Bart Stupak Cashes In

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1holycatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There are no “D”'s that voted to defund Planned Parenthood. How is this possible if some profess to be pro-life?
Well.l.l. you see it’s a misunderstanding…😃

The General Public isn’t capable of understanding such complex issues…😛

But we at least got some transparency:thumbsup:
 
There are no “D”'s that voted to defund Planned Parenthood. How is this possible if some profess to be pro-life?
We have already been over this. Those that held onto theor seats were not the moderates, but the extremists.
 
You you must have missed all the cheering he got when he was stumping for John McCain…who, incidentally, id not 100% pro-life.
Not every Republican is 100% pro-life, even though the RNC position is, but that imperfect position of a candidate trumps the Democrat’s 100% pro-death position every time.

Let’s compare party planks on abortion:

The Republican plank:
Faithful to the first guarantee of the Declaration of Independence, we assert the inherent dignity and sanctity of all human life and affirm that the unborn child has a fundamental individual right to life which cannot be infringed. We support a human life amendment to the Constitution, and we endorse legislation to make clear that the Fourteenth Amendment’s protections apply to unborn children. We oppose using public revenues to promote or perform abortion and will not fund organizations which advocate it. We support the appointment of judges who respect traditional family values and the sanctity and dignity of innocent human life.
…
The Democratic plank:
The Democratic Party strongly and unequivocally supports Roe v Wade and a woman’s right to choose a safe and legal abortion, regardless of ability to pay, and we oppose any and all efforts to weaken or undermine that right. The Democratic Party also strongly supports access to affordable family planning services and comprehensive age-appropriate sex education which empower people to make informed choices and live healthy lives.
…
One party’s plank is completely incompatible with Catholicism, one is not.
 
1holycatholicOne party’s plank is completely incompatible with Catholicism, one is not.
So are you saying that merely being a Democrat, even one who is consistently pro-life, is still immoral, because of a plank (and a plank which he ignores at that)? Haven’t you noticed that almost no one in this country, even most politicians, is wholly in line with their party’s planks?
40.png
StTommyMore:
We have already been over this. Those that held onto theor seats were not the moderates, but the extremists.
And I think the far right is quite pleased about that. Watch the pro-life democrats get eradicated, so they say there’s never been such a thing as a pro-life Democrat. Perfectly Orwellian. We’ve always been at war with Eurasia, even though yesterday we had always been allied with Eurasia.
 
Not every Republican is 100% pro-life, even though the RNC position is, but that imperfect position of a candidate trumps the Democrat’s 100% pro-death position every time.

Let’s compare party planks on abortion:

The Republican plank:
Faithful to the first guarantee of the Declaration of Independence, we assert the inherent dignity and sanctity of all human life and affirm that the unborn child has a fundamental individual right to life which cannot be infringed. We support a human life amendment to the Constitution, and we endorse legislation to make clear that the Fourteenth Amendment’s protections apply to unborn children. We oppose using public revenues to promote or perform abortion and will not fund organizations which advocate it. We support the appointment of judges who respect traditional family values and the sanctity and dignity of innocent human life.
…
The Democratic plank:
The Democratic Party strongly and unequivocally supports Roe v Wade and a woman’s right to choose a safe and legal abortion, regardless of ability to pay, and we oppose any and all efforts to weaken or undermine that right. The Democratic Party also strongly supports access to affordable family planning services and comprehensive age-appropriate sex education which empower people to make informed choices and live healthy lives.
…
One party’s plank is completely incompatible with Catholicism, one is not.
make sure you get this: no single political party that is a “Catholic Party”
 
So are you saying that merely being a Democrat, even one who is consistently pro-life, is still immoral, because of a plank (and a plank which he ignores at that)? Haven’t you noticed that almost no one in this country, even most politicians, is wholly in line with their party’s planks?
No other issue is proportionate to abortion, so the other planks of the Democratic party are irrelevant, even the planks that violate Church teaching on subsidiarity etc…
 
make sure you get this: no single political party that is a “Catholic Party”
I didn’t say there was, yet one party’s stated goal is entirely incompatible with the teaching of the Church. In fact, they are a refuge for large numbers of Catholic dissidents. If a prominent Catholic stands in direct public opposition to what the Church teaches, one party will exploit Catholic dissidents against the Church and then reward them for their disobedience.
 
I didn’t say there was, yet one party’s stated goal is entirely incompatible with the teaching of the Church. In fact, they are a refuge for large numbers of Catholic dissidents. If a prominent Catholic stands in direct public opposition to what the Church teaches, one party will exploit Catholic dissidents against the Church and then reward them for their disobedience.
A case can be made that the Republican Party stands in opposition to the teaching of the Church
 
A case can be made that the Republican Party stands in opposition to the teaching of the Church
Not by quoting any church document or teaching one can’t On the other hand it has been demonstrated in this thread alone that the Democrst party stands in direct opposition to core moral teachings of the Vhurch
 
Not by quoting any church document or teaching one can’t On the other hand it has been demonstrated in this thread alone that the Democrst party stands in direct opposition to core moral teachings of the Vhurch
Sure you can. Rerum Novarum runs counter to Republican Party positions, as does the Catechism with regards to the death penalty and just war doctrine.
 
irrelevant. We vote for candidates, not parties.
Sure you can. Rerum Novarum runs counter to Republican Party positions, as does the Catechism with regards to the death penalty and just war doctrine.
The church has always allowed for the death penaly. Both wars were supported by a manority of Democrats and Republicsns,besides the fact that the Pope specifically stAted Catholics could in good conscience support both the wars and the death penalty. There is no policies of the GOP that run contrary to Rerum Movarum or Ny other teaching of the church
 
As someone once said, the Democrats do the damage and the Republicans come in to make sure nobody can fix it. I don’t trust either party as a whole. There may be a few decent candidates here and there, but for the most part it seems that even ones that campaign on moral grounds that are very similar to what the Church teaches they pretty much forget about that entirely once in office.
 
Sure you can. Rerum Novarum runs counter to Republican Party positions, as does the Catechism with regards to the death penalty and just war doctrine.
No, you see, they relegate all that social justice stuff to this little “out” called “prudential judgment.” The Republicans love “prudential judgment” because it allows one to ignore the spirit of a Church teaching while literally complying with the words, to wit, we can congratulate ourselves on our compassion for the poor because “conservatives give more money to charities” while cutting public funding for services that directly benefit the poor.

And of course, throw abortion in the face of everyone who disagrees with a single iota of Republican dogmatic ideology and you’ve got the perfect set up for presenting the Republican Party as… :bowdown2: The One True, Catholic and Apostolic Party. :bowdown2:
 
No other issue is proportionate to abortion, so the other planks of the Democratic party are irrelevant, even the planks that violate Church teaching on subsidiarity etc…
Doesn’t really answer my question. As St,TommyMore said, we vote for candidates, not for parties. If a Democrat is truly pro-life, then what? One still cannot vote for him, because a certain plank of the party to which he belongs goes against Church teaching, even though he rejects that plank? As far as I’m concerned, pro-life is pro-life, whether one’s a D or an R, and if you think abortion it’s so central to the Democratic party platform that a real Democrat can’t be pro-life (in spite of empirical evidence), well then I guess you could say pro-life Democrats just aren’t real Democrats, but then that’s for the other Democrats to decide.

And subsidiarity? So what, now one also has to adhere to right wing positions on devolution and dimembering the federal government to be a real Catholic? Tell me, is it against Church teaching to oppose the abolition of public education too?
 
40.png
LCMS_No_More:
No, you see, they relegate all that social justice stuff to this little “out” called “prudential judgment.” The Republicans love “prudential judgment” because it allows one to ignore the spirit of a Church teaching while literally complying with the words, to wit, we can congratulate ourselves on our compassion for the poor because “conservatives give more money to charities” while cutting public funding for services that directly benefit the poor.
I have a hard time believing anyone who uses the “prudential judgment” argument has ever worked in a homeless shelter before. All those people are poor, starving, and freezing to death without clothes because they forsook “prudential judgment?”
40.png
LCMS_No_More:
And of course, throw abortion in the face of everyone who disagrees with a single iota of Republican dogmatic ideology and you’ve got the perfect set up for presenting the Republican Party as… The One True, Catholic and Apostolic Party.
That seems to be how some people think. Doesn’t matter what the GOP does, as long as they’re not as bad as those baby-killing Democrats. By that logic, we should throw parades for Josef Stalin and celebrate all the massacres and forced famines he ordered, merely because the guy he was fighting against happened to be worse.
 
Code:
Doesn't really answer my question. As St,TommyMore said, we vote for candidates, not for parties. If a Democrat is truly pro-life, then what? One still cannot vote for him, because a certain plank of the party to which he belongs goes against Church teaching, even though he rejects that plank? As far as I'm concerned, pro-life is pro-life, whether one's a D or an R, and if you think abortion it's so central to the Democratic party platform that a real Democrat can't be pro-life (in spite of empirical evidence), well then I guess you could say pro-life Democrats just aren't real Democrats, but then that's for the other Democrats to decide.
The problem with your thinking is that it doesn’t take into account the history of the behavior of these so-called “pro-life Democrats”. When push comes to shove, they often cave in to the pro-abort leadership like Nancy Pelosi, Obama, et al. The other point to make is that to vote for a so-called “pro-life” Democrat congressman or senator, is to empower the pro-abortion rights leadership of the Democrat party. Let me give you an example: If you vote for a so-called “pro-life” Democrat senator and that gives the Democrats the majority, then the net effect is to strengthen the political hand of the pro-abortion rights lobby. That is the political reality that I think you are failing to understand when you sing the virtues of voting for these supposed “pro-life” Democrats. A vote for the “pro-life” Democrat may make some very happy and self-safisfied at not having voted for the evil Republicans, but all they’ve done is strengthen Nancy Pelosi and Barbara Boxer. Do you want the pro-infanticide rights senator Boxer to be in the minority or majority?
And subsidiarity? So what, now one also has to adhere to right wing positions on devolution and dimembering the federal government to be a real Catholic? Tell me, is it against Church teaching to oppose the abolition of public education too?
Your characterization of the Catholic priniciple of subsidiarity as “right-wing” merely shows how ignorant you are of the subject. I would recommend reading Pope John Paul 2’s encyclical, “Centesimus Annus” for an example of the principle of subsidiarity as it relates to the modern welfare state. Here is a link with some commentary:

acton.org/pub/religion-liberty/volume-6-number-4/principle-subsidiarity

This, of course, assumes you want to go beyond the superficial name calling and actually have a serious discussion.

Ishii
 
I have a hard time believing anyone who uses the “prudential judgment” argument has ever worked in a homeless shelter before. All those people are poor, starving, and freezing to death without clothes because they forsook “prudential judgment?”

That seems to be how some people think. Doesn’t matter what the GOP does, as long as they’re not as bad as those baby-killing Democrats. By that logic, we should throw parades for Josef Stalin and celebrate all the massacres and forced famines he ordered, merely because the guy he was fighting against happened to be worse.
No, I vote for Republicans because, by and large they don’t think a woman should have the right to go to a clinic and snuff out her unborn child. The Democrats overwhelmingly want to preserve the right of a woman to kill her unborn child. Its really not that complicated. It starts getting complicated when Democrat catholics who hate Republicans more than they hate abortion try to justify their support for the Party of Abortion (the Democrat party). The justification usually goes something like: " *the Democrats may support baby killing, but atleast they want to provide free lunches for the poor." *Or " the Democrats may support baby killing but the Republicans want to poison the environment." Here’s another: “the Democrats may support baby killing but atleast they’re for the unions and the workin’ man - good jobs and good wages.”

Its really not that complicated. A vote for the Democrat is a vote to strengthen abortion rights. A vote for the Republican is a vote to help curtail abortion rights. This may change at some point. God willing there may be serious pro-life Democrats in the future who will actually stand up for the unborn and say: “Sorry Nancy Pelosi and Barbara Boxer, but I’m not going to vote for this bill because of abortion funding. Sorry Obama and Barbara Mikulski and Patty Murray. I am not voting to confirm this person for supreme court justice because they think the constitution guarentees a right to abortion.” If a Democrat really stood up for the unborn in that way I would consider donating to their campaign. And if you want to call me a single issue voter, I would ask you, what’s the use of “free healthcare” if you have been killed in the womb? What good is a free-lunch at school if you’ve already been aborted? What good is free child care if you were killed in the womb? None of the pet issues of the Democrats rise to the level of abortion. We all have a moral obligation to oppose it and work to end legal abortion.

Ishii
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top