Arctic ice 'disappearing fast'

  • Thread starter Thread starter Matt25
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ah yes, the ice shrinks…ok big deal. Whoever said the earth’s climate was stable? We are leaving an iceage, and before then the earth was a great deal hotter than it is now. It always seems to bounce back without too much of a problem. 😉
Pray very hard that you are right, because if not you can kiss goodbye to NO, LA, NY, and lots of these low lying cities. Continued human stupidity could, for once, make Hollywood right wshen it produced a dumb film called Waterworld.
So they have been studying it for how long? Do they even have data for one solar cycle (11 year cycle)? How about more than one? For the length of man’s polution history? How can they even prove this? :confused:
Actually they have been looking at the Earths weather history for about 500,000,000 (thats five hundred million) years. The current trends bear absolutely no comparisons with what has been seen before, i.e. the results are the same, cooling and warming, the time frame is unparralled, in other words a hell of a lot faster than anything in the past. What’s the only difference? WE ARE.
Ah yes, when they can predict the temperatures for next year/month/week by that accuracy I might listen to their 100 year prediction. :rolleyes:
Ah, the “why should I listen to predictions when they can’t even tell me if it’s going to rain tomorrow” argument. I wonder, do you have money in a pension fund? If so can you tell me what the stock market is going to do tomorrow? Or is it that you are relying in it’s growth (based on averages of course) over the much longer term? And what is the evidence for predicting such growth?

It seems that many are willing to invest their future in monetary terms on the say predictive so of financial analysts but, reject those same future predictions based on scientific principles, by scientists, because …?
 
40.png
Libero:
Well I for one am in support of the kyoto agreement, it infuriated me some years back at the G8 summit when President Bush refused to accpet that humans have an effect over climate control and global warming. How can America, perhaps the country that will have the greatest effect on global warming refuse to accept any responsibility? Especially with more erratic weather conditions such as Katrina and Rita occuring more frequently.
OK, this is not difficult to understand. The US is concerned about jobs. If you want to get a treaty passed then you can’t give China or India a free pass. China for example has the world’s 3rd largest GDP with an industrial growth rate 4 times that of the US. If you want to solve what is supposedly a global issue, do you think that an attempt at a fair treaty would have been a good idea??? I have been around and around on this issue, but for some reason the one question I posted that no one on the pro-Kyoto treaty side of the fence has addressed is why can’t the treaty be fair? Why a free pass and a competitive edge to China?
People like you want to smack the US around for not signing this poorly worded, unfair treaty. You look the other way when the subject of developing countries come up. These developing countries are luring companies from all over the globe to relocate their manufacturing there. So you want the US to implement standards that will increase the cost of manufacturing there, which are already higher by the way since we pay a decent wage, and allow China to have a competitive edge.
 
40.png
Libero:
Especially with more erratic weather conditions such as Katrina and Rita occuring more frequently.
Is Katrina and Rita erratic weather? I don’t know, lets see in a few years before we can say that, it could be a start of a trend but it might not be.

Check out this list. What explains the erratic weather in 1960 and 1961 when there where back to back years of two Catogory 5 hurricanes?

weathermatrix.net/tropical/cat5storms.htm
 
I don’t know how much the Kyoto protocal wiill impact the financial well-being of a nation when I see the Scandinavian countries doing so well:

taipeitimes.com/News/front/archives/2005/09/29/2003273640

When it comes to economics I am fairly conservative but I would like to see conservationism realinged with conservativism. Living and teaching in Taiwan for a year has impacted we views on the world population significantly.

Adam
 
40.png
shockerfan:
OK, this is not difficult to understand. The US is concerned about jobs. If you want to get a treaty passed then you can’t give China or India a free pass. China for example has the world’s 3rd largest GDP with an industrial growth rate 4 times that of the US. If you want to solve what is supposedly a global issue, do you think that an attempt at a fair treaty would have been a good idea??? I have been around and around on this issue, but for some reason the one question I posted that no one on the pro-Kyoto treaty side of the fence has addressed is why can’t the treaty be fair? Why a free pass and a competitive edge to China?
People like you want to smack the US around for not signing this poorly worded, unfair treaty. You look the other way when the subject of developing countries come up. These developing countries are luring companies from all over the globe to relocate their manufacturing there. So you want the US to implement standards that will increase the cost of manufacturing there, which are already higher by the way since we pay a decent wage, and allow China to have a competitive edge.
The problem has nothing to do with what China did or did not, or will or will not do. It simply revolves around America’s constant denials that anything may be wrong. If America feels that Kyoto is wrong, fine, come up with something else that the rest of the world can be comfortable with. The only thing until recently America seems to have contributed to the discussion is a flat denial of any problem. At last the administration has now conceded that there IS a problem, maybe the next step is to come uo with some concrete steps to deal with it. Unfortunately all that seems to have been said so far is the “science” in the way of new and unimagined forms of mass energy is the answer. we here about how people are “Working” on the problem. Haven’t heard any budget figures yet or even any claims of progress, I suppose something must be happening. smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/10/10_3_6.gif
 
40.png
shockerfan:
People like you want to smack the US around for not signing this poorly worded, unfair treaty. You look the other way when the subject of developing countries come up. These developing countries are luring companies from all over the globe to relocate their manufacturing there. So you want the US to implement standards that will increase the cost of manufacturing there, which are already higher by the way since we pay a decent wage, and allow China to have a competitive edge.
The European Union countries have signed up to Kyoto. We compete with China too you know. Some things are more important than the short term.

Yes every country should be involved in controlling greenhouse gas emissions. Kyoto was not the best agreement theoretically possible. It was the best agreement practically agreeable. A “coalition of the willing” which practically reduces pollution today is better than doing nothing until a “coalition of perfection” can be acheived sometime, maybe never.

Developing countries accuse developed countries of hypocrisy in industrialising but then tryin to forbid others, ie developing countries, from doing the same. We need to stop polluting now as well as finding clean cheap technologies to allow the third world to industrialise safely. Its not a question of either/or both must be done now.
 
40.png
Libero:
I really wish the church would take a greater involvement about this, we are always on about defending the future of the church, but If something isn’t done then there shall not be a planet Earth to practice Catholicism on in a few centuries.
Actually the Church has spoken out see conservation.catholic.org/index.htm

Global Climate Change:A Plea for Dialogue, Prudence, and the Common Good*

A Statement of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops***
**

The Call of Creation: God’s Invitation and the Human Response
** The Natural Environment and Catholic Social Teaching
**The Catholic Bishops Conference of England and Wales
 
OK, this is not difficult to understand. The US is concerned about jobs. If you want to get a treaty passed then you can’t give China or India a free pass. China for example has the world’s 3rd largest GDP with an industrial growth rate 4 times that of the US. If you want to solve what is supposedly a global issue, do you think that an attempt at a fair treaty would have been a good idea??? I have been around and around on this issue, but for some reason the one question I posted that no one on the pro-Kyoto treaty side of the fence has addressed is why can’t the treaty be fair? Why a free pass and a competitive edge to China?
People like you want to smack the US around for not signing this poorly worded, unfair treaty. You look the other way when the subject of developing countries come up. These developing countries are luring companies from all over the globe to relocate their manufacturing there. So you want the US to implement standards that will increase the cost of manufacturing there, which are already higher by the way since we pay a decent wage, and allow China to have a competitive edge.
I thought that claims of ‘unfair’ were instantly void on this forum, I found that to be the case when discussing the attitude towards homosexuals. Also, just because China etc. have set a bad example does not mean the US can just follow suit, two wrongs do not make a right. As for the cost, many other European countries have signed the treaty and have to increase costs, also what good is money if we dont have a planet. By cutting on costs now, we are only increasing the amount of money we will have to spend the preserve, and prevent the destruction of our planet at a later date. Developing countries are not luring manufacturing work, large coroporate companies take advantage of cheap labour and a huge workforce. The countires would not be developing (or at least not to as great an extent) if work was not sent their way.
 
40.png
Libero:
I thought that claims of ‘unfair’ were instantly void on this forum, I found that to be the case when discussing the attitude towards homosexuals.
??? Not exactly related to Arctic Ice disappearing fast.
40.png
Libero:
Also, just because China etc. have set a bad example does not mean the US can just follow suit, two wrongs do not make a right.
This is not about China setting a bad example…its about the international community exempting them from the treaty. They were allowed to play by special rules, that others were not allowed to play by.
40.png
Libero:
As for the cost, many other European countries have signed the treaty and have to increase costs, also what good is money if we dont have a planet.
Please answer this question: If the planet is so important, why not require all countries to play by the same rules. Why give China, India, et. al., a free pass and create an unlevel playing field?
40.png
Libero:
Developing countries are not luring manufacturing work, large coroporate companies take advantage of cheap labour and a huge workforce. The countires would not be developing (or at least not to as great an extent) if work was not sent their way.
Then I guess they don’t need to have special exemptions, now do they?
 
This is not about China setting a bad example…its about the international community exempting them from the treaty. They were allowed to play by special rules, that others were not allowed to play by.
Please answer this question: If the planet is so important, why not require all countries to play by the same rules. Why give China, India, et. al., a free pass and create an unlevel playing field?
Just because one country has conditions different to another does not mean that a particular country should not participate, does this not seem childish. Some may say that it is unfair that Ireland and the US have to abide by the same rules, the US has caused much greater damage to the earth than Ireland. So what if china gets to play by special rules, it makes the country that uses this as an excuse not to join the treaty seem far worse. No nobody else kicks up a huge fuss, is America just creating bad excuses?
 
40.png
Libero:
Just because one country has conditions different to another does not mean that a particular country should not participate, does this not seem childish.
A worker in an American factory loses their job to a new factory built in China because the costs are lower to build it there. How is concern for a person’s ability to provide for their family “childish”???
40.png
Libero:
So what if china gets to play by special rules
So what if the US doesn’t sign the treaty
40.png
Libero:
No nobody else kicks up a huge fuss, is America just creating bad excuses?
If you cannot understand the basic concept of fairness then you can’t grasp why a lot of Americans like myself oppose the Kyoto treaty. We have the number one GDP in the world…we have the most to lose. As I have said before, either global warming is a global problem or its not. No free pollution passes for just some countries.
 
A worker in an American factory loses their job to a new factory built in China because the costs are lower to build it there. How is concern for a person’s ability to provide for their family “childish”???
You don’t think that every other developed country has thought this, England, Ireland, Italy, France, Germany? They took the risk of loosing jobs in order to save a planet. When there is a will there is a way, American families will be provided for, with or without the factories. Your factories will move to developing countries anyway, there are other reasons.
So what if the US doesn’t sign the treaty.
The USA uses an extremely large amount of the worlds resources, they produce an extremely large amount of greenhouse gases, the US is vital to the success of the kyoto agreement, It is like the US presence in the League of Nations; the US will be the keystone here. If the US does not sign the treaty, then it is argueable that they are most to blame about the decline of this planet.
If you cannot understand the basic concept of fairness then you can’t grasp why a lot of Americans like myself oppose the Kyoto treaty. We have the number one GDP in the world…we have the most to lose. As I have said before, either global warming is a global problem or its not. No free pollution passes for just some countries.
Such an attitude is childish ‘I won’t play unless they do this’ and so on, if everyone else on this planet to that attitude then it would be a shambles. What is most to lose meant to mean? The kyoto agreement is one that stands to protect our planet and the lives of our predecessors, we would be making an act of providence, a display of intelligence, everyone could loose out, but in the long run, we stand to loose alot more.
 
%%% EXPERIMENTAL%%%
Are you guys saying that if there were no oil from the ground, countries of the world cannot industrialize???
In the future, all this oil from the ground WILL BE GONE!!! Will the factories of the world end up in a standstill??? Will cars, vehicles, airplanes stop moving???

What about ethanol and other alcohol equivalents???

Countries of the world should be busy planting sugar canes and other plants necessary for the production of ethanol and these other alcohol equivalents SO THAT THESE CO2 GASES IN THE AIR WILL BE ABSORBED BY THE PLANTS, REDUCED IN VOLUME INTO A SOLID, SO THAT THE ATMOSPHERE WILL BECOME A SMALLER TARGET FOR THE SUN’S RAYS, AND IN SO DOING, ABSORB LESS OF THE SUN’S RAYS AND CAUSE COOLING OF THE EARTH, JUST AS THE EARTH INDEED GETS COOLER IN WINTER WHEN THE EARTH IS FAR FROM THE SUN IN ITS ELLIPTICAL ORBIT AND THUS RECEIVES LESS OF THE SUN’S RAYS THAN WHEN IT DOES IN SUMMER WHEN THE EARTH IS NEAR THE SUN IN ITS ELLIPTICAL ORBIT.
the-eurasian@earthlink.net
 
40.png
Libero:
They took the risk of loosing jobs in order to save a planet.
Perhaps they took a leap of faith that somehow this treaty will make an impact. 95.5% of green house gases are NOT man made.
40.png
Libero:
Your factories will move to developing countries anyway, there are other reasons.
If the factories will move to more deloping countries anyway, wouldn’t it make sense to include those countries in the treaty so that greenhouse gases will be reduced? Or is pollution from China some kind of “magic pollution” different from all other kinds of pollution that does not contribute green house gases?

Dance as you will around the point I have had in all of my threads…if all countries were included in the treaty…with no exemptions, you might have a point.
 
Perhaps they took a leap of faith that somehow this treaty will make an impact. 95.5% of green house gases are NOT man made.
Such an attitude should not be taken, if 95% of all rape crimes are never solved, should we just not care about the other 5% and give up on all investigations?
If the factories will move to more deloping countries anyway, wouldn’t it make sense to include those countries in the treaty so that greenhouse gases will be reduced? Or is pollution from China some kind of “magic pollution” different from all other kinds of pollution that does not contribute green house gases?
Dance as you will around the point I have had in all of my threads…if all countries were included in the treaty…with no exemptions, you might have a point.
It would make sense, however in times of crisis sense is not always fully present. Developing countires are special cases however, they need money, imposing treaties on developing countries so early on in their development could futher cripple them. Just because America does not think this treaty is fair on them does not mean they can just ignore it. What goes around comes around, was it fair that America attacked a country with an inferior army and then destoryed two thousand years of their history due to questionable motives in the first place? Life is not fair.
 
40.png
Libero:
What goes around comes around, was it fair that America attacked a country with an inferior army and then destoryed two thousand years of their history due to questionable motives in the first place?
Ah yes Liberalism is shining thru…you defend an unfair treaty by changing the subject to a war against a brutal dictator who murdered hundreds and thousands of his people. Wow. China gets a free pass on the Kyoto treaty, and Saddam Hussein gets a free pass as well.

At least you’re consistent.
40.png
Libero:
Life is not fair.
Correct you are. And until you and your kind can come up with a fair treaty, me and my kind will continue to vote for politicians who will not sign treaties like that.

God Bless.
 
Sun’s effect on global warming underrated: report
Increased solar output contributed to at least 10 to 30 per cent of global warming from 1980 to 2002, two Duke University physicists report…

In the absence of standardized data, Scafetta and West wrote, other researchers reported there was no increase in heating from the sun, thus concluding that all global warming increases observed between 1980 and 2002 were caused by greenhouse gases.

According to Scafetta, records of sunspot activity suggest that solar output has been rising slightly for about 100 years. Using a 22-year interval to examine solar changes, the physicists filtered out shorter range effects that can influence surface temperatures but are not related to global warming.

These shorter-range effects include volcanic eruptions – which can temporarily cool the climate – and ocean current changes that affect global weather patterns… greenhouse gases… would still give a contribution, but not so strong as was thought," Scafetta said.
 
Ani Ibi said:
Sun’s effect on global warming underrated: report

Increased solar output contributed to at least 10 to 30 per cent of global warming from 1980 to 2002, two Duke University physicists report…

*"[Greenhouse] gases would still give a contribution, but not so strong as was thought," Scafetta said in a written statement.

…

“For now, if our analysis is correct, I think it is important to correct the climate models so that they include reliable sensitivity to solar activity. Once that is done, then it will be possible to better understand what has happened during the past hundred years.”*

Mike
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top