Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zachary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Nye should read this:

What The World Would Be Like If Engineering Didn’t Exist

“If you can think of any machine, device, or process that makes life simpler and more convenient for humanity, you are talking about engineering at work. Without it, civilization would barely exist as we know it today. To remove engineering would be to regress humanity back to the most basic innovation; the invention of the wheel. Without engineering, none of the Seven Wonders of the World would ever have existed and even the most basic of tools would not exist. The first forged weapon, the first spear, anything more complex than a thrown rock — all the work of the first engineers, before there was even a name for it.”
 
This is what I don’t understand; the complete denial of history. A lot of people DID believe that the Earth was flat even up through the Middle Ages and many of the people who kept that fable alive that long were Christians. And that horizon? People thought it was just the edge of the Earth where their God(s) had placed a dome from which the stars hang like christmas ornaments. BTW - the OT doesn’t say anything about an ellipsoidal Earth. It describes it as a circle, which is only two-dimensional ie flat.
It is a myth that people in the middle ages thought that the world was flat:
The myth of the Flat Earth is the modern misconception that the prevailing cosmological view during the Middle Ages saw the Earth as flat, instead of spherical.[1]
During the early Middle Ages, virtually all scholars maintained the spherical viewpoint first expressed by the Ancient Greeks. From at least the 14th century, belief in a flat Earth among the educated was almost nonexistent, despite fanciful depictions in art, such as the exterior of Hieronymus Bosch’s famous triptych The Garden of Earthly Delights, in which a disc-shaped Earth is shown floating inside a transparent sphere.[2]
According to Stephen Jay Gould, “there never was a period of ‘flat earth darkness’ among scholars (regardless of how the public at large may have conceptualized our planet both then and now). Greek knowledge of sphericity never faded, and all major medieval scholars accepted the Earth’s roundness as an established fact of cosmology.”[3] Historians of science David Lindberg and Ronald Numbers point out that “there was scarcely a Christian scholar of the Middle Ages who did not acknowledge [Earth’s] sphericity and even know its approximate circumference”.[4]
Historian Jeffrey Burton Russell says the flat-earth error flourished most between 1870 and 1920, and had to do with the ideological setting created by struggles over evolution.[5] Russell claims “with extraordinary [sic] few exceptions no educated person in the history of Western Civilization from the third century B.C. onward believed that the earth was flat”, and credits histories by John William Draper, Andrew Dickson White, and Washington Irving for popularizing the flat-earth myth.[6]
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_Flat_Earth
 
Only in the biological sense are homo sapiens 200,000 years old. The species did not achieve full behavioral modernity until around 50,000 years ago.
And you know that how? You need more than an assertion.
As I said, homo sapiens reached full behavioral modernity only 50,000 years ago (roughly). So no, no “human history” or civilization for 150,000 years.
Beyond that point, we do have evidence of culture, like the 25,000-year-old Venus of Willendorf. But yes, writing came later.
That is a guess with about as much credibility as voodoo. Also based on old Earth assumptions. It is a carved female figure out of limestone. Naturally the rock predates to carving. Not exactly hard science.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_of_Willendorf

After a wide variety of proposed dates, following a revised analysis of the stratigraphy of its site in 1990, the figure was estimated to have been carved 24,000–22,000 BCE,[4] but more recent estimates have pushed the date back slightly to between about 28,000 and 25,000 BCE.​

It’s not like they can take that carving without any background info and come up with a date from the actual material, let alone when it was carved into a statute. They determine the date based on location. In other words it is all background information.
 
Obviously, but no one figured it out by reading the Bible. The Bible describes a flat Earth which is why biblical literalists continued to flog that dead horse for well over a thousand years after the Greeks had proven otherwise.
The newspaper describes the sun as rising and setting.
 
Why did this thread devolve (pun intended) into a useless discussion about flat Earth models?

Sorry, EmperorNapoleon, but a spherical Earth was a part of the prevailing cosmological model throughout the entire Middle Ages.

Did some people believe in a flat Earth? Sure. Some people today believe in a flat Earth.

But the belief was not a part of the scientifically accepted, conventional model.

I get what you’re trying to do here, as I agree wholeheartedly that making one’s position on a question about the natural world contingent upon Biblical literalism is asinine.

But the whole flat Earth thing is just a bad example. Let’s stick with the principle at hand and not rewrite history here.
 
Why did this thread devolve (pun intended) into a useless discussion about flat Earth models?

Sorry, EmperorNapoleon, but a spherical Earth was a part of the prevailing cosmological model throughout the entire Middle Ages.

Did some people believe in a flat Earth? Sure. Some people today believe in a flat Earth.

But the belief was not a part of the scientifically accepted, conventional model.

I get what you’re trying to do here, as I agree wholeheartedly that making one’s position on a question about the natural world contingent upon Biblical literalism is asinine.

But the whole flat Earth thing is just a bad example. Let’s stick with the principle at hand and not rewrite history here.
You are the biblical literalist, not anybody else. You seem to believe the Bible teaches the Earth is flat. You find common ground with literalists, whoever they are, because both interpret Scripture in the same manner and come to the same conclusions.
 
I’m trying to speed read through this thread. I keep hearing people say (not just here, elsewhere), that Biblical literalism forces a young belief and pits religion against science. There is a Protestant talk show host by me that talks incessantly about a literal 6 day creation, about how it is NOT POSSIBLE to take Genesis as anything but literal and he has even published something called “Top Ten Proofs that Evolution is False.” He is constantly going through his “evidence” of how false the old earth claims are and how true but censored the young earth claims are.

I don’t have time to weed through the science. His attitude annoys me. I’m just wondering - is this YECS stuff believeable? The Fundamentalist YECSers that call his show and post on his facebook page seem awfully sure of their science.

Most of what I read just says that they are ignoring science but doesn’t address the actual scientific claims they make. Is there any weight to their claims?:confused:
 
I’m trying to speed read through this thread. I keep hearing people say (not just here, elsewhere), that Biblical literalism forces a young belief and pits religion against science. There is a Protestant talk show host by me that talks incessantly about a literal 6 day creation, about how it is NOT POSSIBLE to take Genesis as anything but literal and he has even published something called “Top Ten Proofs that Evolution is False.” He is constantly going through his “evidence” of how false the old earth claims are and how true but censored the young earth claims are.

I don’t have time to weed through the science. His attitude annoys me. I’m just wondering - is this YECS stuff believeable? The Fundamentalist YECSers that call his show and post on his facebook page seem awfully sure of their science.

Most of what I read just says that they are ignoring science but doesn’t address the actual scientific claims they make. Is there any weight to their claims?:confused:
Perhaps when they are able to actually make a scientific claim it will be reviewed and addressed. That’s the trouble: the don’t make any credible scientific claims, rather they tend to make logical sounding arguments based on inductive reasoning (which is not fool-proof, like deductive reasoning), but with some errors or misconceptions or outright invented claims mixed in that lead the argument even further astray. When they successfully do some actual science, perhaps it will pass peer review by a respectable journal.
 
Perhaps when they are able to actually make a scientific claim it will be reviewed and addressed. That’s the trouble: the don’t make any credible scientific claims, rather they tend to make logical sounding arguments based on inductive reasoning (which is not fool-proof, like deductive reasoning), but with some errors or misconceptions or outright invented claims mixed in that lead the argument even further astray. When they successfully do some actual science, perhaps it will pass peer review by a respectable journal.
And when someone makes a claim about something or other about the past what reasoning do they use?
 
And when someone makes a claim about something or other about the past what reasoning do they use?
How often do you suppose that things like the constant speed of light, the behavior of physical chemistry, and physical mathematics change?
 
How often do you suppose that things like the constant speed of light, the behavior of physical chemistry, and physical mathematics change?
If they are dependent on a variable such as radioactive decay then all the time. There may be some designed limits though.

Physicists do not even know if the physical laws are the same here as in other parts of the universe.
 
You are the biblical literalist, not anybody else. You seem to believe the Bible teaches the Earth is flat. You find common ground with literalists, whoever they are, because both interpret Scripture in the same manner and come to the same conclusions.
Woah, rein in your rhetorical attack dogs, dude. What’s with the snark and the straw men?

Of course the Bible doesn’t teach that the world is flat. I was, if you’ll notice, defending the position that people in the Middle Ages generally did not believe that the Earth was flat. Rather, they knew it was round.

Deep breaths. They’re good for you.
I’m trying to speed read through this thread. I keep hearing people say (not just here, elsewhere), that Biblical literalism forces a young belief and pits religion against science. There is a Protestant talk show host by me that talks incessantly about a literal 6 day creation, about how it is NOT POSSIBLE to take Genesis as anything but literal and he has even published something called “Top Ten Proofs that Evolution is False.” He is constantly going through his “evidence” of how false the old earth claims are and how true but censored the young earth claims are.

I don’t have time to weed through the science. His attitude annoys me. I’m just wondering - is this YECS stuff believeable? The Fundamentalist YECSers that call his show and post on his facebook page seem awfully sure of their science.

Most of what I read just says that they are ignoring science but doesn’t address the actual scientific claims they make. Is there any weight to their claims?:confused:
Watching the debate that sparked this thread would probably be a great place to start. 🙂
 
I always like reading internet atheists go against what professional historians are saying and then at the same time imply that religion is fundamentally the kind of anti-science fundamentalism that this dim-wit Ham espouses and not a post-enlightenment aberration completely foreign to the classical theistic tradition.

It’s funny because I thought I’d come into this thread to read about one fundamentalist who has given up on reason (Ham), but instead I got to read two. It’s not for mere rhetoric that many have called this “new” atheism “the new fundamentalism”.

It’s really pathetic to read presumably grown men argue like children on a playground, using nothing but rhetoric, ad-homs, presumption of correctness, name-calling, bluster and hand-waving. I really can’t wait until Dawkins, Dennett, Krauss, Myers, Harris and all the rest finally get out of the lime light and maybe some more fruitful dialogue will develop in society instead of us having to deal with these hacks and propagandists and their internet disciples.
 
Why did this thread devolve (pun intended) into a useless discussion about flat Earth models? Sorry, EmperorNapoleon, but a spherical Earth was a part of the prevailing cosmological model throughout the entire Middle Ages. Did some people believe in a flat Earth? Sure. Some people today believe in a flat Earth. But the belief was not a part of the scientifically accepted, conventional model. I get what you’re trying to do here, as I agree wholeheartedly that making one’s position on a question about the natural world contingent upon Biblical literalism is asinine. But the whole flat Earth thing is just a bad example. Let’s stick with the principle at hand and not rewrite history here.
Sorry, but the only historical revision going on here is the claim that people in the Middle Ages didn’t believe that the Earth was flat. They did, and there is plentiful evidence of it. Isidore’s two-dimensional Earth-wheel map wasn’t reproduced and circulated for 700 years for posterity. It was reproduced and circulated for 700 years because people actually believed it was an accurate depiction of the Earth. To say that just because the general consensus among the minuscule number of well educated individuals during that time period was that the Earth is round therefore no one believed the Earth is flat is just ludicrous and we know it isn’t true. The scientifically accepted and conventional model today is that the Earth is some 4.5 billion years old, but there are plenty of people who believe its only 6,000 years old and they are trying to force that view into our schools. Some very well educated people in the Middle Ages did believe the Earth was flat and the general population bought into it. The point is, who cares if the general consensus among the handful of educated people believed the Earth to be round in the Middle Ages? That doesn’t matter as long as people like Ham are able to sway large numbers of people to believe that metaphysical nonsense is as equally valid as science. What matters is the amount of damage even one man can do to society by sowing seeds of doubt about empirical reality.
 
Sorry, but the only historical revision going on here is the claim that people in the Middle Ages didn’t believe that the Earth was flat. They did, and there is plentiful evidence of it. Isidore’s two-dimensional Earth-wheel map wasn’t reproduced and circulated for 700 years for posterity. It was reproduced and circulated for 700 years because people actually believed it was an accurate depiction of the Earth. To say that just because the general consensus among the minuscule number of well educated individuals during that time period was that the Earth is round therefore no one believed the Earth is flat is just ludicrous and we know it isn’t true. The scientifically accepted and conventional model today is that the Earth is some 4.5 billion years old, but there are plenty of people who believe its only 6,000 years old and they are trying to force that view into our schools. Some very well educated people in the Middle Ages did believe the Earth was flat and the general population bought into it. The point is, who cares if the general consensus among the handful of educated people believed the Earth to be round in the Middle Ages? That doesn’t matter as long as people like Ham are able to sway large numbers of people to believe that metaphysical nonsense is as equally valid as science. What matters is the amount of damage even one man can do to society by sowing seeds of doubt about empirical reality.
You know I’m with you on evolution, Ham’s influence, etc. It’s embarrassing at best and disastrous at worst that so many Americans allow ideology to prevent them from accepting the findings of solid, reputable science.

Perhaps your comparison is more apt than you know: yes, a shamefully large number of people today do embrace creationism rather than an acceptance of evolution.

Does that justify saying that people in general today don’t believe in evolution? No, of course not. The scholarly consensus is clear. It’s not too much of a generalization to say that, in every way that matters, the twenty-first century world has accepted the theory of evolution, which has been sufficiently proven.

So it is with a spherical Earth in the Middle Ages. Were there some people who believed it was flat? Sure, but that wasn’t the consensus, not even in the early Middle Ages. I’m sure you’re familiar with what has been known for decades as “the Myth of the Flat Earth.”
 
theflatearthsociety.org/cms/

Some people still think the earth is flat.
In fact, some people think the curve of the earth is actually convex and outer space is actually inside the earth, and it’s just a type of illusion that makes it appear otherwise.

From that page:
the Earth is con-caved and we live inside it basically. Outer-Space is Inner space. For all practical purposes the Flat Earth theory is really the Inverted Hollow Earth theory as the only real difference is outer-space is really inner space and each piece of Earth connects to itself. The Glass Sky distorts our perception of reality.
Basically the Universe is a Egg inside of a Square the 4 Corners are Outside the Earth and Outer-Space is actually INSIDE the Earth.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top