Are we really that ignorant?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LIT56RD
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If I understand what you are saying is that it doesn’t matter what the infallible teachings are we are to just do and say what ever the church tells us to do. We don’t need to be bothered with knowing what is infallible or not.:confused:
No, I didn’t say that and neither did the link I pointed you towards. When someone suggests an answer, read it. It beats shoving words down their throat – you’re not confused, friend, you’re trolling.

dj
 
+JMJ+

Oh, LIT56RD, there are lots of Catholic independent thinking in regards to the Bible that are perfectly acceptable to Mother Church! Proof? Why, just consider the Rosary!

The Rosary is centered on meditating 20 (recently added from 15) episodes (called Mysteries) in the lives of Jesus and Mary, 18 of which are directly lifted from the Holy Bible. Just ask each and every one of those who pray the Rosary here and elsewhere, and I bet no one will say that they had any one meditation on any particular Mystery that is the same with another meditation on the same Mystery!

Just consider the homilies on different Holy Masses for the same day! Just try it: go to different Holy Masses of the same day and listen to the homilies of different priests on the same Readings. I’d be surprised if you find even the same focus of discussion for each.

Please reflect on what G.K. Chesterton wrote more than a hundred years ago:

And if we took the third chance instance, it would be the same; the view that priests darken and embitter the world. I look at the world and simply discover that they don’t. Those countries in Europe which are still influenced by priests, are exactly the countries where there is still singing and dancing and coloured dresses and art in the open-air. Catholic doctrine and discipline may be walls; but they are the walls of a playground… We might fancy some children playing on the flat grassy top of some tall island in the sea. So long as there was a wall round the cliff’s edge they could fling themselves into every frantic game and make the place the noisiest of nurseries. But the walls were knocked down, leaving the naked peril of the precipice. They did not fall over; but when their friends returned to them they were all huddled in terror in the centre of the island; and their song had ceased.

G.K. Chesterton, Orthodoxy (emphasis mine)

You see, it is the walls of Catholic doctrine that lets us enjoy reading, praying, and living on Scripture with joy and without fear. Those walls are the reason we can play around the concepts and insights that we glean from the Word of God and make surprisingly beautiful expressions of faith, hope, and love for God. Those walls are the reason why we have so many beautiful devotions like Divine Mercy, Immaculate Heart of Mary, the Rosary, Sacred Heart of Jesus, and so on and so forth. Those rigid doctrines are the reason why we have so diverse expressions of piety in the form of the different orders: the Carmelites, Jesuits, Franciscans, Benedictines, Dominicans, etc.

The flower-girl Glycera was so skilled in varying the arrangement and combination of her flowers, that out of the same kinds she produced a great variety of bouquets; so that the painter Pausias, who sought to rival the diversity of her art, was brought to a standstill, for he could not vary his painting so endlessly as Glycera varied her bouquets. Even so the Holy Spirit of God disposes and arranges the devout teaching which He imparts through the lips and pen of His servants with such endless variety, that, although the doctrine is ever one and the same, their treatment of it is different, according to the varying minds whence that treatment flows.

St. Francis de Sales, “Preface”, Introduction to the Devout Life (emphasis mine)

As for the Protestants? The origins of the Protestant movement are exactly a protest to those same walls of authority. And what happened to them? They themselves became as rigid as the doctrines they originally protested against. One group proclaims their own interpretation of Scripture, and a different group a different one of their own, and of course so on for other groups. Instead of making a consensus, they held themselves rigid and split apart from each other. And yet these new groups make new groups in each, each as rigid as the ones before. On and on this process went until we have the thousands of different Protestant denominations, each agreeing to disagree with each other, each blind to their own rigidity (as you are, LIT56RD, in maintaining to your own "independent interpretation of Scripture), each wounded in varying degrees due to their fall to heresy from the heights of orthodoxy.

God love you.
Congratulations. Excellent post!

dj
 
I believe that when the holy spirit acts he may infallible. But I believe the HS is more of a guiding force rather than a factual and dominating force.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church
scborromeo.org/ccc.htm

The CCC calls the Catholic Church the “Temple” of the Holy Spirit.

"*The Holy Spirit - God’s gift
733 "God is Love"124 and love is his first gift, containing all others. "God’s love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us."125

734 Because we are dead or at least wounded through sin, the first effect of the gift of love is the forgiveness of our sins. The communion of the Holy Spirit126 in the Church restores to the baptized the divine likeness lost through sin.

735 He, then, gives us the “pledge” or “first fruits” of our inheritance: the very life of the Holy Trinity, which is to love as "God [has] loved us."127 This love (the “charity” of 1 Cor 13) is the source of the new life in Christ, made possible because we have received “power” from the Holy Spirit.128

736 By this power of the Spirit, God’s children can bear much fruit. He who has grafted us onto the true vine will make us bear "the fruit of the Spirit: . . . love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control."129 “We live by the Spirit”; the more we renounce ourselves, the more we "walk by the Spirit."130

Through the Holy Spirit we are restored to paradise, led back to the Kingdom of heaven, and adopted as children, given confidence to call God “Father” and to share in Christ’s grace, called children of light and given a share in eternal glory.131

The Holy Spirit and the Church

737 The mission of Christ and the Holy Spirit is brought to completion in the Church, which is the Body of Christ and the Temple of the Holy Spirit. This joint mission henceforth brings Christ’s faithful to share in his communion with the Father in the Holy Spirit. The Spirit prepares men and goes out to them with his grace, in order to draw them to Christ. The Spirit manifests the risen Lord to them, recalls his word to them and opens their minds to the understanding of his Death and Resurrection. He makes present the mystery of Christ, supremely in the Eucharist, in order to reconcile them, to bring them into communion with God, that they may "bear much fruit.“132 *”
 
All of the teachings of the Apostles, the Councils, and the Sacred tradition (including the New Testament) are infallible. However, as far as papal pronouncements, the list is very short, and you can get it easily with a google search. 😉
From what I get from the statement above is that every teaching of the church is infallible. Is that correct.

I have googled infallible documents and have not gotten any lists definitive lists.
 
A good example of how this works are optical illusions. The brain automatically tries to fit what the eye sees in with what the brain already knows (to make sense of the (name removed by moderator)ut). A person cannot look at a stimulus, whether it is a book, or a puzzle, without the brain attempting to interpret.
In other words, if we can not stop our brain from interpreting the Bible we should not read it, for we are not to interpret the Bible on our own.
 
What makes you say there are no cross references? I thought you were reading a catechism? There should be enough references in there to keep you busy for a decade at least. 😃
Is everything listed in the catechism infallible?
 
No, I didn’t say that and neither did the link I pointed you towards. When someone suggests an answer, read it. It beats shoving words down their throat – you’re not confused, friend, you’re trolling.

dj
I know he seems like he is trolling. He did to me at first, too. But when one reads through his posts, it is clear he has been deeply wounded by what he thinks is the Catholic Church (misdirecting priest and catechists). He is angry and resentful about it, and is currently in an anti-Catholic community that is stirring up his hurt and resentment.
 
No, I didn’t say that and neither did the link I pointed you towards. When someone suggests an answer, read it. It beats shoving words down their throat – you’re not confused, friend, you’re trolling.

dj
Unless I misunderstand the your meaning of trolling. No I am not. The only thing I am trolling for, right now, is a list put out by the church that says which teachings are infallible and which are not. I have not been able to find a definitive list even with google searches.
 
From what I get from the statement above is that every teaching of the church is infallible. Is that correct.
The Teaching of Jesus that was deposited to the Church once for all through the Apostles is infallible. This is the highest level of teaching.

There are also teachings that relate to certain times and places, customs:
.
Acts 15:28-29
28 For it has seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us to lay upon you no greater burden than these necessary things: 29 that you abstain from what has been sacrificed to idols and from blood and from what is strangled and from unchastity. If you keep yourselves from these, you will do well. Farewell."

There are pastoral instructions:
1 Cor 7:12-14

12 To the rest** I say, not the Lord, **that if any brother has a wife who is an unbeliever, and she consents to live with him, he should not divorce her. 13 If any woman has a husband who is an unbeliever, and he consents to live with her, she should not divorce him.

And there are disciplines, such as fasting, that are subject to revision and change.
I have googled infallible documents and have not gotten any lists definitive lists.
Clearly I misunderstood you. I thought you wanted Papal declarations that were considered infallible.

There are no “documents” that are infallible. Infallibility is a quality of persons, not writings, however Holy. The act of writing documents without error is an infallible act. The New Testament is the most widely known example of the infallible action of the Holy Spirit through the Church.
 
In other words, if we can not stop our brain from interpreting the Bible we should not read it, for we are not to interpret the Bible on our own.
Obviously people read the scriptures every day, not realizing they are interpreting. They think that the Holy Spirit has guided them into their interpretations, and they do not realize that they are being influenced by their own perceptions.

This is the mistake I think the priest made with you and your friends. Instead of telling you not to read, he should have taught you how to read it correctly. That would have possibly spared you a lifetime of suffering.

I think the references in this thread have made it clear that the Apostolic method of reading scripture is that we read it in the light of what Jesus taught. These teachings are infallibly preserved in the Catholic Church by the Holy Spirit. When one reads the scriptures separately from the faith that produced them, all kinds of strange errors manifest themselves. Some people who read it don’t believe Jesus is divine, or that the HS is a person. 🤷
 
Is everything listed in the catechism infallible?
The catechism is not a “list”. It is the “faithful echoing” of the teaching of the Apostles. The catechism is a summary of the doctrines of the faith, but it is not considered an infallible document. It contains the infallible teachings that were once for all deposited to the Church. It is a sure norm which we can use to understand the faith of the Apostles.

The Teachings of the Apostles are not given to us in “lists”. They taught a way of life, a world view, a manner of being on earth. The infallible teachings are part of this lifestyle, called in the NT “The Way”.
Unless I misunderstand the your meaning of trolling. No I am not. The only thing I am trolling for, right now, is a list put out by the church that says which teachings are infallible and which are not. I have not been able to find a definitive list even with google searches.
That will be a fruitless “troll” then, LIT, because the Apsotles did not teach the faith using “lists”. They taught a way of life that is centered around Jesus Christ, the Son of God. If you read the words of Jesus in the NT, I think you will quickly see that the faith He taught does not come in “lists”. 😃

I am not sure there are any ecclesial communties that teach in “lists” but if you need this, you will not be able to find it in the Catholic Church.
 
So as catholics we should reading the Bible but not really thinking about what it is saying. We need to have the church tell us what it is saying.:eek:
We’re all the way back to this? Your prejudice is so vast that you can’t even seem to comprehend what people are saying without attempting to force your own predisposed ideas onto their words. I’m trying to stay calm.

Try this for a correction to the above:

So as catholics, we SHOULD read the Bible and think about what it is saying, but we should ALSO learn what Sacred Tradition says about the passages we read and ways in which learned saints of the past have pondered the way the passages we read harmonize with OTHER passages to form a cohesive whole gospel message. Otherwise, each successive generation starts over from scratch and the holy wisdom of 2,000 years of saints goes wasting, and humanity repeats over and over again heresies that were first identified and refuted thousands of years ago.
 
Unless I misunderstand the your meaning of trolling. No I am not. The only thing I am trolling for, right now, is a list put out by the church that says which teachings are infallible and which are not. I have not been able to find a definitive list even with google searches.
Lit –

The others are going to laugh at me for quoting Wikipedia, since anyone can edit it to say whatever they want to say, but it does seem to have a start at the listing you’re asking for.

As for me personally, I would list the following as infallible pronouncements of the Catholic Church:
The Bible;
The Nicene Creed;
The documents of the 21 ecumenical councils (a list is available here, with links to each council);
The official pronouncement of the Immaculate Conception of Mary; and
The official pronouncement of the Assumption of Mary.
But here’s the Wikipedia entry:
Instances of papal infallibility
It is not even correct to hold that doctrine teaches that the Pope is infallible in everything he says. In reality, the invocation of papal infallibility is extremely rare.
Catholic theologians agree that both Pope Pius IX’s 1854 definition of the dogma of the Immaculate Conception of Mary, and Pope Pius XII’s 1950 definition of the dogma of the Assumption of Mary are instances of papal infallibility, a fact which has been confirmed by the Church’s magisterium.[20] However, theologians disagree about what other documents qualify.
Regarding historical papal documents, Catholic theologian and church historian Klaus Schatz made a thorough study, published in 1985, that identified the following list of ex cathedra documents (see Creative Fidelity: Weighing and Interpreting Documents of the Magisterium, by Francis A. Sullivan, chapter 6):
“Tome to Flavian”, Pope Leo I, 449, on the two natures in Christ, received by the Council of Chalcedon;
Letter of Pope Agatho, 680, on the two wills of Christ, received by the Third Council of Constantinople;
Benedictus Deus, Pope Benedict XII, 1336, on the beatific vision of the just prior to final judgment;
Cum occasione, Pope Innocent X, 1653, condemning five propositions of Jansen as heretical;
Auctorem fidei, Pope Pius VI, 1794, condemning seven Jansenist propositions of the Synod of Pistoia as heretical;
Ineffabilis Deus, Pope Pius IX, 1854, defining the Immaculate Conception;
Munificentissimus Deus, Pope Pius XII, 1950, defining the Assumption of Mary.
For modern-day Church documents, there is no need for speculation as to which are officially ex cathedra, because the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith can be consulted directly on this question. For example, after Pope John Paul II’s apostolic letter Ordinatio Sacerdotalis (On Reserving Priestly Ordination to Men Alone) was released in 1994, a few commentators speculated that this might be an exercise of papal infallibility.[21] In response to this confusion, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith has unambiguously stated, on at least three separate occasions,[22][23][24] that Ordinatio Sacerdotalis although not an ex cathedra teaching (i.e., although not a teaching of the extraordinary magisterium), is indeed infallible, clarifying that the content of this letter has been taught infallibly by the ordinary and universal magisterium.[25]
The Vatican itself has given no complete list of papal statements considered to be infallible. A 1998 commentary on Ad Tuendam Fidem, written by Cardinals Ratzinger (the later Pope Benedict XVI) and Bertone, the prefect and secretary of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, listed a number of instances of infallible pronouncements by popes and by ecumenical councils, but explicitly stated (at no. 11) that this was not meant to be a complete list.[24]
The number of infallible pronouncements by ecumenical councils is significantly greater than the number of infallible pronouncements by popes.
Wikipedia entry, “Papal Infallibility,” excerpted 5/19/11.

Another thing that might be useful would be to ask what doctrines are infallible. The Church once listed a series of such doctrines (non-exhaustively, unfortunately) as follows:
the articles of faith of the Creed, the various Christological dogmas and Marian dogmas; the doctrine of the institution of the sacraments by Christ and their efficacy with regard to grace; the doctrine of the real and substantial presence of Christ in the Eucharist and the sacrificial nature of the eucharistic celebration; the foundation of the Church by the will of Christ; the doctrine on the primacy and infallibility of the Roman Pontiff; the doctrine on the existence of original sin; the doctrine on the immortality of the spiritual soul and on the immediate recompense after death; the absence of error in the inspired sacred texts; the doctrine on the grave immorality of direct and voluntary killing of an innocent human being.
Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio Fidei, by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.
 
In other words, if we can not stop our brain from interpreting the Bible we should not read it, for we are not to interpret the Bible on our own.
Actually, it’s just the opposite. Here’s the official Catholic Church teaching on reading Scripture:
V. Sacred Scripture in the Life of the Church
131 “and such is the force and power of the Word of God that it can serve the Church as her support and vigour, and the children of the Church as strength for their faith, food for the soul, and a pure and lasting fount of spiritual life.” Hence “access to Sacred Scripture ought to be open wide to the Christian faithful.”
132 “Therefore, the study of the sacred page should be the very soul of sacred theology. the ministry of the Word, too - pastoral preaching, catechetics and all forms of Christian instruction, among which the liturgical homily should hold pride of place - is healthily nourished and thrives in holiness through the Word of Scripture.”
133 The Church "forcefully and specifically exhorts all the Christian faithful… to learn the surpassing knowledge of Jesus Christ, by frequent reading of the divine Scriptures. Ignorance of the Scriptures is ignorance of Christ.
CCC ¶¶ 131-133.

Now, of course, the problem then arises: what if two Christians disagree about what Scripture says? E.g., suppose Frank says, “The Bible says that we are saved by faith alone, and not by works!” But Tom says, “The Bible says that faith without works is dead and has no power to save!” How does Susan decide who’s right?

The Church teaches us how to understand Scripture:
III. The Holy Spirit, Interpreter of Scripture
109 In Sacred Scripture, God speaks to man in a human way. To interpret Scripture correctly, the reader must be attentive to what the human authors truly wanted to affirm, and to what God wanted to reveal to us by their words.
110 In order to discover the sacred authors’ intention, the reader must take into account the conditions of their time and culture, the literary genres in use at that time, and the modes of feeling, speaking and narrating then current. “For the fact is that truth is differently presented and expressed in the various types of historical writing, in prophetical and poetical texts, and in other forms of literary expression.”
111 But since Sacred Scripture is inspired, there is another and no less important principle of correct interpretation, without which Scripture would remain a dead letter. “Sacred Scripture must be read and interpreted in the light of the same Spirit by whom it was written.”
The Second Vatican Council indicates three criteria for interpreting Scripture in accordance with the Spirit who inspired it.
112 Be especially attentive “to the content and unity of the whole Scripture”. Different as the books which compose it may be, Scripture is a unity by reason of the unity of God’s plan, of which Christ Jesus is the center and heart, open since his Passover.
The phrase “heart of Christ” can refer to Sacred Scripture, which makes known his heart, closed before the Passion, as the Scripture was obscure. But the Scripture has been opened since the Passion; since those who from then on have understood it, consider and discern in what way the prophecies must be interpreted.
113 2. Read the Scripture within “the living Tradition of the whole Church”. According to a saying of the Fathers, Sacred Scripture is written principally in the Church’s heart rather than in documents and records, for the Church carries in her Tradition the living memorial of God’s Word, and it is the Holy Spirit who gives her the spiritual interpretation of the Scripture (". . . according to the spiritual meaning which the Spirit grants to the Church").
114 3. Be attentive to the analogy of faith. By “analogy of faith” we mean the coherence of the truths of faith among themselves and within the whole plan of Revelation.
The senses of Scripture
115 According to an ancient tradition, one can distinguish between two senses of Scripture: the literal and the spiritual, the latter being subdivided into the allegorical, moral and anagogical senses. the profound concordance of the four senses guarantees all its richness to the living reading of Scripture in the Church.
116 The literal sense is the meaning conveyed by the words of Scripture and discovered by exegesis, following the rules of sound interpretation: “All other senses of Sacred Scripture are based on the literal.”
117 The spiritual sense. Thanks to the unity of God’s plan, not only the text of Scripture but also the realities and events about which it speaks can be signs.
  1. the allegorical sense. We can acquire a more profound understanding of events by recognizing their significance in Christ; thus the crossing of the Red Sea is a sign or type of Christ’s victory and also of Christian Baptism.
  2. the moral sense. the events reported in Scripture ought to lead us to act justly. As St. Paul says, they were written “for our instruction”.
  3. the anagogical sense (Greek: anagoge, “leading”). We can view realities and events in terms of their eternal significance, leading us toward our true homeland: thus the Church on earth is a sign of the heavenly Jerusalem.
118 A medieval couplet summarizes the significance of the four senses:
The Letter speaks of deeds; Allegory to faith;
The Moral how to act; Anagogy our destiny.
119 “It is the task of exegetes to work, according to these rules, towards a better understanding and explanation of the meaning of Sacred Scripture in order that their research may help the Church to form a firmer judgement. For, of course, all that has been said about the manner of interpreting Scripture is ultimately subject to the judgement of the Church which exercises the divinely conferred commission and ministry of watching over and interpreting the Word of God.”
CCC ¶¶ 109-119.
 
I really think it is ironic that there is not definitive listing of all the infallible teachings of the Catholic church. To my understanding is that because of this we are to assume that every teaching, thought and proposal that comes from the Pope, bishops, and even the priests would be considered infallible. And then at some point in time when they all decide to change their mind they can say that it is ok because the original was teaching was not infallible and we can change that for it was not recorded as infallible at the time. Seems quite convenient to me.:eek:
 
I really think it is ironic that there is not definitive listing of all the infallible teachings of the Catholic church. To my understanding is that because of this we are to assume that every teaching, thought and proposal that comes from the Pope, bishops, and even the priests would be considered infallible. And then at some point in time when they all decide to change their mind they can say that it is ok because the original was teaching was not infallible and we can change that for it was not recorded as infallible at the time. Seems quite convenient to me.:eek:
There isn’t a list but there is a standard of what is infallible and what isn’t.
"Although the individual bishops do not enjoy the prerogative of infallibility, they can nevertheless proclaim Christ’s doctrine infallibly. This is so, even when they are dispersed around the world, provided that while maintaining the bond of unity among themselves and with Peter’s successor, and while teaching authentically on a matter of faith or morals, they concur in a single viewpoint as the one which must be held conclusively. This authority is even more clearly verified when, gathered together in an ecumenical council, they are teachers and judges of faith and morals for the universal Church. Their definitions must then be adhered to with the submission of faith"
You continue to ask to make statements like
In other words, if we can not stop our brain from interpreting the Bible we should not read it, for we are not to interpret the Bible on our own
When the Bible says
30And Philip running thither, heard him reading the prophet Isaias. And he said: Thinkest thou that thou understandest what thou readest?
31 Who said: And how can I, unless some man shew me? And he desired Philip that he would come up and sit with him.
Do you think Scripture thinks your ignorant?
 
We’re all the way back to this? Your prejudice is so vast that you can’t even seem to comprehend what people are saying without attempting to force your own predisposed ideas onto their words. I’m trying to stay calm.
One must keep in mind that the OP selected the title for this thread. 😉
 
Lit –

The others are going to laugh at me for quoting Wikipedia, since anyone can edit it to say whatever they want to say, but it does seem to have a start at the listing you’re asking for.
I thought about posting something similar, but I don’t think that is really what the OP wants. That information is readily available in a google search, which he said he did, and could not find. :confused:

Therefore, I must conclude that he is really asking for somthing else.

He has also demonstrated that he is not willing to do the research himself, so doing it for him will be counterproductive. He has been given many great links and leads in this thread, yet he still keeps repeating the same drivel - “so, we shouild not read the bible?”

This is what makes him seem like (as the thread title demonstrates) or a troll. If he really wants to know what the Church believes and teaches, he will look into it. If he just wants to ply the anti-Catholic prejudice into which he has been indoctrinated, then he will not be here for long.
 
I really think it is ironic that there is not definitive listing of all the infallible teachings of the Catholic church.
I find it ironic that you would think the Teaching of Jesus would appear in “lists”. It seems pretty self evident to me, in reading the Scriptures, that Jesus taught in parables most of the time. I can’t think of a single occasion when he taught anything in a “list”. He even answered questions put to him by using parables and not “lists”.
Code:
To my understanding is that because of this we are to assume that every teaching, thought and proposal that comes from the Pope, bishops, and even the priests would be considered infallible.
It is regrettable that you have been misinformed about the Catholic faith.

It is even more regrettable that you are unwilling, or unable to have the misinformation given to you corrected.

I will pray for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top