Hurting the Mother of God? “Baptist smashes Virgin Mary”?
It would seem you’re talking about a real person, but you’re talking about a statue here.
Probably not a valuable, or blessed, or consecrated statue. One not containing any relics.
Please refrain from idolatry and keep your perspective. Statues have no ears and may not hear; they have no eyes and may not see. We do not worship mere stone and marble, but we honor what they represent. Therefore, someone who smashes a statue cannot hurt the Blessed Virgin Mary, she lives in Heaven and in our hearts.
The heresy of iconoclasm is nothing new, it was alive and well in the eighth century, it nearly tore our Church apart. The Byzantines are quite familiar with it. And the Eastern Churches don’t even use statues, they use painted (written) icons.
WHAAAT???
MY GOD, please don’t tell me you mean this wholeheartedly???
It doesn’t matter to me whether he had a statue of Mary, St Therese, or another saint, he did something completely unacceptable!
Let’s change the context slightly: Let’s say it had been a statue of George Washington being spray-painted. Or perhaps Thomas Jefferson’s image being smashed. Or, how would we react if someone attempted to place graffiti on Lincoln’s statue in the Lincoln Memorial in Washington, D.C. Seems to me we’d be rightly enraged.
These statues aren’t living, breathing, people, no, but neither did anyone ever declare them to be people. Even so, we still honor the existence of the unblemished statue precisely as a means of honoring the now-deceased person’s accomplishments in life.
Everyone understands this in general life, but for some reason, we seem willing to forget it when we walk into a church.
Or to put it in a different context, let’s say this had been a Catholic Church (or Protestant, for that matter) on the Sunday immediately preceding Martin Luther King Day. Let’s say this had been a white priest (or a minister) with a statue of Martin Luther King, Jr. Let’s say the cleric would smash or deface THAT statue.
Do you think this community of believers would react calmly to that?
I don’t! I think they’d threaten a riot!
Certainly I would condemn violence associated with this act, or any similar, but we have a right–and an obligation–to roundly condemn this blasphemy!
I’m well aware that this preacher doesn’t believe what I believe. I understand he thinks we’re nuts. I’m sorry, but that’s not an acceptable excuse for smashing anything.
In the case of the Koran burning, I thought that a hideous abuse of Freedom of Speech; I would condemn such acts against any book. Keep in mind, that doesn’t mean I wouldn’t throw them out or shred them. But rest assured, I’d do so IN PRIVATE, not making a public spectacle of the act!
Lastly, if we don’t get furious about this, what else might we tolerate?
Seems to me that this minister most likely doesn’t believe in the Real Presence of Christ in the sacrifice on the altar either. If we don’t object to this act, he’d have ample cause to smash an altar, or (God forbid) a tabernacle.
We have a right to expect greater tolerance and mutual understanding from our separated brothers and sisters!