Are we really that ignorant?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LIT56RD
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Good for you LIT! 👍

Now you are making some progress. :clapping:

Giving up the search for a “list” is a breakthrough.

But no, there are plenty of infalible teachings. There have been only two infallible papal declarations, that is true.

Everything that comes from Jesus through the Apostles is infallible.
I have NOT given up the search for a list. That is very important to me.
 
I have NOT given up the search for a list. That is very important to me.
Others have rightly stated that this is off topic. If you wish to pursue it, either join a current thread or start one of your own. After this posting, I will not comment further
I have had some heated discussions recently about what teachings of the Church have been formally defined as infallible. I believe that under the definition of infallibility set forth at the First Vatican Council and affirmed at the Second Vatican Council in Lumen Gentium, the following teachings have been infallibly taught: the Immaculate Conception, the Assumption, the reservation of priestly ordination to men, and the immorality of abortion and other deliberate killing of innocent persons. So, which teachings of the Church are in fact formally defined?
”A: The Church has not yet compiled a list of all infallible teachings or dogmatic definitions. However, all of the teachings you name are infallible.
Some of them—the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption—have been infallibly taught by a definition of the extraordinary magisterium (i.e., in a definition of a pope or an ecumenical council). Others—the male priesthood, the intrinsic evil of abortion and the deliberate killing of innocents—are infallibly taught, without a definition, by the Church’s ordinary magisterium.
Tests for whether a definition has been made include: (a) if a pope is writing, does he use the phrase “I define”? and (b) if a council is writing, does it use the phrase “let him be anathema”? If either of these is the case, it’s probably an infallible definition, especially as this language has been used in recent centuries. There are other ways popes and councils can issue definitions, but these are phrases commonly used to do so.
 
Back to the topic
Are Catholics free to interpret Bible verses without the Church’s approval?
”A: So far as the interpretations of individual scriptural passages go, keep in mind that the Church does not, as a rule, define how specific verses are to be taken. Instead, it defines doctrine, and that definition may eliminate some interpretations of particular verses. Ludwig Ott’s Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma should answer most of your questions in these areas about the Church’s teaching office.
Only seven passages of Scripture have had their senses partially—but not fully—defined by the extraordinary magisterium. These definitions were made by the Council of Trent (see “The Limits of Scriptural Interpretation” in the January 2001 issue of This Rock):
The reference to being “born of water and the Spirit” in John 3:5 includes the idea of baptism.
In telling the apostles, “Do this [the Eucharist] in memory of me” in Luke 22:19 and 1 Corinthians 11:24, Jesus appointed the apostles priests.
In Matthew 18:18 and John 20:22–23, Jesus conferred on the apostles the power to forgive sins; everyone does not share this power.
Romans 5:12 refers to the reality of original sin.
The presbyters referred to in James 5:14 are ordained, not merely elder members of the Christian community.
 
No, of course not.

[But, which translation are you using? Have you considered studying Hebrew and Latin to get as close to the original as possible?]

[Where do you live? I mean, like, the Bible was written for “country people” … how much do you know about lambs, for example? Back 2000 years ago, or 5000 years ago, everyone knew all about lambs.]

[How much do you know about the tribal customs of people in the Middle East?]

[What will you do when some well-meaning person rings your door bell and tells you that John 6 is not to be taken literally?]

[What is St. Luke’s resume? Important to know that.]

No, we are not ignorant, not at all, but we are physically far removed and, in time, 2000 to 5000 years removed from when the Bible was written. Have you considered visiting the Holy Land so you can walk where Jesus walked and sit where he sat and see what he saw?

What do you think about the Shroud of Turin? Does it amplify or detract from your understanding of the Resurrection … and the Crucifixion.

Anyway, just thought I would try to provide you with some incentive to build up a Biblical reference library, and maybe make a field trip or two. Or take a few courses. Maybe study Hebrew. [What does Son of Man mean?]
 
I have NOT given up the search for a list. That is very important to me.
Doggone it! I thought you were making progress. :crying:

So, why is a "list’ so important to you?

What evidence do you have that ANY of the Teachings of Jesus came in “lists”?
 
Are Catholics really that ignorant and stupid that we can not and should not read the Bible. I was told that once by a parish priest. That we as lay people do not have the ability to read and understand the Bible and that it is best left to those more learned and of more authority in the church. Are we devoid of any common sense that we can not read, and with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, glean some knowledge without someone else telling us EXACTLY what we need to think and do? Didn’t realize I, along with all the other Catholics, were just so stupid.:eek:
What we need to accept as Catholics is an incredible blessing God has given us! This is the blessing that we have not only an infallible Scripture, but also an infallible oral Tradition and an infallible Magesterium. So we have infallible councils and infallible teaching handed on through the apostolic succession of the bishops, from the time of the apostles to this day, as well as infallible scriptures.

None of these sources of truth is in disagreement with one another.

The problem that can arise with regard to individual reading of the Scripture is that sometimes when people read it, they put their personal interpretations of what it means as a higher authority than the infallible Tradition and Magesterium. So when people do this, they make their private and fallible interpretations of the Bible their highest authority, and when the teaching of the Church contradicts their interpretations, they ditch these infallible teachings as secondary to Scripture (or secondary to their readings of scripture), though the the teaching of the Church and the true meaning of the Scripture never actually contradict one another.

It’s great for us to read the Bible, provided we don’t consider our own readings of it and interpretations of it to be superior to those of the Church. The Church teaches infallibly. As Paul writes in 1 Tim. 3:15, “the church of the living God is the pillar and foundation of truth.” It is the foundation on which everything rests.

So we should accept the FULL blessing God gives us: Magesterium, Tradition and Scripture, and not set private, fallible interpretations of the Scripture above the infallible teachings of the Magesterium and Tradition. That is the way we can be really blessed! For then we get all of what God intended for us to know. And not subjectively and fallible but infallibly and objectively, clearly. The light of truth in the Catholic Church is glorious, in that way!

It might help you to remember also that the Apostle Peter wrote in 2 Peter 3:16, “[Paul] writes the same way in all his letters, speaking in them of these matters. His letters contain some things that are hard to understand, which ignorant and unstable people distort, as they do the other Scriptures, to their own destruction.”

Peter says that the Apostle Paul’s writings contain some things that are hard to understand and which ignorant people distort. So people can get confused reading the Bible. You know how many different interpretations there are of it in Protestantism? Huge numbers, even though they all think they’re reading it in a straightforward way, and according to the Spirit’s guidance.

The Lord wants us to read the Bible in harmony with the teachings of Magesterium and Tradition, all the infallible teachings united and understood together.

So reading the Bible, it’s good to read it along with the Catechism, or the Papal or Conciliar documents. It’s great to get the fullness of truth God intended for us, all infallible, rather than depending on our own fallible judgment, or fallible interpretations of the Bible, as our final authority.

It’s good to read the Bible, but not Bible Alone :).
 
Doggone it! I thought you were making progress. :crying:

So, why is a "list’ so important to you?

What evidence do you have that ANY of the Teachings of Jesus came in “lists”?
I am not saying that Jesus’ teachings came in a list. I am referring to all other teaching by the Church.

The list is important because I see a lot of people saying that this is infallible and that is infallible. I want to see documentation that it is not just someones word. I read so many times in these forums “show me the proof, show me the reference.” That is what I am saying here. Show me the documentation of all church infallibility. Not just papal infallibility but all the infallible statements that are enforced by the church.
 
I think that you don’t really understand what the church teaches and why. Some of your comments sound like fundamentalist protestantism. Have you been involved in that kind of thing? It would be really good if you could read up on what the church actually says and clarify things.

As for reading the Bible, sure, we should all do that. However, we are not free to interpret things as we please. That is the difference.

God bless.
 
Hi. After reading this whole thread, I can’t possibly say it better than those who have responded so beautifully to you. I have a lot of protestant influence on me and have had to seek answers to some things. I had to take my blinders off, check bias at the door and look into it with an open mind. If I believed that I had been given any authority to change anything maybe I would make all the feel-good sins and conveniences of life perfectly acceptable. We can read black print on white paper to mean whatever we “need” it or “want” it to mean. When we read the Bible, that was produced by the Church that had been orally teaching it (in it’s context) and living it for centureis before it was ever written down for anyone, we HAVE to read it as the writers meant it to be read. That is why it is a useful tool, but to not be used without the Authority that produced it. The Catholic Church has writings that go all the way back that teach all that is Truth and the information you are seeking. This may seem blunt, but I couldn’t help but think as I read this thread, “How does he know that anything he has ever read or been taught isn’t just words? How does he know that the Bible isn’t just some words that someone made up?” In any story that someone tells, there is a context to it. What documentation do you have that anything you believe is true.? How did you come to believe it? Where was that person’s documentation? Is it something that was taught in the early Church? If it is something opposite that was taught in the early Church, and a newer convenient concept, it was created by man, hence tens of thousands of different churches teaching it’s own version of faith. The Catholic Church preserved these teachings, wrote them (the Bible) for you and for all. The documentation that you seek has been produced by the Catholic Church from the beginning. These various sources have all been mentioned in previous posts. As I had to concede my selfish ways to the Truth, His Will, so do you. If you want to find a church that will approve of pre-marital sex or masturbation or whatever it is you want, I am sure that if you look hard enough, you can find one as there are tens of thousands to choose from. But, if you seek the Truth, the Way, His path for us, there is only One way, and that is through Jesus’ Church that He founded with the Apostles. We have to change to come into alignment with Jesus’ Will, it will NEVER be the other way around.
 
I think that you don’t really understand what the church teaches and why. Some of your comments sound like fundamentalist protestantism. Have you been involved in that kind of thing? It would be really good if you could read up on what the church actually says and clarify things.

As for reading the Bible, sure, we should all do that. However, we are not free to interpret things as we please. That is the difference.

God bless.
So why even read the Bible when we are not suppose to interpret. Just let someone from the church come and tell us what we are to believe and not believe.
 
So why even read the Bible when we are not suppose to interpret. Just let someone from the church come and tell us what we are to believe and not believe.
Hi. Because the Bible tells us not to rely on our own interpretations. We are to take it as it has been taught to us and not twist it to our own destruction. That is what humans do and have done. The original teaching hasn’t changed. People have changed it. Do you have knowledge or authority that the ECF’s and magisterium did not have from the 1st and 2nd centuries through today? Were you given some authority that I wasn’t? We are not all supposed to be teachers or our own interpreters. I am not sure why this is so difficult for you. We are not supposed to interpret it to mean anything different that what it meant to the ECF’s who recorded it for us, taught us that it meant and have protected (through the protection of the Holy Spirit), it’s context and meaning for us from being changed through today. That is One. That is the unity Christ wanted for His Church. We have to believe He protected Her teachings as He said He would. The Apostles passed it on to the ECF’s and they are the magisterium of the Church. That is all we have lit.
 
So why even read the Bible when we are not suppose to interpret. Just let someone from the church come and tell us what we are to believe and not believe.
No one can read the Bible without interpreting what they are reading, obviously. However, the Bible isn’t the only infallible revelation we have, by the goodness of God. We also have the Sacred Tradition and Sacred Magesterium. So we have to interpret the Bible in harmony with them. These show us how the Bible should be understood on many key matters of doctrine, and also they reveal what the faith always has been and will be. They reveal truth. So we can humbly submit to that truth and seek to understand it better when we have problems with parts of it, or we can set our own fallible understandings of doctrine and scripture above the infallible understands that the apostles handed down through the apostolic succession.

The Lord speaks through the Bible and helps us understand His Truth better through it. That is why we read it. But we can’t interpret it in a way that conflicts with God’s infallible Tradition, because that Tradition is infallible, and if we interpret Scripture in a way that contradicts it, we are misunderstanding the Scripture (truth doesn’t contradict truth) and setting our fallible understandings up as our highest authority – a recipe for disaster.
 
Code:
I am not saying that Jesus' teachings came in a list.  I am referring to all other teaching by the Church.
In that case you are just confused.

The only infallible teachings are those of Jesus Christ, preserved in the CC by the HS.

“all other teaching” has various levels, but the Catechism is a sure guide.

Since Jesus did not teach the faith using “lists”, the CC does not, either.
Code:
 The list is important  because I see a lot of people saying that this is infallible and that is infallible.
Really? Who are they? Can you give an example?
Code:
 I want to see documentation that it is not just someones word.  I read so many times in these forums  "show me the proof,  show me the reference."  That is what I am saying here.  Show me the documentation of all church infallibility.  Not just papal infallibility but all the infallible statements that are enforced by the church.
It is good that you are looking for information, LIT. And there are 2000 years worth of church documentation available, so you will have more “answer” than you will be able to digest in a lifetime. 👍

I am not sure what you mean by “enforced”. The Church founded by Christ is not an “enforcer”. The Church is charged with the responsibility to preserve that which was handed down to her from the Apostles. She must dutifully transmit the Teachings of Jesus to the faithful. Each person has a choice if they wish to follow them, or not.

For example, Jesus taught that we should read the Scriptures in the context they were produced. If a Catholic refuses to do this, they may stray from the One Faith. The consequences for straying may be eternal.
 
I think that you don’t really understand what the church teaches and why. Some of your comments sound like fundamentalist protestantism. Have you been involved in that kind of thing? It would be really good if you could read up on what the church actually says and clarify things.

As for reading the Bible, sure, we should all do that. However, we are not free to interpret things as we please. That is the difference.

God bless.
Yes. LIT has explained to us that he has been contaminated by Protestant Fundamentalism. His faith has finally come alive, and his life has been changed by it, and he is now coming back to address some unresolved hostilities toward the CC, whose poor catechesis led him spirituallly astray for most of his life.
 
As for reading the Bible, sure, we should all do that. However, we are not free to interpret things as we please. That is the difference.

God bless.
I think that God did give mankind the freedom to disobey Him. We are free to choose sin, and to walk away from His plan for us. Obviously, people have used this freedom to interpret the bible however they please, because it has created thousands of splintered ecclesial communities.

Perhaps what you mean to say is that our freedoms have limits, and that when we go beyond the boundaries set for us by God, we can become lost, and injured. We are sheep, after all, and it behooves us to stay where the shepherd guides. 😃
So why even read the Bible when we are not suppose to interpret. Just let someone from the church come and tell us what we are to believe and not believe.
Contra Mundum did not say we were not supposed to interpret at all. The point is that we are to interpret what we read according to the faith that produced it.

Yes, it is the duty of the Chruch to transmit the faith that was handed down from the Apostles. The Church was given the authority by Christ to teach with all authority the right doctrine. And yes, someone can rely on this teaching without ever reading the bible, which means people who are illiterate can be saved. 👍
 
So why even read the Bible when we are not suppose to interpret. Just let someone from the church come and tell us what we are to believe and not believe.
I know you can miss things in a thread especially when their are so many answering.
I assume you missed Post 181 It answers your first question.
 
Yes. LIT has explained to us that he has been contaminated by Protestant Fundamentalism. His faith has finally come alive, and his life has been changed by it, and he is now coming back to address some unresolved hostilities toward the CC, whose poor catechesis led him spirituallly astray for most of his life.
Because of my being contaminated by Protestant Fundamentalism I have learned a lot more about God and myself than the catholic church ever taught me.
 
Because of my being contaminated by Protestant Fundamentalism I have learned a lot more about God and myself than the catholic church ever taught me.
It is truly a blessing if protestantism is bringing you closer to God. Again, I recommend you read ‘Surprised by Truth’, I think you’ll find it worth your time.

What have you learned that is different than what the catholic church taught? How do you know it is true? What is your authority?

You mentioned, if I recall correctly, that you have learned to doubt the Eucharist, I can show that the ‘Real Presence’ in the Eucharist has been taught from the earliest days of the church, from prior to the determination of scripture or even existence of the writing of the New Testament.

I don’t mean to ask this to be confrontational, or debate a specific item of doctrine, more to spark contemplation-- the guy predicting the end of the world thought he was teaching truth based in his personal interpretation of the Bible. He learned that about God’s plan but it wasn’t true.

How can you be sure you’ve learned truth about God or are being deceived?

Or would you say I’m simply being lazy by relying on the authority of the Catholic Church, that I’m abdicating the responsibillity to think for myself?
 
+JMJ+
Because of my being contaminated by Protestant Fundamentalism I have learned a lot more about God and myself than the catholic church ever taught me.
And if Protestant Fundamentalism has taught you so much, then why are you in so much distress right now when it comes to interpreting Holy Scripture? Where is the peace of Christ?

The thing is, we are not saying that you have not learned anything about Jesus Christ and His Gospel from Protestant Fundamentalism. What we are saying is that that faith will have some errors and incomplete truths in it, and you are unfortunately being blindsided by them. If not, then why this insistence for a list of infallible pronouncements by the Catholic Church, which the Catholic Church never had seen a need for (which is why you will not see a definite list from the Church, only lists from Catholic theologians)? Such an insistence on clarity and completeness printed on paper is actually foreign to the thinking of the Church but is quite common in Protestant Fundamentalism, which usually insists that all the truths one needs can be found between the covers of the King James Bible. What the Church, in the guidance of the Holy Spirit, saw that the faithful needed was not such a list but catechisms of the basics of the faith, the latest and most comprehensive of which, whose purpose, according to Bl. Pope John Paul II, is to be “a sure norm for teaching the [Catholic] faith” (Fidei Depositum, the apostolic constitution on the publication of the Catechism), is readily available online: scborromeo.org/ccc.htm

So how to use it? If you want to be a bit liberal on your interpretation of the Bible yet still be faithful to the Catholic Church, just read the Bible, make your interpretation of what you read, and check your interpretation against the Catechism. Then if you are still in doubt about what you read, then either talk to a priest or even just post it here at CAF then we’ll help you.

No need to be too worked up on it.

God love you.
 
Because of my being contaminated by Protestant Fundamentalism I have learned a lot more about God and myself than the catholic church ever taught me.
We all know that the Protestant Churches contain elements of truth. If somehow you ‘missed’ those elements while you were Catholic, but ‘discovered them’ through the Protestant Church, you’re still (ultimately) gaining your knowledge through the Catholic Church.

Now it’s also true that in some ways catechesis in some places was pretty poor in the last 40 years or so. But even back when we had students full time in Catholic schools and plenty of religious classes and ‘practice’, there were still students who **did not learn. Not because they were not ‘taught’, but because for whatever reason THEY WOULD NOT LISTEN. **

Finally, no matter what the state of your ‘youth’ or what priest hurt your feelings in 1974, etc., the fact is that nowhere in Catholic (or heck in Protestant teaching so far as I know) is there a little footnote: “All you need to know about the faith you will learn in elementary and sometimes high school, and after that, you KNOW IT ALL and need never try to learn anything again.”

Too many people seem to think that once they sit through ‘school’ they do KNOW IT ALL. Even those who listened well and had a good education can still, as time goes by, start to ‘forget’ or to become confused.

Like most of us, I suffered through, um, studied Algebra, Geometry, and Calculus in high school decades ago. How much of that do you think I remember? And I was an A student. But I never really needed to use the higher mathematics consistently in life (unlike the English and Science courses. Those I remember!) and so much of what I ‘learned’ I have forgotten or remember indistinctly and often incorrectly.

If something is important to you (and your religion should be important) it is something which you need to keep practicing, learning, and reinforcing your life long.

Had you paid Catholicism the same kind of attention in your adulthood as you apparently are doing with protestant studies, it is quite likely you’d still be Catholic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top