I talk only about beliefs which affect the behaviour of the natural world which is what we can detect through our senses.
If our only information about nature and the universe comes from what we can detect with our senses, then we wouldn’t be able to talk about many scientific theories, since they’re based, in a large part on logical extensions and speculations on matters that we cannot sense today - nor will we ever be able to sense them.
This is true with matters of cosmology (or even evolution itself). We talk about things that we’ll never directly experience or sense – but we can abstract from things which are known.
On the contrary, the fact is that a framework of accepting beliefs based on evidence is demonstrably superior to magical thinking in arriving at a coherent understanding of the world.
I think you’re proposing that the most coherent understanding of the world comes from a science-only perspective. This assumes that the world can be fully comprehended by science alone.
I cannot see where science has proven that, if even it could do so.
The scientific method is the only way we know of learning about the universe that arrives at consistent and coherent answers that cut across geographic, cultural, religious, national and racial lines.
Certainly, there are many philosophers who disagree that the sciences are the only means we have for learning about the universe. Science is subordinate to philosophy, for one thing. You prove that here by offering your philosophical views to defend the value of science.
So, science cannot stand alone. It requires a justification from philosophy. In your case, your philosophy holds that the universe is only-material, and there is, for example, no spiritual nature in mankind. That’s based on your* a priori *view that you will only pursue natural/material causes for all things.
What means have you used to search for God? Clearly, using science-alone cannot be very effective when exploring a supernatural being.
It is actually the process of believing without evidence that leads people the world over to arbitrary, incompatible, frequently bizarre, and often clearly erroneous ideas about the world.
That is strictly a negative view. What about all of the great human endeavors that emerged from people who believe in God?
Why posit miracles, which are dislocations of the normal physical laws, to explain phenomena that are well explained by natural causes?
Would you say that everything in nature or human experience is “well explained by natural causes”? Miracles are posited because they’re a very deep component of human existence and many people experience them directly. Every person who prays to God is seeking some kind of miracle, even in a very miniature form. The fact that many do experience God’s power in ways that are personal and convincing is the basis for positing miracles.
In other words, one is not limited to seeking explanations for the miraculous from ancient history, but one can find people who have experienced miracles themselves (at least in small ways).
Every Catholic priest, for example, would say that he has witnessed the supernatural power of God in some small way at least.
There are for example, elements of Catholic dogma which rest on the authority of the Fathers and the Church - such elements of belief depend on pure assertion.
Certainly, there is a lot of assertion. In other cases, the assertions can be supported with historical evidence. The assertions are accepted based on trust. We do the same with much of what comes to us from history, religious or secular. We trust the author for some facts, and then find evidence that supports the text from other sources. But still, it’s based on trust. Are the authors trustworthy? To be fair, one must approach history with a certain level of trust.
A belief in miracles and the supernatural leads to intellectual anarchy - if any magical thing is possible, then one can never create coherent positions such as scientific theories,
In the Catholic world, it doesn’t play out like that. The guidance and help from God, in the form of miracles big and small, actually fight against intellectual anarchy. But this is built on the Catholic understanding of the nature of God and how God collaborates with human beings (and what God desires, His goals for the universe, and how and why He uses His powers).
Certainly, without that understanding about God’s nature and purpose, there would be fear and anarchy. That is precisely what happened with primative religions. They had an understanding of gods, but these were fearful, arbitrary entities that (they thought) used their powers on a whim or for vengence. Even classical paganism had that problem.
and indeed such anarchy is seen in the vast range of bizarre beliefs that people are willing to entertain - many faith-based beliefs are fundamentally incompatible, and since they are regarded by their proponents as ultimate immutable truth, they can never be reconciled.
I agree with that. One cannot say unilaterally that “faith is good” since it can be faith in any number of contradictory things. I agree that they can’t be reconciled fully, but Judiasm and Catholicism, for example, start from the same roots.
I think we have to admit that there are some bizarre beliefs within science also (alien seeding of life on earth).
[continued next post]