Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zachary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The part I don’t understand is why modern cosmology and evolution is such a threat to these people. I have a lot of atheist friends and colleagues that insist that cosmology and evolution are direct proofs of the non-existence of a creator. I am forever arguing that nothing in modern cosmology or evolution theory directly refutes God or a creator. In fact, neither theory has anything at all to say about a creator - so they should stop trying to put words into the mouth of science.
The truth is; IF we would assume that Darwinian Evolution and the Naturalistic explanations of the origin of the universe were true, the conclusion isn’t that there is no God, but rather He is not needed in any way, shape, or form. In other words IF Darwinian Evolution is true as well as their explanations for the origins of the universe, then God is not necessary. What leads from that then is a very clear path for atheists and other kinds of non-believers to walk and believe that they can be intellectually fulfilled in their denial or lack of belief in a Creator God.
 
This whole debate was a ridiculous stunt. The debate was between one person who believes based on faith and one who believes what he can observe and measure. The two are mutually exclusive. It’s like arguing that your orange is better than my bicycle,
 
Testability, predictive power, and explanatory power. Science is all of these things. It is not creating an artificial environment in a hyperbolic chamber and declaring victory. Creating the artificial environment only achieves one of the those things.
Evo is observable, repeatable and predictable?
 
Not at all. Sometimes Christians use the creation tale to decide the subject of their work, but none of the instruments or methodologies they use were produced by it. Science was not founded on the idea that it is impossible to determine what occurred in the past which resulted in what we see today. “You don’t know, you weren’t there.” is about as unscientific as it gets.
Biomimicry is studying and using the designs found in nature.
 
From Wikipedia:

Kenneth “Hock” Todd Ham (born December 12, 1964 in Plainfield, New Jersey) is a retired American astronaut and a Captain in the United States Navy. Ham was selected for NASA’s astronaut program in August 1998, while serving as the F/A-18E/F Super Hornet lead carrier suitability test pilot. Ham’s aviator call sign is “Hock”. As of July 2013, Captain Ham is serving as the Chair of the Aerospace Engineering Department at the United States Naval Academy, in Annapolis, Maryland.[2]

This guy is a joke.
 
From Wikipedia

Kenneth Alfred “Ken” Ham (born 20 October 1951) is a young-Earth creationist[1] who advocates a literal interpretation of the Book of Genesis.[2] He is the president of Answers in Genesis (AiG) and the Creation Museum.[3]

This guy is a joke.

And to be even given credit on a Catholic forum is embarrassing and sad.

And for more enjoyment- from Wikipedia:

Ham believes that the Universe was created about 6,000 years ago, and that Noah’s flood occurred about 4,500 years ago in the year 2348 BC.[24] He believes that the animals carried on Noah’s ark produced the biological diversity observed on Earth. Ham also believes that dinosaurs co-existed with modern humans. He supports his view with biblical scripture.[25] Ham accepts that natural selection can give rise to a number of species from an original population.[26]

He did get an honorary degree from the illustrious Liberty University though. . . . . .
 
The only “agenda” scientists have, which Nye pointed out over and over and over again in that debate…is to be open to investigating and learning and growing and changing our minds when we find new, strong, evidence for something.
A person can believe in whatever God they want, and that’s their own personal decision…but when it gets in the way of science and doing the above and when it blocks moving ahead in knowledge and when it involves teaching children things we already have found out are not true…then it’s a problem–for everybody.
It holds back everybody.

If we have fossils and skeletons and ridges on the Grand Canyon etc, etc, whatever…that consistently show the earth is millions or billions of years old…then to teach children the earth is 6000 years old is…teaching them to be ignorant, it’s…lying to them.
And it’s telling them they should not believe in learning.
This “slippery slope” you call it is called learning and thinking.
You can believe in science and still believe in God if ya want–Nye pointed this out, it doesn’t have to be incompatible.

If a person doesn’t believe in “science”…then they should not be getting life-saving surgeries in hospitals or flying in airplanes or using cell phones or watching television or watching astronauts historically land on the moon or even be using the internet and writing on this forum…
This sounds like you agree with Nye that if you are a young earth creationist, you can’t be a scientist. That point is demonstrably false. Ken Ham and the multitude of Ph.D. scientists at his organization love science and fully embrace it. Darwinian evolution and the word science are not synonyms.

Also, I wish this would have come up in the debate; most Christians, including homeschoolers, including those that are young earth creationists, teach their kids about Darwinian evolution as well as their own beliefs. It is Darwinian evolutionists who don’t want kids learning about Old Earth Creationism, Young Earth Creationism, ID, etc…
 
This sounds like you agree with Nye that if you are a young earth creationist, you can’t be a scientist. That point is demonstrably false. Ken Ham and the multitude of Ph.D. scientists at his organization love science and fully embrace it. Darwinian evolution and the word science are not synonyms.

Also, I wish this would have come up in the debate; most Christians, including homeschoolers, including those that are young earth creationists, teach their kids about Darwinian evolution as well as their own beliefs. It is Darwinian evolutionists who don’t want kids learning about Old Earth Creationism, Young Earth Creationism, ID, etc…
Why would any parents, be they secular, Catholic, or even Protestants, like yourself, teach the falsehood of young Earth Creationism or ID?

Do we teach kids that the earth is flat or that storks bring babies?
 
This sounds like you agree with Nye that if you are a young earth creationist, you can’t be a scientist. That point is demonstrably false. Ken Ham and the multitude of Ph.D. scientists at his organization love science and fully embrace it. Darwinian evolution and the word science are not synonyms.
Sure, you can still be a scientist, in the same way that an auto mechanic can still be an auto mechanic while trying to fix motors with chewing gum.
Also, I wish this would have come up in the debate; most Christians, including homeschoolers, including those that are young earth creationists, teach their kids about Darwinian evolution as well as their own beliefs. It is Darwinian evolutionists who don’t want kids learning about Old Earth Creationism, Young Earth Creationism, ID, etc…
The problem there is that evolution is science whereas YEC is certainly not. Why are you putting them on an equal playing field?
 
Wow, there’s a lot of absurdity in this thread.

For one thing, evolutionary theory is not religious by nature.

Secondly, where in the debate did Bill Nye indicate that he’s a materialist or a naturalist? Natural science deals with the material; it’s a disciplinary restriction, not an ideological one.

Nye actually said several times that he respects people’s faith, and that faith and science are compatible.

Also, let’s ignore any claim made here that evolution is in any way a hypothesis rather than a theory. Sorry, it’s a theory.

Also, observational vs. historical science is not a valid distinction.
 
Why would any parents, be they secular, Catholic, or even Protestants, like yourself, teach the falsehood of young Earth Creationism or ID?
You don’t believe in an intelligent designer?
Do we teach kids that the earth is flat or that storks bring babies?
Empirical, observable science shows us neither of those things is true. 😉 It also shows that storks, no matter how you breed 'em will always be birds.
Sure, you can still be a scientist, in the same way that an auto mechanic can still be an auto mechanic while trying to fix motors with chewing gum.
Rhetorical Analogy. A question; do you reject every single scientist who came before Darwin? Every invention that came before Darwin? Every scientific theory that came before Darwin?
The problem there is that evolution is science whereas YEC is certainly not. Why are you putting them on an equal playing field?
It isn’t that YEC and “evolution” are on the same playing field, it is that YECreationists can indeed be scientists and they do have the exact same evidence and examine it, as does OEC’s, IDers, and Darwinian Evolutionists.
For one thing, evolutionary theory is not religious by nature.
Right, it is philosophical.
Secondly, where in the debate did Bill Nye indicate that he’s a materialist or a naturalist?
Nye rejects Supernaturalism, rejects God, and rejects the Bible no matter the interpretation, he says some of this outright in the debate, and has said it prior to the debate.
Nye actually said several times that he respects people’s faith, and that faith and science are compatible.
It’s one thing to say it, another to actually offer that respect. He didn’t appear to me to be very respectful of Kentucky, or Kentuckians in general during the debate, YMMV.
 
Ken Ham is not an individual whom I would want representing my position in the evo v. creationism debate. I am an “old earth” creationist, and someone such as Stephen C. Meyer would fit the bill for any debate that I would like to watch. And one more thing: These half hour presentations are not “debates”. Bring back Lincoln/Douglas style jousts, both here and in Presidential debates. 😉 Rob

P.S. Even the creationsafaris website concluded that Mr. Ham delivered his standard church-based presentation, instead of tailoring it to a general audience.
 
The truth is; IF we would assume that Darwinian Evolution and the Naturalistic explanations of the origin of the universe were true, the conclusion isn’t that there is no God, but rather He is not needed in any way, shape, or form. In other words IF Darwinian Evolution is true as well as their explanations for the origins of the universe, then God is not necessary. What leads from that then is a very clear path for atheists and other kinds of non-believers to walk and believe that they can be intellectually fulfilled in their denial or lack of belief in a Creator God.
Not true at all. It says only the “how” of creation, not the “why”. You don’t “need” God to explain why water boils at 100 degrees Celsius or why your iPhone works. That’s beside the point. Science, moreover, has no evidence as of yet on anything regarding the “origins” of the universe in the strictest sense. That is to say: lots of fascinating ideas about what was “there” before the Big Bang, nothing of real substance yet. And we’re even the multiverse theories or the membranes ideas true, these don’t preclude God. They don’t make Him unnecessary either, they just don’t speak to matters of faith at all.
 
If Homo Sapiens have been around for 200,000 years, why does written human history disappear post 5000 years? That means it took Homo Sapiens 195,000 to learn to write anything down?
 
Yes it is.

Observational is repeatable, historical is not.
I’m unaware of anyone in the field of philosophy of science that claims that repeatability is a criterion of science. An observation being repeatable seems to be part of the methodology, to ensure that experiment results are true results, not flukes or mistakes. Framing science as either observational or historical is a semantical trick that I don’t believe is accepted by the greater community of scientists.

There are many theories and models in science that has no direct observation that are not challenged by these sorts of people. We cannot directly observe the “lithofication” of remains into a fossil, we cannot directly observe tectonic plates grinding against each other, or directly observe the earth’s mantle or cores. But we can make hypotheses about these subjects according to a model and test the implications of them in the same way biologists do the evolutionary model. These hypotheses based on the evolutionary model are regularly bearer out in scientific inquiry, whereas hypotheses based on a young earth creation model are regularly demonstrated to be false.

That being said, I still see no conflict between the evolutionary model and a Christian religious thinking, except that you have to give up young earthism.
 
If Homo Sapiens have been around for 200,000 years, why does written human history disappear post 5000 years? That means it took Homo Sapiens 195,000 to learn to write anything down?
There are modern cultures without a written language. Is it hard to imagine them being around so long ago? Evidence of homo sapien communities existed before writing. What other explanations can there be besides having no written language, or no samples surviving to this day?
 
Yes it is.

Observational is repeatable, historical is not.
Do you realize that this position is essentially saying one cannot reliably know anything apart from that which one directly sees and experiences? This is called solipsism, and I can’t believe any Christian would embrace it. Under this same position, there also is no reason to believe in the future constancy of physical laws and physical mathematics either. Thus, I might suddenly have my car float off the road and travel to Jupiter in it this evening instead of home, as gravity might change without warning. Or perhaps I’ll run right through my coworker on the way out, matter suddenly might shift to allow us to cross the same place at the same time after all!

This is the height of irrationality and I charge that no one not insane really actually thinks this way. You can’t have a special pleading for the past behavior of physics, if you think it changed suddenly before you should think it can change suddenly at any time.
 
If Homo Sapiens have been around for 200,000 years, why does written human history disappear post 5000 years? That means it took Homo Sapiens 195,000 to learn to write anything down?
Incorrect. There are cave paintings of modern man well older than that. This is evidence of writing to my mind. And yes, in short the development of writing and full consciousness is admittedly not fully understood. It took us a long time to get where we are.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top