Ask a Pagan

  • Thread starter Thread starter Skadi
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
No the NT, although we know there was likely some tampering with the written parts of Germanic lore because alot of it was transcribed by christian monks in the 12th and 13th centuries.
Interesting.

So you dismiss the NT because it was written by men and likely tampered with, but you accept the lore of the Germanic gods which also were written by men and likely tampered with? Why?

Also, do you believe that the Germanic lore was pure and undefiled prior to the transcription in the 12th century?
 
That dosnt necessarily discredit Judaism (YHWH was worshiped by the Canaanites as the head of thier pantheon) or even Christianity (because the Messiah was a big part of Jewish culture) but it does make them warrant scrutiny in my opinion.
Yes–all things religious need to be scrutinized with a critical eye. That is very Catholic.

But what I find quite curious is that you do not seem to be scrutinizing your Germanic lore with the same critical eye that you use for Christianity.

Also, what standard do you use to discern, when scrutinizing, whether something is true or false?
If truth is revealed in a cultural context then it doesn’t shift cultures in some violent spasm.
Firstly, where do you get that notion that truth revealed in a cultural context doesn’t shift cultures in some violent spasm?

Secondly, what “violent spasm” was created with Mormonism? And how is this violent spasm different in quality from the “violent spasm” that was created by Christianity (which I assume you don’t put in the same man-made category as Mormonism)?
And in the end thats what religion is, belief.
Religion, Skadi, is actually about relationship. That’s what religion means. It comes from the Latin word,* religare*, which means: relationship.
 
Where is anything written about what the gods demand?

Also, could you please answer what sources you used to tell you about Nero’s persecution of the Christians?
Hiya, Skadi. 👋

Could you answer this one, please?
 
II think if a child is aborted it should be done before it reaches the level of brain activity that could be considered “Conscious”.
So you do believe this for all women who choose abortion–even if she chose it because she just didn’t want a baby, and wasn’t raped?
 
Religion, Skadi, is actually about relationship. That’s what religion means. It comes from the Latin word,* religare*, which means: relationship.
I think it was Bishop Fulton Sheen who said the bible is not about our search for God but rather God’s search for us.

Either way you look at the bible, it’s about our relationship with God and his relationship with us.
 
So, seeing as there are a couple other threads thrown up by people of various faiths for questions on their religion i figured id do it too.

“Ask a Pagan” is a very broad term though and Paganism is not itself a religion but a blanket term for many who form a sort of community. In addition, various Pagan faiths are very eclectic and there is no Bible or Catechism to outline beliefs, but I have a good general knowledge of paganism (and the occult sense I know the questions are coming) and I’ll do my best to answer any questions.

I was raised catholic and went k-12 in the catholic school system, learned catholic doctrine and apologetics, and understand Catholicisms teachings pretty well. So I look forward to any questions you may have or discussions that may come.

Stay classy Catholics 👍
Beings that you were raised in the Catholic Church, don’t you sometimes get afraid when you totally deny Jesus and follow a false god, According to of course you Catholic background. Especially when it is breaking one of the ten commandments.

Also at what point in your life did you begin to deny Christ and his teaching’s. Did something happen, etc?
 
And because I know where you’re going with this, and because I don’t have any more time to spare to this forum (busy in the gardens, the *real *world, LOL), I’ll also say that truth can only be determined when you have a known. You cannot determine truth with unknowns. Anything that has to do with God, whether what people say God’s laws are, or God’s proper rituals, or what God said in a book that was written by men, or what they said God told them, these things are not knowns, they are all unknowns. Therefore, truth cannot be determined regarding anything to do with God. That’s why they call belief in God “faith.” Faith is a belief that is not based on proof, it is based on an unknown.

If I say that blabolellogram has 47 sides of equal length, there MUST be a known blabolellogram in existence in order to determine the truth of this statement. To say anything at all about God is simply opinion. God is an unknown. Now I know that you almost certainly disagree with this, and that’s fine. But it’s your opinion, it’s not truth.
I’m curious if you find world history and events in time as known things?
 
I’m curious if you find world history and events in time as known things?
Things that are well recorded or supported by archeological evidence. Events like the Battle of Kadesh, The Exodus (at least in the sense of the Jews leaving Egypt), and the Battle of Cannae, while happening thousands of years ago, are attested to (often by multiple sources) and have archeological evidence. Thus we can know with quite a bit of certainty the occurred. But events such as miracles depicted in ancient writings when people had little to no knowledge of science should be taken with a grain of salt in my opinion. weather its the story of the splitting of the red sea, the works of Jesus, the tale of one of Buddhas followers walking on water, or any other supernatural event that has only a single source and no archeological evidence.
 
Beings that you were raised in the Catholic Church, don’t you sometimes get afraid when you totally deny Jesus and follow a false god, According to of course you Catholic background. Especially when it is breaking one of the ten commandments.

Also at what point in your life did you begin to deny Christ and his teaching’s. Did something happen, etc?
No, not really. I fell out of Christianity because the older I got and the more I learned about it the more absurd some of its doctrines and teachings sounded to me. I saw people imposing god on everything. I was a pretty hardened deist by high school and still am quite a bit. That might have been a bit young but as I became older and began to really start looking at religion rather than simply distancing myself from it I still found Christianity to be… not something I believed. The drift was not sudden, and in fact I started praying again for a point after my grandpa died, but over time as I grew older I looked at Christianity objectively and decided I didn’t believe it. No matter how much fire and brimstone the street preachers on campus throw at me, no matter how genuinely concerned for me that missionary may try to appear, I don’t fear what they say. I honestly have concluded I think they are wrong. I can respect them and I respect most Christians, but its a respectful disagreement.

I will say though that this wouldn’t be true of all pagans. There are some serious Christian haters out there. Especially certain witches, They may have had some problems with christian people in the past and alot of witches still arn’t over the whole “Burn the Witch!” time period yet. Yo also get a few of those super feminist ones that think Christianity suppresses women.
 
So you do believe this for all women who choose abortion–even if she chose it because she just didn’t want a baby, and wasn’t raped?
I would say that for a woman who is raped. I don’t think anyone should have an abortion out of convenience. Also If its between the mother living or both dying as happened at that hospital a few years back I would say it would be permissible. Now with that said, im not one who believes religion and government should be put together, so if abortion came to a vote I dont really know what way I would vote. It would take alot of deep though and contemplation.
 
Hiya, Skadi. 👋

Could you answer this one, please?
Not anywhere really, The Eddas arn’t like the bible in that the gods don’t talk directly to humanity. Thus things come from tradition, and from the example of the gods.

History books, im a history major. Most history books take their sources from Tacitus and other roman historians. Why? did someone besides Nero torched Rome? I certainly take him to be the most likely candidate.
 
Interesting.

So you dismiss the NT because it was written by men and likely tampered with, but you accept the lore of the Germanic gods which also were written by men and likely tampered with? Why?

Also, do you believe that the Germanic lore was pure and undefiled prior to the transcription in the 12th century?
No i dismiss the NT because of the motives of the men who wrote it. Like I said earlier there isnt a book on earth that wasnt written by a man putting pen to paper or typing it up.

I also dont put absolute faith in the Eddas (although they are still very important and the largest source we have) because they were transcribed by men with potentially the same motives. Maybe they copied them word for word, or maybe they tried to slip some Christianity in there to ease the process of converting Scandinavia, we don’t know.

Now, this second question is where debates often run into problems because of the difference in the way we view religions. In christianity, things have an almost scientific structure. there is one way to preform the Eucharist. if not done by the right person in the right way it doesn’t work. There is a specific way god wants certain things done.

The Germanic gods give very little like this. There never was nor will there every be a uniform way to celebrate a Blot. It varied from town to town and region to region with only the general themes the same. What matters isnt the tiny details, the exact words or the exact items (except in the case of magic). What matters is the goal, which is to honor the gods. What matters is not the symbols used but what they symbolize.
 
No, not really. I fell out of Christianity because the older I got and the more I learned about it the more absurd some of its doctrines and teachings sounded to me. I saw people imposing god on everything. I was a pretty hardened deist by high school and still am quite a bit. That might have been a bit young but as I became older and began to really start looking at religion rather than simply distancing myself from it I still found Christianity to be… not something I believed. The drift was not sudden, and in fact I started praying again for a point after my grandpa died, but over time as I grew older I looked at Christianity objectively and decided I didn’t believe it. No matter how much fire and brimstone the street preachers on campus throw at me, no matter how genuinely concerned for me that missionary may try to appear, I don’t fear what they say. I honestly have concluded I think they are wrong. I can respect them and I respect most Christians, but its a respectful disagreement.

I will say though that this wouldn’t be true of all pagans. There are some serious Christian haters out there. Especially certain witches, They may have had some problems with christian people in the past and alot of witches still arn’t over the whole “Burn the Witch!” time period yet. Yo also get a few of those super feminist ones that think Christianity suppresses women.
There are people in the world who actually claim to be witches? I did not know that…
 
No i dismiss the NT because of the motives of the men who wrote it. Like I said earlier there isnt a book on earth that wasnt written by a man putting pen to paper or typing it up.
What were their motives?
 
You’re never heard of the religion called “wicca”? Seriously?? Interesting…
Yeah, I have heard of a religion called Wicca. Didn’t know anything about it. Just checked it out: “Wicca is a modern pagan, witchcraft religion.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top