Bart Stupak Cashes In

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1holycatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
More recent history shows that in 2010, there were 37 pro life Democrats in the House. Now, thanks in part to the efforts of Republican lobbies like the Susan B Anthony Foundation, there are probably less than half that number.

It’s a truly sad state of affairs when pro life groups shoot themselves in the foot all in the name of a partisan political agenda, as Susan B Anthony did when they targeted pro life Democrats for defeat because some of them voted contrary to the Republican agenda.

Better, I guess, to revile the Democratic Party than to support those in the party who agree on the evil of abortion. Are we stronger now that the pro life presence in the Democratic party is reduced? I don’t think so.

I would like to make life harder for people like Nancy Pelosi by ADDING to the number of pro life Democrats in the House…not targeting them for defeat.
As the health care vote showed were are few , if any pro-life democrats in the house. People have woken up to the fact that so called pro-life demcrats always fold to the pressure of their party on crucial votes. The alleged pro-life democrats were replaced by authentic pro-life republicans-a win win situation for pro-life .

Pro-life Democrats suffer from battered wife syndrome. No matter how bad their party abuses them no matter how many times they betray them they always come back and always find somebody else to blame for the problem.
 
Where are the Criticisms of the huge number of “pro-life” politicians that claim “I am personally against abortion, but I do not feel that I can interfere the the rights of another to choose”? (Rudy Giuliani, for one)
 
Where are the Criticisms of the huge number of “pro-life” politicians that claim “I am personally against abortion, but I do not feel that I can interfere the the rights of another to choose”? (Rudy Giuliani, for one)
The criticism of Giuliani occurred when he was campaigning and culminated at the ballot box where he was smacked down for his hypocrisy.

He dropped off the radar.
 
Where are the Criticisms of the huge number of “pro-life” politicians that claim “I am personally against abortion, but I do not feel that I can interfere the the rights of another to choose”? (Rudy Giuliani, for one)
You must not have been around there is last election. Rudy Giuliani found out the hard way that there is no support for pro-abortion politicians on the national level in the Republican Party.
 
You must not have been around there is last election. Rudy Giuliani found out the hard way that there is no support for pro-abortion politicians on the national level in the Republican Party.
He was my candidate until I found out his abortion stance. I could not support him.
 
He was my candidate until I found out his abortion stance. I could not support him.
Although there is no doubt he was a great mayor of New York City I personally believe that anybody that supports abortion on demand is so morally flawed that they should not hold any position of leadership whether that he has the president of the United States or the local dog catcher.

It is only with great regret that I vote for someone like McCain who supports abortions in cases of rape and incest but do so knowing that his opponents views were far more egregious.
 
Although there is no doubt he was a great mayor of New York City I personally believe that anybody that supports abortion on demand is so morally flawed that they should not hold any position of leadership whether that he has the president of the United States or the local dog catcher.

It is only with great regret that I vote for someone like McCain who supports abortions in cases of rape and incest but do so knowing that his opponents views were far more egregious.
I am with ya.
 
As the health care vote showed were are few , if any pro-life democrats in the house.
Prior to the 2010 election, there were 37. Now there are alot fewer, so yes, that’s true.

Let me ask…

Which do you think would be harder for Nancy Pelosi to deal with: a pro life Democratic Caucus with 50 members, or a pro life Democratic caucus with 12? Isn’t the whole idea to make it harder for the Democratic Party establishment to maintain its pro abortion stance? Now, the best way to do that is to help pro lifers run as Democrats against Democratic pro abortion incumbents. Right now, they won’t get funding from the Democratic establishment, but they could be helped by a more independent pro life movement.

As it stands now, we have the sorry spectacle of pro lifers of one party working to defeat those in the other all in the name of a partisan agenda.

A lot of Democrats have serious reservations about abortion on demand. They need encouragement, not derision or condemnation.
40.png
estesbob:
The alleged pro-life democrats were replaced by authentic pro-life republicans-a win win situation for pro-life .
Is it? Is it really a benefit to pro life to be more closely associated with some of the more morally problematic policies of the Republican party? How is it a win-win for pro life if pro life is associated, thanks to its close connection to the GOP, with economic and foreign policies that repel thousands of people?

The object should be a strong pro life movement that is independent of any political establishment, whose votes would be up for grabs, not in the pocket of one of the parties.
40.png
estesbob:
Pro-life Democrats suffer from battered wife syndrome.
With “friends” like they have in the other party, no wonder.
 
The criticism of Giuliani occurred when he was campaigning and culminated at the ballot box where he was smacked down for his hypocrisy.

He dropped off the radar.
You you must have missed all the cheering he got when he was stumping for John McCain…who, incidentally, id not 100% pro-life.
 
You you must have missed all the cheering he got when he was stumping for John McCain…who, incidentally, id not 100% pro-life.
McCain supports abortion in the case of rape or incest. Palin does not.
(Guiliani did not make it very far… I think, because of his abortion views.)

As opposed to Obama who would leave a baby in a trash can if he or she happened to live through a botched abortion.
 
McCain supports abortion in the case of rape or incest. Palin does not.
(Guiliani did not make it very far… I think, because of his abortion views.)

As opposed to Obama who would leave a baby in a trash can if he or she happened to live through a botched abortion.
This is not about Obama. It is about the those who employ a double-standard on life issues based on political party.
 
This is not about Obama. It is about the those who employ a double-standard on life issues based on political party.
Agreed I too am greatly disturbed by Catholic Democrats who always put their Party ahead if their faith
 
This is not about Obama. It is about the those who employ a double-standard on life issues based on political party.
Then you would have to include Mr. Obama --------- “No federal Funding for abortions” …One of the first things he did was Federally Fund International Abortions i.e The Mexico Treaty - UN funding
 
Prior to the 2010 election, there were 37. Now there are alot fewer, so yes, that’s true.

Let me ask…

Which do you think would be harder for Nancy Pelosi to deal with: a pro life Democratic Caucus with 50 members, or a pro life Democratic caucus with 12? Isn’t the whole idea to make it harder for the Democratic Party establishment to maintain its pro abortion stance? Now, the best way to do that is to help pro lifers run as Democrats against Democratic pro abortion incumbents. Right now, they won’t get funding from the Democratic establishment, but they could be helped by a more independent pro life movement.
I think it would be hard for Nancy Pelosi to deal with a committed pro-life element in her own party and I would love to see that. Pro-life Democrats need to be encouraged, but when they get wobbly and cave in, they need to be called on it, not given a free ride because “we need to encourage them.”
As it stands now, we have the sorry spectacle of pro lifers of one party working to defeat those in the other all in the name of a partisan agenda.

A lot of Democrats have serious reservations about abortion on demand. They need encouragement, not derision or condemnation.
I agree, they need encouragement. But they need to stand for their beliefs if they are truly genuine. If they cave, then we need to call them on it.
Is it? Is it really a benefit to pro life to be more closely associated with some of the more morally problematic policies of the Republican party? How is it a win-win for pro life if pro life is associated, thanks to its close connection to the GOP, with economic and foreign policies that repel thousands of people?

The object should be a strong pro life movement that is independent of any political establishment, whose votes would be up for grabs, not in the pocket of one of the parties.
I agree. It would be great to have a pro-life movement that transcended party lines. But I think perhaps you underestimate the hold the abortion lobby has on the Democrat party. Emily’s list and other groups are working to ensure that only abortion rights Democrats get elected.

Ishii
 
I think this last time all but five Dems voted to fund Planned Parenthood.

As a party, they are the party of abortion.
But there were five who voted to defund Planned Parenthood. This says that It is possible for a Democrat to be Pro-Live. Granted, they will be rare, especially after this last election (most of the Democrats who lost were more moderate Democrats, leaving the Loony left entrenched in Washington.) You cannot go by voting records of only those currently sitting, but also those of all Dems and Reps who have been in office since 1973. Otherwise your data is skewed.
 
Then you would have to include Mr. Obama --------- “No federal Funding for abortions” …One of the first things he did was Federally Fund International Abortions i.e The Mexico Treaty - UN funding
Don’t forget the thread’s namesake - Bart Stupak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top