Are Mormons Christian?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ContraFool
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
ContraFool:
Oh my. I somehow doubt that the regular rank and file Mormons are aware of this, because I doubt my Mormon friends would be as respectful of Catholicism as they are if they actually thought that.
Well like I said you gotta push pretty hard to get this out of them. But if you ask them about how Joseph Smith founded the LDS church, you will eventually get to “God” telling him that ALL churches were an abomination to him. Plus, it’s in the Book of Mormon. Actually it’s in the first few books. It’s not something that is advertised or really talked about with others, because it ruins their attempts to become more like mainstream Christianity.
 
The dictionary defines “Christian” as anyone who follows the teachings of Jesus.QUOTE] This is what makes Mormons non-Christian. They reject many teachings of Jesus, for example that Jesus is Yahweh, and that the Father and Christ are One. They agree with Jesus on certain points, but they are far from accepting His teachings.
 
You are most likely correct. This is just all a little bit hard for me to accept given how very close I am to this one Mormon girl and how she doesn’t seem at all the image of what most Catholics thinks Mormons are. Sometimes I really do get the impression that she is very unaware of her church’s brutal history and some of their really far out there beliefs, such as their whole anti-Catholic thing. Because what I have seen trough my personal dealings with her and her family and friends is that Mormons are very liberal and acceping people who don’t have any harsh opinions about anyone. heck, she is even against the ban on gay-marriage and I could have sworn I heard that Mormons were very anti-gay in general. Is it possilbe that this girl and her family and friends are not a good example of mainstream Mormon beliefs?
40.png
tkdnick:
Well like I said you gotta push pretty hard to get this out of them. But if you ask them about how Joseph Smith founded the LDS church, you will eventually get to “God” telling him that ALL churches were an abomination to him. Plus, it’s in the Book of Mormon. Actually it’s in the first few books. It’s not something that is advertised or really talked about with others, because it ruins their attempts to become more like mainstream Christianity.
 
Contra…it is quite possible. I have a very dear friend (she is one of my best friends) who is a Jehovah’s Witness. You’d never know it unless we talked religion. There are points we agree on, and much more we don’t. I pray for her conversion every day (she was born into the organization-- and yesterday during a conversation, she did call it just that, not her faith, but their organization).

I just suggest you pray for her (you probably already are). JW’s aren’t supposed to associate with anyone outside of their faith…it could mean excommunication for them. We both realized that we cannot convert each other…so we tend to stay away from these religious discussions…so prayer is the only thing left 🙂
 
ContraFool said:
" My guess would be that their baptism is valid because they converted so many Christians, even Catholics who had proper baptisms…

The Church has recently declared their baptism invalid because they do not believe in the Trinity as being one God but rather three seperate gods. This belief also seperates them from being Christian.
 
This is a footnote.

Did you know that Utah is the only state that allows a condemed man to be put to death by a firing squad?

Presumably because he will spill his own blood in death to pay for his sin of murder.
 
I actually know this to be false. I have heard my Mormon friend acknowledge the Divinity of Christ about 1000 times. Granted she thinks He’s separate from the Father and the Holy Spirit, but still she knows He is Divine.
40.png
puzzleannie:
the guidelines from our diocese for RCIA state that Mormons do not believe in the divinity of Jesus Christ.
 
Yes, I pray for her converstion all the time. I know she is a good person and I know she does not think badly of the Catholic Church. I hardly think she would call me her brother if she did. So I do know that there is hope for her. There just HAS to be.
40.png
all4life:
Contra…it is quite possible. I have a very dear friend (she is one of my best friends) who is a Jehovah’s Witness. You’d never know it unless we talked religion. There are points we agree on, and much more we don’t. I pray for her conversion every day (she was born into the organization-- and yesterday during a conversation, she did call it just that, not her faith, but their organization).

I just suggest you pray for her (you probably already are). JW’s aren’t supposed to associate with anyone outside of their faith…it could mean excommunication for them. We both realized that we cannot convert each other…so we tend to stay away from these religious discussions…so prayer is the only thing left 🙂
 
40.png
ContraFool:
I actually know this to be false. I have heard my Mormon friend acknowledge the Divinity of Christ about 1000 times. Granted she thinks He’s separate from the Father and the Holy Spirit, but still she knows He is Divine.
True as far as it goes, but you hae too remember two things.
  1. Mormons use many of the same words and terms that Christians do, but redefine them beyound recongnition. In this case mormons redefine the word divine.
  2. Mormons beleive that Jesus is divine yes, but no more divine than any faithful “WORTHY” temple married mormon has the potential of becomming. Christians believe in one God in three persons, mormons OTOH believe in at least three seperate “gods” and millions of the “gods” in the making.
There is no comparison.
 
40.png
ContraFool:
You are most likely correct. This is just all a little bit hard for me to accept given how very close I am to this one Mormon girl and how she doesn’t seem at all the image of what most Catholics thinks Mormons are. Sometimes I really do get the impression that she is very unaware of her church’s brutal history and some of their really far out there beliefs, such as their whole anti-Catholic thing. Because what I have seen trough my personal dealings with her and her family and friends is that Mormons are very liberal and acceping people who don’t have any harsh opinions about anyone. heck, she is even against the ban on gay-marriage and I could have sworn I heard that Mormons were very anti-gay in general. Is it possilbe that this girl and her family and friends are not a good example of mainstream Mormon beliefs?
No, I wouldn’t necessarily say your friend is a bad example of mainstream Mormonism, although possible. My best friends are a Mormon family, and I know there are some Mormon teachings that they don’t know about. The LDS religion, has several beliefs (so I have heard) that are hidden even from their own faithful. As far as church history, they all get it in high school and in college (at an LDS college), but it has a HUGE LDS spin on it. It is possible that maybe your friend isn’t a “die hard” Mormon though.
 
ContraFool,

Yes, as stated above, one must be very careful when speaking with Mormons. They will use the same words as Christians, i.e., Christ, God, gospel, scripture, etc., but they have given them totally different meanings than Christianity.

Judeo-Christianity has always believed in one God. Jews and Catholics alike have always been monothiests. We believe in only one God. Mormonism disagrees with historical Judeo-Christianity. Mormons are polythiests. They believe there are many gods, and that their god and Jesus and the Holy Spirit are just 3 of the eons of gods they think exist. And that they will one day (if they follow all of their so called “prophets” rules) become one of these gods and godesses. They believe all these eons of gods and godesses are divine and they will one day be divine like them, too.

Mormon men believe, if they follow all the Mormon rules, they will someday be a god ruling over their own planet, with their goddess wife or wives producing spirit children to populate their own worlds.
 
40.png
all4life:
I just wanted to add that polygamy is still being practiced by a group that branched off from the “regular” LDS…they call themselves Mormon Fundamentalists (FLDS). They reside mostly in Canada, Mexico and throughout the American West. The formal LDS church has “separated” themselves from the FLDS because of the polygamy and such.

By the way, the polygamous Mormons are, in reality the true Mormons. The main group of Mormons today, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints are technically an apostate group. Mormons had to be polygamous almost the first 70 years of the organizations existance. The commandment of polygamy is still in their Book of Doctrine and Covenants. If Mormon males were not polygamous they would not be able to enter their celestial heaven why they died. So by technical terms and Mormon history, the polygamous Mormons out west today are the true Mormons, still following the words they claim were given to their original prophets by God.

Just another of many reasons Mormons are not Christians.
 
So can anyone tell me why all of this weird stuff about Mormons isn’t widely known? I mean everyone is pretty familiar with beliefs central to Catholics and Protestants. Are Mormons some how ashamed of what they believe? Or is it, like it appears to me, that the average Mormon isn’t that familiar with some of the stranger beliefs of their church? Like I have said before, I highly doubt my LDS friend or her family know that they are supposed to be anti-Catholic, or anti-any religion for that matter.
 
40.png
ContraFool:
So can anyone tell me why all of this weird stuff about Mormons isn’t widely known? I mean everyone is pretty familiar with beliefs central to Catholics and Protestants. Are Mormons some how ashamed of what they believe? Or is it, like it appears to me, that the average Mormon isn’t that familiar with some of the stranger beliefs of their church? Like I have said before, I highly doubt my LDS friend or her family know that they are supposed to be anti-Catholic, or anti-any religion for that matter.
In my research on false religions, they all operate with much the same techniques. How much do most people know about Mormon beliefs, Scientology, Jehovah Witnesses, Muslims, the New Age, etc., unless a person decides to do research. Many of these groups, such as the Mormons, keep many of their beliefs as secret as possible. In this way they can slowly indoctrinate unsuspecting individuals. It’s the old frog in the pot story. If you put a frog in a pot of boiling water, he’ll jump out. But if you put him in a pot of cold water and slowly turn up the heat, he’ll stay in it and cook himself. Many people don’t know much about Mormon beliefs when they are so called “baptized” as new converts. Mormon “missionaries” are taught high pressure sales techniques. There are six “missionary” lessons they give when people first inquire about the Mormons. By the second or third lesson, the “missionaries” will try to get a person to commit to being “baptized”, when they are not aware of most of Mormonisms wierd teachings. Mormon “missionaries” call this “milk before meat”. Or, better stated, the plausible before the ludicrous. Mormons themselves, not just the “missionaries” are also taught to follow this technique. They know how to make themselves appear Christian on the surface, while not letting a new investigator on to any of the weird stuff they believe in. When asked about these weirder beliefs, they will either deny them or act as they know nothing about them when they really do.

All these cults use quite a bit of psychological manipulation. They are basically scams that know how to use techniques to pull as many unsuspecting individuals into joing them.
 
One of the problems Mormons have with knowing their beliefs, is that they believe in continuous revelation. They believe that anything their current prophet says is more important than what any previous prophet said. So their doctrine is constantly changing. For a decent look at their beliefs you can look to Doctrine & Covenants and Gospel Principles (somewhat like our Catechism). However, even these aren’t complete. There is a book called The Journal Of Discourses that covers many of the changes that occurred in Mormon theology over the first part of the church history. The book has been removed from print and taken out of LDS libraries because it shows all these differences. For instance, it talks about the fact that Adam was actually God. Some (maybe all) Mormons now hold that Adam was Michael the archangel. There are apparantly several statements in this book that are essentially evidence that Mormonism isn’t true.

On a side note…if anyone knows where I can find a Journal of Discourses, I would be GREATLY appreciative!!!
 
Well thank you very much for that detailed answer. I only hope that the Mormons I know don’t tell me all of this out of ignorance rather than wanting to draw me in. But hopefully they know by now (especially my close LDS friend) that nothing could ever make me leave the Catholic Church.
40.png
Sophie:
In my research on false religions, they all operate with much the same techniques. How much do most people know about Mormon beliefs, Scientology, Jehovah Witnesses, Muslims, the New Age, etc., unless a person decides to do research. Many of these groups, such as the Mormons, keep many of their beliefs as secret as possible. In this way they can slowly indoctrinate unsuspecting individuals. It’s the old frog in the pot story. If you put a frog in a pot of boiling water, he’ll jump out. But if you put him in a pot of cold water and slowly turn up the heat, he’ll stay in it and cook himself. Many people don’t know much about Mormon beliefs when they are so called “baptized” as new converts. Mormon “missionaries” are taught high pressure sales techniques. There are six “missionary” lessons they give when people first inquire about the Mormons. By the second or third lesson, the “missionaries” will try to get a person to commit to being “baptized”, when they are not aware of most of Mormonisms wierd teachings. Mormon “missionaries” call this “milk before meat”. Or, better stated, the plausible before the ludicrous. Mormons themselves, not just the “missionaries” are also taught to follow this technique. They know how to make themselves appear Christian on the surface, while not letting a new investigator on to any of the weird stuff they believe in. When asked about these weirder beliefs, they will either deny them or act as they know nothing about them when they really do.

All these cults use quite a bit of psychological manipulation. They are basically scams that know how to use techniques to pull as many unsuspecting individuals into joing them.
 
Do any of you know if JW baptisms are recognized by The Church (CC, of course!) Wondering, since Mormon ones are not. :hmmm:
 
40.png
catsrus:
Do any of you know if JW baptisms are recognized by The Church (CC, of course!) Wondering, since Mormon ones are not. :hmmm:
I would be very suprised if they were. I was baptized a JW as a teenager and I was taught and believed that Jesus was NOT divine. The Holy Spirit was also NOT God. But, like Mormons if you ask JW’s if they believe, for example that “Jesus died for their sins” they will say yes - however their understanding of Jesus is totally different from yours. So as far as the dictionary saying that “Christian” is anyone who follows Christ… that might work for Webster, but I’m not sure it’s the way God defines Christian.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top