Certainly, one can propose that certain aspects of nature meet a criterion of specificity and complexity – but that’s Intelligent Design science at work.
I accept that there are forensic sciences and anthropological humanities within archaeology that can reasonably determine that an intelligent cause has occurred. But when one starts to talk about analyzing nature itself in that way this leads to a big mess of problems. I’m not saying they are insurmountable. But they are exceedingly difficult to determine without the eyes of faith, which is mostly my point. I don’t think we can psychoanalyze nature in order to determine God’s will.
Some definition of design can be developed and then aspects of nature can be evalutated by it. If a natural cause can be found, then the idea is falsified.
For the record I wouldn’t say they are falsified. It only demonstrates that a natural explanation could be the reason behind the event happening.
I’m very glad to consider these examples, but I’ll say that our conversation will take a radically different direction at that point. If we want to use the Holy Scriptures to determine what God created, how He created it, and how He influenced the development of nature – then I can’t see how Darwinian theory could survive (considering that you’re accepting some literal truth to the Bible stories, as you do here).
Again, I simply don’t see why it has to be an either/or proposition. God could have used evolutionary methods to bring about the various species. And I don’t see any solid reason why He could not have done this.
The Holy Scriptures give ample evidence for Intelligent Design theory – as you’ve done in other instances. Catholic scientists must accept some aspect of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous.
I think that’s true only to an extent.
Catholic scientists, if they are indeed true to their faith, must accept only the
possibility of some aspects of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous, but only insofar that they are not permitted to outright say that it’s
impossible for God to have directly intervened. Clearly, according to the Biblical record, there are ample examples of ways by which God could have acted on His creation in the past. But, on the other side of the argument, Catholic scientists, if they are indeed true to their faith, must also accept the
possibility of some aspects of creationism, intelligent design and the miraculous not applying in the degree that science can directly measure His presence.
Is the working of God in nature something that we can observe and detect? If so, then it is possible that it can be defined.
I think that reason and revelation can detect this. I do not think that science can do this though.
I’m willing to accept that angels move the tree-tops and also that God parted the Red Sea, caused manna to come down from the sky, and caused people to rise up to heaven body and soul. These are all events that can be observed and which cannot be explained by natural laws.
I think the moving of the tree-tops can be explained by natural events, such as the wind for example.
The parting of the Red Sea, although much less likely so, could also have a natural explanation to, as I’m sure you’re aware. Myself, since the Bible describes the parting as follows…
By the blast of your nostrils the waters piled up. The surging waters stood firm like a wall; the deep waters congealed in the heart of the sea.
…I’m less inclined to accept that this is simply a windstorm blowing the waters back. But I think you understand what I mean.
Manna literally means “What is this?” And it could also have a natural explanation too.
For example,
angel’s hair is a wispy and flakey edible thing which has been observed to fall from the sky and quickly dissipate (some times it’s justfound on the ground. Of course, people who have observed this angel’s hair still don’t know exactly what it is (some think it is spider’s web), which reminds me of the Jewish people encountering the Manna.
Some think it could be from Tamarisk trees (particularly Tamarix Gallica), which were once comparatively extensive throughout the southern parts of the Sinai Peninsula. Their resin is similar to wax, melts in the sun, is sweet and aromatic (like honey), and has a dirty-yellow colour, fitting somewhat with the biblical descriptions of manna.
Still others think it could be a kind of fungi, since most of characteristics of manna are similar to that of psilocybe cubensis.
I’m not saying that these are the cases. It could be something totally new created literally from nothing, something that specifically attests to God’s creative power. I’m only saying that there are natural events recorded in history which could conceivably explain these events without recourse to the miraculous.
Finally, regarding the raising from the dead,
I totally agree with you. This miracle, unlike the other miracles noted above,
could not have a natural explanation.