Bart Stupak Cashes In

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1holycatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The fact that the Church has not elucidated a conclusive position on a particular issue does not mean that all positions on that issue are equally valid or equally in keeping with a Christian worldview. The fact that the Church has not specifically condemned, say, the general advocacy of a position by the Republicans does not mean that one could not cite particular examples of Republican policies that are, in fact, against Church teaching. Just because not all issues are as “simple” as abortion does not mean that all opinions are equally valid and equally in keeping with Catholic teaching.
The Church has definitively defined abortion as an intrinsic evil and that no other political issue is proportionate to abortion. By that standard alone the Democratic party has disqualified themselves from consideration.
 
Do not put words in my mouth. It is uncharitable. I am 100% pro-life. All I have been saying is that “Republican” is not equivalent to “Catholic”
No one sAid they were. Nor BTW the is Republican equivalent to Satan The problem is given the Democat parthia total allegiance to the Culture if deaths Catholics options are limited. Not a problem for me as I support most of the policies of the GOP.
 
1holycatholicThe Church has definitively defined abortion as an intrinsic evil and that no other political issue is proportionate to abortion. By that standard alone the Democratic party has disqualified themselves from consideration.

Of the first sentence I am well aware, and the second is not true. Candidates are disqualified from consideration from their positions but members of parties are not compelled to obey the platforms of their parties. Parties don’t vote in congress and don’t enact policy, individuals do and those individuals should account for their own actions, not for those of others. If Church teaching compels a Catholic politician to disobey his party, so be it, regardless of whether party requires the same obedience from its member (in this case it generally does not).

You’re argument is fundamentally flawed: “Democrats support abortion; x is a Democrat; ergo x supports abortions.” but the first premise is false, as it is not necessarily true. You can cite the “platform” all you want, a mere scrap of paper. Actions speak louder, and if a Democrat’s votes and policies are truly pro-life he’s as pro-life as a pro-life Republican, and a consistenly pro-choice Republican is just as bad as a consistently pro-choice Democrat, regardless of their parties’ platforms.
 
You’re argument is fundamentally flawed: “Democrats support abortion; x is a Democrat; ergo x supports abortions.” but the first premise is false, as it is not necessarily true. You can cite the “platform” all you want, a mere scrap of paper. Actions speak louder, and if a Democrat’s votes and policies are truly pro-life he’s as pro-life as a pro-life Republican, and a consistenly pro-choice Republican is just as bad as a consistently pro-choice Democrat, regardless of their parties’ platforms.
Actions do speak louder. The actions of “pro-life” Democrats reveals the hypocrisy of their position. Exhibit “A” is Bart Stupak.

Your logic could have justified a vote for Tariq Aziz and the Ba’ath Party.
 
I am not promoting any such thing. I am trying to explain that the Republican Party is not the “Catholic Party”
The Republican party is irrelevant. You can’t justify the evil of the Democratic positions by pointing out the positions of another.

The Democratic party positions are explicitly contrary to the teaching of the Church.
 
No one sAid they were. Nor BTW the is Republican equivalent to Satan The problem is given the Democat parthia total allegiance to the Culture if deaths Catholics options are limited. Not a problem for me as I support most of the policies of the GOP.
Lucky you. To hell with the rest of us I guess.
 
The Republican party is irrelevant. You can’t justify the evil of the Democratic positions by pointing out the positions of another.

The Democratic party positions are explicitly contrary to the teaching of the Church.
Just give it up. Your politics are not Catholic dogma.
 
Just give it up. Your politics are not Catholic dogma.
The issue is the Democratic party whose positions are explicitly contrary to the teaching of the Church. The same Democratic party that exploits dissident Catholics to further their anti-Catholic agenda.

DNC’S NEW WEBSITE DEVOID OF ANTI-CATHOLIC LINK
On April 8, the Democratic National Committee (DNC) unveiled its new website. Gone from the site is the links page which directed users to various allied organizations. Among them was an anti-Catholic group, Catholics for a Free Choice.
…
That group is a ticket to excommunication.
 
The issue is the Democratic party whose positions are explicitly contrary to the teaching of the Church. The same Democratic party that exploits dissident Catholics to further their anti-Catholic agenda.

DNC’S NEW WEBSITE DEVOID OF ANTI-CATHOLIC LINK
On April 8, the Democratic National Committee (DNC) unveiled its new website. Gone from the site is the links page which directed users to various allied organizations. Among them was an anti-Catholic group, Catholics for a Free Choice.
…
That group is a ticket to excommunication.
You are just simply wrong. Membership in a political party cannot get you excommunicated. In the case of a pro-life democrat, i would have no problems voting for him. Apparently you would because you believe your handle applies to the Republicans.
 
You are just simply wrong. Membership in a political party cannot get you excommunicated. In the case of a pro-life democrat, i would have no problems voting for him. Apparently you would because you believe your handle applies to the Republicans.
I didn’t say being a Democrat was a ticket to excommunication, the group Catholics for a Free Choice which the Democrats promote is. You would have known that if you had read the linked article titled “Vatican affirms excommunication…”. :rolleyes:
 
I didn’t say being a Democrat was a ticket to excommunication, the group Catholics for a Free Choice which the Democrats promote is. You would have known that if you had read the linked article titled “Vatican affirms excommunication…”. :rolleyes:
I have basically been ignoring you, except to refute your silliness regarding the alleged holiness of the Republican Party and the intrinsic evil of all things Democrat. I just want you to see that no political party can be identified with the Church.
 
I have basically been ignoring you, except to refute your silliness regarding the alleged holiness of the Republican Party and the intrinsic evil of all things Democrat. I just want you to see that no political party can be identified with the Church.
I have not said that any one party is identified with the Church, only that some hold positions on abortion that are absolutely incompatible with the teaching of the Church and, as the Church teaches, that no other issue is proportionate to abortion. I’m saying exactly the same thing as Pope Benedict XVI.

I haven’t said that every Democratic party position is intrinsically evil, but their support of abortion undeniably is. That issue alone disqualifies them from consideration, at least for Catholics.

Other parties don’t support the intrinsic evil of abortion.
 
*At this point, the Democratic Party risks transforming itself definitively into a “party of death” due to its choices on bioethical issues, as Ramesh Ponnuru wrote in his book “The Party of Death: The Democrats, the Media, the Courts and the Disregard for Human Life.”

And I say this with a heavy heart, because we all know that the Democrats were the party that helped our Catholic immigrant parents and grandparents to better integrate into and prosper in American society. But it’s not the same anymore.

Nonetheless, there are among Democrats some pro-lifers, but they are, unfortunately, rare.
*

*Cardinal Burke
*
 
I have not said that any one party is identified with the Church, only that some hold positions on abortion that are absolutely incompatible with the teaching of the Church and, as the Church teaches, that no other issue is proportionate to abortion. I’m saying exactly the same thing as Pope Benedict XVI.

I haven’t said that every Democratic party position is intrinsically evil, but their support of abortion undeniably is. That issue alone disqualifies them from consideration, at least for Catholics.

Other parties don’t support the intrinsic evil of abortion.
No one is disqualified from consideration by party membership, but only by positions on issues. Unless you can see the difference between the two, this conversation must end.
 
I have read a great deal of history, thank you very much.
Wonderful. You may read a great deal of history, but you are wrong to imply that Roe v Wade was the only reason Catholics left the Democrat party and that Catholics didn’t leave the Democrat party until after Roe V Wade. There were many more reasons as I outlined in my response. Perhaps you are reading the wrong history books?

Ishii
 
No one is disqualified from consideration by party membership, but only by positions on issues. Unless you can see the difference between the two, this conversation must end.
I have noticed that this thread has devolved into a silly shouting match. On the one hand there are those who say, rightly, that the Democrat party is overwhelmingly pro-abortion rights and that the few pro-life Democrats like Bart Stupak cave into the party leadership when push comes to shove - i.e. party loyalty is more important that standing up for principle of the sanctity of life. They are using facts and logic to back up their points. The response of a few posters has been to engage in the ad hominem, emotional outbursts, and false accusations:

“You think the GOP is the perfect Catholic party” (which no one has suggested).

“you think that all Democrats are pro-abortion rights” (which no one has suggested).

“the GOP wants to deregulate everything so its just as anti-Catholic as pro-abortion rights Democrats.” (which is totally false).

“The principle of subsidiarity is right-wing” (no it isn’t, its Catholic social thought).

And when their points are refuted systematically and logically they say “I’m done with this thread.”

And if one wants to know why Roe V wade remains the law of the land, and why pro-abortion rights candidates keep getting elected with Catholic votes, let this thread be exhibit A as to why.

Ishii
 
I have noticed that this thread has devolved into a silly shouting match. On the one hand there are those who say, rightly, that the Democrat party is overwhelmingly pro-abortion rights and that the few pro-life Democrats like Bart Stupak cave into the party leadership when push comes to shove - i.e. party loyalty is more important that standing up for principle of the sanctity of life. They are using facts and logic to back up their points. The response of a few posters has been to engage in the ad hominem, emotional outbursts, and false accusations:

“You think the GOP is the perfect Catholic party” (which no one has suggested).

“you think that all Democrats are pro-abortion rights” (which no one has suggested).

“the GOP wants to deregulate everything so its just as anti-Catholic as pro-abortion rights Democrats.” (which is totally false).

“The principle of subsidiarity is right-wing” (no it isn’t, its Catholic social thought).

And when their points are refuted systematically and logically they say “I’m done with this thread.”

And if one wants to know why Roe V wade remains the law of the land, and why pro-abortion rights candidates keep getting elected with Catholic votes, let this thread be exhibit A as to why.

Ishii
The ad hominems are coming from the other side. Learn to read completely, and not just what seems to support your own side.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top