God’s work in nature as time goes on, and the teleological argument grows stronger – with more evidence from science to give indications of God’s work in nature. Sadly, the atheistic culture in science fights against this.
I think that reason and revelation can detect this. I do not think that science can do this though.
Could you explain that further? How can reason detect God’s work in nature in a way that science cannot? Reason must judge what it observes through the senses. If what it observes gives evidence of God’s creative power, this is something that can be analyzed by science.
Finally, regarding the raising from the dead, I totally agree with you. This miracle, unlike the other miracles noted above, could not have a natural explanation.
I’m grateful that you have faith in this. I’m going to hold my comments further except to say that it troubles me to see you explain away the parting of the Red Sea and manna falling from heaven (both events referenced by Jesus Himself) as natural phenomena (or that they “could be” such).

I cannot see what value there is in doubting the teachings of the Holy Scripture or the perennial teaching of the Catholic Faith. How does this profit us to salvation?

I ask the same thing about evolutionists who waste years trying to prove that a certain feature on one of God’s creatures “evolved” from something else – only to have this proven false. What did they gain? What would they have gained if they were correct?

Again, lacking the eyes of faith, people walk in blindness and follow unproductive paths. I think the Prophets and the Psalmist (and certainly all of the Saints) have taught us much differently.
 
Please do, only make it a story about how the designer reached into the world to arrange bacterial DNA in such a way as to produce the flagellum.
Here’s a story about what scientists really know about evolution at the molecular level:
The science of life is undergoing changes so jolting that even its top researchers are feeling something akin to shell-shock. Just four years after scientists finished mapping the human genome - the full sequence of 3 billion DNA “letters” folded within every cell - they find themselves confronted by a biological jungle deeper, denser, and more difficult to penetrate than anyone imagined.
“Science is just starting to probe the wilderness between genes,” said John M. Greally, molecular biologist at New York’s Albert Einstein School of Medicine. “Already **we’re surprised and confounded **by a lot of what we’re seeing.”
“The picture that’s emerging” of how living cells actually operate and evolve “is so immensely more complicated than anyone imagined, it’s almost depressing,” Rigoutsos said.
Interesting, it’s “immensely more complicated” than Darwinists imagined. Again, I think “imagined” is the right word here.
Usually, they “imagine” that things are quite simple and that they have “explained” all of nature through evolutionary theories.
Like Darwin “explaining” how a bear became a whale (one of my favorite Darwinian stories):
“In North America the black bear was seen . . . swimming for hours with widely open mouth, thus catching, like a whale, insects in the water. Even in so extreme a case as this, if the supply of insects were constant, and if better adapted competitors did not already exist in the country, I can see no difficulty in a race of bears being rendered . . . more and more aquatic in their structure and habits, with larger and larger mouths, till a creature was produced as monstrous as a whale”
*Charles Darwin, Origin of Species, First edition *
This seems quite simple. Just like the bacterial flagellum. “It could have evolved” in a number of imaginary ways.

But we sometimes get a glimpse of what is really happening. When the complexity of life is recognized (and they’re only seeing the tip of the iceberg at best) we hear Mr. Rigoutsos say that it’s so complicated that it’s almost depressing.

It’s depressing for the atheist-materialist because it indicates that there is something greater than his own ego at work in nature.
 
Here’s a story about what scientists really know about evolution at the molecular level:
The continued failure of the ID side to provide any explanation of the ID story is noted.

Newspaper headlines are designed to sell advertising, not to impart scientific information correctly. “Major discovery - evolution changes radically” is much better for advertising sales than “Minor discovery - nobody dead.”

Scientists know that they do not yet know everything, if they did then there would be no jobs in science. The reason you never see such headlines about ID is the ID is not actually researching anything so it has no new discoveries of its own to report, all it does is to parasitise on the research done by mainstream scientists.

As a passing note in this discussion, I would note that a prominent ID supporter, Mike Gene, has accepted Nick Matzke’s hypothesis that the bacterial flagellum evolved from pre-existing mechanisms in bacteria and that it is not good evidence for design. See Evolution of Bacterial Flagellum. My congratulations to Mike Gene for saying this. Like any good scientist he is following the evidence.

rossum
 
If the foundational filter for all the evidence is that no intelligence guided any processes, then only natural, unguided processes must be considered or implied. To say something looks like something or might do something is not the same as actually being something functional. Example: if I need to replace a part, I need the exact part. If it’s the wrong size, it doesn’t fit, if it’s the wrong shape, it doesn’t fit. The same would be true if I wanted to add a part. It would have to be the correct size, and shape, and it would have to go in the correct place. To suggest otherwise is just wishful thinking. The cell is an integrated, interconnected factory.

As Pope Benedict points out, there is a guiding intelligenge. The alternative view is to say there were haphazard mistakes until a solution randomly fell into place. A good example is the imagined reality of Junk DNA. In it, scientists thought, would be evidence of all of man’s evolutionary twists and turns. But that turned out to not be the case.

In his article, Finding Design in Nature, Cardinal Schoenborn is explicit about design (not the political variety):

“Now at the beginning of the 21st century, faced with scientific claims like neo-Darwinism and the multiverse hypothesis in cosmology invented to avoid the overwhelming evidence for purpose and design found in modern science, the Catholic Church will again defend human reason by proclaiming the immanent design evident in nature is real.”

nytimes.com/2005/07/07/opinion/07schonborn.html

God bless,
Ed
 
If the foundational filter for all the evidence is that no intelligence guided any processes, then only natural, unguided processes must be considered or implied.
There is no such foundational filter in science. Scientists are very happy to entertain a design hypothesis where required. An archaeologist finding a particular shaped flint is perfectly happy to consider the design hypothesis that the flint is deliberately shaped to be an arrowhead.

The problem with Intelligent Design is that we have no way of telling what the proposed designer(s) can and cannot do. How would a scientist recognise something that was not designed by the proposed designer? What are the limits on the designer’s powers? How do the designer’s power operate? When was the designer active in the past? Is the designer currectly active? ID needs to provide a lot more detail before its hypotheses are useful to science. The archaeologist can recognise a designed arrowhead from a non-designed pebble. The archaeologist knows the limits of what was possible using stone age techniques. The archaeologist knows roughly within what geographical and time limits a particuar style of arrowhead fits. ID can provide nothing like this background.

If God is to be taken as the designer than the pebble in the river is just as designed, by God, as the arrowhead. A technique that cannot distinguish an arrowhead from a pebble is not going to be a great deal of use. If the entire universe is designed by God then everything will register a positive on any design detector and nothing will register a negative. That is of no use to anybody; you might as well save money and just attach the green light permanently to the battery and not bother to fit the red light or any of the actual mechanism of the detector.
To say something looks like something or might do something is not the same as actually being something functional. Example: if I need to replace a part, I need the exact part. If it’s the wrong size, it doesn’t fit, if it’s the wrong shape, it doesn’t fit. The same would be true if I wanted to add a part. It would have to be the correct size, and shape, and it would have to go in the correct place. To suggest otherwise is just wishful thinking. The cell is an integrated, interconnected factory.
You do not need an exact fit, you need a good enough fit. Yockey (1992) has calculated that there are 2 x 10[sup]93[/sup] ways to make a functioning Cytochrome C enzyme. Different species generally have different versions of that enzyme (though humans and Chimpanzees have identical versions). You are expecting too much here, evolution can be sloppy at times; all it has to do is to find something that works well enough to enable an individual to reproduce more than other members of its population. Good enough is fine until something better comes along.
As Pope Benedict points out, there is a guiding intelligenge.
Which intelligence is powerful enough to set up the universe so that life self-assembles within that universe. Why do you seek to reduce the power of God by requiring Him to tinker from time to time? God is powerful enough to get it completely right from the start, with no need to tinker.

I note that you have still failed to tell us what the ID story is to put against the evolution story. Suppose that one hour is set aside for ID in the classroom. What is the teacher going to say to the children for the one-hour lesson?"This morning we are going to learn about Intelligent Design. Sometime, somewhere, somehow the Intelligent Designer, or Designers, did something. We do not know how many designers there were. We do not know when they did it. We do not know where they did it. We do not know how they did it. We do know that they did do it, whatever it was.

“Now please sit quietly for fifty minutes doing nothing until the lesson ends.”
If you want ID in schools then you are going to have to provide teachng materials. Where is the ID story?

rossum
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top