Are we really that ignorant?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LIT56RD
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If there isn’t a list than where can I find the standard of what is infallible and what is not?
Yes, but I think it would only be useful to a person who was intereseted in learning about the faith.

And since it is off topic in this thread, it would be better if you started a new thread on that. It is one of the forum rules that you stay on topic in the thread (even one you made yourself). You wanted to talk about reading Scripture, remember?

One of the signs of a troll is that, when they get an answer, they change the subject. You have been given a lot of information about the Catholic position on reading Scripture, but you have ignored it, and continued to forward your anti-catholic ignorance of the facts.

Now, you seem to want to change the subject.
 
nytimes.com/2011/05/20/us/20rapture.html?_r=1&ref=us&pagewanted=all

Lit,
So, if you read the story at the link, an individual’s personal interpretation of the Bible is indicating to him the ‘rapture’ starts tomorrow. Well, we’ll know if he’s correct tomorrow-- but his personal interpretation is drasticially affecting many lives- not all to the good. It would be nice if God set up some kind of authority on earth to provide guidance in such matters, kind of protect his flock by ensuring they’ll know truth. Although less dramatic and not easily verifiable, there are interperations leading folks astray with profound implications for their salvation. For example, you reject the Real Presence in the Eucharist, which means you can not avail yourself of an amazing gift from God in assisting you here on earth in your relationship with God.

Have you ever read, “Faith of the Early Fathers”? I’ve been reading volume II while on business travel. Many of the saints discuss the issue of scripture, the authority of the Church and the fact that the Paul directed that we adhere to the traditions passed on by both word of letter and word of mouth. They were already discussing at the time the constitution of scripture was being decidied, i.e. the Bible, that scripture is inadequate in and of itself to be interpreted properly without referencing the totality of what was taught by the apostles. St. Chrysostam (sp?) devoted a lot of ink to the necessity to confess to God through the priests because of the authority bestowed on them to bind/loose on earth and bind/loose in heaven.
 
I thought about posting something similar, but I don’t think that is really what the OP wants. That information is readily available in a google search, which he said he did, and could not find. :confused:

Therefore, I must conclude that he is really asking for somthing else.

He has also demonstrated that he is not willing to do the research himself, so doing it for him will be counterproductive. He has been given many great links and leads in this thread, yet he still keeps repeating the same drivel - “so, we shouild not read the bible?”

This is what makes him seem like (as the thread title demonstrates) or a troll. If he really wants to know what the Church believes and teaches, he will look into it. If he just wants to ply the anti-Catholic prejudice into which he has been indoctrinated, then he will not be here for long.
guanophore;
I actually thought that you were starting to understand how I think and feel. Evidently I didn’t convert fast enough for the folks on this forum.

I have typed in “list of infallible catholic teachings” and never got a list. If you can find a LIST I would apprecate the link. I do not mean an article that says we are to follow the church leaders blindly but rather a list of the rules that the catholic church says will never change.

From what I am reading on the last few posts is that because I haven’t changed my thinking and fallen in line with everyone else on the forum that I must just be lost cause or probably a troll. Maybe I am a little dense but I still have not seen absolute concrete evidence of what I am looking for. I am a black or white type guy. Either it is yes or it is no.

If I don’t fit into the NORM for members of this forum please let me know and I will leave. :mad:
 
Yes, but I think it would only be useful to a person who was intereseted in learning about the faith.

And since it is off topic in this thread, it would be better if you started a new thread on that. It is one of the forum rules that you stay on topic in the thread (even one you made yourself). You wanted to talk about reading Scripture, remember?

One of the signs of a troll is that, when they get an answer, they change the subject. You have been given a lot of information about the Catholic position on reading Scripture, but you have ignored it, and continued to forward your anti-catholic ignorance of the facts.

Now, you seem to want to change the subject.
So I must be troll. 😦 cause I ended up going off in new direction. When you are having conversation with someone, do you need to make of point of telling them that it is now time to change the subject, before you can actually talk about it.

I haven’t ignored the information about the catholic position on reading scripture, it is that I am not convinced that all of that information is correct.
 
Actually, it’s just the opposite. Here’s the official Catholic Church teaching on reading Scripture:

CCC ¶¶ 131-133.

Now, of course, the problem then arises: what if two Christians disagree about what Scripture says? E.g., suppose Frank says, “The Bible says that we are saved by faith alone, and not by works!” But Tom says, “The Bible says that faith without works is dead and has no power to save!” How does Susan decide who’s right?

The Church teaches us how to understand Scripture:

CCC ¶¶ 109-119.
Thanks for posting this 👍
 
I really think it is ironic that there is not definitive listing of all the infallible teachings of the Catholic church. To my understanding is that because of this we are to assume that every teaching, thought and proposal that comes from the Pope, bishops, and even the priests would be considered infallible. And then at some point in time when they all decide to change their mind they can say that it is ok because the original was teaching was not infallible and we can change that for it was not recorded as infallible at the time. Seems quite convenient to me.:eek:
No, actually, it’s exactly the opposite. Infallibility is not to be presumed unless it is “manifestly evident.”

For what it’s worth, here’s what canon law (which is not a normal teaching document but does address the issue in part) has to say about it:
Can. 749 §1. By virtue of his office, the Supreme Pontiff possesses infallibility in teaching when as the supreme pastor and teacher of all the Christian faithful, who strengthens his brothers and sisters in the faith, he proclaims by definitive act that a doctrine of faith or morals is to be held.
§2. The college of bishops also possesses infallibility in teaching when the bishops gathered together in an ecumenical council exercise the magisterium as teachers and judges of faith and morals who declare for the universal Church that a doctrine of faith or morals is to be held definitively; or when dispersed throughout the world but preserving the bond of communion among themselves and with the successor of Peter and teaching authentically together with the Roman Pontiff matters of faith or morals, they agree that a particular proposition is to be held definitively.
§3. No doctrine is understood as defined infallibly unless this is manifestly evident.
Code of Canon Law ¶ 749.

So, regarding your request for the criteria of infallibility, a doctrine is not to be called infallible unless:
  • It is given by the Pope;
  • It is given in his capacity as supreme pastor and teacher (e.g., he’s teaching at the time, not answering questions during a news conference or delivering a commencement speech at a university);
  • It is proclaimed (i.e., it takes the form of a formal teaching, not, say, a letter to a friend);
  • It is given in a definitive act (i.e., it probably has to be written, not just spoken somewhere, and it has to be clearly annunciated as a proposition to be held by the faithful);
  • It concerns a doctrine of faith or morals; and
  • It is clear that this is the formal teaching of the Church (and not, say, theological speculation).
Alternatively, a doctrine can also be called infallible if:
  • It is pronounced by the college of bishops (NB: not just a few of them; it has to be in their corporate capacity);
  • It is done through an ecumenical council;
  • It is given in a definitive act (i.e., it probably has to be written, not just spoken somewhere, and it has to be clearly annunciated as a proposition to be held by the faithful);
  • It concerns a doctrine of faith or morals;
  • It is done in communion with the Pope (this is actually very straightforward; the Pope announces his agreement with the teaching);
  • It is announced for the entire Church (not just for part of it); and
  • It is clear that this is the formal teaching of the Church (and not, say, theological speculation).
So, no: just because a priest or bishop says it, doesn’t make it infallible. And just because a pope says it, doesn’t make it infallible. There are very few documents that satisfy all the criteria. And – wonder of wonders – most of them (not all, but most) are agreed to by most of the Protestant world, too.
 
LIT…I am glad that you are finding joy in your new church…MANY Catholics have come back to the Church by way of a protestant period in their lives (myself included). I challenge you to do what the others here have said…absolutely read Sacred Scripture…and then check it against what the Catechism says…and don’t just rely on the Catechism…bring your questions here…you should at least know where your heritage lies in the Church…then…pray about it, enter lively debate with those here AND those in your church. Many protestant teachings have sound theology in them…it is in about 20% of situations (probably a much too general statement really) that protestant theology CANNOT provide the answers, because they had to CHANGE their theology in the last couple centuries, or risk losing their congregations to THE CHURCH. The Church has not answered each and every question possible about Scripture.(nor has it claimed to be definitive on all matters)…but has answered it more completely and authoritatively than any other religion…without “changing it’s mind” when there was dissent.
There are MANY MANY “Catholics to be” filling lots of other churches in the world. Only when they seek the Truth can they find it. As one poster said earlier…this may be a journey for you to seek out the Truth, and evangelize others to join you…and you may…as many others have…be very surprised to find yourself “coming home” to the Catholic Church. God Bless You!!!
 
When I’m reading a great masterpiece of literature, whether it is Dante’s Divine Comedy, Milton’s Paradise Lost, or even Mark Twain’s Huckleberry Finn, I don’t just ‘pick up the book’ cold, read through in a sitting, and then meditate by pulling passages out of the air and applying my own experiences and standards onto them in order to make them ‘fit’ into what I ‘think’ they are saying.

Few of us are educated enough to be able to take any of these works and to have the requisite knowledge of the authors, the time the book was written, the various events that had an impact on the authors, the literary references the authors make to OTHER authors/events/etc.

And so I look for expert opinion. I read a biography of Twain (Clemens) to know something about the man (and in so doing, I can compare and contrast his childhood to the works he wrote. . .I can explore how he was using various devices to couch concepts in ways that were unexpected, and might therefore be met without the ingrained initial prejudice or jumping to conclusions that might have otherwise been felt by readers.

I read other works to see the similarities and the differences.

I read the dictionary to see why he used particular words. . .and if the words themselves had a different kind of meaning at the time he wrote.

I read American History to know what was going on in the mid 19th and early 20th century. . .and I read world history to see what was going on there as well.

If references are made to a particular event or a speech or a quotation. . .I look THAT up as well and as much as I can find about it.

You see, I am reading for myself. . .but I’m not just reading ‘in the dark’ without any kind of plan, waiting to get ‘hit with inspiration’. I am seeking a full CONTEXTUAL knowledge and I am seeking it from EXPERTS.

Now you see why Catholics are encouraged not only to read Scripture, but to read it in context and to use the experts (which would be the Church itself) to gain the best and fullest understanding of Scripture. . .
 
When I’m reading a great masterpiece of literature, whether it is Dante’s Divine Comedy, Milton’s Paradise Lost, or even Mark Twain’s Huckleberry Finn, I don’t just ‘pick up the book’ cold, read through in a sitting, and then meditate by pulling passages out of the air and applying my own experiences and standards onto them in order to make them ‘fit’ into what I ‘think’ they are saying. .
WOW! to say that what you have written is Excellent would be an understatement.
 
guanophore;
I actually thought that you were starting to understand how I think and feel. Evidently I didn’t convert fast enough for the folks on this forum.
I think you have made your feelings clear, and you have been clear about the misinformation you have been giving.

You don’t have to convert, but if you ask a question about what we believe, then refuse to accept the answer, and continue to force your wrong ideas into the thread, all you will do is frustrate people here. We are here to provide you with Catholic Answers. If you want them, you will follow the links, read, learn, and have an intelligent discussion with us. If you don’t want them why are you here?
I have typed in “list of infallible catholic teachings” and never got a list. If you can find a LIST I would apprecate the link.
I have already responded to this request in several posts. It is possible that you missed them. If you use the “view first unread” link at the top left of the thread it will take you to the last post you read. It is easier not to miss posts that way. You can also use the little blue square next to the posters name in the message to jump back to the post the response came from, if you have lost the train of a response.

I can assure you that you I will not be giving you any more responses to this point until I am sure that you have read what I already wrote. If you are serious about your question, you will read and think about the responses. If you are not, then people here will think you are a troll (person here just to waste our time or grind an axe). Trolls are not serious about learning anything, and are not really looking for Catholic Answers.
Code:
I do not mean an article that says we are to follow the church leaders blindly but rather a list of the rules that the catholic church says will never change.
I don’t know of any Catholic documents that say we should follow church leaders blindly. Several posters have already responded to you on that point, also, and you are not accepting our answers. This also makes you look like a troll.

If you are just here to push your anti-Catholic antagonism you will not be here for long.
Code:
From what I am reading on the last few posts is that because I haven't changed my thinking and fallen in line with everyone else on the forum that I must just be lost cause or probably a troll.
You don’t have to change your mind about anything. In fact, if you are not willing to learn a point of view other than the one you have, you are probably better in your fundamentalist anti-Catholic community. Catholicism requires an intelligent person to study their faith, apply reasoning, use discernment, and solve problems using logic. If you are unable to do those things, then Catholicism may just be too hard for you.
Code:
Maybe I am a little dense but I still have not seen absolute concrete evidence of what I am looking for.  I am a black or white type guy.  Either it is yes or it is no.
This makes sense. This explains why you are having so many problems understanding our point of view. It is not necessary for you to share our way of looking at things, but if you are unable to even understand another point of view (even if you don’t agree with it) then it is not likely that Catholic Answers will be of much use to you.
Code:
If I don't fit into the NORM for members of this forum please let me know and I will leave.    :mad:
As far as I know, there is no “norm” of people here. There are black and white thinkers like yourself, gray thinkers, atheists, faithful and devout persons, and everything in between. What we are all required to do is to follow the forum rules, and that includes staying on topic, and not trolling.

There is also an expectation that, if you ask a question, you will accept the answers, even if you disagree with them, and take into consideration what you are being told. If you are given information and links, to look at them and give a reasonable response to them. If you cannot, or will not do this, then you are probably not going to get much out of your stay here.
 
So I must be troll. 😦
That may be. It is possible that your resentment and prejudice against the Catholic faith is so strong that you are unable to benefit from even the most basic information or discussion points.

You may have just come here to complain about how you were mistreated, and to spew the anticatholic BS that you have been fed. 🤷

It happens.
cause I ended up going off in new direction. When you are having conversation with someone, do you need to make of point of telling them that it is now time to change the subject, before you can actually talk about it.
We all stray off the topic from time to time, and we all need to help one another to focus. Some of us have been reprimanded by Moderators about it (as well as other infractions).

If you want to move to a new topic, you can open a new thread.
I haven’t ignored the information about the catholic position on reading scripture, it is that I am not convinced that all of that information is correct.
All we can tell you is that the information you came here with is not correct. If you are unwilling to accept being corrected, then nothing will be very helpful for you. You will probably go to your grave hanging onto false ideas.

You have been told that the Catechism is correct. If you cannot accept this, there is probably nothing else that will benefit you very much. Since you are black and white, then you are either willing to accept the truth, or not.
 
I have already responded to this request in several posts. It is possible that you missed them. If you use the “view first unread” link at the top left of the thread it will take you to the last post you read. It is easier not to miss posts that way. You can also use the little blue square next to the posters name in the message to jump back to the post the response came from, if you have lost the train of a response.
If I missed the post that contained every infallible teaching that the church has I apologize. I must have overlooked it. Would you be so kind as to give the post number.
 
If I missed the post that contained every infallible teaching that the church has I apologize. I must have overlooked it. Would you be so kind as to give the post number.
The answer to your question may not be the answer you wanted.

This question has been addressed since post number 137 with many excellent responses. It seems that, since you are not getting what you wanted, none of them are of any use to you. That is ok.

You may not be able to grasp that Jesus did not teach in “lists”.

Besides, the topic of infallibility is OFF TOPIC IN THIS THREAD, so I am not going to follow you down that path. If you no longer wish to talk about reading the Scriptures, that is your choice. You are free to start a new thread, or if you prefer, you can “search” threads on infallibility. It is a frequent topic here and you will find many threads, some of which are still open.
 
Unless I misunderstand the your meaning of trolling. No I am not. The only thing I am trolling for, right now, is a list put out by the church that says which teachings are infallible and which are not. I have not been able to find a definitive list even with google searches.
Trolls are folks who are just out to complain and aren’t legitimately looking for answers. Give them a link to read and they avoid it, only to ***** moan and complain further.

Rather than a list that you presume exists why not try to understand the Magisterium itself:

"The rule of what we must believe as Catholics was defined by the First Vatican Council (1870). Thus: “Further, all those things are to be believed with divine and Catholic faith which are contained in the Word of God, written or handed down, and which the Church, either by a solemn judgment or by her ordinary and universal teaching [magisterium], proposes for belief as having been divinely revealed” (Dogmatic Constitution, De Fide, Ch 3).

Note that the “solemn judgment”, also referred to at times as the extraordinary Magisterium, refers to an infallible teaching emanating from the sacred deposit of faith and derives from the *sensus fidelium *(or the supernatural sense of faith – sensus fidei) of the Church. Sensus fidelium is the “sense of the faithful” and refers to the idea that beliefs, consciences and experiences of the faithful is one of the valid sources of truth in Catholic theology. Its very nature preserves it from fundamental error and is rooted in the promise of Christ to protect his Church (the mystical body of Christ) from error through the guidance of the Spirit.

So while nostrums such as “everyone makes mistakes” and “no one is infallible” may guide the ordinary citizen in the conduct of his secular affairs, when it comes to matters of the* extraordinary Magisterium *and its guidance by the Holy Spirit, these apparent common sense maxims no longer apply – derisive comments by the Church’s cultural detractors not withstanding.

And it is here one must understand that the *extraordinary Magisterium *is just that: something rarely invoked (only twice in the past couple hundred years: Pope Pius IX’s definition of the Immaculate Conception of Mary (1854), and Pope Pius XII’s definition of the Assumption of Mary (1950)) and begs to be distinguished from the *ordinary *and *universal *Magisterium which pours out thousands upon thousands of encyclicals, exhortations, homilies, addresses, letters and messages (estimated to be more in the last forty years that the previous 1960)."
from Understanding the Magisterium

So there is your list for you.

Robert George, writing in The Clash of Orthodoxies, explains: “Understanding the nature of the Church and its authority makes all the difference when it comes to issues of moral consequence. People who view the Church as essentially a political body and the Magisterium as a legislative office will chafe under the authority of decisions that strike them as restricting freedoms they enjoy. They will test those decisions by appeal to conscience — understood now, not as a judgment of what one is morally required to do or not do, but, rather, as one’s feeling about whether a certain activity — abortion, premarital sex, or whatever — is in fact morally available for one’s choice, the Church’s teaching about the wrongfulness of that activity notwithstanding.

By contrast, people who understand the essentially mystical reality of the Church and the function of the Magisterium as teacher of Christ’s saving truths will adopt an attitude of humble — and grateful — submission to the Church’s moral teachings. They understand those teachings as making known the mind of Christ and thus helping to make possible our salvation. Such people will treat those teachings as principles of the formation of their consciences. And they will struggle to live in accordance with them.”

dj
 
djeter;

Thank you for posting these links. *Understanding the Magisterium & The Clash of Orthodoxies *That is probably one of the best suggestions I have received here.
something rarely invoked (only twice in the past couple hundred years:
To my understanding than there are only 2 infallible teachings in the last 200 years.
 
djeter;

Thank you for posting these links. *Understanding the Magisterium & The Clash of Orthodoxies *That is probably one of the best suggestions I have received here.

To my understanding than there are only 2 infallible teachings in the last 200 years.
Your understanding is defective.
Catholic Reference.net
INFALLIBILITY, EPISCOPAL

Preservation from error of the bishops of the Catholic Church. They are infallible when all the bishops of the Church are assembled in a general council or, scattered over the earth, they propose a teaching of faith or morals as one to be held by all the faithful. They are assured freedom from error provided they are in union with the Bishop of Rome and their teaching is subject to his authority. The scope of this infallibility, like that of the Pope, includes not only revealed truths but any teaching, even historical facts, principles of philosophy, or norms of the natural law that are in any way connected with divine revelation.
The object of his infallibility is his teaching of faith and morals. This means especially revealed doctrine like the Incarnation. But it also includes any nonrevealed teaching that is in any way connected with revelation.
The condition of the infallibility is that the Pope speaks ex cathedra. For this is required that: 1. he have the intention of declaring something unchangeably true; and 2. he speak as shepherd and teacher of all the faithful with the full weight of his apostolic authority, and not merely as a private theologian or even merely for the people of Rome or some particular segment of the Church of God.
 
djeter;

Thank you for posting these links. *Understanding the Magisterium & The Clash of Orthodoxies *That is probably one of the best suggestions I have received here.

To my understanding than there are only 2 infallible teachings in the last 200 years.
Your understanding is defective.
]
Alternatively, a doctrine can also be called infallible if:
  • It is pronounced by the college of bishops (NB: not just a few of them; it has to be in their corporate capacity);
  • It is done through an ecumenical council;
  • It is given in a definitive act (i.e., it probably has to be written, not just spoken somewhere, and it has to be clearly annunciated as a proposition to be held by the faithful);
  • It concerns a doctrine of faith or morals;
  • It is done in communion with the Pope (this is actually very straightforward; the Pope announces his agreement with the teaching);
  • It is announced for the entire Church (not just for part of it); and
  • It is clear that this is the formal teaching of the Church (and not, say, theological speculation).
So, no: just because a priest or bishop says it, doesn’t make it infallible. And just because a pope says it, doesn’t make it infallible. There are very few documents that satisfy all the criteria. And – wonder of wonders – most of them (not all, but most) are agreed to by most of the Protestant world, too.
Most of what Catholic believe is infallible. An infallible pronouncement—whether made by the pope alone or by an ecumenical council—usually is made only when some doctrine has been called into question. Most doctrines have never been doubted by the large majority of Catholics. You are mixing up what is infallible with what has been declared infallible.
 
djeter;

Thank you for posting these links. *Understanding the Magisterium & The Clash of Orthodoxies *That is probably one of the best suggestions I have received here.

To my understanding than there are only 2 infallible teachings in the last 200 years.
Good for you LIT! 👍

Now you are making some progress. :clapping:

Giving up the search for a “list” is a breakthrough.

But no, there are plenty of infalible teachings. There have been only two infallible papal declarations, that is true.

Everything that comes from Jesus through the Apostles is infallible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top