Are we really that ignorant?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LIT56RD
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sorry, but that’s a non-answer to the questions I posed to you. Are our thoughts never in error? Yes they can be.Do we always know what is from God and what isn’t? No but neither does anyone else. I do not buy into the the fact that the Catholic church can never make a mistake. So which is worse, me making a mistake in my interpretation or blindly following what someone else has interpreted which may be a mistake also.It’s easy to claim God is our final authority when we go by our preference for our beliefs in Who He Is or Isn’t and what He has revealed of Himself or hasn’t; what we are doing, then, is making God into our own image - that’s a mighty easy god to believe in and be obedient to.
With intense prayer and guidance from respected Christians who will help me decide what is best for me, (not just tell what I should be doing) I believe that for the most part God and I get alone quite well.
 
In that verse the eunuch did not know what the readings meant. If I don’t understand what something in the Bible means I will ask someone whom I believe I can discuss it with, and after discussing it I will then, with the guidance of the Holy spirit and prayer, discern what the verse means.

I believe that the same verse with in the Bible can speak to people differently, depending upon where they are in their human life and their spiritual life.
Oh. So you turn to others and listen to what they have to say.

And we Catholics turn to others and listen to what THEY have to say. And then we listen to the Lord. And we follow as He guides us.

I also believe the same verse can speak ‘differently’ to different people because much of the Bible is nuanced and multi-layered.

A young unmarried woman will not have quite the same ‘view’ of the passages about Jesus being 3 days lost while his parents look for him. A mother or father would tend to think about their own children. But neither the unmarried or the married people would be seeing the passage ‘differently’ per se.

Now a person who read the passage and said, “ah, you see, this says that 12 year olds can keep secrets from their parents and be on their own”. . .well, that’s sure a DIFFERENT interpretation and I believe few if any of us would find it an, um, ‘acceptable’ interpretation, am I correct?

So there ARE ‘different interpretations’ which are absolutely ‘wrong’ as well as ‘different interpretations’ which emphasize one or the other points about one particular LAYER of a passage (such as the perspective from a parent’s view) while still maintaining a correct understanding.

Now here’s the thing. We Catholics can read through Scripture and as I said, we can look at it from the point of view of parents (if we’re parents). We can see the ‘female’ view (tending to a more ‘nurturing’ view and finding passages resonate in our hearts which speak of God’s tender care. We can see the ‘masculine’ view (tending to a more ‘outward’ view and finding passages resonate in our hearts which speak of God’s ACTIONS among His people). We can see things as they relate to social justice (looking for passages which speak of God’s care for the poor); we can look for prophecy and how it was fulfilled; we can look for passages like the Song of Songs for their sheer poetic beauty of the spoken word, etc. etc. NOTHING in the Catholic Church stops us from that kind of interpretation which can be as ‘individual’ as you please.

So what, lit, is your problem?

As a woman and a mother, I tend to see much of the Bible from the viewpoint of a mother, to be focused in feminine and ‘motherly’ ways. And there is nothing wrong with that. No one from the Catholic police is knocking on my door telling me that I absolutely CANNOT read the Bible in such a way.

I recommend the latter.
 
You know, the last I looked around in places from here on CA to various blogs, to various Catholic news sites, the Vatican web site, the USCCB, the on-line catechisms, etc. etc… . .it struck me that there were a LOT of explanations, of dialogue, of question and answer and helps and aids. . .

So I wonder just how lit is getting the idea that somehow the Catholic Church just ‘tells us what to do without explanation’".

Doesn’t he think that any of us belong to church groups? Bible studies? Talk with friends? Read the Bible? Read about Catholicism? Discuss with our families? PRAY???

I think he has a tremendous amount of misconceptions about Catholics and Catholicism.
 
With intense prayer and guidance from respected Christians who will help me decide what is best for me, (not just tell what I should be doing) I believe that for the most part God and I get alone quite well.
And that part in which you and God don’t get along is what?

Regarding a prior post and your response to it; we can stipulate for purposes of discussion that you do not consider yourself a troll. But when you describe yourself as a “recovering Catholic”, you are obviously comparing it to the ubiquitous term “recovering alcoholic” which suggests that you came in here to challenge the beliefs of others for some purpose of your own (or perhaps that of the “respected Christians” to whom you look for guidance) and in an “in your face” sort of way, as if Catholicism is some kind of despicable addiction.

Then, of course, you accuse Catholics of being stupid and ignorant, and for a reason (being told not to read the Bible) which is entirely mythical. In all my years, never, ever, ever was I told not to read the Bible. On the contrary, from grade school on, I was mightily encouraged to do it by my (Catholic school) teachers, the priests and my own parents. In every Catholic Mass, as you know (being a “recovering Catholic” and all) there are scripture readings from both the Old and New Testaments and, to be quite frank about it, much more voluminously than I have ever heard in any protestant service I have ever been to; more than ten put together.

So what’s the purpose of this thread? To proclaim that all Catholics are stupid and that the ridiculous old myth that “Catholics are forbidden to read the Bible” is actually true? Did God tell you to do this? I really want to know your response, because it is, to me, unimaginable that God would encourage this, any more than He would encourage me to go onto some protestant site, misrepresent their beliefs and announce that protestants are stupid. And if God did not encourage it, then whom?
 
LIT56RD, may I ask: several people have cited the following passages relating to Scriptural interpretation. What is your understanding of their meaning?

Acts 8:26-31.
The eunuch did not understand what he was reading and Philip was there to help him. If the eunuch had been reading and believed he understood how it effected his life, and Philip asked him if he understood he would have said yes and that would have been the end of the discussion.

2 Peter 1:16-20.
16For we did not follow(A) cleverly devised(B) myths when we made known to you(C) the power and(D) coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but(E) we were eyewitnesses of his majesty. 17For when he received honor and glory from God the Father, and the voice was borne to him by the Majestic Glory,(F) “This is my beloved Son,[a] with whom I am well pleased,” 18we ourselves heard this very voice borne from heaven, for we were with him on(G) the holy mountain. 19And(H) we have something more sure, the prophetic word, to which you will do well to pay attention(I) as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until(J) the day(K) dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts, 20knowing this first of all, that no prophecy of Scripture comes from someone’s own interpretation.
I understand this to mean that when scripture was written and recorded, it was revealed by God and not by man

2 Peter 3:11-18.

11Since all these things are thus to be dissolved,(A) what sort of people ought you to be in lives of holiness and godliness, 12(B) waiting for and hastening the coming of the day of God, because of which the heavens will be set on fire and dissolved, and(C) the heavenly bodies will melt as they burn! 13But according to his promise we are waiting for(D) new heavens and a new earth(E) in which righteousness dwells.
Final Words
14(F) Therefore, beloved, since you are waiting for these, be diligent to be found by him(G) without spot or(H) blemish, and(I) at peace. 15And count(J) the patience of our Lord as salvation, just as(K) our beloved brother Paul also wrote to you(L) according to the wisdom given him, 16as he does in all his letters when he speaks in them of these matters.(M) There are some things in them that are hard to understand, which the ignorant and unstable twist to their own destruction,(N) as they do the other Scriptures. 17You therefore, beloved,(O) knowing this beforehand,(P) take care that you are not carried away with the error of lawless people and lose your own stability. 18But(Q) grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.(R) To him be the glory both now and to the day of(S) eternity. Amen.


In verse 16 God does warn that some things are hard to understand and the ignorant and unstable should be careful not to bring on their own destruction. I don’t believe I am unstable and by reading the Bible I hope to be lessening the ignorance. In verse 17 and 18 God warns us to not be carried away with error but to grow in grace and knowledge of Christ. I see me reading and studying the Bible growing in the knowledge of Christ.

The Catholic understanding of these passages is that God gave us His Word in the Scriptures, but He also created the Church to help us understand His Word (the Church being full of professionals who spend their lives studying the Scriptures far more than we laymen can do). I would be interested to hear your understanding of them.
 
You know, the last I looked around in places from here on CA to various blogs, to various Catholic news sites, the Vatican web site, the USCCB, the on-line catechisms, etc. etc… . .it struck me that there were a LOT of explanations, of dialogue, of question and answer and helps and aids. . .

So I wonder just how lit is getting the idea that somehow the Catholic Church just ‘tells us what to do without explanation’". What I am saying is that on certain subjects there is no discussion as to what is acceptable. This is the way it is, end of discussion. Disagree and go to hell.

Doesn’t he think that any of us belong to church groups? Bible studies? Talk with friends? Read the Bible? Read about Catholicism? Discuss with our families? PRAY??? You can always discuss but you d*** well better not disagree.

I think he has a tremendous amount of misconceptions about Catholics and Catholicism.
 
Well you have me interested. How about a list of the Church’s ‘absolutarian’ decrees in which you ‘disagree and go to hell’. And I guess they have to be scriptural only since you speak of Scriptural interpretation.

I mean, the Church has not yet pronounced One. Single. Solitary. Person. In. Hell. So it’s kind of strange that a Church which doesn’t even say Judas or Hitler ‘is in hell’ is somehow pulling out all kinds of “disagree on X and you go to hell”. . .
 
I am pretty sure that the Church strongly encourages reading the Bible. 🙂
 
And that part in which you and God don’t get along is what?

Regarding a prior post and your response to it; we can stipulate for purposes of discussion that you do not consider yourself a troll. But when you describe yourself as a “recovering Catholic”, you are obviously comparing it to the ubiquitous term “recovering alcoholic” which suggests that you came in here to challenge the beliefs of others for some purpose of your own (or perhaps that of the “respected Christians” to whom you look for guidance) and in an “in your face” sort of way, as if Catholicism is some kind of despicable addiction.

Then, of course, you accuse Catholics of being stupid and ignorant, and for a reason (being told not to read the Bible) which is entirely mythical. In all my years, never, ever, ever was I told not to read the Bible. On the contrary, from grade school on, I was mightily encouraged to do it by my (Catholic school) teachers, the priests and my own parents. In every Catholic Mass, as you know (being a “recovering Catholic” and all) there are scripture readings from both the Old and New Testaments and, to be quite frank about it, much more voluminously than I have ever heard in any protestant service I have ever been to; more than ten put together.

So what’s the purpose of this thread? To proclaim that all Catholics are stupid and that the ridiculous old myth that “Catholics are forbidden to read the Bible” is actually true? Did God tell you to do this? I really want to know your response, because it is, to me, unimaginable that God would encourage this, any more than He would encourage me to go onto some protestant site, misrepresent their beliefs and announce that protestants are stupid. And if God did not encourage it, then whom?
I detect a bit of anger and hostility in your post.

God and I get along very well thank you. It is all the rules and regulations that the church has put out there and says that you will go to hell if you don’t follow them to the T.

You may never have been told to not read the Bible. But on an April afternoon in 1974 I and three other classmate were sitting in church reading and discussion the Bible. The parish priest came over and asked what we were doing. We said we were reading and discussing the Bible. He said. “I wish you wouldn’t do that for that is not in keeping with Catholic understanding. You can not read the Bible without clergy present to interpret anything that is read.”

The purpose of this thread is to find out if the Catholic church allows independent thinking when it come to reading the Bible. Or if the church’s stand is that every idea and thought from the Bible must be run through the Catholic process before we can hear it.
 
I detect a bit of anger and hostility in your post.

God and I get along very well thank you. It is all the rules and regulations that the church has put out there and says that you will go to hell if you don’t follow them to the T.

You may never have been told to not read the Bible. But on an April afternoon in 1974 I and three other classmate were sitting in church reading and discussion the Bible. The parish priest came over and asked what we were doing. We said we were reading and discussing the Bible. He said. “I wish you wouldn’t do that for that is not in keeping with Catholic understanding. You can not read the Bible without clergy present to interpret anything that is read.”

The purpose of this thread is to find out if the Catholic church allows independent thinking when it come to reading the Bible. Or if the church’s stand is that every idea and thought from the Bible must be run through the Catholic process before we can hear it.
After nearly 40 years you remember what the parish priest said word for word? You’re absolutely sure he said that and only that? And he never explained further? And you never ever spoke to any other person, especially not any other priest, about it?

To me that is really cutting your nose to spite your face. If it happened, it’s shockingly wrong on the part of "one parish priest’ in 1974, but it is NOT the teaching of the Church. . .and for you to have let it ‘fester’ in you all these years and now accuse the entire Church of this wrong based on the hearsay words of one priest all those years ago is truly sad.

There is no ‘Catholic process’.
There is, however, truth.

In your ‘independent thinking’ it is entirely possible for you to come up with a completely incorrect (though sincere) interpretation of Scripture. That is what happened when some (not all) Protestants read John 6 and mistakenly concluded, “Well, Jesus wasn’t really talking about his actual BODY. . communion is just SYMBOLIC”.

That ‘independent’ thinking is completely wrong. No two ways about it.

If you become so independent that what you’re thinking is no longer the true word of God, then there is only one path to take. . .back to truth. . .if you care more about truth itself than about being ‘independent’.
 
I detect a bit of anger and hostility in your post. Then you are detecting something that isn’t there…sort of like the “Catholic rule against reading the bible” that isn’t there. On the other hand, “recovering Catholic” would, I think, strike almost any reasonable person as hostile, if not angry and hostile. 🙂

God and I get along very well thank you. It is all the rules and regulations that the church has put out there and says that you will go to hell if you don’t follow them to the T. This is profound misunderstand of what the Church actually teaches. Truly profound. Do you not know that the Church really teaches (as Jesus did) that “even the just man falls seven times a day”, and that the point of redemption is forgiveness? Yet, Jesus Himself talked about hell, and quite a bit, and for reasons that, sometimes to humans, seem a bit strict and rigid.

You may never have been told to not read the Bible. But on an April afternoon in 1974 I and three other classmate were sitting in church reading and discussion the Bible. The parish priest came over and asked what we were doing. We said we were reading and discussing the Bible. He said. “I wish you wouldn’t do that for that is not in keeping with Catholic understanding. You can not read the Bible without clergy present to interpret anything that is read.” A truly bizarre thing for a priest to say, because it is far from what the Church actually teaches. You say this happened in 1974 and you are absolutely sure your recollection is perfectly clear on what he said and what preceded it? Sounds to me like there is more to this story.

The purpose of this thread is to find out if the Catholic church allows independent thinking when it come to reading the Bible. Or if the church’s stand is that every idea and thought from the Bible must be run through the Catholic process before we can hear it.
These are two totally separate things, not one thing. Does the Church encourage us to go into the Bible and just interpret it the way it strikes us? No, it does not, and 40,000 protestant churches, each claiming it has the fullness of truth and the others don’t, attests to the reasonableness of that approach. In disagreement, they cannot all be “right”.

Now, as to the other part, no. The Church does not declare that every idea and thought from the Bible must be run through the Catholic process before we can hear it. If that was true, no Catholic could ever read the Bible or hear parts of it read in the Mass. Yet, both are encouraged.

What the Church does discourage is our taking up the Bible, utterly ignorant of how it has been understood right from the beginning, and inventing our own religion in doing so. I don’t know what your religion is, and I don’t think you have told us. But, if you are not, for example, a Jehovah’s Witness, do you believe that Jesus is actually an angel and not Divine Himself? Jehovah’s Witnesses believe that, and they can quote you pieces from scripture where they “prove” it. I was once involved in a lawsuit between two competing congregations of the Church of Christ. One held that in communion only one cup could be used by the whole congregation. The other held that each person had to have his own cup. And both of them had snippets from the Bible “proving” their own position. And, of course, both were absolutely persuaded that their own group was the ONLY church actually established by Jesus Christ, and for reasons just like that.

And so you, who acknowledge the help of others in your understanding of what the Bible REALLY means, are in here telling Catholics that we should not?

Or do you believe that each and every one of the 40,000 protestant groups, each of which thinks it’s interpretation of the Bible is right and everyone elses is wrong, are all correct? All of them? And do you believe God wants them all to think that way? If so, what do you think His purpose is in fostering that dissonance and that confusion?
 
Well you have me interested. How about a list of the Church’s ‘absolutarian’ decrees in which you ‘disagree and go to hell’. And I guess they have to be scriptural only since you speak of Scriptural interpretation.

I mean, the Church has not yet pronounced One. Single. Solitary. Person. In. Hell. So it’s kind of strange that a Church which doesn’t even say Judas or Hitler ‘is in hell’ is somehow pulling out all kinds of “disagree on X and you go to hell”. . .

  1. *]Use of contraceptives
    *]Not ejaculating within your wife when having sex
    *]Masturbation, solo or mutual
    *]Not believing the church can’t make a mistake
    *]The reason Onan was killed
    Disagreeing with the church an any item.

    All of these listed Items I have seen mentioned on various threads throughout this forum. And every one of them has been described as a grave moral issue or in other words mortal sin which send you to hell. It was even stated that to have sex with your wife just for the pure pleasure of sex could be down graded to only a venial sin if you didn’t enjoy it to much. Yes I saw this on a thread yesterday.
 
I am probably the most ignorant of the catholic faith. I take some responsibility for that but I also expect the church to shoulder some of the responsibility for it. Yes I know it was years ago but I was taught not to read the Bible. And I was also taught that you were to never question the church teaching or a priest. Both have the authority to send you to hell on a moments notice. Yes I am much older now but over all these years I have never been informed or brought to my attention that these things were not really what the church was teaching.Forgive me, but I’ve been Catholic for 30 years, attended Catholic school for jr. high and high school, have attended mass at various parishes across multiple counties, and was never told that questioning a priest would send me to hell. A priest does not have that power, and no Catholic I have ever met, well catechized or not would say that. Ever. That is heresy.

My wife and I have spent the last 3 1/2 years attending a local Protestant church. In my entire life I have never felt as close to God as I have while be part of that church. If I miss church services they always say that they are glad to see us and welcome us back. If we missed Mass at the local church for a couple of weeks we were usually asked. “Where the h*ll have you been. It’s about time you came back to church”. Real welcoming 😦 Really? That’s odd, and completely out of the realm of my experience. We have multiple times, and some people have obligations at different parishes, so they may not be at a mass I attend any given week. Your parish sounds like something one of my Baptist relatives imagines a Catholic church is like.

By my reading the Bible I feel that I have made a connection with God that I have never been able to in the past. So when I hear that I can not have any of my own belief in the the Bible says, that tells me that the connection that I have made with God over the last 3 years was against all of the CC teaching. It is by my own interpretation of the Bible verses that have helped me grow much closer to God. No one will tell you you can’t read a bible. That’s nonsense. What you will hear, and rightly so is that if you are learning in an autodactic environment, you’re probably going to make some errors in your conclusions. That’s why we have classes-- would you like your bridge builder to tell you, "yeah, but I read about it in a book, and I have it totally under control. :rolleyes:

FHG
LIT
 
After nearly 40 years you remember what the parish priest said word for word? You’re absolutely sure he said that and only that? And he never explained further? And you never ever spoke to any other person, especially not any other priest, about it?

To me that is really cutting your nose to spite your face. If it happened, it’s shockingly wrong on the part of "one parish priest’ in 1974, but it is NOT the teaching of the Church. . .and for you to have let it ‘fester’ in you all these years and now accuse the entire Church of this wrong based on the hearsay words of one priest all those years ago is truly sad.

There is no ‘Catholic process’.
There is, however, truth.

In your ‘independent thinking’ it is entirely possible for you to come up with a completely incorrect (though sincere) interpretation of Scripture. That is what happened when some (not all) Protestants read John 6 and mistakenly concluded, “Well, Jesus wasn’t really talking about his actual BODY. . communion is just SYMBOLIC”.

That ‘independent’ thinking is completely wrong. No two ways about it.

If you become so independent that what you’re thinking is no longer the true word of God, then there is only one path to take. . .back to truth. . .if you care more about truth itself than about being ‘independent’.
Yes I do remember exactly what he said. It really p*ssed me off at the time and still does. I was taught very strictly that you never, never, ever disagree with a priest or you will go to hell. They have ultimate authority. Never questioned it until now.

Yes there is a catholic process. According to what posters are saying is that all Bible instruction must be approved by the church so everyone thinks and acts the same.
 
Yes I do remember exactly what he said. It really p*ssed me off at the time and still does. I was taught very strictly that you never, never, ever disagree with a priest or you will go to hell. They have ultimate authority. Never questioned it until now.

Yes there is a catholic process. According to what posters are saying is that all Bible instruction must be approved by the church so everyone thinks and acts the same.
Not exactly. Let me ask you this. How do you interpret the passage on which the Eucharist rests? Do you read it as His literal body, or is it symbolic? If literal, how do you know? Did you come to this relevation on your own, or through guidance with an instructor (CFF, bible study, etcy). If you say symbolic, then I guess the RCC really isn’t the place for you.

Again, a priest can’t throw anyone into hell. Did you hear this in a class, or was it something someone told you?
 
And that’s the key. It is not enough to only read the readings in the missal. There are many “Bible in a Year” studies. Read the bible and if there are questions, come to places like the scriptures forum or reference the catechism, other documents etc.

There is never an excuse for not reading the Bible outside of the readings.
But readings are a very good place to begin. There are commentaries that can be delivered by email, or paper meditations that will help with Lectio Divina. When one reads in unity with the Liturgical year, the seasonal focus has a chance to sink in, and the bigger picture is easier to assimilate.
 
These are two totally separate things, not one thing. Does the Church encourage us to go into the Bible and just interpret it the way it strikes us? No, it does not, and 40,000 protestant churches, each claiming it has the fullness of truth and the others don’t, attests to the reasonableness of that approach. In disagreement, they cannot all be “right”.

Now, as to the other part, no. The Church does not declare that every idea and thought from the Bible must be run through the Catholic process before we can hear it. If that was true, no Catholic could ever read the Bible or hear parts of it read in the Mass. Yet, both are encouraged.

What the Church does discourage is our taking up the Bible, utterly ignorant of how it has been understood right from the beginning, and inventing our own religion in doing so. I don’t know what your religion is, and I don’t think you have told us. But, if you are not, for example, a Jehovah’s Witness, do you believe that Jesus is actually an angel and not Divine Himself? Jehovah’s Witnesses believe that, and they can quote you pieces from scripture where they “prove” it. I was once involved in a lawsuit between two competing congregations of the Church of Christ. One held that in communion only one cup could be used by the whole congregation. The other held that each person had to have his own cup. And both of them had snippets from the Bible “proving” their own position. And, of course, both were absolutely persuaded that their own group was the ONLY church actually established by Jesus Christ, and for reasons just like that.

And so you, who acknowledge the help of others in your understanding of what the Bible REALLY means, are in here telling Catholics that we should not?

Or do you believe that each and every one of the 40,000 protestant groups, each of which thinks it’s interpretation of the Bible is right and everyone elses is wrong, are all correct? All of them? And do you believe God wants them all to think that way? If so, what do you think His purpose is in fostering that dissonance and that confusion?
The scriptures may be read and instruction given on them, but I am not suppose to form my own opinion of them.

When I ask for help in understanding something I will ask for an opinion. If you go by what the church says I am not able to or suppose to disagree with it. Isn’t there a time when we can say we agree to disagree?
 
Code:
guanophore,
According to the references I have listed below, I am not suppose to read and interpret the Bible on my own.

If however when reading the scriptures you think it tells you something other than what is contained on the Catholic Faith and you put your faith in your own understanding then you would be stupid. ( Copied from post #5)
I am not sure how you get that from this, LIT. It clearly says “when reading the scriptures”. I guess you could have someone read them to you, instead of reading them on your own. 🤷

I like to listen to them on MP3, myself. 😃

This does not work too well if the earphones are in someone else’s ear. They have to be in my ear for me to “hear”. It seems like you would have to have your own bible in your own hands in order to “when reading the scriptures”. Is there something I am missing?
Code:
 *Those powers were given to the Apostles. Not to a book. Scripture is our Tradition. Scripture says that you need others to interpret. Acts 8:30 * (copied from post #23)
Everyone who reads interprets. That is a fact of human nature. When we interpret, we are to do so in the light of what the Holy Spirit has already revealed to the the Church.
Code:
 *Seriously though, I'm sure he only meant that it's easy to fall into error and so, when studying the Scriptures, we need to always consult the interpretation of the Church in certain matters, as some things are not subject to differing interpretation. *
I am afraid you lost me again here. If you are not reading your Bible, then what good would it do for you to consult the interpretation of the Chuch? I can’t imagine what use there would be for that.
LIT56RD;7858292:
If you’ve read commentary from some (many) Catholics, it’s not surprising that the priest would discourage it. A lot of people leave the Church because of “the Bible” (or more accurately, an incorrect interpretation of the Bible).
Copied from post #25)
This doesn’t say you “can’t read the bible” on your own, either. It says that an incorrect interpretation of what you are reading can cause a shipwreck of your faith.

Of course, you were already shipwrecked because someone misled you when you were younger that you were not to read the Bible, so now you are finding some floatation devices and finding your way back to the Ark. 👍
 
Oh. So you turn to others and listen to what they have to say.

And we Catholics turn to others and listen to what THEY have to say. And then we listen to the Lord. And we follow as He guides us.

I also believe the same verse can speak ‘differently’ to different people because much of the Bible is nuanced and multi-layered.

A young unmarried woman will not have quite the same ‘view’ of the passages about Jesus being 3 days lost while his parents look for him. A mother or father would tend to think about their own children. But neither the unmarried or the married people would be seeing the passage ‘differently’ per se.

Now a person who read the passage and said, “ah, you see, this says that 12 year olds can keep secrets from their parents and be on their own”. . .well, that’s sure a DIFFERENT interpretation and I believe few if any of us would find it an, um, ‘acceptable’ interpretation, am I correct?

So there ARE ‘different interpretations’ which are absolutely ‘wrong’ as well as ‘different interpretations’ which emphasize one or the other points about one particular LAYER of a passage (such as the perspective from a parent’s view) while still maintaining a correct understanding.

Now here’s the thing. We Catholics can read through Scripture and as I said, we can look at it from the point of view of parents (if we’re parents). We can see the ‘female’ view (tending to a more ‘nurturing’ view and finding passages resonate in our hearts which speak of God’s tender care. We can see the ‘masculine’ view (tending to a more ‘outward’ view and finding passages resonate in our hearts which speak of God’s ACTIONS among His people). We can see things as they relate to social justice (looking for passages which speak of God’s care for the poor); we can look for prophecy and how it was fulfilled; we can look for passages like the Song of Songs for their sheer poetic beauty of the spoken word, etc. etc. NOTHING in the Catholic Church stops us from that kind of interpretation which can be as ‘individual’ as you please.

So what, lit, is your problem?

As a woman and a mother, I tend to see much of the Bible from the viewpoint of a mother, to be focused in feminine and ‘motherly’ ways. And there is nothing wrong with that. No one from the Catholic police is knocking on my door telling me that I absolutely CANNOT read the Bible in such a way.

I recommend the latter.
I greatly appreciate your insight and descriptions in the above examples. Your statements make a lot of sense to me.

Thanks
LIT
 
Not exactly. Let me ask you this. How do you interpret the passage on which the Eucharist rests? Do you read it as His literal body, or is it symbolic? If literal, how do you know? Did you come to this relevation on your own, or through guidance with an instructor (CFF, bible study, etcy). If you say symbolic, then I guess the RCC really isn’t the place for you.

Again, a priest can’t throw anyone into hell. Did you hear this in a class, or was it something someone told you?
Than evidently the RCC is not where I should be. To me the Eucharist is symbolic. If it was really the body and blood of Christ or anyone it would taste like flesh and blood. I believe that Christ instituted the Eucharist as an outward sign of him giving himself to us as our savior and redeemer. And every time we perform this outward sign we are to remember what Christ did for us.

I was told in 3rd or 4th grade CCD class that a priest can determine your salvation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top