Animal Biotechnology and Guided Evolution

  • Thread starter Thread starter Camron
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If one accepts your definition of guided evolution, why not a process of guided gravity, and guided chemistry and guided light propagation? - the scientists might as well pack up and go home. But since science works, and all aspects of the world appear just as they would if the world behaves according to a set of unguided natural laws, it is magical thinking that we should reject, and belief without evidence.
I’d be glad to hear another definition of Guided Evolution versus Unguided Evolution. One does not need to accept my definition of the same.

What influence do you believe God has had on the universe and how does God’s creative power affect evolution?

That was the intial question.

I believe your answer is: “I don’t believe that God exists”.

If so, I don’t really think it’s worth your (or anyone’s) time to say much more than that. I wouldn’t say that you have any respect for Catholicism, so I’d really wonder what you hope to accomplish by posting your opinions on it.

If your Catholic-Darwinist friends do not oppose your opinion here, I’ll be convinced that they basically agree with you (classifying priests with witch doctors, and dismissing the claims of the Catholic Faith as illusory and magical thinking).

Materialist philosophy has nothing to say about God and the supernatural, except that “it doesn’t exist”.

I got your point on that a long time ago on that and I can’t see where you added anything new to it.

As for trying to convince us that “we should reject” belief in miracles and God’s power, I think you really need to come up with more convincing arguments. As it stands, you’re just making assertions of some kind.

If you want to be an apologist for atheism, I think you should try to speak the language that Catholics understand and win some respect from them – that way we’ll trust you and learn to accept whatever wisdom you have to offer.

Otherwise, you’re just speaking the language of atheism and materialism and you don’t have even a basic respect for what Catholics believe. This hurts your effectiveness.
 
Not only are you anti-neo-Darwinism - you are also anti any other mechanism for the evolution of species,
I guess that makes me an anti-mechanist.
which you have called materialist nonsense.
I meant no offense to mechanisms at all.
In other words, any science that gets in the way of your religious beliefs is rejected a priori - a deeply unscientific attitude.
Well, it depends on what you mean by “unscientific”. Usually that term means “something that is unpopular with the self-proclaimed scientific community”.
I know of no scientist who makes this proposal. Do you?
I guess it depends what you mean by “Darwinian processes”. Usually that term means whatever a scientist wants it to mean in order to win an argument.
And one that all serious scientists agree with.
Apparently, you know all of the serious scientists in the world and you’ve asked their opinion on it. I’ll have to give you credit for that bit of research.

Ok, there’s a much easier way to prove your point. Rather than actually surveying every “serious scientist”, you just need to say that anyone who agrees with it “is a serious scientist” and those who disagree are “not serious scientists”.

Therefore, you’re infallibly correct. Merely shift the target to match the data. That sounds a lot like great Darwinian science in action – not to mention some wonderful statistical research. 😉
 
The word “reason” has been substituted for the word atheism. It is not reasonable to believe anyone other than serious scientists. This is just arguing to people of faith to capitulate to the Scientific Technocracy and bow down before them. As history has shown, those who desire only this life desire primarily earthly things and lots of it.

That is why the word science and evolution have become interchangeable and why some desperately speak as its disciples. “Man invents himself.” has become “Man creates himself.” “Man is the measure of all things.” is actually the outcome of the phrase “ye shall be as gods” uttered by the prince of the air in the beginning.

Trust me, believer or not, those who bow down before imperfect men shall suffer their imperfect whims and consequences. They will not have your best interests in mind as they follow the Marxist tenets: The State (or they) shall create propaganda to eliminate all religious beliefs and superstitions from among the people." This did not stop Stalin from murdering millions. The atheist and workers’ paradise is no more.

Peace,
Ed
 
Ok, rather than go into this again since I have misunderstood you here and I have done so before (that is not my intention at all, by any means) … could you explain your comment here in more detail?
Sure. No problem.
To me, that looks like we *only *have to accept the *possibility *of the miraculous, and not have to affirm, as a profession of Faith, the miraculous itself.
No, that’s not what I’m saying.

I’m saying that, based on the Bible and Tradition and the teaching of the Magisterium, we need to be ready to accept that God could have created in any of three ways…
  1. Direct Specific Creations, such as the example of the Universe being created out of nothing.
  2. Miraculous Modifications, such as the example of Laban’s sheep being genetically modified via a miracle.
  3. Consequential Creations, such as the example of Jacob’s brothers indirectly accomplishing God’s Will in a circuitous route that no one could have foreseen.
Theistic Evolution falls into the 3rd category, since all the laws and effects within God’s Creation could have unfolded in tandem according to His Will, working together in a circuitous route that many would have difficulty seeing without deeply meditating on it.

Therefore, I’m not saying that we only have to accept the possibility of the miraculous, and not have to affirm, as a profession of Faith, the miraculous itself.

I am saying that we have to accept the miraculous, and also have to affirm, as a profession of Faith, the miraculous itself.

I am also saying that, as far as the speciation of life on Earth is concerned, since this has not been specifically defined by the Catholic Church, it could be any of the 3 types of creation specified above: Direct Specific Creations, Miraculous Modifications, or Consequential Creations.

Therefore, if any Theistic Evolutionist says it’s impossible that God could have used Miraculous Modifications for example to bring forth the various life forms on Earth, they are doing so on their own. The Catholic Church has not claimed that this is impossible. Neither does the Theistic Evolutionist have the authority to safely teach this as part of the Catholic Church’s Dogma.

Likewise, if any IDer says it’s impossible that God could have used Consequential Creations for example to bring forth the various life forms on Earth, they too are doing so on their own. The Catholic Church has not claimed that this is impossible either. As with the Theistic Evolutionist noted above, the IDer likewise does not have the authority to safely teach this as part of the Catholic Church’s Dogma either.

We can certainly express our personal opinions in what we believe. The Church has permitted a wide range of opinions on exactly how God could have created when He created the various life forms on Earth: Direct Specific Creations, Miraculous Modifications, or Consequential Creations.

My personal opinion is that God mainly used Consequential Creations interspersed with periods of Miraculous Modifications.
I can’t follow that, or perhaps it’s mis-worded from what you really meant. I would appreciate an explaination further though, please.
Does that explain this better?
 
As for trying to convince us that “we should reject” belief in miracles and God’s power, I think you really need to come up with more convincing arguments. As it stands, you’re just making assertions of some kind.
I talk only about beliefs which affect the behaviour of the natural world which is what we can detect through our senses.

It’s ironic that you claim that I am merely making assertions in claiming the superiority of evidence-based thinking at arriving at an understanding of the world. On the contrary, the fact is that a framework of accepting beliefs based on evidence is demonstrably superior to magical thinking in arriving at a coherent understanding of the world. The scientific method is the only way we know of learning about the universe that arrives at consistent and coherent answers that cut across geographic, cultural, religious, national and racial lines.

It is actually the process of believing without evidence that leads people the world over to arbitrary, incompatible, frequently bizarre, and often clearly erroneous ideas about the world. Why posit miracles, which are dislocations of the normal physical laws, to explain phenomena that are well explained by natural causes? There are for example, elements of Catholic dogma which rest on the authority of the Fathers and the Church - such elements of belief depend on pure assertion. A belief in miracles and the supernatural leads to intellectual anarchy - if any magical thing is possible, then one can never create coherent positions such as scientific theories, and indeed such anarchy is seen in the vast range of bizarre beliefs that people are willing to entertain - many faith-based beliefs are fundamentally incompatible, and since they are regarded by their proponents as ultimate immutable truth, they can never be reconciled. That seems to me to be a grossly inadequate basis for finding out any truth at all about the world.

On the other hand, while the scientific method is imperfect, and we struggle through controversy and rival hypotheses, at least our understanding of the world does get demonstrably closer to the actual case with time, especially as we are sufficiently humble to allow our beliefs to be modified by the emergence of new facts.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
I guess that makes me an anti-mechanist.
Yes, in this matter at any rate, you are a magical thinker.
Well, it depends on what you mean by “unscientific”. Usually that term means “something that is unpopular with the self-proclaimed scientific community”.
This is pure obfuscation - the scientific approach is to go where the evidence leads. To decide, a priori, that certain answers are unacceptable on religious grounds is unscientific.
I guess it depends what you mean by “Darwinian processes”. Usually that term means whatever a scientist wants it to mean in order to win an argument.
You were the one who said " So, if the proposal is ‘everything in nature is explained by Darwinian theory’ then these anomalies are more important." I am merely pointing out that you are creating a blatant strawman. I know of no scientist who claims that ‘everything in nature is explained by Darwinian theory’, and obviously, neither do you.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
The previous post is a perfect example of the Anti-Faith Based initiative being promoted by other scientists like PZ Myers (the eucharist is just a cracker), the author of the God Delusion and Sam Harris (who abhores the alien hiss of religion among his colleagues and the outside world).

While the topic is guided evolution, it has degenerated into a tirade against myth, superstition and ‘magical thinking.’ As Catholics are aware, miracles can and do still happen. The Congregation for Saints’ Causes does exist and so does the Pontifical Academy of Sciences.

All that is being promoted here under the guise of evolution is Scientific Atheism. Articles published in the past have suggested coming up with some secular substitute for religion. The poster above echoes the nonsensical statements of others like Bill Maher who say that religion is silly and dangerous. In their Utopia, religion no longer exists. But, given man’s history, even eliminating what some call ‘magical thinking’ will not eliminate greed for land, envy for power and position, as individuals and among countries, and the desire to take something by force.

The poster should be more honest. It’s not and never has been about science, it’s about an atheistic Technocracy.

God bless,
Ed
 
Does that explain this better?
Yes, I didn’t realize that you were referring to the miraculous with regards to the development of nature. It looked like an absolute – as if we do not have to accept any miracles. Thanks for the clarification.
 
I talk only about beliefs which affect the behaviour of the natural world which is what we can detect through our senses.
If our only information about nature and the universe comes from what we can detect with our senses, then we wouldn’t be able to talk about many scientific theories, since they’re based, in a large part on logical extensions and speculations on matters that we cannot sense today - nor will we ever be able to sense them.
This is true with matters of cosmology (or even evolution itself). We talk about things that we’ll never directly experience or sense – but we can abstract from things which are known.
On the contrary, the fact is that a framework of accepting beliefs based on evidence is demonstrably superior to magical thinking in arriving at a coherent understanding of the world.
I think you’re proposing that the most coherent understanding of the world comes from a science-only perspective. This assumes that the world can be fully comprehended by science alone.
I cannot see where science has proven that, if even it could do so.
The scientific method is the only way we know of learning about the universe that arrives at consistent and coherent answers that cut across geographic, cultural, religious, national and racial lines.
Certainly, there are many philosophers who disagree that the sciences are the only means we have for learning about the universe. Science is subordinate to philosophy, for one thing. You prove that here by offering your philosophical views to defend the value of science.

So, science cannot stand alone. It requires a justification from philosophy. In your case, your philosophy holds that the universe is only-material, and there is, for example, no spiritual nature in mankind. That’s based on your* a priori *view that you will only pursue natural/material causes for all things.

What means have you used to search for God? Clearly, using science-alone cannot be very effective when exploring a supernatural being.
It is actually the process of believing without evidence that leads people the world over to arbitrary, incompatible, frequently bizarre, and often clearly erroneous ideas about the world.
That is strictly a negative view. What about all of the great human endeavors that emerged from people who believe in God?
Why posit miracles, which are dislocations of the normal physical laws, to explain phenomena that are well explained by natural causes?
Would you say that everything in nature or human experience is “well explained by natural causes”? Miracles are posited because they’re a very deep component of human existence and many people experience them directly. Every person who prays to God is seeking some kind of miracle, even in a very miniature form. The fact that many do experience God’s power in ways that are personal and convincing is the basis for positing miracles.

In other words, one is not limited to seeking explanations for the miraculous from ancient history, but one can find people who have experienced miracles themselves (at least in small ways).
Every Catholic priest, for example, would say that he has witnessed the supernatural power of God in some small way at least.
There are for example, elements of Catholic dogma which rest on the authority of the Fathers and the Church - such elements of belief depend on pure assertion.
Certainly, there is a lot of assertion. In other cases, the assertions can be supported with historical evidence. The assertions are accepted based on trust. We do the same with much of what comes to us from history, religious or secular. We trust the author for some facts, and then find evidence that supports the text from other sources. But still, it’s based on trust. Are the authors trustworthy? To be fair, one must approach history with a certain level of trust.
A belief in miracles and the supernatural leads to intellectual anarchy - if any magical thing is possible, then one can never create coherent positions such as scientific theories,
In the Catholic world, it doesn’t play out like that. The guidance and help from God, in the form of miracles big and small, actually fight against intellectual anarchy. But this is built on the Catholic understanding of the nature of God and how God collaborates with human beings (and what God desires, His goals for the universe, and how and why He uses His powers).

Certainly, without that understanding about God’s nature and purpose, there would be fear and anarchy. That is precisely what happened with primative religions. They had an understanding of gods, but these were fearful, arbitrary entities that (they thought) used their powers on a whim or for vengence. Even classical paganism had that problem.
and indeed such anarchy is seen in the vast range of bizarre beliefs that people are willing to entertain - many faith-based beliefs are fundamentally incompatible, and since they are regarded by their proponents as ultimate immutable truth, they can never be reconciled.
I agree with that. One cannot say unilaterally that “faith is good” since it can be faith in any number of contradictory things. I agree that they can’t be reconciled fully, but Judiasm and Catholicism, for example, start from the same roots.

I think we have to admit that there are some bizarre beliefs within science also (alien seeding of life on earth).

[continued next post]
 
On the other hand, while the scientific method is imperfect, and we struggle through controversy and rival hypotheses, at least our understanding of the world does get demonstrably closer to the actual case with time, especially as we are sufficiently humble to allow our beliefs to be modified by the emergence of new facts.
Ok, that seems more than reasonable and an attractively modest position. The scientific method has had many successes. It works well for what it is built to do. But the biggest problem is that it only works if the goal of life is to attain an understanding of the material world alone.

While science has made progress with this, there’s one brutal and undeniable fact … science always fails us in the end and always has since the beginning of the human race. What I mean by that is that science has not ever won the battle against death. It has had some temporary victories, and we’re all grateful for those, but in the end, science must stand back and watch every human being die.

This is why we seek God. All of the bizarre beliefs and religious practices of humanity are oriented to that one fact – that science and magic do not win in the end and something beyond both of those are the only things that give life meaning.

That’s the problem with a science-only view as I see it.

Thanks for an excellent post, by the way. Your points were well-stated and I appreciate the thought you put into it.
 
I think we need to talk about this more (Guided Evolution) – since that is the topic of this thread.

I have an idea about the difference between Guided Evolution and Unguided Evolution, but I’m not sure that I’m correct.

I would say that Unguided Evolution is Darwin’s theory. Guided Evolution is considerably different as I see it.

I do not think we can call ordinary natural processes “guided” in the way the term is used in Guided Evolution. Yes, God’s providence guides all things, but we don’t think of gravity, for example, as a “guided” process.
And yet, if it is indeed working to accomplish God’s will, then it is guided by God, sustained by God, and brought to its completion by God. Indeed, if Psalm 48:14 says, "For this God is our God for ever and ever; He will be our guide even to the end”, then God could certainly use many natural means to “guide” our paths, and even use nature itself to guide the creation of our bodies too.

As the Bible says regarding the Apostles with Jesus in Matthew 8:27, “What kind of man is this? Even the winds and the waves obey him!” And certainly, according to the Bible, all of nature obeys God’s command. Jesus is God.

So if this is true, then why are you stressing that these laws are “unguided”?

Even you agree that humanity tends to picture nature itself undergoing anthropomorphosis into human attributes, projecting its own image into nature. If so, then why can it not be that God could also gradually bring about a literal anthropomorphosis of nature, literally projecting His own image into nature by gradually forming man from the very elements of the universe (from the earth) via the laws and precepts that He sets forth, sustains, and guides-- all according to His will?

In other words, why exactly couldn’t God have guided nature according to His will to form the very body of the first human being in order for Him to breathe a soul into Adam, all to gradually find it’s completion in the coming of Jesus?

This is still, I suppose, a miraculous thing. But it would simply be much grander in scope, spanning over billions of years as God unfolds His creation like a scroll for all who have eyes to see exactly as He intended?

What exactly is your objection to this?
Gravity is predictable and consistent.
And so is God.

So couldn’t one infer that the Creator of these laws is not likewise predictable and consistent?

And is this considered Intelligent Design or Theistic Evolution?
It is sustained by God, but it is “unguided” as a natural law.
Not if God is “guiding” it, no it isn’t.
We can pray that God will “redirect” gravity from it’s inevitable path – but that means we want God to intervene and change the “unguided law” and “guide it” in ways it would not ordinarily go.
It could also mean that we want to change God’s will too.

Could Moses or Elijah have prayed to stop the Flood of Noah’s day?
When a storm comes, we pray that the tree won’t fall on our house.
The next day, when we see the most obvious path for the tree was directly at our house, but that it somehow turned away and missed – we rightly thank God for this miracle of His Guidance of the natural law.
But isn’t He already guiding it anyway?

Or is He only guiding nature when we pray for Him to guide nature?
Otherwise, without His help – our house would have been crushed. The unguided law would have worked without God’s help and would have done the obvious and predictable thing.
But this was always God’s will to begin with, wasn’t it?

We have certainly not changed God’s mind, have we?

We have only participated in God’s revelation by stating in advance, as revealed through prayer, what God intended all along.

Think about it. 🙂
 
Normally, I would not want to argue by the anomalies or exceptions, but as I see it, evolution (I mean Darwinian theory) makes such sweeping claims and admits no questions or doubts (I’ve had that experience with some of the evolutionary-defenders here on CAF) that one must push first to establish that there are things in nature which evoutionary theories have not explained adequately.
Perhaps this is more the fault of the advocates of the theory than the theory itself. I consider evolution to be a fact. I don’t need to shove this down other’s throats though. 🙂
I’d say that you’re quite rare in admitting that here. There are many who refuse to accept that there are any weaknesses in the standard evolutionary theory at all.
Technically, the theory stands on its own merit very well according to the tests that are currently available
I would agree that the spider wasp provides a major challenge. There are others as well – the sonar systems on dolphins and bats, the micro-fiber sticky hands of the gecko, electric eels … actually there are many others (I’d almost say that it’s more than just anomalies). Even the evolution of the eye is difficult to explain.
Many of these things, such as the eye, are not actually that difficult to explain. At least, the explanations given are highly plausible in most cases even if we dont know if they are fully true.

But, again, the fossil record within the matching geographical areas displayed within the continental drift combined with the genetic records of DNA development provides an extremely powerful testimony to the explanatory power of the theory of evolution.
So, if the proposal is “everything in nature is explained by Darwinian theory” then these anomalies are more important.
That’s simply not true and you know this. Anomalies are exceptions to the rule. And they are indeed minor when compared to the fossil record within the matching geographical areas displayed within the continental drift combined with the genetic records of DNA development.

No. People will not throw away the theory of evolution because of these. They will only search harder for the answers. And if they do exist, then an answer will most likely be found at some point.
If the proposal is “evolution may explain some things in nature” - that is a radically different idea.
My proposal is that evolution explains many things, but not everything. The human soul cannot be explained away by the theory of evolution no matter how hard the evolutionary psychologists might claim otherwise.
Yes, but when evaluating things in scientific terms, if we can demonstrate them in a laboratory, we cannot say that God’s “special creation” or “guidance” was necessary in a way we can observe.
How so?
I understand what you’re getting at. In some ways, that is an irrefutable point, depending on how one views God. I do think it’s an issue for Catholic philosophy and theology to establish first. Otherwise, one could imagine “a god” doing things like this.
I mean first we have the notion – “Nature looks like it was designed (as Richard Dawkins among many others admit) but it was actually caused by random chance.”
Dawkins thinks the glass is half-empty.

We know it’s half-full.
But then we would have to twist that:
“Nature looks like it was designed, but the process used to design was essentially random, although – it just appears like the process is random, when it really is God designing it.”
Again, that cannot be refuted as I see it. God could have created the appearance of design, then the appearance of randomness, but the reality was design.
But if that’s true - why wouldn’t we just say that the appearance of design is true – since it was designed? I guess there are too many loops in that cycle for me.
But, looking through the Biblical history, could it not be said that the re-emergence of monotheism “appears” to be developing randomly even though it is definitely unfolding according to God’s unforeseen plan?
Then we would consider Catholic philosophy and theology to understand the nature of God. Would God create something that looks like He designed it, only to show us that there are processes that look random, so we’d then conclude that the randomness is not random, and the design is not design - except through the appearingly random process?
I think Catholic philosophy would direct us to conclude that God would not create that many illusions in our grasp of reality. By unaided reason, we can see the essence of things. Through intuition and common sense, we can see God’s creative intelligence expressed in nature. I just don’t see how a"random-appearing" process really fits. But we have to look at this more later.
Well, the Bible does say in Romans 11:33…
Oh, the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable his judgments, and his paths beyond tracing out!
And the Bible also says, in the very same book of the Bible according to Romans 1:20…
For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse.
So how exactly do you reconcile Romans 11:33 (unsearchable paths) with Romans 1:20 (clearly seen)?
I fully agree with you on this and it’s a great insight.
But I think we have something more than an assertion of faith in making our point. Personally, I believe that we can show that an understanding of God is necessary for understanding nature.
I agree that there is a purpose to nature. And I agree that God is necessary for understanding nature’s purpose too.
 
But isn’t He already guiding it anyway?

Or is He only guiding nature when we pray for Him to guide nature?
An interesting question, and a good excuse for a joke:A flood is predicted so buses are arranged to evacuate people. A bus stops outside a house and asks the owner if he wants a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise and the owner is forced to move upstairs. A rescue boat approaches and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise further and the owner is forced into the attic. Another rescue boat approaches and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise further and the owner is forced onto the roof. A helicopter flies over and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The flood rises further and the house owner goes to heaven.

He asked “Lord, why didn’t you save me from the flood?”

The Lord replied, “I sent a bus, two boats and a helicopter; what more did you want me to do?”
If God is as advertised then He can use the ordinary to achieve His ends as well as using the miraculous. I get the feeling that some creationists want God to use only miraculous means, when from observation He seem to use ordinary means a lot more frequently.

rossum
 
An interesting question, and a good excuse for a joke:A flood is predicted so buses are arranged to evacuate people. A bus stops outside a house and asks the owner if he wants a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise and the owner is forced to move upstairs. A rescue boat approaches and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise further and the owner is forced into the attic. Another rescue boat approaches and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise further and the owner is forced onto the roof. A helicopter flies over and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The flood rises further and the house owner goes to heaven.

He asked “Lord, why didn’t you save me from the flood?”

The Lord replied, “I sent a bus, two boats and a helicopter; what more did you want me to do?”
If God is as advertised then He can use the ordinary to achieve His ends as well as using the miraculous. I get the feeling that some creationists want God to use only miraculous means, when from observation He seem to use ordinary means a lot more frequently.

rossum
Thank you for posting that. 🙂

I love that joke because it really highlights the potential fallacy of many arguments for God’s grander divine interventions. :love:

I’m not saying that God doesn’t perform miracles.
He does, just as the joke highlights. 👍

I’m also not saying that God doesn’t guide nature.
He does that too, just as the joke highlights. 👍

I’m only saying that I agree that whereas many are looking for the grander miracles, God may be working on a more sublime level, using what we would consider rather ordinary means to vicariously accomplish His will through a circuitous way that was not readily apparent to the casual observer who has their eyes fixed on spotting a miracle. :doh2:
 
An interesting question, and a good excuse for a joke:A flood is predicted so buses are arranged to evacuate people. A bus stops outside a house and asks the owner if he wants a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise and the owner is forced to move upstairs. A rescue boat approaches and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise further and the owner is forced into the attic. Another rescue boat approaches and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The waters rise further and the owner is forced onto the roof. A helicopter flies over and offers a ride.

“No thank you, the Lord will save me from the flood.”

The flood rises further and the house owner goes to heaven.

He asked “Lord, why didn’t you save me from the flood?”

The Lord replied, “I sent a bus, two boats and a helicopter; what more did you want me to do?”
If God is as advertised then He can use the ordinary to achieve His ends as well as using the miraculous. I get the feeling that some creationists want God to use only miraculous means, when from observation He seem to use ordinary means a lot more frequently.

rossum
Jesus Christ contradicts this assumption. His nature as perfect man and perfect God showed what God can and still is doing. With all due respect to the poster, yes, God can work through seemingly non-miraculous means. However, this would diminish the creator God who did create from nothing.

Jesus cleansed the lepers, gave sight to the blind, and healed a woman who suffered an issue of blood for many years. He exorcized demons (real beings), raised the dead, calmed the wind, and so on. By attempting to keep the focus on what can be perceived only by human senses and human devices, it distracts from God’s nature. That these abilities are reduced to unprovable claims by the skeptic ignores more recent miracles.

The tilma or cloak of Our Lady of Guadalupe is a real artifact. Look at it, study it, draw your own conclusions.

Contact the Congregation for Saints’ Causes. People are not elevated to sainthood without 2 miracles attributed to them. That is going on today.

Reducing the world to a natural only explanation reduces man to an ambulatory biological device whose primary purpose is to reproduce and engage in adaptive behaviors in the process. And then die.

God bless,
Ed
 
Reducing the world to a natural only explanation reduces man to an ambulatory biological device whose primary purpose is to reproduce and engage in adaptive behaviors in the process. And then die.
You appear to have missed my point. God can and does use natural events to fulfill His purposes. God sent the bus, boats and helicopter. They were not miraculous but ordinary. God is omnipotent, He is perfectly capable of using the ordinary. Observing the world, we see that most of the time He does exactly that. Miracles are rare, not common. If they were common then they would not be as special as they are.

If God wants something to happen then it happens. If He wants it to happen through the action of natural laws, then it happens through the action of natural laws. If He wants it to happen through chance, then it happens through chance. If He wants it to happen through a miracle, then it happens through a miracle.

rossum
 
And yet, if it is indeed working to accomplish God’s will, then it is guided by God, sustained by God, and brought to its completion by God. Indeed, if Psalm 48:14 says, "For this God is our God for ever and ever; He will be our guide even to the end”, then God could certainly use many natural means to “guide” our paths, and even use nature itself to guide the creation of our bodies too.

As the Bible says regarding the Apostles with Jesus in Matthew 8:27, “What kind of man is this? Even the winds and the waves obey him!” And certainly, according to the Bible, all of nature obeys God’s command. Jesus is God.

So if this is true, then why are you stressing that these laws are “unguided”?
The choice is yours. The title of this thread refers to “Guided Evolution”. That is not a term I use, nor is it one I can define. I asked you in a previous post to explain the difference between Guided and Unguided evolution. You chose to avoid that question. In the desire to be considerate to you, and to move the conversation forward – I tried to define “Guided Evolution” versus “Unguided”.

Now I can see that you are arguing that “everything is guided by God”.

You are now arguing that the term Guided Evolution is meaningless and redundant.

But you’re mixing up categories and making the concept of “the miraculous” irrelevant (not to mention the need for prayer). Since everything is guided by God, then the concept of a miracle also loses all meaning.
If so, then why can it not be that God could also gradually bring about a literal anthropomorphosis of nature, literally projecting His own image into nature by gradually forming man from the very elements of the universe (from the earth) via the laws and precepts that He sets forth, sustains, and guides-- all according to His will?
The opposition to this comes from our knowledge of the nature of God and what His purpose for mankind is. God desires to teach his creatures through nature.
In other words, why exactly couldn’t God have guided nature according to His will to form the very body of the first human being in order for Him to breathe a soul into Adam, all to gradually find it’s completion in the coming of Jesus?
Again, you’ve already set aside any distinction between Guided and Unguided. Therefore, whatever happens is what God did (according to this notion). Whatever will happen is what God will do.
This is still, I suppose, a miraculous thing.
I cannot see how you can find “a miraculous thing” in this scenario where God does everything anyway.
But it would simply be much grander in scope, spanning over billions of years as God unfolds His creation like a scroll for all who have eyes to see exactly as He intended?
What exactly is your objection to this?
My objection is that this is identical with the atheistic position and it denies St. Paul’s teaching on the teleological argument. It’s the Deist version of God, at best. God is out there “guiding everything” (and thus having no discernable presence at all).
So couldn’t one infer that the Creator of these laws is not likewise predictable and consistent?
If you think that our Creator is “predictable” then that is a radically different theology than what is found in the writings (and lives) of the Saints and Prophets. We do not know the ways of God. We know some things – we know what pleases God and what offends Him. We know how to draw closer to him and reach unity. But the fact that we all must pass through the Dark Night of the Soul to fully reach maturity means that God is not predictable like gravity. God gives us predictable laws to show his constancy – but they balanced by unpredictable forces in nature to show his sovereignty. So we know God’s constancy, but we can never feel as if we know the mind of God, or complain about how God “should do things”.
This is very much unlike gravity.
And is this considered Intelligent Design or Theistic Evolution?
I’m sorry that I don’t understand the question here.
But isn’t He already guiding it anyway?
Or is He only guiding nature when we pray for Him to guide nature?
We pray to ask God to intervene in nature in a special way. Otherwise, there would be no reason to ask these things of God. “Guided nature” itself would provide everything for us. But the fact that there is a component of nature that is Unguided (God has created the concept of randomness and the fatalism of natural laws), is reason for us to pray and ask God’s help to overcome nature (or even to bend the laws of nature as many Saints have done).
We have only participated in God’s revelation by stating in advance, as revealed through prayer, what God intended all along.
Again, if you’re saying that the term “Unguided” (or accidental or random) is meaningless with regards to evolution, then one would not be able to detect God’s actions in nature. Additionally, there would be nothing “remarkable” about creation since the creation of the human eye or consciouness is not significantly different than watching a stone roll down a hill, or having scientists create things in a laboratory.

There would be no evidence of the supernatural as well.

It’s basically the atheistic argument - that there is no evidence of God’s work in nature at all. That is a denial of the teachings of the Catholic Church (Vatican Council 1 as quoted in the Catechism of the Catholic Church).
 
Again, it’s simple enought to observe how the Church judges the miraculous in the cases of canonization (you mentioned this previously and I didn’t have a chance to answer it).

If a man cuts his finger and then notices in two weeks, the cut has healed, he can claim it was a miracle. But the Holy See will not accept that as a special expression of God’s supernatural power. Why? Because cut fingers heal in that amount of time due to nature or science. Thus, it’s not an example of God’s intervention.

But, looking through the Biblical history, could it not be said that the re-emergence of monotheism “appears” to be developing randomly even though it is definitely unfolding according to God’s unforeseen plan?
So how exactly do you reconcile Romans 11:33 (unsearchable paths) with Romans 1:20 (clearly seen)?
St. Paul is talking about two different aspects of God’s nature and ways.
Oh, the depth of the riches of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable his judgments, and his paths beyond tracing out!
In this case, St. Paul is referring to the inner life of God – His judgements, wisdom and knowledge. St. Paul says that God’s wisdom and knowledge have a “depth of riches” – God’s attributes are infinite in perfection. If it was meant that His ways are “unsearchable” (incomprehensible), then there would be no sense in any theology. What St. Paul means here is that God is sovereign and
His nature
is beyond human grasp.
For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse.
In this quote however, St. Paul points out that the invisible power of God is “clearly seen” from “what he has made”. What we can see clearly (God’s intelligent design in nature) is but a glimpse of the “unsearchable ways” of God, but we can understand enough of God’s power in nature that men are without excuse.

In other words, the intelligent design of nature is something that is clearly obvious, and nature tells us much about God since He communicates Himself through nature.
I agree that there is a purpose to nature. And I agree that God is necessary for understanding nature’s purpose too.
It’s good to hear that.
 
If God is as advertised then He can use the ordinary to achieve His ends as well as using the miraculous. I get the feeling that some creationists want God to use only miraculous means, when from observation He seem to use ordinary means a lot more frequently.
God does use the ordinary to achieve His ends.

But there’s a bit of complexity here.
  1. What is “the ordinary” (is there “an ordinary”)?
  2. What are God’s ends that He hopes to achieve?
  3. What are the miraculous?
 
Jesus Christ contradicts this assumption. His nature as perfect man and perfect God showed what God can and still is doing. With all due respect to the poster, yes, God can work through seemingly non-miraculous means. However, this would diminish the creator God who did create from nothing.

Jesus cleansed the lepers, gave sight to the blind, and healed a woman who suffered an issue of blood for many years. He exorcized demons (real beings), raised the dead, calmed the wind, and so on. By attempting to keep the focus on what can be perceived only by human senses and human devices, it distracts from God’s nature. That these abilities are reduced to unprovable claims by the skeptic ignores more recent miracles.

The tilma or cloak of Our Lady of Guadalupe is a real artifact. Look at it, study it, draw your own conclusions.

Contact the Congregation for Saints’ Causes. People are not elevated to sainthood without 2 miracles attributed to them. That is going on today.
These are all excellent points. The problem today is not that people think that God is always working miracles. On the contrary. The biggest problem is that people do not think that God can work any miracles at all.

God works both in the ordinary things of life as well as in grand miracles.

Catholics believe that a profound miracle occurs daily at Masses offered throughout the world. Every Catholic priest is a part of the miracle of the Eucharist. Beyond that, very many people who receive a gifts or graces from God after praying devoutly for them, acknowledges God’s miraculous power.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top