Are we really that ignorant?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LIT56RD
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That’s what I have been saying all along is that I can not have an independent interpretation of the Bible. It always has to go through someone or some other document.:confused:
Of course you can, LIT. If this were not possible, there would not be a bizzilion Protestant communities. 😃

There are as many independent interpretations of the Bible as there are belly buttons, and just about that many “bible churches” to house them.

Catholics read the Scriptures using a certain pair of glasses. These lenses are called Sacred Tradition. They enable us to read the text from the point of view of those who wrote it. This way, we don’t make mistakes about what it means.
And the problem with that is???.
Our interpretations are limited by our expereinces and education (or lack of it). As a result, we can misunderstand what the authors meant.
Must we always refer to some else to tell us what to believe or not to believe or can we at some point say this is what I believe because of such and such.
You don’t have to consider what the Holy Spirit has already revealed to the Apostles and their disciples, and to the Church Jesus founded for the last 2000 years. You can ignore everything that God has said to mankind up to this point, and read the Scriptures as if you are the most pre-eminent authority that ever lived.

Plenty of people do this, and when their ideas about what it means disagree with the Church they are in, they just go out and start another one. This is why there is so much fragmentation in Christendom today.
Is it impossible to think that the Holy Spirit may also be influencing the lives and beliefs of ordinary people. Not just those who have chosen to be deacons, priests, bishops and popes.
The writers of the NT were “ordinary” people, LIT. Luke was a physician, most of the Apostles were fishermen, and Paul was a tentmaker. Of course the HS influences all of us to live and believe according to the One Faith of the Apostles. The HS does not lead one believer opposite of what He has led the Church for 2000 years.
Once again we must run every thought past someone else to see if it follows what they think and not what we believe God has guided us to believe.
It is not “someone else”, LIT, but God’s point of view that we must bring ourselves into alignment with.

It is very easy for one person, or several people, to stray from what God has guided us to believe. He founded a Church and appointed authorized teachers (the Magesterium) to keep the flock from straying into danger.
You owe obedience to God as your final authority>
Yes. 👍

And He gave that authority to His Apostles, and they to their successors, the Bishops. They have the responsibility to feed and care for the flock. Included in that is preventing us from going astray with wild ideas about what the Scripture means. We are to understand it from the point of view of those that wrote it. This perspective is preserved infallibly by the Holy Spirit in the Catholic Church.
In that verse the eunuch did not know what the readings meant. If I don’t understand what something in the Bible means I will ask someone whom I believe I can discuss it with, and after discussing it I will then, with the guidance of the Holy spirit and prayer, discern what the verse means.
Ok.

But if the person you choose does not have the perspective of the Apostolic faith, then you will not be protected by Jesus’ promise to the Church that He will lead into “all Truth”. This is how people fall into errors understanding the Scripture. He gave the promise to protect us from missing the mark. If we depart from the Apostolic faith, then we are no longer protected by the promise that was given to them.
I believe that the same verse with in the Bible can speak to people differently, depending upon where they are in their human life and their spiritual life.
Yes. This is absolutely true. Even the same person differently over time. 😉

This is part of Lectio Divina, a prayerful reading of the Scriptures that helps us to apply them to our lives.
 
No but neither does anyone else. I do not buy into the the fact that the Catholic church can never make a mistake.
In that case, you have already left the faith of the Apostles. 🤷

It is ok that you are not “buying”, since the Gospel of Christ is not for sale. It is infallibly preserved in His One Body, the Church, however.
Code:
 So which is worse, me making a mistake in my interpretation or blindly following what someone else has interpreted which may be a mistake also.
I think both of these are mistakes. If it were not possible to make them, then we would not need the gift of infallibility, would we?

But, it is a mistake to think that reading the Scriptures according to the faith that produced them is “blindly following”. Nothing could be further from the Truth.,
Code:
It's With intense prayer and guidance from respected Christians who will help me decide what is best for me, (not just tell what I should be doing) I believe that for the most part God and I get alone quite well.
Ok. So, what brings you here to CAF? From this statement, it seems you have no use for the Church founded by Christ. Did you just come here because you are still angry over wrong information you were given as a youth?
What I am saying is that on certain subjects there is no discussion as to what is acceptable. This is the way it is, end of discussion. Disagree and go to hell.
To some extent, this is the case. The Kingdom of God is a theocracy, not a democracy. He created us, so He gets to make the rules. He gives us commandments, and tells us that, if we don’t follow them, the end thereof is the way of death.

Jer 21:8
Thus says the LORD: Behold, I set before you the way of life and the way of death.

Deut 30:18-19
19 I call heaven and earth to witness against you this day, that I have set before you life and death, blessing and curse; therefore choose life,

Prov 14:12
12 There is a way which seems right to a man,
but its end is the way to death.

So what happens if a man takes the way that “seems right” to him, but it’s end is the way of death?

Jesus gave us the Church to prevent this from happening. There is no requirement that you receive the benefits of the gifts He gave to His Church. You can strike out on your own, or take your path with others who have a way that seems right to them. It is your choice.
God and I get along very well thank you. It is all the rules and regulations that the church has put out there and says that you will go to hell if you don’t follow them to the T.
It seems like you don’t think that God, as our Creator, gets to make the rules.

Or, maybe you don’t realize that there is no separation between Jesus and the Church. That is why the Church cannot err. She has Jesus as her Head, and the Holy Spirit as her Soul.
You may never have been told to not read the Bible. But on an April afternoon in 1974 I and three other classmate were sitting in church reading and discussion the Bible. The parish priest came over and asked what we were doing. We said we were reading and discussing the Bible. He said. “I wish you wouldn’t do that for that is not in keeping with Catholic understanding. You can not read the Bible without clergy present to interpret anything that is read.”
No, I did not have anything like this happen to me, but I was not encouraged to read it, either. It is too bad he answered this way, instead of sitting down and having bible study with you.

He did not express the fact very well that we are to read scripture in accordance with what God has already revealed for the Church. He is right, the clergy are supposed to help us to understand this perspective.

I think Scripture study is one of the greatest deficiencies in Catholic parishes today. How do you know that God is not calling you to address that problem? You clearly have a love of the word, and you also have personal experience of how much injury it causes not to read it.

  1. *]Use of contraceptives
    *]Not ejaculating within your wife when having sex
    *]Masturbation, solo or mutual
    *]Not believing the church can’t make a mistake
    *]The reason Onan was killed
    Disagreeing with the church an any item.

    All of these listed Items I have seen mentioned on various threads throughout this forum. And every one of them has been described as a grave moral issue or in other words mortal sin which send you to hell. It was even stated that to have sex with your wife just for the pure pleasure of sex could be down graded to only a venial sin if you didn’t enjoy it to much. Yes I saw this on a thread yesterday.

  1. I think it is important LIT, for you to understand why the Church teaches what she does on these points, before you rebel or reject them.

    Yes, they are all grave moral issues.

    Yes, mortal sins cause eternal death.

    However, you should not believe everything you read here, either. There are as many opinions here as there are belly buttons also. Some of them are consistent with Catholic Teaching, some are not. Do your own research on such issues, and learn the reasons behind the Teachings. If you are going to reject the Teaching of the Apostles preserved infallibly in the Catholic Church, at least do so with integrity.

    Don’t make the same mistake you did as a youth, not investigating if what the priest told you was really correct, then getting angry later when you found out it was not.
 
The purpose of this thread is to find out if the Catholic church allows independent thinking when it come to reading the Bible. Or if the church’s stand is that every idea and thought from the Bible must be run through the Catholic process before we can hear it.
The Church cannot prevent independent thinking, no matter what the issue is. Further, she would not wish to do so, since the abiltity to reason is one of God’s gifts that the Church has the responsibility to foster in the faithful.

That being said, it is not necessary or advisable for anyone to be using their God given reason apart from what God has revealed to mankind as Truth. Proper reasoning is entirely consistent with God’s revealed Truth.

I am not sure what you mean by “run through the Catholic process”. Perhaps you can clarify?

If you mean is our conduct to be consistent with what Jesus taught the Apostles, then yes that is the expectation for Catholics.
Yes I do remember exactly what he said. It really p*ssed me off at the time and still does. I was taught very strictly that you never, never, ever disagree with a priest or you will go to hell. They have ultimate authority. Never questioned it until now.
Well, then you now have an opportunity for spiritual and characterological growth, don’t you?

You were given misinformation, and you can choose to forgive the persons responsible, and move on with your growth, or you can choose to harbor a resentment. I will tell you though, as a person with a lot of expereince with resentment, holding on to it is like drinking poison, and expecting the other person to die. Your resentment toward those that injured you is not hurting them, only you.

Matt 6:14-15

14 For if you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father also will forgive you; 15 but if you do not forgive men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.

It is your growth that will be impeded.
Yes there is a catholic process. According to what posters are saying is that all Bible instruction must be approved by the church so everyone thinks and acts the same.
Well, I am at a loss as to what this means. I have never been educated in any such “process”. Are you sure that it is not more misunderstanding?

I think your own experience proves the fact that not “all bible instruction must be approved by the church so everyone thinks and acts the same”. You clearly have not been participating in bible study approved by the Church, have you? You seem to be absorbing a number of anti-Catholic sentiments.

As far as “think and act the same”, I am not sure what you mean by that. The Apostles taught that we should have agreement in doctrine.

1 Cor 1:10

10 I appeal to you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that all of you agree and that there be no dissensions among you, but that you be united in the same mind and the same judgment.

Phil 2:2-3
2 complete my joy by being of the same mind, having the same love, being in full accord and of **one mind. **

The faith is One. When we embrace it, we have unity of mind with one another.
The scriptures may be read and instruction given on them, but I am not suppose to form my own opinion of them.
I dont’ understand why you keep saying things like this. It seems as though you don’t understand the most basic operations of the human mind. Everything that comes into our senses is interpreted. The mind AUTOMATICALLY forms a perception (opinion) about the data. A person can’t “not form” such a perception. A person has no control over it. It is like saying you can eat food, but you “can’t digest it”. Digestion happens automatically.
When I ask for help in understanding something I will ask for an opinion.
This seems kinda strange to me. Why would you be satisfied with another person’s opinon, when you have available to you what the author meant?
If you go by what the church says I am not able to or suppose to disagree with it. Isn’t there a time when we can say we agree to disagree?
I hope you can show me where the Church says this, because it seems to me that this is opposite of what the Church teaches. Understanding scripture is not a matter of people’s opinions, and disagreeing with their opinons. The authors had a certain meaning. That meaning is infallibly preserved in the Catholic Church. Of course you can agree to disagree! Look up “church” in your local yellow pages. You will find that there are a great many ecclesial communities that disagree with what the Apsotles believed and taught, and found it expedient to substitute their own opinions.

You are made in the image and likeness of God. That means you are free to avoid choosing life.
 
Than evidently the RCC is not where I should be. To me the Eucharist is symbolic.
You think Jesus gave His “symbolic” body and blood on the cross?

**Luke 22:19-20
19 And he took bread, and when he had given thanks he broke it and gave it to them, saying, “This is my body which is given for you. Do this in remembrance of me.” 20 And likewise the cup after supper, saying, "This cup which is poured out for you is the new covenant in my blood.

How exactly does one bleed “symbolic” blood?
If it was really the body and blood of Christ or anyone it would taste like flesh and blood. **

It certainly is a mystery, how it retains the appearance of bread and wine, yet is in fact, His Body and Blood.

God made HIs Apostles stewards of this, along with other Divine Mysteries;

1 Cor 4:1
4:1 This is how one should regard us, as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God.

A mystery is beyond the ability of human senses, and intellect.
40.png
LIT56RD:
Code:
However, I thin  I believe that Christ instituted the Eucharist as an outward sign of him giving himself to us as our savior and redeemer.  And every time we perform this outward sign we are to remember what Christ did for us.
Yes, it is a sign of His sacrifice. In that sign, we are made present at the foot of His cross, as the elements are transformed by Him.
I was told in 3rd or 4th grade CCD class that a priest can determine your salvation.
I am sorry that you were given so much misinformation about the Catholic faith. I wish it were an isolated incident, but it is not. However, you are no longer in CCD, and it is not 1974. It is time for you to find out about the faith into which you are baptized,
 
Lit65Rd: No matter what a person has experienced no matter what terrrible misfortunes a person may encounter in life no matter what sin or sins(mortal or venial)a person has committed God will always take him back.If Hitler last dying words were Jesus Im truelly sorry for all the sins i have committed.I’ve been wrong all my life and now I’ve failed in this war I brought on humanity please forgive.Jesus would forgive him.
 
The scriptures may be read and instruction given on them, but I am not suppose to form my own opinion of them.

When I ask for help in understanding something I will ask for an opinion. If you go by what the church says I am not able to or suppose to disagree with it. Isn’t there a time when we can say we agree to disagree?
You never answered the questions. I’ll repeat three and pose two more.

Do you think all 40,000 protestant sects are correct in their interpretation of the Bible, or do you think some are right and some are wrong?

If you think any are interpreting it wrongly, then does that represent what God wants?

If God wants a multiplicity of interpretations of the Bible and disagreements about it, please explain why that is His will.

In stating particular areas in which you do not think the Catholic Church should have any moral authority, most relate to sex, and particularly masturbation. In your interpretation of the Bible, is masturbation a moral evil, a moral good or just neutral?

Finally, to what church do you now belong, if any?

I think we all understand that you reject the Catholic Church and felt it important to come into a Catholic site and repeat that, over and over again. We got that. We understand that you feel yourself justified in understanding the Bible the way you want to understand it. We get that too. But you have never said what you, yourself, believe about anything, other than that you believe your personal interpretation of the Bible is right.
 
@guanophore:
First I would like to thank you for discussing with me and not just lambasting me for my thoughts.

I am not sure how to better describe the Catholic Process of scripture. What I am saying it that the Church has interpreted what the holy scriptures mean and has declared them as the official meaning. That being said, there is no room for any other belief or interpretation or opinion. It is a closed deal. No changing. No discussion. That to me is the Catholic Process.
As far as “think and act the same”, I am not sure what you mean by that. The Apostles taught that we should have agreement in doctrine.
An agreement in doctrine, to my understanding, is that there is not room for any change or discussion. We all must think and act the same. No room for any personal opinion.
You are made in the image and likeness of God. That means you are free to avoid choosing life.
What I see in the above quote is what I have been saying all along. Is that if I express and believe my opinion than I am going to H*ll. No questions asked.
However, you should not believe everything you read here, either. There are as many opinions here as there are belly buttons also. Some of them are consistent with Catholic Teaching, some are not.
Maybe I am wrong. here but I am under the assumption that what people right on here is the absolute truth about the church and her teachings. I thought that everyone here had all the knowledge that came from the church and what they write is the truth.
 
Code:
@guanophore:
First I would like to thank you for discussing with me and not just lambasting me for my thoughts.
You put me in mind of myself. 😉
Code:
I am not sure how to better describe the *Catholic Process* of scripture.  What I am saying it that the Church has interpreted  what the holy scriptures mean and has declared them as the official meaning.
No, this is not the case. The Church has only done this for a small handful of verses. This is not the approach used by the CC.
Code:
 That being said, there is no room for any other belief or interpretation or opinion.  It is a closed deal.  No changing. No discussion.  That to me is the *Catholic Process.*
Well, you will not be able to find this in any Catholic document, official teaching, or writings of the Fathers or Doctors of the Church. It does not exist there because it is not Catholic. 🤷

I think, LIT, if you want to take issue with the CC, it makes more sense to pick a fight about what she really believes and teaches, rather than falsehoods.
An agreement in doctrine, to my understanding, is that there is not room for any change or discussion. We all must think and act the same. No room for any personal opinion.
This is not true either. There can be plenty of unity in theological diversity. But we don’t sacrifice unity for diversity.
What I see in the above quote is what I have been saying all along. Is that if I express and believe my opinion than I am going to H*ll. No questions asked.
Maybe you can explain how you see that, since this is not what I said, and not what the Church teaches.
Maybe I am wrong. here but I am under the assumption that what people right on here is the absolute truth about the church and her teachings.
Yes, you are wrong. While most of us strive to accurately represent the Church teachings,none of us can take the place of them, and we have all been wrong about things.
I thought that everyone here had all the knowledge that came from the church and what they write is the truth.
I am not sure it is possible to have “all the knowledge of the Church”. I study for a few hours every day, but to absorb 2000 years seems humanly impossible!

If you don’t ask questions, and express doubt, you may never be able to grow.
 
You want private interpretation of Sacred Scripture concerning masturbation and the use of artifical birth control.
Use of contraceptives
Not ejaculating within your wife when having sex
Masturbation, solo or mutual
Not believing the church can’t make a mistake
The reason Onan was killed
Disagreeing with the church an any item.
Why didn’t you post that to begin with?
 
You want private interpretation of Sacred Scripture concerning masturbation and the use of artifical birth control.

Why didn’t you post that to begin with?
Use of contraceptives
Not ejaculating within your wife when having sex
Masturbation, solo or mutual
Not believing the church can’t make a mistake
The reason Onan was killed
Disagreeing with the church an any item.
If i would have mentioned this in the first place the entire discussion would have been about where and how each one of these topics were discussed in the Bible and that If I had a different opinion than that I was going to hell. So I structured the question to encompass all differences of opinion not just on certain topics.
 
No matter the generation, the Magisterium is not going to allow what Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture has forbidden.

That holds true for masturbation, contraception, contraceptive acts, abortion, sexual acts outside of marriage, homosexual marriage, euthanasia, embroyonic stem cell research, etc.
 
Than evidently the RCC is not where I should be. To me the Eucharist is symbolic. If it was really the body and blood of Christ or anyone it would taste like flesh and blood. I believe that Christ instituted the Eucharist as an outward sign of him giving himself to us as our savior and redeemer. And every time we perform this outward sign we are to remember what Christ did for us.
Which kind of cuts to the heart of the matter, your understanding of the Bible contradicts the actual practise and beliefs of the early Church prior to the formation of the Bible as scripture. So, why are you correct and the first followers of the apostles wrong?
St. Iraneaus, St. Justin the Martyr, St. Ignatius etc etc all specifically declare the Eucharist as the actual Body and Blood of Christ.

The penalty for apostasy (leaving and then returning to the church) at one point was a 10 year ban from receiving the Eucharist, with a deathbed exception.

2 Corinthians,
“26 Whenever you eat this bread, then, and drink this cup, you are proclaiming the Lord’s death until he comes. Therefore anyone who eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily is answerable for the body and blood of the Lord. Everyone is to examine himself and only then eat of the bread or drink from the cup; because a person who eats and drinks without recognising the body is eating and drinking his own condemnation.”

I don’t see how eating just a symbol would lead to our condemnation, or why an apostate would be banned from participating in a symbolic gesture for such a long period of time.

LIT,
I can not tell you what to believe, or get from the scriptures. I can only tell you what I believe and why. But again, as I said earlier I accept the Bible as scripture because I accept the authority of the Church. Otherwise, to me, it would just be another nice book of ancient religious writings.
 
If i would have mentioned this in the first place the entire discussion would have been about where and how each one of these topics were discussed in the Bible and that If I had a different opinion than that I was going to hell. So I structured the question to encompass all differences of opinion not just on certain topics.
I don’t think so, LIT. I think the conversation would have gone immediately to what is the real issue here, which is authority. You don’t want the Church to have authority over you.

Reading the scripture apart from that authority is what enables people to justify following their own ideas, instead of the commandments of God. You are angry because a priest(person in position of authoirty) told you not to read the Scripture. In addition to blaming the whole Catholic Church for this one person giving you bad advice, you are also now reading the Holy Scriptures in isolation from the faith of the Apsotles that produced it.

I dont think this has come up yet in this thread, but since it pertains to authority, I will state it here. The Catholic Church does not come out of the Bible, and the teachings to which you object were not extrapolated from various scripture passages. The faith of the Catholic Church is based upon the Teaching of Jesus committed by the Apostles to the Church. It was whole and entire, as were all the doctrines above to which you object, before a word of the NT was ever written. The Scripture came out of the Church, not the other way around.

The NT was written by, for, and about Catholics. there is nothing in it that is not Catholic. The reason that none of the contents contradict the Teachings of the Church is because they all came out of the same place (God).
 
Than evidently the RCC is not where I should be. To me the Eucharist is symbolic. If it was really the body and blood of Christ or anyone it would taste like flesh and blood. I believe that Christ instituted the Eucharist as an outward sign of him giving himself to us as our savior and redeemer. And every time we perform this outward sign we are to remember what Christ did for us.
Have you considered that God is calling you to a higher level of obedience and discipleship?
 
Lit

Just thought you might like to explain, how you interpret these verses in. Matthew 16: 13-17, from post # 59. Do you deny St. Peter was given the explicit knowledge from God the Father, revealing, Jesus was the Messiah, and that St.Peter was the vehicle by which the other Apostles came to know Jesus as the Messiah ?

Peace:)
 
“Come on back - don’t walk away and leave My ministry - I was only talking figuratively. Geesh, of course you won’t be eating My actual Body and Blood. You people…are a bit crazy. I stretched My Word a bit too far. My bad.”
John 6:53
The Jews quarreled among themselves, saying, “How can this man give us (his) flesh to eat?”
Jesus said to them, "Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood, you do not have life within you. Whoever eats My Flesh and drinks My Blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day. For My Flesh is true food, and My Blood is true drink. Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him. Just as the living Father sent Me and I have life because of the Father, so also the one who feeds on Me will have life because of Me.

This is the bread that came down from heaven. Unlike your ancestors who ate and still died, whoever eats this bread will live forever."

These things He said while teaching in the synagogue in Capernaum.
"Does this shock you?
What if you were to see the Son of Man ascending to where He was before? It is the Spirit that gives life, while the flesh is of no avail. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and life. But there are some of you who do not believe."
Jesus knew from the beginning the ones who would not believe and the one who would betray him.
And He said, “For this reason I have told you that no one can come to Me unless it is granted him by my Father.”

**As a result of this, many (of) his disciples returned to their former way of life and no longer accompanied him.
Jesus then said to the Twelve, “Do you also want to leave?” **
Simon Peter answered him, “Master, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. We have come to believe and are convinced that you are the Holy One of God.”

Jesus answered them, “Did I not choose you twelve? Yet is not one of you a devil?”
 
I would like to ask that we not address the specifics regarding the issues of the Real Presence, contraception, etc., because Lit’s question is not about all of those specific issues but is about the process of understanding the Bible. That’s a perfectly legitimate question, one that addresses the “how” and “why” of many other questions often addressed on these threads, and I think he’s entitled to an answer.

I happen to agree that the Church does not say “This is how you interpret Scriptural passage X, and you’re going to Hell if you disagree,” but I understand completely how Lit arrived at that understanding. How many times have we encountered Protestants who insisted on their method of understanding Scriptures, who refused even to consider our methodology, and how often have we been frustrated at their unwillingness to engage in a legitimate discussion concerning Biblical exegesis?

Sometimes we fall prey to the same faults. There are plenty of people on CAF who take the same “I’m right, and you’re going to Hell” approach, and the more reasoned explanations often get lost in the shuffle. And I absolutely believe that Lit received some sort of “Don’t pay attention to the Bible, we’ll tell you what to believe” instruction, because I’ve seen priests and laymen take similar approaches – in RCIA, yet.

Anyway, if we start getting a lot of posts about “You’re wrong on contraception, and here’s why!” or whatever, we’ll lose the question Lit has asked.
 
I don’t think so, LIT. I think the conversation would have gone immediately to what is the real issue here, which is authority. You don’t want the Church to have authority over you.

Reading the scripture apart from that authority is what enables people to justify following their own ideas, instead of the commandments of God. You are angry because a priest(person in position of authoirty) told you not to read the Scripture. In addition to blaming the whole Catholic Church for this one person giving you bad advice, you are also now reading the Holy Scriptures in isolation from the faith of the Apsotles that produced it.

I dont think this has come up yet in this thread, but since it pertains to authority, I will state it here. The Catholic Church does not come out of the Bible, and the teachings to which you object were not extrapolated from various scripture passages. The faith of the Catholic Church is based upon the Teaching of Jesus committed by the Apostles to the Church. It was whole and entire, as were all the doctrines above to which you object, before a word of the NT was ever written. The Scripture came out of the Church, not the other way around.

The NT was written by, for, and about Catholics. there is nothing in it that is not Catholic. The reason that none of the contents contradict the Teachings of the Church is because they all came out of the same place (God).
You are right. I do not let anyone have authority over me.

As a side not let me give you a little personal back ground into my life. I was born to a very catholic set of parents. I was always told what to do but not why I should be doing it. Back to my parents. I am the youngest of 6 children. My father was 50 years old when I was born and my mom was 44. Over the years of growing up my parents were the age of my friends grandparents. More times than not my parents were so tired of parenting that I pretty much had to survive for myself. Don’t get me wrong, they really did love me but they were tired of parenting. That being said I learned that I can survive without depending on anyone. I did it myself.

I came from a farm background. I leased land and farmed on my own before I had a drivers license. Before I was out of high school I owned farm equipments and was operating of 1000 acres. From that point on I lived my own life. I took care of myself and asked no one for anything. So you might be able to see where my independent streak comes from.
the teachings to which you object were not extrapolated from various scripture passages.
I am not really sure what you are trying to say here. Am I to understand that there is nothing in the bible that deals with the teachings that I am opposed to.
The reason that none of the contents contradict the Teachings of the Church is because they all came out of the same place (God).
It all depends on how the Bible is interpreted whether there are contradiction to the Church’s teachings.
 
I would like to ask that we not address the specifics regarding the issues of the Real Presence, contraception, etc., because Lit’s question is not about all of those specific issues but is about the process of understanding the Bible. That’s a perfectly legitimate question, one that addresses the “how” and “why” of many other questions often addressed on these threads, and I think he’s entitled to an answer.

I happen to agree that the Church does not say “This is how you interpret Scriptural passage X, and you’re going to Hell if you disagree,” but I understand completely how Lit arrived at that understanding. How many times have we encountered Protestants who insisted on their method of understanding Scriptures, who refused even to consider our methodology, and how often have we been frustrated at their unwillingness to engage in a legitimate discussion concerning Biblical exegesis?

Sometimes we fall prey to the same faults. There are plenty of people on CAF who take the same “I’m right, and you’re going to Hell” approach, and the more reasoned explanations often get lost in the shuffle. And I absolutely believe that Lit received some sort of “Don’t pay attention to the Bible, we’ll tell you what to believe” instruction, because I’ve seen priests and laymen take similar approaches – in RCIA, yet.

Anyway, if we start getting a lot of posts about “You’re wrong on contraception, and here’s why!” or whatever, we’ll lose the question Lit has asked.
Godfollower:
Thanks for a great post. I appreciate that.👍
 
@guanophore:
First I would like to thank you for discussing with me and not just lambasting me for my thoughts.

I am not sure how to better describe the Catholic Process of scripture. What I am saying it that the Church has interpreted what the holy scriptures mean and has declared them as the official meaning. That being said, there is no room for any other belief or interpretation or opinion. It is a closed deal. No changing. No discussion. That to me is the Catholic Process.

An agreement in doctrine, to my understanding, is that there is not room for any change or discussion. We all must think and act the same. No room for any personal opinion.

What I see in the above quote is what I have been saying all along. Is that if I express and believe my opinion than I am going to H*ll. No questions asked.

Maybe I am wrong. here but I am under the assumption that what people right on here is the absolute truth about the church and her teachings. I thought that everyone here had all the knowledge that came from the church and what they write is the truth.
Lit, I’d like to recommend the following link to you. It’s a Catholic Answers column from “This Rock” about ten years ago, in which the author makes the point that the Catholic Church doesn’t even have official interpretations of most passages of Scripture, precisely because a particular passage’s meaning can change from person to person and from circumstance to circumstance. You might find it helpful.

catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0101bt.asp

And I’ll tell you this: we absolutely are permitted to challenge our priests about their interpretations of Scripture. Of course there are limits (you don’t just jump up in the middle of Mass and yell “That’s wrong!” like that rude politician a year or two back), but those are limits of politeness, not limits of damnation.

The Church does place limits on who gets to teach in its name, of course – so, if a theologian at a Catholic university teaching in the theology department wants to teach a scriptures course on prooftexts saying that Jesus wasn’t really divine, s/he’ll be tossed from the faculty. But that’s a standard institutional no-one-gets-to-identify-him-or-herself-as-teaching-this-institution’s-theology-unless-it-actually-is-our-theology rule, not a disagree-with-us-and-you’re-going-to-Hell rule.

There are people on these Boards who are perfectly willing to consign various others to Hell. I once saw a posting where a child asked “Is my dad really doomed to hell because he committed suicide?” (he had fallen to his death from the Twin Towers). The Church’s official answer – easily checked in the Catechism and elsewhere – is roughly “We can’t possibly know whether any person is in Hell, but God is infinitely merciful, and even suicides can repent; plus it doesn’t sound like he was committing suicide so much as fleeing a fire; in any event, we commend suicides’ souls to the mercy of God.” In other words, we have no reason to think your dad is in Hell, so relax a little. But one poster repeatedly posted the opposite, saying roughly “Yes, your father is burning in Hell right now.” That person ended up getting banned and some of his posts were deleted by the moderators, but you can imagine the effect that had on the child asking the question.

Some people here are rude; and some of them are absolutely determined to prove to you that their rudeness is correct, even when they’re wrong. Don’t let that deter you from inquiring about our beliefs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top