Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zachary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m unaware of anyone in the field of philosophy of science that claims that repeatability is a criterion of science. An observation being repeatable seems to be part of the methodology, to ensure that experiment results are true results, not flukes or mistakes. Framing science as either observational or historical is a semantical trick that I don’t believe is accepted by the greater community of scientists.

There are many theories and models in science that has no direct observation that are not challenged by these sorts of people. We cannot directly observe the “lithofication” of remains into a fossil, we cannot directly observe tectonic plates grinding against each other, or directly observe the earth’s mantle or cores. But we can make hypotheses about these subjects according to a model and test the implications of them in the same way biologists do the evolutionary model. These hypotheses based on the evolutionary model are regularly bearer out in scientific inquiry, whereas hypotheses based on a young earth creation model are regularly demonstrated to be false.

That being said, I still see no conflict between the evolutionary model and a Christian religious thinking, except that you have to give up young earthism.
One has to give up rationalism to think a brain formed by blind unguided chance can discern truth.

Empirical is observable, repeatable and predictable. Hypothesis requires the ability to test it.

Scientific Method – Why is it important?
The scientific method can be divided into two primary categories: (1) empirical science and (2) historical science. Empirical science entails a systematic approach to epistemology that uses observable, testable, repeatable, and falsifiable experimentation to understand how nature commonly behaves. It finds its implementation in such disciplines as immunology, rocket science, molecular biology, etc. Historical science involves the interpretation of evidence and the deduction of past occurrences, which is normally based upon an underlying supportive paradigm. - See more at: allaboutscience.org/scientific-method.htm#sthash.dAN0snZ3.dpuf
 
If anything good can come of this debate it will be to ensure creation stays out of the science class. There is currently a campaign in the UK to get Creation banned from science classes.
 
Do you realize that this position is essentially saying one cannot reliably know anything apart from that which one directly sees and experiences? This is called solipsism, and I can’t believe any Christian would embrace it. Under this same position, there also is no reason to believe in the future constancy of physical laws and physical mathematics either. Thus, I might suddenly have my car float off the road and travel to Jupiter in it this evening instead of home, as gravity might change without warning. Or perhaps I’ll run right through my coworker on the way out, matter suddenly might shift to allow us to cross the same place at the same time after all!

This is the height of irrationality and I charge that no one not insane really actually thinks this way. You can’t have a special pleading for the past behavior of physics, if you think it changed suddenly before you should think it can change suddenly at any time.
No, knowledge can be transmitted from others. To understand the world we have to look at it as it was created in a special way by God. We cannot deduce it. Because it was freely chosen by God the order in nature could be otherwise. The only way we know is to find out what He actually did.
 
If anything good can come of this debate it will be to ensure creation stays out of the science class. There is currently a campaign in the UK to get Creation banned from science classes.
\

I submit only empirical science in the science classroom. Students should take a mandatory philosophy class. Agree?
 
There are modern cultures without a written language.
And they have zero interest in their past?
Is it hard to imagine them being around so long ago?
Nobody managed to write anything down post 5,000 years. That is hard for me to imagine given the totality of human experience. Not isolated incidents. Humans write, they record. The flood, for example is recorded at least in two accounts by humans who had little if any contact with each other as far as we know.
Evidence of homo sapien communities existed before writing.
Written history is more concrete. Especially multiple accounts of one event. One problem i have is dating methods. There is only a handful of people who actually understand what they are doing or how they come to their conclusions and the rest of us are supposed to trust them? Even if a lot of what they are saying contradicts Jesus? No flood, no Moses? We are to assume the Earth is billions of years old?
What other explanations can there be besides having no written language, or no samples surviving to this day?
If they were around for 200,000 years and it took them 195,000 years to write anything down about their life, their ancestors, their conquests etc. then they were not humans like we are humans or they were not around that long. Humans, as a whole, are informational. Nothing happened in 195,000 years that was not worth remembering and passing down to future generations?
 
One has to give up rationalism to think a brain formed by blind unguided chance can discern truth.

Empirical is observable, repeatable and predictable. Hypothesis requires the ability to test it.

Scientific Method – Why is it important?
The scientific method can be divided into two primary categories: (1) empirical science and (2) historical science. Empirical science entails a systematic approach to epistemology that uses observable, testable, repeatable, and falsifiable experimentation to understand how nature commonly behaves. It finds its implementation in such disciplines as immunology, rocket science, molecular biology, etc. Historical science involves the interpretation of evidence and the deduction of past occurrences, which is normally based upon an underlying supportive paradigm. - See more at: allaboutscience.org/scientific-method.htm#sthash.dAN0snZ3.dpuf
  1. Why exactly does one have to give up rationalism if the brain was[BIBLEDRB][/BIBLEDRB] formed by blind, unguided chance?
  2. Empirical pertains to empiricism, an epistemology where one comes to knowledge through sensory observation. Repeatability and testability are part of the scientific method, which is empirical. Conflating empiricism and the scientific method is a mistake.
  3. Show me that claim from allaboutscience.org from a respected peer-reviewed source on science or philosophy of science and then we’ll be getting somewhere. As it stands that website is a mouthpiece for a religious ideological group (hit “home” At the site and see where it gets you). That distinction of science is an outlier at best, an aberration at worst.
 
And they have zero interest in their past? Nobody managed to write anything down post 5,000 years. That is hard for me to imagine given the totality of human experience. Not isolated incidents. Humans write, they record. The flood, for example is recorded at least in two accounts by humans who had little if any contact with each other as far as we know. Written history is more concrete. Especially multiple accounts of one event. One problem i have is dating methods. There is only a handful of people who actually understand what they are doing or how they come to their conclusions and the rest of us are supposed to trust them? Even if a lot of what they are saying contradicts Jesus? No flood, no Moses? We are to assume the Earth is billions of years old? If they were around for 200,000 years and it took them 195,000 years to write anything down about their life, their ancestors, their conquests etc. then they were not humans like we are humans or they were not around that long. Humans, as a whole, are informational. Nothing happened in 195,000 years that was not worth remembering and passing down to future generations?
It makes it even harder considering humans have not evolved for 270,000 years. 🙂
 
And they have zero interest in their past? Nobody managed to write anything down post 5,000 years. That is hard for me to imagine given the totality of human experience. Not isolated incidents. Humans write, they record. The flood, for example is recorded at least in two accounts by humans who had little if any contact with each other as far as we know. Written history is more concrete. Especially multiple accounts of one event. One problem i have is dating methods. There is only a handful of people who actually understand what they are doing or how they come to their conclusions and the rest of us are supposed to trust them? Even if a lot of what they are saying contradicts Jesus? No flood, no Moses? We are to assume the Earth is billions of years old? If they were around for 200,000 years and it took them 195,000 years to write anything down about their life, their ancestors, their conquests etc. then they were not humans like we are humans or they were not around that long. Humans, as a whole, are informational. Nothing happened in 195,000 years that was not worth remembering and passing down to future generations?
I’m sure a great many of these preliterate people were interested in their histories and etc. The power of oral tradition is very strong, especially in societies without writing. Strong in such away that societies WITH writing forget how amazingly a person can commit vast amounts of information to memory. Plenty of societies get by storing their histories by memory, and retelling them in verse and song. Through most of recorded history the vast, vast majority of people were completely illiterate. Writing was for a very specialized class only. It’s easy to look back on history with lenses tinted by our time and culture. But we can see how writing was rather unimportant to most people, in fact the earliest samples of writing from vastly different cultures consists of temple and tax records. It took a lot of time before the first narrative was written, and even longer for it to be commonplace.

As for flood accounts, that seems only natural. Every culture I’ve ever studied around the time writing was developed were situated near or upon a body of (sometimes dangerous water). Naturally there would be flood stories. Evidence of these early civilizations interacting is rather striking, and stories exchange like any other cultural commodity.
 
No, knowledge can be transmitted from others. To understand the world we have to look at it as it was created in a special way by God. We cannot deduce it. Because it was freely chosen by God the order in nature could be otherwise. The only way we know is to find out what He actually did.
No offense but I’m confused by your response. You didn’t respond to what I said at all, and not only that, what you wrote above makes no sense whatsoever. What I said remains undeniable: this “observational” v. “historical” science false dichotomy is philosophically nothing short of an embrace of Solipsism. It’s determining to live in a world of total irrationality where physical laws and mathematics themselves can change at any time. How do you know the Earth is round right now? Or will be tomorrow? It could rearrange itself overnight after all. Nuclear fission could suddenly begin operating under different mathematics and the Sun supernova today, right? Or is only PAST physics changeable? If so, what is your basis for this belief?

And please clarify what you mean in your post above.:confused:

And one other question: how is it that Ham and his ilk are doing anything to further the investigation to “find out what God actually did”?
 
  1. Why exactly does one have to give up rationalism if the brain was formed by blind, unguided chance?
  2. Empirical pertains to empiricism, an epistemology where one comes to knowledge through sensory observation. Repeatability and testability are part of the scientific method, which is empirical. Conflating empiricism and the scientific method is a mistake.
  3. Show me that claim from allaboutscience.org from a respected peer-reviewed source on science or philosophy of science and then we’ll be getting somewhere. As it stands that website is a mouthpiece for a religious ideological group (hit “home” At the site and see where it gets you). That distinction of science is an outlier at best, an aberration at worst.
  1. How can a brain formed as a result of survival of the fittest know any truth? It can deceive itself as it has no orientation to the truth. Most atheists do not believe in absolute truth. How could anyone trust this kind of brain? Do you believe absolute truth exists?
  2. Gravity is proved by observation, repeatability and predictability. We can with confidence know what happens here on earth when we bounce a ball. The steps of the scientific method include - test with experiment.
  3. The claim is verified by so many scientists starting with Newton. The pursuit of origins science is historical as it happened once. This is a well known distinction.
 
No offense but I’m confused by your response. You didn’t respond to what I said at all, and not only that, what you wrote above makes no sense whatsoever. What I said remains undeniable: this “observational” v. “historical” science false dichotomy is philosophically nothing short of an embrace of Solipsism. It’s determining to live in a world of total irrationality where physical laws and mathematics themselves can change at any time. How do you know the Earth is round right now? Or will be tomorrow? It could rearrange itself overnight after all. Nuclear fission could suddenly begin operating under different mathematics and the Sun supernova today, right? Or is only PAST physics changeable? If so, what is your basis for this belief?

And please clarify what you mean in your post above.:confused:
I take solipsism to mean

sol·ip·sism
ˈsälipˌsizəm/
noun
noun: solipsism


  1. *]1.
    the view or theory that the self is all that can be known to exist.

    I do not agree with it.

    I understand the world to be intelligible as it was created by a rational mind.

    A supernatural intervention could cause your examples. In this context though it would happen only once. This would be historical science. We could not repeat it in a lab. Laws could have operated differently in the past. We now know radioactive decay varies.
 
  1. How can a brain formed as a result of survival of the fittest know any truth? It can deceive itself as it has no orientation to the truth. Most atheists do not believe in absolute truth. How could anyone trust this kind of brain? Do you believe absolute truth exists?
  2. Gravity is proved by observation, repeatability and predictability. We can with confidence know what happens here on earth when we bounce a ball. The steps of the scientific method include - test with experiment.
  3. The claim is verified by so many scientists starting with Newton. The pursuit of origins science is historical as it happened once. This is a well known distinction.
  1. I’m not saying it can be. You’re saying it cannot. Can you support your claim or are you going to rely on the negative argument?
  2. Right there is the rub. Induction cannot prove anything. Induction can only offer evidence of. There is a whole lot of evidence for gravity, I grant you. But the theory of gravity isn’t PROVEN. Any scientist who is honest and passionate about their craft will admit that.
  3. Where does Newton write this? Is it in De Grav? The Principia? When someone drops a ball and they interprete the data, they are working with historical observations, observations of some event in that occurred in the past. The frame of history is just very, very small. Coming across a fossil, or a dead body, or burnt-out home is treated in the same way - the frame of history is just larger.
 
\

I submit only empirical science in the science classroom. Students should take a mandatory philosophy class. Agree?
100% I would love to see some philosophy taught to 11-16 year olds. With the amount of information thrown at young kids these days through advertisements/government propaganda some critical thinking would be very beneficial.
 
hat isn’t really what Nye was saying at all. He was pointing out the fact that modern scientific advancement, in medicine for example, depends upon the practitioners understanding of evolutionary science and physics. It is predicated upon those theories being true and it works. The belief that Earth is 6,000 years old and all life was created by a God has never resulted in the production of, for example, lifesaving medicines and medical treatments. He was not saying that a person could not believe in God and be a scientist, but he did point out the fact that it can’t be used to predict anything therefore it is impossible for to practice modern science and/or produce anything of any tangible value through that mindset.
The fastest, most intense advancements in human society came from nations and places where the dominant religion was Christianity.
 
100% I would love to see some philosophy taught to 11-16 year olds. With the amount of information thrown at young kids these days through advertisements/government propaganda some critical thinking would be very beneficial.
If you’re talking about American public education, many folks in that system don’t want critical thinking that threatens left-wing political interests.
 
I take solipsism to mean

sol·ip·sism
ˈsälipˌsizəm/
noun
noun: solipsism


  1. *]1.
    the view or theory that the self is all that can be known to exist.

    I do not agree with it.

    I understand the world to be intelligible as it was created by a rational mind.

    A supernatural intervention could cause your examples. In this context though it would happen only once. This would be historical science. We could not repeat it in a lab. Laws could have operated differently in the past. We now know radioactive decay varies.

  1. Yes, but when you say the world is “intelligible” that means it’s able to be understood, and the only way this is possible is if the physical laws under which it operates are constant and reliable. Changing laws mean total chaos and irrationality, there would be nothing to BE understood.

    Solipsism as a viewpoint entails that, since only my mind exists, the only reliable knowledge I can have would be that which I directly experience. This is the very dark heart and core of what is going on when the creationist yells “but you weren’t there!!”

    I’m reiterating it again because it’s so obviously irrefutably true: the crux of Ham’s argument about “historical science” is, essentially, solipsism. Under his view I have no reason to think the Sun will rise tomorrow, the laws of the universe are NOT RELIABLE and so cannot give us any knowledge about the past or the future. It is on its face irrational thinking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top