Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zachary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“But when you look at CMB map, you also see that the structure that is observed, is in fact, in a
weird way, correlated with the plane of the earth around the sun. Is this Copernicus coming
back to haunt us? That’s crazy. We’re looking out at the whole universe. There’s no way there
should be a correlation of structure with our motion of the earth around the sun — the plane of
the earth around the sun — the ecliptic. That would say we are truly the center of the universe.
The new results are either telling us that all of science is wrong and we’re the center of the
universe, or maybe the data is imply incorrect, or maybe it’s telling us there’s something weird
about the microwave background results and that maybe, maybe there’s something wrong with
our theories on the larger scales. And of course as a theorist I’m certainly hoping it’s the latter,
because I want theory to be wrong, not right, because if it’s wrong there’s still work left for the
rest of us”. - A Universe From Nothing - Lawrence Krauss
 
I think Ken Ham won the debate. He did not unequivocally prove his position, but he gained the most points in the actual debate. The debate (a) gave a lot of publicity to the Creation Museum which I did not even know was something a group had put together (hats off to them), (b) he clearly noted ‘science’ does not involve speculations and interpretations of the past, (c) there are many ways of measuring the age of the earth and so on. Meanwhile, Bill Nye, appealed to (a) Americanism (what does that have to do with the price of tea in China?), (b) American tax payer’s money, (c) the Bible was not originally written in English and so on. Albert Einstein wrote his Annus mirabilis papers in German and Aristotle who established the scientific method wrote in Greek. That’s neither here nor there.

I am open to both understandings.

What I don’t understand is why the creationist have not presented a paper providing a theory for acceleration as the cause for not only of the age of the earth but also for the distance of the expansion of the universe. I can say ‘x’ star is so many light years away based on the speed of light as we know it and with the assumption that it has always been constant; but the velocity of how they got there is a different matter. So, I can say there are now three cars in front of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, that’s one thing, but another is the distance and speed it took each car to get there. Interesting, well let me not hurt one of my neurons and get back to work.
 
As Peirce himself showed , there is a problem with abductive reasoning. 16

Consider the following syllogism:

If it rains, the streets will get wet.
The streets are wet.
Therefore, it rained.

In this syllogism, a past condition (it was raining) is inferred from a present clue (the streets are wet). Nevertheless, this syllogism commits a logical fallacy known as affirming the consequent. Given that the street is wet (and without additional evidence to decide the matter), one can only conclude that perhaps it rained. Why? Because there are other possible ways the street may have gotten wet. A street-cleaning machine, an uncapped fire hydrant, or rain might have caused the street to get wet.
In other words, if you see that the street is wet, you should immediately ignore a well-known natural process as a most probable cause, and start looking for street-cleaning machines. (Even despite the fact that you live in the Middle Ages, and street-cleaning machines have not yet been invented).

Alternatively, if you find out that your underage daughter is pregnant then you should immediately exclude the usual explanation and conclude that supernatural factors must be involved.

Thanks, I finally understood the creationist mindset!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top