Are we really that ignorant?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LIT56RD
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am having a real hard time of making sense of all of this. So you are saying is that even popes are human and have all human frailties they never make a mistake.

If I may expand on the math problem: If the math test asks what is 4 times 4? The pope declares that it is 17, than 17 will be what it is for now and for ever.🤷
Goodness, no I’m not saying they never make mistakes. Peter clearly gave in to fear and peer pressure at times in his personal conduct. For example, he refrained from eating ‘unkosher’ foods even after it had already been revealed that that Mosaic restriction no longer applied due to peer pressure and gave the appearance of marginalizing the gentile converts (seem to appear second class christians). Paul rightly rebuked him. But you’ll notice that he never wrote an apostolic letter telling believers they still had to eat kosher. That’s the difference between impeccable and infallible. His personal behavior isn’t protected (rather obviously). His official teaching is.

To your example, the pope isn’t, in fact, infalliable at math. If he WERE and he personally thought 4x4=17, he’d be unable to express that erroneous thought formally and officially. Could be mentioned at a dinner party with friends, but something would happen to prevent it becoming official teaching. The pen runs dry, the printer breaks down, the car crashes, a terrifying dream occurs the night before, war breaks out… One way or another, it never becomes official teaching. Pope ain’t a normal job. 😉
 
Goodness, no I’m not saying they never make mistakes. Peter clearly gave in to fear and peer pressure at times in his personal conduct. For example, he refrained from eating ‘unkosher’ foods even after it had already been revealed that that Mosaic restriction no longer applied due to peer pressure and gave the appearance of marginalizing the gentile converts (seem to appear second class christians). Paul rightly rebuked him. But you’ll notice that he never wrote an apostolic letter telling believers they still had to eat kosher. That’s the difference between impeccable and infallible. His personal behavior isn’t protected (rather obviously). His official teaching is.

To your example, the pope isn’t, in fact, infalliable at math. If he WERE and he personally thought 4x4=17, he’d be unable to express that erroneous thought formally and officially. Could be mentioned at a dinner party with friends, but something would happen to prevent it becoming official teaching. The pen runs dry, the printer breaks down, the car crashes, a terrifying dream occurs the night before, war breaks out… One way or another, it never becomes official teaching. Pope ain’t a normal job. 😉
I am still a little shaky on the infallible thing. I still don’t understand that a human can be infallible and never create some thing that is not correct. You are talking some pretty far reaching circumstances in the above quote.

Is there a complete list of all the infallible teachings? So someone could look at that and clear up what is infallible and what is just suggestions.
 
I am still a little shaky on the infallible thing. I still don’t understand that a human can be infallible and never create some thing that is not correct. You are talking some pretty far reaching circumstances in the above quote.

Is there a complete list of all the infallible teachings? So someone could look at that and clear up what is infallible and what is just suggestions.
An apparently reasonable request except that it avoids the basic issue:

The Relationship Between Freedom And Faith
Accepting full intellectual and moral responsibility for his decision, the Catholic decides who to listen to, who to follow, and, come the crunch, to whom to submit. The Catholic believes that, in the apostolically constituted community of faith, the Bishop of Rome is Peter among us. The Catholic believes that the words of Jesus, “He who hears you hears me,” have abiding historical applicability until the end of time. The bishops teaching “with and under” Peter can teach infallibly. Infallibility means that the fullness of apostolic authority will never be invoked to require us to believe anything that is false. The relationship between freedom and faith is set forth in Vatican IIs Constitution on the Church in the Modern World:

It is only in freedom, however, that human beings can turn to what is good, and our contemporaries are right in highly praising and assiduously pursuing such freedom, although often they do so in wrong ways as if it gave a license to do anything one pleases, even evil. Genuine freedom is an outstanding sign of the divine image in human beings. . . . Human dignity demands that the individual act according to a knowing and free choice, as motivated and prompted personally from within, and not through blind internal impulse or merely external pressure.

I may not understand an authoritative teaching of the Magisterium, I may have difficulties with a teaching, but, as Newman understood, a thousand difficulties do not add up to a doubt, never mind a rejection. I may think a teaching is inadequately expressed, and pray and work for its more adequate expression in the future. But, given a decision between what I think the Church should teach and what the Church in fact does teach, I decide for the Church. I decide freely and rationally — because God has promised the apostolic leadership of the Church guidance and charisms that He has not promised me; because I think the Magisterium just may understand some things that I don’t; because I know for sure that, in the larger picture of history, the witness of the Catholic Church is immeasurably more important than anything I might think or say. In short, I obey.

The nuances of such obedience, of what is meant by “thinking with the Church” (sentire cum ecclesia), are admirably spelled out in the 1990 instruction of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, “The Ecclesial Vocation of the Theologian.” It is an instruction that can be read with enormous benefit also by those who are not professional theologians. My point is this: Liberal Catholicism cannot be reinvented, it cannot be rehabilitated, it will not be vibrantly Catholic, until it candidly and convincingly comes to terms with obedience.
Reading Selections from The Persistence of the Catholic Moment by Fr. Richard John Neuhaus

The link above will give you much much more to consider.

dj
 
Is there a complete list of all the infallible teachings? So someone could look at that and clear up what is infallible and what is just suggestions.
An apparently reasonable request except that it avoids the basic issue:
If I understand what you are saying is that it doesn’t matter what the infallible teachings are we are to just do and say what ever the church tells us to do. We don’t need to be bothered with knowing what is infallible or not.:confused:
 
I am still a little shaky on the infallible thing. I still don’t understand that a human can be infallible and never create some thing that is not correct. You are talking some pretty far reaching circumstances in the above quote.

Is there a complete list of all the infallible teachings? So someone could look at that and clear up what is infallible and what is just suggestions.
Yes, I am talking some pretty far reaching, mind bending circumstances, aren’t I? God is able to do things we can’t even imagine.

As the above poster notes, it is not as simple as making two lists one headed “Infallible, must believe” and the other headed “Ignore if you so desire”. He explained better than I can why catholics should never think the way expressed in my second list header.

But the first list isn’t necessarily a bad attitude, especially for someone laboring under the misunderstanding that catholicism treats any and every subject with narrow dogma. You will be surprised to learn how little is rigidly defined (mainly because it was explicitly revealed). The simplest way to learn about it is an old book by Ludwig Ott “Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma”. It’s dense, scholarly reading, but blessedly lacks a lot of the ambiguity of more recent writings (whose authors often tend to value “being nice” higher than being precise. (Written prior to Vatican II). As a protestant, you’ll find some things in there that alarm you a bit. Flag them, move on and come back to the alarming stuff at the end with cross references to the Current Catechism of the Catholic Church (which is less blunt, but has the advantage in this circumstance of often being written to clarify words and phrases historically commonly misunderstood or misinterpreted).

amazon.com/Fundamentals-Catholic-Dogma-Dr-Ludwig/dp/0895550091/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1305728783&sr=8-1
 
I am still a little shaky on the infallible thing. I still don’t understand that a human can be infallible and never create some thing that is not correct. You are talking some pretty far reaching circumstances in the above quote.
It may be that we aren’t being clear. We are not saying that the Pope “can be infallible and never create some thing that is not correct.” The Pope is only infallible when pronouncing definitively on matters of faith and morals – so an offhand comment at a news conference doesn’t cut it. Popes make mistakes all the time. Popes sin all the time; John Paul II and Benedict XVI are both known to go to confession regularly. They are human beings, just like you and I. But they have this one difference: I can absolutely guarantee you that no pope will ever issue an encyclical definitively stating that Christians are called to believe that Jesus Christ was just a really good man and not really God. Why? Because the Holy Spirit will prevent that from happening.
Is there a complete list of all the infallible teachings? So someone could look at that and clear up what is infallible and what is just suggestions.
No, there is no specific list. But we can get you started. The Nicene Creed and Apostles’ Creed (found here) are a good start. Conciliar documents are often infallible (but only ecumenical ones, not regional councils).

Hope this helps.
 
From you posts it appears your having a conceptual problem. Do you believe the Holy Spirit is infallible?

peace
 
LIT56RD,

Infallible doesn’t mean the Pope will have all the answers all the time. It means when the Church doesn’t have the answer it will be guided to not rule.

On those things the Church (because the bishops teaching together are also infallible) is not sure of it remains silent. To circle back to your original point about specific sections of scripture, there are many, if not most, where the Church has remained silent and an authoritative and binding interpretation. You can read most of the bible receiving inspiration and guidance for that phase of your life that, as long as it is consistent with Church teaching, is perfectly acceptable. I.E. you may read it one week as you’re struggling and be inspired to persevere offering your sacrifices to God, another week and be inspired to be thankful for all those things you have received in life.
 
No, there is no specific list. But we can get you started. The Nicene Creed and Apostles’ Creed (found here) are a good start. Conciliar documents are often infallible (but only ecumenical ones, not regional councils). Hope this helps.
So in other words when someone on these forums says something is infallible, there is no way to determine if that is truth or not. There is no cross reference as to what is infallible. And now you say that even bishops can be infallible. And still no list. 🤷

I have not a clue what Conciliar documents are let alone if they are ecumenical or regional. :confused:
 
From you posts it appears your having a conceptual problem. Do you believe the Holy Spirit is infallible?

peace
I believe that when the holy spirit acts he may infallible. But I believe the HS is more of a guiding force rather than a factual and dominating force.
 
LIT56RD,

Infallible doesn’t mean the Pope will have all the answers all the time. It means when the Church doesn’t have the answer it will be guided to not rule.

On those things the Church (because the bishops teaching together are also infallible) is not sure of it remains silent. To circle back to your original point about specific sections of scripture, there are many, if not most, where the Church has remained silent and an authoritative and binding interpretation. You can read most of the bible receiving inspiration and guidance for that phase of your life that, as long as it is consistent with Church teaching, is perfectly acceptable. I.E. you may read it one week as you’re struggling and be inspired to persevere offering your sacrifices to God, another week and be inspired to be thankful for all those things you have received in life.
The high lighted portion in above post goes back to the original question I posted in post #1. Evidently we are not smart enough to read the Bible and determine how it can effect and influence our life with out cross referencing everything with the church.:mad:
 
The high lighted portion in above post goes back to the original question I posted in post #1. Evidently we are not smart enough to read the Bible and determine how it can effect and influence our life with out cross referencing everything with the church.:mad:
Well, think about it. Our faith is 2000 years old. It is taught in every country in the world pretty much. We are led by hundreds of different bishops who have dioceses with many people of differing needs.

Luckily the Church is very, well, nuanced. Contrary to popular opinion, you can have a whole spectrum of different understandings and they’ll all be Catholic teachings. But simply because there is such a wide range, there is a necessity to have a ‘limit’ because otherwise people would start to push the boundaries, arguing that since already there is ‘some’ divergence’ that THEIR view is simply a ‘wider’ divergence.

Without an authority (and we’ll say The Church is that authority), where do you draw the line for, let’s say, helping the poor. Well, one person’s idea of helping the poor might be with money. Another might argue for education. Another might say improving physical health. All of these things are good, right?

Ah. But now, suppose that (as often happens) the ‘poor’ happens to be a woman, a woman of color, a poor woman, a woman with 2 children ‘already’ and she’s only 20. And she becomes pregnant. Well, she is already getting aid for the 2 children she has, and she already has to ‘wait’ until those children are grown before she can ‘live her own life’ so in that sense one more is not a ‘huge’ burden. And cooking for 4 instead of 3 is not really that much more expensive. But oh MY you are going to get TREMENDOUS arguments from those who want to help the poor that this woman SHOULD GET AN ABORTION.

Why? Because she ‘already has too much to take care of." "It’s too much of a burden on her.’ "The other children won’t have as much time with her’. "She’ll lose even more time before she can be a ‘productive’ member of society’.

Without an authority like the Church to hold the line stubbornly with ‘Abortion is murder’, you’re going to have people argue that it is HELPING the mother if she aborts. And these people are reading Scripture on their own and they are finding justification because, in their minds, this one more life is going to make that mother ‘stay poor’ longer, and since poverty is the one unforgiveable sin, ANYTHING which thereotically ‘stops’ that poverty is to be applied. . .even abortion.

That’s the kind of danger that ‘independent’ thinkers come across. They tend to fixate on Scripture out of context or just focus on what they think Jesus ‘meant’ to be ‘most important’. Quite often they’re wrong, and even when they start out right, they often end up going wrong because they’re just using their own, limited, fallible intellect and not really relying on God and His Church. I mean, He didn’t just establish a Church so we’d have cool Gothic cathedrals and the fun of seeing men wearing miters and robes. He established a Church so He could delegate His Paraclete and guide that Church, and nobody would be running around going, "God, can you hear me, am I right, give me a sign, with everybody arguing that THEY were the ones who had it right. . .
 
Are Catholics really that ignorant and stupid that we can not and should not read the Bible. I was told that once by a parish priest. That we as lay people do not have the ability to read and understand the Bible and that it is best left to those more learned and of more authority in the church. Are we devoid of any common sense that we can not read, and with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, glean some knowledge without someone else telling us EXACTLY what we need to think and do? Didn’t realize I, along with all the other Catholics, were just so stupid.:eek:
hmm actually I’ve never met a Catholic who thinks that they shouldn’t read the Bible.

The Catholic teaching is that we should read the Bible, but also that the Church interprets it - so we need to be informed about the Church’s interpretation of Scripture, and not just have a view that goes against Church doctrine… for example, like how Protestants ended up with many conflicting teachings that don’t have basis in the early Church at all.

But sure, we can and should read Scripture, that is what the Church has always taught… all those myths about the Church discouraging reading the Bible during the middle ages, etc - those are all myths, firstly because there was no printing press so people coudln’t read anyways, secondly - in the case of the Counter Reformation - the Church didn’t want people to go into heresy by* interpreting *Scripture on their own - but they could always read it. In fact, we hear many Bible passages at Mass 🙂

this website might help:
davidmacd.com/catholic/index2.htm

God bless 🙂
 
hmm actually I’ve never met a Catholic who thinks that they shouldn’t read the Bible.

The Catholic teaching is that we should read the Bible, but also that the Church interprets it - so we need to be informed about the Church’s interpretation of Scripture, and not just have a view that goes against Church doctrine… for example, like how Protestants ended up with many conflicting teachings that don’t have basis in the early Church at all.

But sure, we can and should read Scripture, that is what the Church has always taught… all those myths about the Church discouraging reading the Bible during the middle ages, etc - those are all myths, firstly because there was no printing press so people coudln’t read anyways, secondly - in the case of the Counter Reformation - the Church didn’t want people to go into heresy by interpreting **Scripture on their own - but they could always read it. In fact, we hear many Bible passages at Mass 🙂

this website might help:
davidmacd.com/catholic/index2.htm

God bless 🙂
So as catholics we should reading the Bible but not really thinking about what it is saying. We need to have the church tell us what it is saying.:eek:
 
I am having a real hard time of making sense of all of this. So you are saying is that even popes are human and have all human frailties
Well, of course they are! What did you think? When they accepted appointment as the servant of the servants of God they suddenly became divine?

The Apostles shared the gift of infallibility. It is quite clear in the scriptures they never stopped being human, and making mistakes.
they never make a mistake.
Jesus promised to lead the Church into “all Truth”. He does this in SPITE of our human failings. We need the gift of infallibility BECAUSE we are frail.

Why is it so impossible to believe that God can do something perfect through a fallible human being?

Acts 18:24 -28

24 Now a Jew named Apol’los, a native of Alexandria, came to Ephesus. He was an eloquent man, well versed in the scriptures. 25 He had been instructed in the way of the Lord; and being fervent in spirit, he spoke and taught accurately the things concerning Jesus, …When he (Apollos) arrived, he greatly helped those who through grace had believed, 28 for he powerfully confuted the Jews in public, showing by the scriptures that the Christ was Jesus.

Apollos was teaching infallibly by the power of the Holy Spirit.

He was accurate, and was able to confute the opposition.
If I may expand on the math problem: If the math test asks what is 4 times 4? The pope declares that it is 17, than 17 will be what it is for now and for ever.🤷
No, the Pope cannot make an infallible proclamation about anything that is contrary to what the Holy Spirit has already revealed to the Church in the Holy Scriptures or the Sacred Tradition.
I am still a little shaky on the infallible thing. I still don’t understand that a human can be infallible and never create some thing that is not correct.
It is good you are shaky on “that infallible thing”. I am sure it is possible for God to work so powerfully in the life of a person that they would never make a mistake, but it seems like it would be a very rare occurance, given the human propensity for sin.

But, since that is not what the gift of infalliblity means, it is irrelevant. 😃
Code:
You are talking some pretty far reaching circumstances in the above quote.
Yes, but it shows how far Jesus is willing to go to make sure His Holy Bride is preserved in purity, and that His promise that the Church will be led into “all Truth” is kept. 👍
Is there a complete list of all the infallible teachings? So someone could look at that and clear up what is infallible and what is just suggestions.
All of the teachings of the Apostles, the Councils, and the Sacred tradition (including the New Testament) are infallible. However, as far as papal pronouncements, the list is very short, and you can get it easily with a google search. 😉
 
If I understand what you are saying is that it doesn’t matter what the infallible teachings are we are to just do and say what ever the church tells us to do. We don’t need to be bothered with knowing what is infallible or not.:confused:
There are many levels of teachings in the Church. It is important to be familiar with what they are, and the content of the Teachings, so that we are not led astray by wolves among the sheep, like you were as a youth.

Really, I don’t think the priest who scolded you for reading the bible had evil intentions. He just wanted to prevent what eventually happened to you - you were led astray from the Faith because you misunderstood what you were reading.
So in other words when someone on these forums says something is infallible, there is no way to determine if that is truth or not.
Sure there is. Why not? Don’t you think that God has revealed Truth to mankind?
There is no cross reference as to what is infallible. And now you say that even bishops can be infallible. And still no list. 🤷
What makes you say there are no cross references? I thought you were reading a catechism? There should be enough references in there to keep you busy for a decade at least. 😃

If your bible does not have cross references, then you can get one that does. there are excellent study bibles available.

Be a Berean!

Acts 17:11-12
11 Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessaloni’ca, for they received the word with all eagerness, examining the scriptures daily to see if these things were so.
I have not a clue what Conciliar documents are let alone if they are ecumenical or regional. :confused:
The first example of a conciliar document is in Acts 15. The Magesterium met in council, made an infallible decision, then wrote to the faithful with instructions on how to implement what God had revealed to them.
I believe that when the holy spirit acts he may infallible. But I believe the HS is more of a guiding force rather than a factual and dominating force.
I don’t think you really mean this the way it sounds. If the HS “may” be infallible, then that also means the HS “may” make a mistake.

Yes, the HS guides, and does not force. But the content of His guidance is most certainly “factual”, if that means Truth.

John 16:13-15
3 When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth; for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come. 14 He will glorify me, for he will take what is mine and declare it to you. 15 All that the Father has is mine; therefore I said that he will take what is mine and declare it to you.

Either the Spirit of Truth came, or He didn’t.
Either He declared the Truth of God, or He didn’t
Either He guided the Church into “all Truth”, or He didn’t.

It basically boils down to whether you believe Jesus kept His promises, or not.
The high lighted portion in above post goes back to the original question I posted in post #1. Evidently we are not smart enough to read the Bible and determine how it can effect and influence our life with out cross referencing everything with the church.:mad:
It has nothing to do with smarts, Lit. Millions of very smart people in the last 2000 years have read the Bible, and made decisions about how it influences their lives.

Many of these people do it without cross referencing what they think with what the Holy Spirit has already revealed to the Church.

The Bible is a product of the Catholic Church. The New Testament was written by, for, and about Catholics. Catholicism is the faith that produced it, and the context from which it emanates. When it is removed from it’s context, the meaning is easily lost.

The same thing happens when someone reads Shakespeare outside of the historical context in which he wrote. It will be difficult to understand and appreciate what he wrote.
 
So as catholics we should reading the Bible but not really thinking about what it is saying. We need to have the church tell us what it is saying.:eek:
I think you will find that this is impossible. Everything that comes in through the senses is interpreted by the brain, and the mind “thinks” about what comes into it. How we understand the information that goes into our senses is influenced by our life experiences, and education (or lack of it).

A good example of how this works are optical illusions. The brain automatically tries to fit what the eye sees in with what the brain already knows (to make sense of the (name removed by moderator)ut). A person cannot look at a stimulus, whether it is a book, or a puzzle, without the brain attempting to interpret.

And yes, we all need the Church to teach us the faith. The One Faith was entrusted to the Church, and is infallibly preserved in her by the Holy Spirit. It is her duty to faithfully pass down what was entrusted to her.
 
+JMJ+
The purpose of this thread is to find out if the Catholic church allows independent thinking when it come to reading the Bible. Or if the church’s stand is that every idea and thought from the Bible must be run through the Catholic process before we can hear it.
Oh, LIT56RD, there are lots of Catholic independent thinking in regards to the Bible that are perfectly acceptable to Mother Church! Proof? Why, just consider the Rosary!

The Rosary is centered on meditating 20 (recently added from 15) episodes (called Mysteries) in the lives of Jesus and Mary, 18 of which are directly lifted from the Holy Bible. Just ask each and every one of those who pray the Rosary here and elsewhere, and I bet no one will say that they had any one meditation on any particular Mystery that is the same with another meditation on the same Mystery!

Just consider the homilies on different Holy Masses for the same day! Just try it: go to different Holy Masses of the same day and listen to the homilies of different priests on the same Readings. I’d be surprised if you find even the same focus of discussion for each.

Please reflect on what G.K. Chesterton wrote more than a hundred years ago:

And if we took the third chance instance, it would be the same; the view that priests darken and embitter the world. I look at the world and simply discover that they don’t. Those countries in Europe which are still influenced by priests, are exactly the countries where there is still singing and dancing and coloured dresses and art in the open-air. Catholic doctrine and discipline may be walls; but they are the walls of a playground… We might fancy some children playing on the flat grassy top of some tall island in the sea. So long as there was a wall round the cliff’s edge they could fling themselves into every frantic game and make the place the noisiest of nurseries. But the walls were knocked down, leaving the naked peril of the precipice. They did not fall over; but when their friends returned to them they were all huddled in terror in the centre of the island; and their song had ceased.

G.K. Chesterton, Orthodoxy (emphasis mine)

You see, it is the walls of Catholic doctrine that lets us enjoy reading, praying, and living on Scripture with joy and without fear. Those walls are the reason we can play around the concepts and insights that we glean from the Word of God and make surprisingly beautiful expressions of faith, hope, and love for God. Those walls are the reason why we have so many beautiful devotions like Divine Mercy, Immaculate Heart of Mary, the Rosary, Sacred Heart of Jesus, and so on and so forth. Those rigid doctrines are the reason why we have so diverse expressions of piety in the form of the different orders: the Carmelites, Jesuits, Franciscans, Benedictines, Dominicans, etc.

The flower-girl Glycera was so skilled in varying the arrangement and combination of her flowers, that out of the same kinds she produced a great variety of bouquets; so that the painter Pausias, who sought to rival the diversity of her art, was brought to a standstill, for he could not vary his painting so endlessly as Glycera varied her bouquets. Even so the Holy Spirit of God disposes and arranges the devout teaching which He imparts through the lips and pen of His servants with such endless variety, that, although the doctrine is ever one and the same, their treatment of it is different, according to the varying minds whence that treatment flows.

St. Francis de Sales, “Preface”, Introduction to the Devout Life (emphasis mine)

As for the Protestants? The origins of the Protestant movement are exactly a protest to those same walls of authority. And what happened to them? They themselves became as rigid as the doctrines they originally protested against. One group proclaims their own interpretation of Scripture, and a different group a different one of their own, and of course so on for other groups. Instead of making a consensus, they held themselves rigid and split apart from each other. And yet these new groups make new groups in each, each as rigid as the ones before. On and on this process went until we have the thousands of different Protestant denominations, each agreeing to disagree with each other, each blind to their own rigidity (as you are, LIT56RD, in maintaining to your own "independent interpretation of Scripture), each wounded in varying degrees due to their fall to heresy from the heights of orthodoxy.

God love you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top