"Bible Christian" Who does this better fit: Protestants or Catholics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter donnyblake
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But no one knows the Bible like a Southern Baptist. Most Southern Baptist grade school kids can run circles around your average liturgical Christian adult. The Baptist kid could quote more scripture and doctrine in context and knows the books of the bible in order.

If you told most Roman Catholic adults (or Anglicans) to look in
II Hezekiah verses 23:4…they would depsaretly search for it.

Rev North
Reverend that not fair…you should tell us where it is:p

I have to confess, when a Protestant I always loved the line of the Mass “Lord I am not worthy to receive Thee, but only say the word and I shall be healed.” It wasn’t until I became Orthodox and put 2 and 2 together that I realized where it was from (Matthew 8:8). Funny when you think of Liturgy and Scripture like oil and water, how you miss the obvious.
 
lol…well that’s the 64 Million dollar question now isn’t it…do you want to use a lifeline?😛

Iesus Christus Creavit Unam, Sanctam, Catholicam, et Apostolicam Ecclesiam…quam alter Dei non possuit, sed quam alter en nomine Domini habet aliquis vitam…:bible1: :knight2: :tsktsk:
 
The HS is no Prime Minister … He is God, Himself… and will be with the church that Christ founded until the end of time.
Btw Martin what’s your scripture argument for the Trinity? Christ’s divinity? Does it convert the JWs, I mean they only read the Bible, but they have different results than you.

Well, maybe not that different.😛
 
and yet…with respect that is a consolation prize or excuse used by us liturgical types for the downright ignorance of the Word of God. We (Roman Catholics, Anglicans, Orthodox) need to get off of our collective butts and begin bible studies in parishes for adults (teach doctrine as well). Many…many…Roman Catholic adults (and Anglicans) are simply spiritually lazy. Go to church for an hour and go home (if they get there on time and stay for all of Mass). Most Baptists attend church at least once a week for an hour and a half and Bible Study (for all ages) on Sunday for another hour AND during the week more Men’s Bible Studies and so on (kids programs like AWANA).

Give them credit where credit is do.

Rev North
Yes.

However, if you look at a Divine Liturgy book that has the verses of Scripture from which the lines of the DL are cited come from, you would be amazed at how much scripture you already (or should) know!
 
Protestants are better trained than Catholics as children. You never hear of Catholics having Sunday school, do you?
No, we didn’t have “Sunday School”, instead we either went to Catechism on Saturday mornings every week, or we went to Parochial Schools where we got our religious education on a daily basis.
Not saying that Catholics aren’t exposed to scripture, just that Protestants are more immersed in it at an earlier age.
Not necessarily. My “exposure” began at the age of 5. Depends on how you look at it. Don’t take what I am about to say personally…but the fact is, many of the erstwhile protestant “christians” that I have known…can parrot/recite snippets of scriptures all day long…but have little or no real understanding of what those scriptures mean.
Still though, unless you have faith in God and believe what He taught throughout the ages, no amount of bible study can make you a “Bible Christian”. 🙂
Very true…😃
 
But no one knows the Bible like a Southern Baptist. Most Southern Baptist grade school kids can run circles around your average liturgical Christian adult. The Baptist kid could quote more scripture and doctrine in context and knows the books of the bible in order.
Yes, while they can quote and quote… I have found that most of them haven’t really got a clue as to what the scriptures mean in reality. Or they simply spout out what they were told they mean.

I have found that their greatest accomplishment is “taking snippets of scripture out of context” and trying to using it wrongfully to try and force a bogus agenda. Unimpressive at best.

Almost 40 years ago I memorized the calibration and alignment steps (more than 130 steps) for two different combat radar systems…and could perform them and recite them. But it didn’t make me know what made a radar work, nor did it make me a radar expert.
If you told most Roman Catholic adults (or Anglicans) to look in
II Hezekiah verses 23:4…they would depsaretly search for it.
Rev North
I would have laughed and asked them what weird book they were reading…but whether or not someone has “memorized” the bible and can quote it backwards and forwards…isn’t really whats important…its the faith, belief, and the actions (yep…works) that prove the faith and belief…
 
Yes, while they can quote and quote… I have found that most of them haven’t really got a clue as to what the scriptures mean in reality. Or they simply spout out what they were told they mean.

I have found that their greatest accomplishment is “taking snippets of scripture out of context” and trying to using it wrongfully to try and force a bogus agenda. Unimpressive at best.

Not in my expereince. In AWANA the kids not only learn scripture but in fact it is most definately **not **out of context. It is very structured so that they learn to support Baptist (Protestant) doctrines which from their point are biblical.

Don’t feel bad. I think your lack of knowledge about what is going on is typical but it is something Roman Catholics should come to terms with. Baptist know what they believe and why from the Bible. When they meet joe average Catholic who has no clue how many books are in the bible or even how to sytematically support RCC doctrine they end up converting joe Catholic. You need to make RCC children and adults as strong in their knowledge based. Denial will not help you do it only delude you into a false sense of security and superiority.

Rev North
 
isn’t it known that when Ignatius was referring the Christian Church as a Catholic Church, they saw that he was writing the letter as if referring to the Christian Church as Catholic was common?. I read this somewhere i forgot it was awhile ago.
 
Not in my expereince. In AWANA the kids not only learn scripture but in fact it is most definately **not **out of context. It is very structured so that they learn to support Baptist (Protestant) doctrines which from their point are biblical.

Don’t feel bad. I think your lack of knowledge about what is going on is typical but it is something Roman Catholics should come to terms with. Baptist know what they believe and why from the Bible. When they meet joe average Catholic who has no clue how many books are in the bible or even how to sytematically support RCC doctrine they end up converting joe Catholic. You need to make RCC children and adults as strong in their knowledge based. Denial will not help you do it only delude you into a false sense of security and superiority.

Rev North
it’s different in my experience, I have met many ex Baptists who felt that the Baptists are only motivated to readthe bible just so they can prove a non Baptist wrong just so they can feel high and mighty., knowledge of the Doctrines of the Catholic Church is avalible to those who want it.
 
Not in my expereince. In AWANA the kids not only learn scripture but in fact it is most definately **not **out of context. It is very structured so that they learn to support Baptist (Protestant) doctrines which from their point are biblical.

Don’t feel bad. I think your lack of knowledge about what is going on is typical but it is something Roman Catholics should come to terms with. Baptist know what they believe and why from the Bible. When they meet joe average Catholic who has no clue how many books are in the bible or even how to sytematically support RCC doctrine they end up converting joe Catholic. You need to make RCC children and adults as strong in their knowledge based. Denial will not help you do it only delude you into a false sense of security and superiority.

Rev North
This is odd to say the least: no Catholic feels the need to defend his faith raised a cradle Catholic: the truth has been revealed to him, a life of sacraments, of love of God, in the Mass and in the everyday, of faith and good works.

Our creed does not mention the Bible because it does not need to. It’s Protestants who fall into the false worship of the Bible: read Reverend Peter Gomes on that.

Systematically? You are playing with words disingenuously. Once you speak of average anybody nobody can deal systematically with anything. But perhaps you are just writing out of another Protestant conceit: the Bible is open to all and every man is his own interpreter. What rubbish.

Very few people know both Hebrew and Greek, so most Catholics trust, and must trust, to the RCC’s learning, which, after all, produced the Bible in the first place.

Nothing an average Protestant could ever say to me could matter: wrong Bible, in translation.

I pray for the conversions of all Protestants to the RCC, and Muslims and atheists, too, whose moral as opposed to Biblical superiority is far less offensive.
 
But you deny that the Lord had a Body, it’s just a metaphor.
You really don’t get the born again indwelling do you?

Where in the world did I ever say such a thing?
Each and every born-again Christian is a temple for our living God, how is that not a body??
 
oh, YOU’re that angel of light I’ve been warned about.
One of you refers to me as demoniac and now you inferring satan, you guys are the definition of charity and understanding in regards to our Lords body of believers.🤷
 
Does it convert the JWs, I mean they only read the Bible, but they have different results than you.

Well, maybe not that different.😛
Read the JW version of John 1:1
for example! They changed translations there along with 3 or 4 other areas to twist it into there theology.
 
Don’t take what I am about to say personally…but the fact is, many of the erstwhile protestant “christians” that I have known…can parrot/recite snippets of scriptures all day long…but have little or no real understanding of what those scriptures mean.
For some, yes, and others, no. It really is a mixed bag.
And no, I didn’t take it personally. 😉
 
One of you refers to me as demoniac and now you inferring satan, you guys are the definition of charity and understanding in regards to our Lords body of believers.🤷
If St. Paul had no compunction about rebuking St. Peter on the dogma of the Faith…

…if you’re worried about it, stop preaching another Gospel from the one we handed down from the Lord.

What body of believers, pray tell, is that?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top