Biology / science / ressurrection

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rogerteder
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Tim science is clearly wrong about the resurrection. Why cant it be wrong about evolution?
It could be but it is not.
Pope Benedict XVI never said any such thing about monogenism. Even if he did his speeches and private interviews arent Church teaching.
Well, which is it? He didn’t or it doesn’t matter?
They are his private opinions.
They were published in “The July 2004 Vatican Statement on Creation and Evolution”. The document, which he approved, says:
While the story of human origins is complex and subject to revision, physical anthropology and molecular biology combine to make a convincing case for the origin of the human species in Africa about 150,000 years ago in a humanoid population of common genetic lineage.
How can you possibly read that as anything but an acknowledgement of polygenism?
We have clear magisterial statements that Genesis is to be taken literally. Why can’t we say the resurrection was spiritual and not literal. Science indicates this is impossible.
So, it’s either scripture or science? Is it impossible for you to see that both are means of finding truth? The Church accepts science. Why are you opposed to the Church?

Peace

Tim
 
I would hope we would all say science is wrong on this matter.
…I don’t exactly see why you would say that, no.

Many scientists are certainly wrong about the resurrection, but natural science as such has no specific theory regarding the resurrection that can be supported or overturned.

You cannot make the “science is wrong about this” claim if the scientific community as a whole isn’t actually backing a particular theory.
Why (and some people dispute evolution on a scientific basis) cant we say science is wrong on creation? I mean every Pope, in an official way, (not speeches, not interviews etc) almost all the Church Fathers, the theologians in 13th, 14th centuries (Aquinas, Bonaventure, Anselm, ) all interpreted Genesis literally.
It’s funny you left out Augustine. I seem to remember him specifically cautioning against taking things literally if there was good reason to hold that they were not intended literally.
ALL WERE CREATIONISTS!!!
Hmm… well, perhaps I should point out that SO ARE WE. :rolleyes:
Not young-earth creationists, it’s true – but we do believe that God created the universe. And we believe that Adam and Eve really existed, lived in the garden, were given preternatural gifts of immortality and freedom from suffering, and were kicked out of the garden after committing the Original Sin. (And as long as we don’t lose sight of these facts, I don’t believe that Aquinas or Augustine or Anslem would have the slightest problem with our position.)
Now science seems to have the answer with evolution.
“The answer” to what, may I ask? And how does it threaten Catholic doctrine?
WHY cant we say NO!!!
You can, sure, but I think it’s a really bad idea in the long run…
This coupled with Pius XII’s statement in Humani Generis that polygenism can not seem to be compatible with the Catholic faith. Why are we taking science over the magesterium?
WE’RE NOT… :confused: in large part because polygenism is not an essential element of evolution theory. So when the Church says it’s not a valid option, we don’t have any real problem rejecting it. Do you actually see anyone here trying to fit polygenism into Catholic doctrine for the sake of maintaining evolution theory?
 
By the way, at least Pope Benedict XVI seems to disagree with the monogenism requirement
No way. Not a chance. The fact that all human beings are descended from Adam and Eve is an essential doctrine of the Catholic faith. There’s no way Pope Benedict has said or ever will say anything contrary to that.
The document, which he approved, says: “…physical anthropology and molecular biology combine to make a convincing case for the origin of the human species in Africa about 150,000 years ago in a humanoid population of common genetic lineage.” How can you possibly read that as anything but an acknowledgement of polygenism?
Uh… quite easily, I assure you. 😛

Perhaps we simply have a different understanding of what “polygenism” means. As I understand it, polygenism rejects that all modern humans are ultimately descended from a single pair of parents. This is absolutely incompatible with Catholic doctrine. You could hold that Adam and Eve themselves were descended from a larger humanoid population, but that doesn’t impact the fact that all human beings can ultimately trace back their lineage back to a single set of parents (monogenism). Did you have a different understanding?
 
Did you have a different understanding?
Actually, I think that the human species evolved and Adam and Eve were the first to be ensouled. Are we and Adam and Eve descendents of one original pair? I don’t know.

I think you will acknowledge that most people on this forum would say we are both wrong. Adam and Eve were the first humans and all of mankind is biologically descendent from them.

Peace

Tim
 
…I don’t exactly see why you would say that, no.

Many scientists are certainly wrong about the resurrection, but natural science as such has no specific theory regarding the resurrection that can be supported or overturned.

You cannot make the “science is wrong about this” claim if the scientific community as a whole isn’t actually backing a particular theory.

It’s funny you left out Augustine. I seem to remember him specifically cautioning against taking things literally if there was good reason to hold that they were not intended literally.

Hmm… well, perhaps I should point out that SO ARE WE. :rolleyes:
Not young-earth creationists, it’s true – but we do believe that God created the universe. And we believe that Adam and Eve really existed, lived in the garden, were given preternatural gifts of immortality and freedom from suffering, and were kicked out of the garden after committing the Original Sin. (And as long as we don’t lose sight of these facts, I don’t believe that Aquinas or Augustine or Anslem would have the slightest problem with our position.)

“The answer” to what, may I ask? And how does it threaten Catholic doctrine?

You can, sure, but I think it’s a really bad idea in the long run…

WE’RE NOT… :confused: in large part because polygenism is not an essential element of evolution theory. So when the Church says it’s not a valid option, we don’t have any real problem rejecting it. Do you actually see anyone here trying to fit polygenism into Catholic doctrine for the sake of maintaining evolution theory?
I didnt leave Augustine out. That is why I said ALMOST ALL. ANYWAY question: Do you believe in polygenism or monogenism. Do you believe what Piux XII wrote in Humani Generis?
 
Because it isn’t.Interestingly, recent popes, when presented the scientific evidence, no longer are strict 6 day creationists. I wonder what the other people you invoked would have said if they had the evidence we now have.YOU already have. Why do you insist that the rest of us give up science simply because you have a fundamentalist interpretation of scriptures.We are taking science WITH the magesterium. You are just rejecting the science.

By the way, at least Pope Benedict XVI seems to disagree with the monogenism requirement.

Peace

Tim
I know of no official magisteriul texts that talk about Genesis being symbolic. Like I said earlier, almost all the Church Fathers believed in a literal interpretation of Genesis. Numerous Popes have arned against evolution in official texts, Pius X being one of them. The new catechism mentions nothing about evolution. (despite Jimmy Akin’s attempts–see Sungenis’ rebutal to him–I love you Jimmy) You may have a speech or a publication that alludes to evolution, but none in official magisterial texts.

You mention that because of the new evidence in science Popes (saints Fathers etc) would not be creationists (6 day literal). Well science all along has said (in general) that a man who is dead can;t rise again, but we believed it happened. Why because our Church teaches it (I understand their are other reasons). We reject science in this case.

In the case of evolution it is disputed by some. There are scientists (a small number i admit) who don’t believe it is true at all. So why are we so QUICK to fall over and love and kiss (especially when we have Popes like Pius XII who have taught monogenism, and that Adam and Eve are real people AND THE FALL WAS AN ACTUAL HISTORICAL EVENT) science when it comes to evolution. I dare say I think some of you are afraid to be ridiculed by freinds, co-workers etc. You would be laughed at if you were to be a 6 day literal creationist. So you fall over and kiss science.

Also Vatican I taught infallibly that God created “out of nothing” that there was no pre-existing matter before God’s creation. Do you believe that? Or are you going to cower to science.
 
Vatican I God created “out of nothing” science MUST reject that…how could they have any explanation for that–as a matter of fact these evolutionists scientists specifically MUST reject that. How could there at one time be nothing? THINK ABOUT IT!!!

This one true God,
Code:
* by his goodness and almighty power,
* not with the intention of increasing his happiness,
* nor indeed of obtaining happiness,
* but in order to manifest his perfection by the good things which he bestows on what he creates,
* by an absolutely free plan,
* together from the beginning of time
* brought into being from nothing
      o the twofold created order, that is
            + the spiritual and the bodily,
            + the angelic and the earthly,
REMEMBER FATIMA----------SCIENCE SAYS THAT COULDNT HAPPEN EITHER!!! BUT IT DID!!! IN FRONT OF 70, 000 PEOPLE!!!
 
Actually, I think that the human species evolved and Adam and Eve were the first to be ensouled.
…I don’t think I would disagree.
But it depends on what you say about the following:
Are we and Adam and Eve descendants of one original pair? I don’t know.
It doesn’t particularly matter if Adam and Eve were descended from an original pair – that’s a completely separate question – …but I was just saying that all men (that is, rational animals having a spiritual soul directly created and infused by God) are biologically descended from Adam and Eve. Whatever else might have happened before Adam and Eve is pretty much irrelevant.
I think you will acknowledge that most people on this forum would say we are both wrong.
I don’t know, I seem to remember this particular poll not too long ago… 🙂
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=271724
Adam and Eve were the first humans and all of mankind is biologically descendant from them.
If that’s your position, then we’re in agreement.
I didnt leave Augustine out. That is why I said ALMOST ALL.
…alright, fair enough.
ANYWAY question: Do you believe in polygenism or monogenism. Do you believe what Piux XII wrote in Humani Generis?
Monogenism (all men from Adam and Eve), and yes.
REMEMBER FATIMA----------SCIENCE SAYS THAT COULDN’T HAPPEN EITHER!!! BUT IT DID!!! IN FRONT OF 70, 000 PEOPLE!!!
OK, now hold on just a flipping minute.
First of all, we really shouldn’t be bringing Fatima into this.

But since it’s done, what exactly do you think happened at Fatima? Because it’s DEFINITELY a fact that the *entire world *did not witness the miracle of the sun. So either (1) the sun actually danced around and came closer to the earth, only a small percentage of the world saw it, and God miraculously prevented it from appearing that way to absolutely everyone else – OR (2) the sun itself didn’t actually move anywhere, but the miracle was more properly a miraculous vision (or perhaps some supernatural manipulation of the sun’s light and/or earth’s atmosphere) seen by everyone present (plus, apparently, the Pope in Rome), followed by the miraculous drying up of all the rain water that had been falling in Fatima for so many days, and the subsequent vision of Christ, Mary, and the Holy Family in the sun, etc.

So yes, if option 1 is what actually happened, then science has absolutely no way to explain how the Earth and/or the Sun could have moved so abruptly out of their normal paths temporarily. And that’s fine – sometimes miracles like that might actually happen, and natural science has no way of accounting for supernatural miracles. But if it was actually option 2 – and I’m personally inclined to think that it was something more like that – then your “Remember Fatima!” war cry loses just a little bit of its power, insofar as the miraculous character would be slightly less opposed to modern science (supernatural visions from God seeming far more palatable to many than actually kicking something as huge as the Earth or Sun out of its motion temporarily, and that even more if such a thing wasn’t actually seen by the billions of other people living across that half of the globe).
 
Wouldnt it be fair to say that almost EVERY SCIENTIST WOULD ANSWER THAT IT IS SCIENTIFICALLY IMPOSSIBLE FOR THIS SCENARIO TO HAPPEN???

Is it scientifically possible for a human being to actually physically die and be dead for three days and then rise again and be alive? can we all agree most scientists would that that is impossible from a scientific perspective???

The question has nothing to do with science, which can neither support it nor cast doubt on it.​

Scientific truth is not the only kind. Science & scientific method is a great gift, in no way to be despised - but it is wholly inadequate to take account of supernatural entities such as the saving acts of God.

By the way, Christ’s Resurrection is important because it is His; had it been that of Lazarus, it would had been of no importance, for Lazarus is not the Lord Who died, broke the power of death, & rose again in glory. What has science to do with these things ? Nothing. To believe in the things done by God for the Glory of His Son on scientific grounds, is madness: they are to be believed in because they are revealed by God - they need no other evidence.
 
As I quoted earlier the Church teaches God created the world “out of nothing” ------do you evolutionists agree with that??? HOW CAN MODERN SCIENCE REMOTELY SUPPORT THAT?
 
As I quoted earlier the Church teaches God created the world “out of nothing” ------do you evolutionists agree with that???
Absolutely I do. 🙂

EDIT: Actually, it’s going to depend on what you mean when you say “the world”. I believe that God created the universe (“the world”) ex nihilo – the earth (“the world”), however, didn’t come around until quite a bit later, and was formed out of already-existing materials.
HOW CAN MODERN SCIENCE REMOTELY SUPPORT THAT?
It’s can’t. 🙂 BUT it can’t reject it, either… for the exact same reason that it can’t support it.
Because creation ex nihilo is not a scientific theory that can be tested or verified. The closest sort of confirmation in this regard that you can get from modern science is the Big Bang model, and even that isn’t an absolutely demonstrable proof of creation ex nihilo.

…but what does creation ex nihilo have to do with any of this, anyway?
 
PLEASE ANSWER THE ACTUAL QUESTION!!! IT IS A SIMPLE YES OR NO ANSWER—THEN WE WILL HAVE FURTHER DISCUSSIONS–THANKS!!! WOULD THEY SAY (SCIENTISTS) THAT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE???
There was a thread “Are Spirits scientifically possible?” some few months ago very similar to this one. People claimed that gods were spirits and that spirits and religion were “beyond” science. They’re not, of course. They are in fact, non-science or pseudoscience.

That said, scientists can “believe in” any little old thing they wish, including spirits and miracles and lucky numbers.
 
“Natural” science? What other kinds of science are there?
Several, actually… but that’s because I’m speaking as an Aristotelian/Thomist would. 🙂

My apologies.
But just for future reference, it works roughly like this:

science = knowledge (from Latin scientia)

A science is an organized body of knowledge following demonstratively from certain premises which are either immediately known to be true, or which are proved in another other science.

Natural Science = science of nature (natural things)
Mathematical Science = science of mathematics

…there are plenty of other examples (for example, Saint Thomas speaks about the Science of Sacred Doctrine in the Summa), but those two are probably the most prominent ones.

And it all really just ties back to the original meaning and usage of the word “science” = knowledge. It was not until quite a bit later, during/after the Scientific Revolution, that “natural science” became simply known as “science”. Heck, even at the very beginning, Galileo entitled one of his books “Two New Sciences”, considering motion and resistance.

So in short, no, I’m not crazy. Just a little out of date. 😛 (Merry Christmas!) 🙂
 
Roger << As I quoted earlier the Church teaches God created the world “out of nothing” ------do you evolutionists agree with that??? HOW CAN MODERN SCIENCE REMOTELY SUPPORT THAT? >>

Science does support that. It is called “The Big Bang”…SEE

Stephen Hawking, the Big Bang, and God by Henry Schaeffer
The Ultimate Question of Origins: God and the Beginning of the Universe by William Lane Craig
Creation and Big Bang Cosmology by Craig
In Defense of the Kalam Cosmological Argument by Craig
Theism, Atheism, and Big Bang Cosmology by Craig and Quentin Smith (Oxford Univ Press, 1995)

The universe was created “out of nothing” says the Big Bang.

Ever since the Big Bang was proposed, this has been seen as (at least) evidence that the universe had a beginning (and therefore a cause), meaning at one point in the finite past “there was no space, no time, no matter, NOTHING.”

Atheists acknowledge this, and try to “solve” this problem (some quotes from my old FidoNet debates with atheists) :

Fom physicist and astronomer Paul Davies’ GOD AND THE NEW PHYSICS (1983) –

“These days most cosmologists and astronomers back the theory that there was indeed a creation…when the physical universe BURST INTO EXISTENCE in an awesome explosion popularly known as the ‘big bang’. There are many strands of evidence to support this astonishing theory…The reason stems directly from a large body of scientific evidence that is encompassed by the most universal law of physics known – the second law of thermodynamics…[from which follows] the universe CANNOT HAVE EXISTED FOR EVER, otherwise it would have reached its equilibrium end state an infinite time ago. Conclusion: THE UNIVERSE DID NOT ALWAYS EXIST.” (p. 10,11)

“The idea of space being created out of nothing is a subtle one that many people find hard to understand, especially if they are used to thinking of space as already being ‘nothing.’…To the physicist ‘nothing’ means ‘NO SPACE’ as well as NO MATTER.” (p. 18)

“If we accept that space and time really did erupt OUT OF NOTHING in the big bang, then clearly there was a creation and the universe has a finite age. The paradox of the second law of thermodynamics is therefore immediately solved.” (p. 20)

And to be fair, Davies asserts (at this time in 1983) that “In conclusion, there seems to be nothing terribly wrong with either an eternal universe, or one that is of a finite age, bounded in the past by a singularity.” (p. 19)

For his latest views on these questions, see his The Goldilocks Enigma: Why Is the Universe Just Right for Life? (paperback, 2008)

ALSO THAT:

"If time BELONGS to the physical universe, and is subject to laws of physics, it must be included in the universe that God is supposed to have created. But what does it mean to say that God CAUSED time to come into existence, when by our usual understanding of causation a cause must PRECEDE its effect? Causation is a temporal activity. Time must already exist before anything can be caused. The naive image of God existing BEFORE the universe is clearly absurd if time did not exist – if there was no ‘before.’ (p. 44)

From the ATHEIST DEBATER’S HANDBOOK by B.C. Johnson (Prometheus Books,1983) –

“Besides, even IF we suppose past time to have had a beginning, this would not mean God exists. For we assume that every event WITHIN time has a cause, yet this might not apply to the beginning of time itself because the commencement of time would not be an event WITHIN time. If time might have been nonexistent, then so might CAUSALITY. The universe and time might have just popped into existence WITHOUT A CAUSE.” (p. 69-70)

From atheist philosopher Quentin’s Smith (called by Craig, Smith’s) “Gettysburg Address of atheism” –

“…the most reasonable belief is that we came from nothing, by nothing, and for nothing.” (Craig/Smith, page 135, cited in The Case For A Creator by Lee Strobel)

As I said, atheists are willing to acknowledge that the universe had a beginning. They have a harder time trying to answer the problem “from nothing, nothing comes.” They also assert that to say “God caused the universe” replaces a mystery with a bigger mystery. However, theists have no problem with this.

Phil P
 
I answered Roger’s (rogerteder) post a while ago. He keeps bringing up the same things.

(1) Roger confuses science with miracles. The resurrection was a one-time or rare event – Jesus rose bodily from the dead. Science has nothing to say about such miracles. They are not testable, they are not repeatable. This one-time event wasn’t (directly) observed. True, bodies do not normally rise from the dead, says science and reason. But “God raised Jesus from the dead” is the best explanation of what happened given the historical context. (E.G. death of Jesus on the cross, His tomb was found empty, the appearances of Jesus alive to various witnesses after His death, and the origin of the Christian faith, etc). See all of William Lane Craig’s successful debates or the exhaustive The Resurrection of the Son of God by Anglican N.T. Wright or the video by Ignatius Press.

bringyou.to/apologetics/IgnatiusResurrectionDVD.jpg

(2) Roger asks why can’t we reject science when it comes to creationism (a young earth in particular) ? Because it is not logical to do so. It is against reason. We’ve known the earth is millions of years old for at least 150 years, and precisely 4.5 billion years old for over fifty years. Science has confirmed these findings over and over. Even Pius XII acknowledges the ancient age of the earth (see John Paul II quote of Pius XII in "Cosmology and Fundamental Physics")

POPE JOHN PAUL II: “Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth; and God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truth – in a word, to know himself – so that, by knowing and loving God, men and women may also come to the fullness of truth about themselves.” (Fides et Ratio [1998], cf. Ex 33:18; Ps 27:8-9; 63:2-3; Jn 14:8; 1 Jn 3:2).
  1. Faith and science: “…methodical research in all branches of knowledge, provided it is carried out in a truly scientific manner and does not override moral laws, can never conflict with the faith, because the things of the world and the things of faith derive from the same God. The humble and persevering investigator of the secrets of nature is being led, as it were, by the hand of God in spite of himself, for it is God, the conserver of all things, who made them what they are.” [Vatican II GS 36:1] (also 283-284)
CARDINAL SCHONBORN: "Now there is another misunderstanding that is constantly found in the ongoing discussion, and I have to deal with it right here at the beginning. I refer to what is called ‘creationism.’ Nowadays the belief in a creator is automatically run together with ‘creationism.’ But in fact to believe in a creator is not the same as trying to understand the six days of creation literally, as six chronological days, and as trying to prove scientifically, with whatever means available, that the earth is 6000 years old. These attempts of certain Christians at taking the Bible absolutely literally, as if it made chronological and scientific statements – I have met defenders of this position who honestly strive to find scientific arguments for it – is called ‘fundamentalism.’ Or more exactly, within American Protestantism this view of the Christian faith originally called itself fundamentalism. Starting from the belief that the Bible is inspired by God, so that every word in it is immediately inspired by Him, the six days of creation are taken in a strict literal way. It is understandable that in the United States many people, using not only kinds of polemics but lawsuits as well, vehemently resist the teaching of creationism in the schools…

“The Catholic position on this is clear. St. Thomas says that ‘one should not try to defend the Christian faith with arguments that are so patently opposed to reason that the faith is made to look ridiculous.’ It is simply nonsense to say that the world is only 6000 years old. To try to prove this scientifically is what St. Thomas calls provoking the irrisio infidelium, the scorn of the unbelievers. It is not right to use such false arguments and to expose the faith to the scorn of unbelievers. This should suffice on the subject of ‘creationism’ and ‘fundamentalism’ for the entire remainder of this catechesis; what we want to say about it should be so clear that we do not have to return to the subject.” (Christoph Cardinal Schonborn, Cat Lec for 11/13/2005)

Clear enough for you?

(3) Roger says all past theologians, the Church Fathers, and past Popes were all creationists (meaning young earth). What he doesn’t mention is that all SCIENTISTS were creationists as well. Up until Galileo, all scientists (and theologians, and churchmen) were geocentrists. The scientific evidence is what changed their mind. It wasn’t a conspiracy. The young earth became an old earth because of the scientific evidence. Read and learn about it. No need to hug or kiss it. 😛 Some of your most prominent geologists who discovered these truths were Catholics and Christians. The history is layed out in detail here. Read it, learn it, don’t kiss it. 😛

MERRY CHRISTMAS TO ALL.

Phil P
 
I answered Roger’s (rogerteder) post a while ago. He keeps bringing up the same things.

(1) Roger confuses science with miracles. The resurrection was a one-time or rare event – Jesus rose bodily from the dead. Science has nothing to say about such miracles. They are not testable, they are not repeatable. This one-time event wasn’t (directly) observed. True, bodies do not normally rise from the dead, says science and reason. But “God raised Jesus from the dead” is the best explanation of what happened given the historical context. (E.G. death of Jesus on the cross, His tomb was found empty, the appearances of Jesus alive to various witnesses after His death, and the origin of the Christian faith, etc). See all of William Lane Craig’s successful debates or the exhaustive The Resurrection of the Son of God by Anglican N.T. Wright or the video by Ignatius Press.

bringyou.to/apologetics/IgnatiusResurrectionDVD.jpg

(2) Roger asks why can’t we reject science when it comes to creationism (a young earth in particular) ? Because it is not logical to do so. It is against reason. We’ve known the earth is millions of years old for at least 150 years, and precisely 4.5 billion years old for over fifty years. Science has confirmed these findings over and over. Even Pius XII acknowledges the ancient age of the earth (see John Paul II quote of Pius XII in "Cosmology and Fundamental Physics")

POPE JOHN PAUL II: “Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth; and God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truth – in a word, to know himself – so that, by knowing and loving God, men and women may also come to the fullness of truth about themselves.” (Fides et Ratio [1998], cf. Ex 33:18; Ps 27:8-9; 63:2-3; Jn 14:8; 1 Jn 3:2).
  1. Faith and science: “…methodical research in all branches of knowledge, provided it is carried out in a truly scientific manner and does not override moral laws, can never conflict with the faith, because the things of the world and the things of faith derive from the same God. The humble and persevering investigator of the secrets of nature is being led, as it were, by the hand of God in spite of himself, for it is God, the conserver of all things, who made them what they are.” [Vatican II GS 36:1] (also 283-284)
CARDINAL SCHONBORN: "Now there is another misunderstanding that is constantly found in the ongoing discussion, and I have to deal with it right here at the beginning. I refer to what is called ‘creationism.’ Nowadays the belief in a creator is automatically run together with ‘creationism.’ But in fact to believe in a creator is not the same as trying to understand the six days of creation literally, as six chronological days, and as trying to prove scientifically, with whatever means available, that the earth is 6000 years old. These attempts of certain Christians at taking the Bible absolutely literally, as if it made chronological and scientific statements – I have met defenders of this position who honestly strive to find scientific arguments for it – is called ‘fundamentalism.’ Or more exactly, within American Protestantism this view of the Christian faith originally called itself fundamentalism. Starting from the belief that the Bible is inspired by God, so that every word in it is immediately inspired by Him, the six days of creation are taken in a strict literal way. It is understandable that in the United States many people, using not only kinds of polemics but lawsuits as well, vehemently resist the teaching of creationism in the schools…

“The Catholic position on this is clear. St. Thomas says that ‘one should not try to defend the Christian faith with arguments that are so patently opposed to reason that the faith is made to look ridiculous.’ It is simply nonsense to say that the world is only 6000 years old. To try to prove this scientifically is what St. Thomas calls provoking the irrisio infidelium, the scorn of the unbelievers. It is not right to use such false arguments and to expose the faith to the scorn of unbelievers. This should suffice on the subject of ‘creationism’ and ‘fundamentalism’ for the entire remainder of this catechesis; what we want to say about it should be so clear that we do not have to return to the subject.” (Christoph Cardinal Schonborn, Cat Lec for 11/13/2005)

Clear enough for you?

MERRY CHRISTMAS TO ALL.

Phil P
Nice Job Phil!!! Merry Christmas!! Here is my point. Scientists would say it is impossible for a man to be dead and rise from the dead. Yet you would reject that, and say with God all things are possible, correct? One of the reasons you would say this is because the Church teaches it. My assertion is that official Church statements support creationism, not evolution. Not to mention there are Catholics who (Bob Sungenis being one of them, Kolbe center etc.) who dispute evolution on a scientific basis.

QUESTION PHIL AND OTHERS: Do you believe Jesus actually physically rose from the dead or do you believe it was a spiritual resurrection?
 
Merry Christmas!! Here is my point. Scientists would say it is impossible for a man to be dead and rise from the dead. Yet you would reject that, and say with God all things are possible, correct? One of the reasons you would say this is because the Church teaches it. My assertion is that official Church statements support creationism, not evolution. Not to mention there are Catholics who (Bob Sungenis being one of them, Kolbe center etc.) who dispute evolution on a scientific basis.
Well, the Vatican teaches creationism and other miracle stories as fact. This is indisputable.
QUESTION PHIL AND OTHERS: Do you believe Jesus actually physically rose from the dead or do you believe it was a spiritual resurrection?
As for Jesus or any other person coming back to life after being executed and dead for several days, Jesus is a legendary cultural invention like Hercules or William Tell or other heroes. And as one who knows there are no such things as spirits, I have to answer neither. Culturally speaking, however, I can understand why people invest so much faith in these stories of spirits and superheroes.

Merry Christmas Everyone!
 
Roger << Do you believe Jesus actually physically rose from the dead or do you believe it was a spiritual resurrection? >>

Yes, bodily resurrection. And the books of N.T. Wright and William Lane Craig and Peter Kreeft (and other apologists) have shown it is reasonable to believe.

We can ask further questions about what happened after the resurrection. What is the precise nature of the resurrection body? Can it age? Does it need food? Does it need blood? Can it be destroyed with a chainsaw or crushed with a large object? Is it flammable? Is it truly immortal, etc. And where did Jesus “go” and where does Jesus “live” after the ascension? What does the “right hand of the Father” mean? Those are separate issues and some of these are covered in the Craig debates (especially Craig vs. Cavin, and Craig vs. Ludemann)

To continue discussion, I think we need a clear definition of:

SCIENCE is xxxxxxxx…
(i.e. relates to measurable, observable, testable things)

DOGMA is xxxxxxx…
(i.e. relates to doctrines on faith and morals only)

Once those are clearly defined, I don’t think most Catholics in here would have much disagreement.

Phil P
 
Roger << Do you believe Jesus actually physically rose from the dead or do you believe it was a spiritual resurrection? >>

Yes, bodily resurrection. And the books of N.T. Wright and William Lane Craig and Peter Kreeft (and other apologists) have shown it is reasonable to believe.

We can ask further questions about what happened after the resurrection. What is the precise nature of the resurrection body? Can it age? Does it need food? Does it need blood? Can it be destroyed with a chainsaw or crushed with a large object? Is it flammable? Is it truly immortal, etc. And where did Jesus “go” and where does Jesus “live” after the ascension? What does the “right hand of the Father” mean? Those are separate issues and some of these are covered in the Craig debates (especially Craig vs. Cavin, and Craig vs. Ludemann)

To continue discussion, I think we need a clear definition of:

SCIENCE is xxxxxxxx…
(i.e. relates to measurable, observable, testable things)

DOGMA is xxxxxxx…
(i.e. relates to doctrines on faith and morals only)

Once those are clearly defined, I don’t think most Catholics in here would have much disagreement.

Phil P
Ok Phil so you believe that JESUS actually bodily rose from the dead after he was dead for three days. SCIENCE says it is impossible for a man to do that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top