Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zachary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The debate question was “Is creation a viable model of origins?”
Well, yes, but that isn’t actually what either one really talked about. Nye had attacked (prior to the debate) the idea that Creationism could be believed and utilized by scientists and also posited that if Creationism was embraced then science in America was doomed. Ken Ham seemed mainly focused on attacking those points, while Nye was busy intimating those very things while attacking “Ken Ham’s Story of Creation.”

In short, to me, it was a very disjointed “debate” that was rather two separate presentations going on side-by-side. I don’t see how either presentation would sway someone on either side or even add to the knowledge pool in any meaningful way.
 
The Ham-Nye Creation Debate: A Huge Missed Opportunity - See more at: evolutionnews.org/2014/02/the_ham-nye_deb081911.html#sthash.CylcRVIp.dpuf

After watching Tuesday night’s Ken Ham-Bill Nye debate, I was reminded of what attracted me in the first place to the approach to investigating origins represented by the theory of intelligent design.

Sure, Ham talked about some science here and there, but almost all of what he said focused on trying to support a young earth viewpoint. Since he’s not a scientist, the great majority of his arguments amounted – over and over again – to “Because the Bible says so.” Nye’s main argument was, “Because the evidence says so,” and he cited a lot of reasonable evidence for an old earth. While Ham did make a few effective points that you don’t have to accept evolution to do good science, the compelling scientific evidence for design in nature got skipped over.

Because the focus was so overwhelmingly on the age of the earth, the point was never made that a mainstream scientific view about the age of the earth is totally compatible with an intelligent design view that totally refutes Nye’s intolerant, materialist beliefs about the history of life. For goodness sake, Bill Nye was the one defending Big Bang cosmology. Viewers would never know that the Big Bang is one of the best arguments for the design of the universe ever offered by science.
 
Help me out here.

So Bill Nye, the TV personality that most kids watch to get some science is an athiest. Not only that but he now debates on it?

I guess I should of known in that he was on public TV but it is so difficult when parents are searching for something to show their children. I wish they would post who they are before they produces shows for everyone’s children to watch but then I guess many would not watch.

How about Mr. Wizard?
Just because he is an atheist, it doesn’t mean his children’s shows are invalidated. You can still show your children his shows, because he doesn’t touch upon his atheism in them; he simply teaches science.
 
Just because he is an atheist, it doesn’t mean his children’s shows are invalidated. You can still show your children his shows, because he doesn’t touch upon his atheism in them. He simply teaches science.
As Ham would ask - observational science or historical science?
 
Just because he is an atheist, it doesn’t mean his children’s shows are invalidated. You can still show your children his shows, because he doesn’t touch upon his atheism in them; he simply teaches science.
Yes but he may still put in his influence, his perspective in the shows and what parent wants to or even has the time to filter them.

Mr. Wizard was all about science but almost too intellectual for this age.

Bull Nye was a bit dramatic alright quite dramatic but at least he was trying to get people interested in science again.

This to me is just bad news.
 
Honestly, it wasn’t much of a “debate” proper, more like two separate presentations. Add that to the fact that it didn’t seem like there was actually one single topic they were supposed to address. Nye doesn’t think that someone can advance science and be inventors, engineers, geneticists, etc… without believing in Naturalism. Well, Ham showed within minutes of the start that isn’t true. Someone’s stance on Creationism doesn’t prevent them from being true scientists, quite the opposite and that is easy to prove by showing all the Creationists down through history and in the present that are indeed truly scientists, engineers, botanists, etc…
That isn’t really what Nye was saying at all. He was pointing out the fact that modern scientific advancement, in medicine for example, depends upon the practitioners understanding of evolutionary science and physics. It is predicated upon those theories being true and it works. The belief that Earth is 6,000 years old and all life was created by a God has never resulted in the production of, for example, lifesaving medicines and medical treatments. He was not saying that a person could not believe in God and be a scientist, but he did point out the fact that it can’t be used to predict anything therefore it is impossible for to practice modern science and/or produce anything of any tangible value through that mindset.
If the debate was supposed to offer a bunch of evidence for either side, then they both failed. I say Ham won just because of Nye saying odd theological statements and then saying, “I’m not a theologian.” Well, you were right; you’re not. 🤷
Nye definitely won the debate and he went easy on Ham. When Ham asserted that continental drift used to be a much faster process than it is today, Nye didn’t challenge him and ask why no one noticed a land mass we call South America go sailing by at a rate of at least 1 mile per year. When Ham asserted that only a small number of “kinds” were present on the arc, for example only 1 “kind” of beetle, and that all of the different species we see today descended from those “kinds”, Nye didn’t challenge him and ask why he believes evolution to be impossible when he just described evolution to support his own argument. When Ham asserted that Christianity is the only religion to have ever existed with a religious text containing an account of the creation of the Earth and the stars, Nye didn’t challenge him and ask why he chooses to ignore dozens of cultures and religions throughout history with exactly that. Perhaps the most telling speech of the debate was a response to a question from the audience directed at both participants. The question was: “What would change your mind?” Ham’s response: “Nothing.” Nye’s response: “Evidence.”

Ham didn’t choose intellectual giants like Dawkins or Hawking because they would have made him look an inch tall. Nye was chosen because he is a lightweight who wants people to reach their own conclusions on what is most reasonable without exposing his opponent’s ignorance and in the most diplomatic way possible. At the end of the day, the debate won’t change anyone’s mind and touring the Creation Museum will still be like walking into an episode of the Flinstones.
 
Ham got utterly destroyed and offered no evidence to back up his absurd claims other than “You won’t there” or “There is a book that says…” and came across as rather…unpleasant.

Bill Nye on the other hand offered evidence backed up by years and years of research and scientific study, while being respectful of religious beliefs. We need more Nyes.
This is heading down a slippery slope though, we all know science does not want to give credit to God for creation or anything else for that matter, so is it right for christians to believe what science tells us is true, or should be instead be wary since they have their own agenda and it does not involve God.

The bible does tell us many will be fooled by deceptions, science and all they try to cram down our throats seems a bit like an agenda to me. what happens when science trys to tell us Jesus never existed as a man, or was not born of a virgin, or God COULD NOT have created the universe, etc?

Their goal is to give a natural explanation for everything in history, thus excluding God, I truly believe when Jesus does come again, our modern day experts will try to tell everyone it is not the second coming and they can explain the events away. I have a feeling many christians will be fooled by science.
 
That isn’t really what Nye was saying at all. He was pointing out the fact that modern scientific advancement, in medicine for example, depends upon the practitioners understanding of evolutionary science and physics. It is predicated upon those theories being true and it works. The belief that Earth is 6,000 years old and all life was created by a God has never resulted in the production of, for example, lifesaving medicines and medical treatments. He was not saying that a person could not believe in God and be a scientist, but he did point out the fact that it can’t be used to predict anything therefore it is impossible for to practice modern science and/or produce anything of any tangible value through that mindset.
It is indeed what Nye had said before the debate, how long before the debate I can’t recall, but his statements are one of the main reasons that Ken Ham wanted to do the debate. One of the issues with what you are saying comes in with what they were debating about; the difference between macro and micro evolution. For example, evolutionary science can be observed as accurate when we are talking about speciation, mutation, etc… and that does not limit Creationists who are also microbiologists, geneticists, physicists, etc… Further, Creationism and ID can indeed be used for predictive purposes, and in fact we can see where a denial of those types of positions are actually limiting Naturalistic/Materialistic science.
Nye definitely won the debate and he went easy on Ham. When Ham asserted that continental drift used to be a much faster process than it is today, Nye didn’t challenge him and ask why no one noticed a land mass we call South America go sailing by at a rate of at least 1 mile per year. When Ham asserted that only a small number of “kinds” were present on the arc, for example only 1 “kind” of beetle, and that all of the different species we see today descended from those “kinds”, Nye didn’t challenge him and ask why he believes evolution to be impossible when he just described evolution to support his own argument. When Ham asserted that Christianity is the only religion to have ever existed with a religious text containing an account of the creation of the Earth and the stars, Nye didn’t challenge him and ask why he chooses to ignore dozens of cultures and religions throughout history with exactly that. Perhaps the most telling speech of the debate was a response to a question from the audience directed at both participants. The question was: “What would change your mind?” Ham’s response: “Nothing.” Nye’s response: “Evidence.”
Ham didn’t choose intellectual giants like Dawkins or Hawking because they would have made him look an inch tall. Nye was chosen because he is a lightweight who wants people to reach their own conclusions on what is most reasonable without exposing his opponent’s ignorance and in the most diplomatic way possible. At the end of the day, the debate won’t change anyone’s mind and touring the Creation Museum will still be like walking into an episode of the Flinstones.
Yeah… I disagree, but will leave it at that. On a side note, I have been to the museum and enjoyed it immensely, and add that the Answers in Genesis website covers all of Nye’s objections and “evidences” if anyone is interested in finding out one YEC position on the subject. As always I feel it is imperative for people who are talking about this topic and debating it to actually look into other beliefs first hand, including Darwinian evolutionists on Darwinian evolution, Theistic evolutionists, IDers, OEC’s and YEC’s.
 
It is indeed what Nye had said before the debate, how long before the debate I can’t recall, but his statements are one of the main reasons that Ken Ham wanted to do the debate. One of the issues with what you are saying comes in with what they were debating about; the difference between macro and micro evolution. For example, evolutionary science can be observed as accurate when we are talking about speciation, mutation, etc… and that does not limit Creationists who are also microbiologists, geneticists, physicists, etc… Further, Creationism and ID can indeed be used for predictive purposes, and in fact we can see where a denial of those types of positions are actually limiting Naturalistic/Materialistic science.
Ham accepts evolutionary theory and physics for the purposes of practicing modern science yet is forced to reject them and assert that laws of physics and nature must have drastically changed in the last 6,000 years in order for his supernatural YEC claims to make any sense at all. He offered no supporting evidence for that assertion, which Nye aptly described as an “extraordinary claim.” Ham couldn’t even provide 1 example of a prediction made on the basis of the existence of a God which would validate such a presupposition. Can you?
 
Ham accepts evolutionary theory and physics for the purposes of practicing modern science yet is forced to reject them and assert that laws of physics and nature must have drastically changed in the last 6,000 years in order for his supernatural YEC claims to make any sense at all. He offered no supporting evidence for that assertion, which Nye aptly described as an “extraordinary claim.” Ham couldn’t even provide 1 example of a prediction made on the basis of the existence of a God which would validate such a presupposition. Can you?
I’ve studied both Ham’s position and Nye’s position. Nye is wrong in asserting that one needs to embrace Darwinian evolution to be a true scientist, engineer, inventor, etc… Ham doesn’t have to accept Darwinian evolutionary theory in order to practice modern science, to experiment, to invent, etc… that is just a ludicrous proposition given the track record of Creation-believing scientists. Darwinian macro-evolutionary theory has precious little to do with actual observational science, engineering, and on and on. You can go right to AiG’s website and look up predictions from their theory. You can go do popular ID websites, such as Uncommon Descent, and look up predictions from their theory.
 
I’ve studied both Ham’s position and Nye’s position. Nye is wrong in asserting that one needs to embrace Darwinian evolution to be a true scientist, engineer, inventor, etc… Ham doesn’t have to accept Darwinian evolutionary theory in order to practice modern science, to experiment, to invent, etc… that is just a ludicrous proposition given the track record of Creation-believing scientists.
Actually, Nye’s assertion is correct. Even Creation-believing scientists do not use the existence of a supernatural entity as the basis of any of the scientific work they do. If they did, they’d never produce anything.
Darwinian macro-evolutionary theory has precious little to do with actual observational science, engineering, and on and on. You can go right to AiG’s website and look up predictions from their theory. You can go do popular ID websites, such as Uncommon Descent, and look up predictions from their theory.
I would encourage everyone to research their so-called predictions. They are demonstrably false.
 
Actually, Nye’s assertion is correct. Even Creation-believing scientists do not use the existence of a supernatural entity as the basis of any of the scientific work they do. If they did, they’d never produce anything.
Here is an example of Creation-believing scientists using Biblical descriptions as the basis of their scientific work.
 
Actually, Nye’s assertion is correct. Even Creation-believing scientists do not use the existence of a supernatural entity as the basis of any of the scientific work they do. If they did, they’d never produce anything.
This makes no scientific or logical sense. Every scientist uses, and draws from, a supernatural worldview; logic, consciousness, existence, life, etc… depend upon the fact of a non-material intelligent being existing transcendentally. Further, your (and Nye’s assertion) doesn’t fit with external evidence; plenty of well-known scientists are creationists, and science existed before Darwin, or his theory of evolution. In fact, many scientists directly credit God and the order of His universe for their love of science, and their ability to observe the world, perform meaningful experimentation, design new inventions, etc…
I would encourage everyone to research their so-called predictions. They are demonstrably false.
We can indeed agree that everyone that is interested needs to research the predictions that exist on all sides of the debate.
 
JustLurking;11675037[URL="http://www.keelynet.com/biology/baugh.htm":
is an example of Creation-believing scientists using Biblical descriptions as the basis of their scientific work.

Testability, predictive power, and explanatory power. Science is all of these things. It is not creating an artificial environment in a hyperbolic chamber and declaring victory. Creating the artificial environment only achieves one of the those things.
 
Testability, predictive power, and explanatory power. Science is all of these things. It is not creating an artificial environment in a hyperbolic chamber and declaring victory. Creating the artificial environment only achieves one of the those things.
Nonetheless, it does provide an example of Creation-believing scientists using Creation as the basis of their scientific work.
 
Nonetheless, it does provide an example of Creation-believing scientists using Creation as the basis of their scientific work.
Not at all. Sometimes Christians use the creation tale to decide the subject of their work, but none of the instruments or methodologies they use were produced by it. Science was not founded on the idea that it is impossible to determine what occurred in the past which resulted in what we see today. “You don’t know, you weren’t there.” is about as unscientific as it gets.
 
This is heading down a slippery slope though, we all know science does not want to give credit to God for creation or anything else for that matter
What does that even mean?

Does it mean that not enough peer-reviewed scientific articles end with the phrase, “praise God!”?

Does it mean that zoologists should be citing the book of Genesis in their research more?

Does it mean that we just shouldn’t even try to figure anything out, because it’s all a supernatural mystery?

Seriously.

What.
Does.
That.
Even.
Mean?
so is it right for christians to believe what science tells us is true, or should be instead be wary since they have their own agenda and it does not involve God.
Sure, you can avoid most modern scientific innovations if you want. You can start by not going to the doctor. Don’t take your car to the mechanic. Stop using the internet. Etc. Basically, become Amish. That’s absolutely your choice.
40.png
EmperorNapoleon:
Not at all. Sometimes Christians use the creation tale to decide the subject of their work, but none of the instruments or methodologies they use were produced by it. Science was not founded on the idea that it is impossible to determine what occurred in the past which resulted in what we see today. “You don’t know, you weren’t there.” is about as unscientific as it gets.
Yes.
 
I would have much rather seen a debate between Dr. Hugh Ross and Bill Nye.
 
The part I don’t understand is why modern cosmology and evolution is such a threat to these people. I have a lot of atheist friends and colleagues that insist that cosmology and evolution are direct proofs of the non-existence of a creator. I am forever arguing that nothing in modern cosmology or evolution theory directly refutes God or a creator. In fact, neither theory has anything at all to say about a creator - so they should stop trying to put words into the mouth of science.
 
The part I don’t understand is why modern cosmology and evolution is such a threat to these people. I have a lot of atheist friends and colleagues that insist that cosmology and evolution are direct proofs of the non-existence of a creator. I am forever arguing that nothing in modern cosmology or evolution theory directly refutes God or a creator. In fact, neither theory has anything at all to say about a creator - so they should stop trying to put words into the mouth of science.
Yes, exactly! We are most certainly not helped by young-Earth Creationists when they agree with atheists that the Big Bang Theory or evolution refutes Christianity. They are claiming that something with intensely strong evidence, if true, would refute our very religion. The link between the two makes people who agree with evolutionary theory very reluctant to be Christian. But it is a false dichotomy! As the Church has said, evolution is completely compatible with Catholicism. So is the Big Bang Theory. Each individual Catholic is free to rationalize/reconcile it with their faith or deny it completely, but it should NEVER be stated that a scientific theory would refute the existence of God. Even a multiverse theory can’t refute Him; no scientific theory, no matter how outlandish, if proven true, could. Science and religion cannot contradict.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top