Boston bomber killed

  • Thread starter Thread starter latin_rite
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
what’s the precedent? there were killers on the loose, the cops flooded in, killed one, arrested another, and went back to their cop shops. this is called an “emergency”.

so what has been “accepted”?

F/
He meant, that one lone guy or the search for him, shut down an ENTIRE large metropolitan area, Boston became a police state, and everyone there simply accepted that it was the right way to go about this. There was no need for the entire city to be on lock-down, that was an over-reaction to a manageable manhunt.
 
He meant, that one lone guy or the search for him, shut down an ENTIRE large metropolitan area, Boston became a police state, and everyone there simply accepted that it was the right way to go about this. There was no need for the entire city to be on lock-down, that was an over-reaction to a manageable manhunt.
Definitely an overreaction. It could also be argued that it made things worse. The guy wasn’t caught until people were allowed outside and somebody saw movement in that backyard. More pairs of eyes able to look for him is better than fewer.
 
He meant, that one lone guy or the search for him, shut down an ENTIRE large metropolitan area, Boston became a police state, and everyone there simply accepted that it was the right way to go about this. There was no need for the entire city to be on lock-down, that was an over-reaction to a manageable manhunt.
that’s quite an assertion. on what basis, other than hindsight, do you believe that the parameters of the manhunt were excessive? the joint task force didn’t release all the information it had to the public, and of course, they were there on the spot. I seriously doubt your views are held by any but the smallest minority in Boston.

a “police state” is a phrase that connotes east germany, laos, the Soviet Union, where dissenters are shot or sent into the gulags and the conditions like that exist for decades; or late night radio, where its used by k00ks. the presence of a lot of police looking for two armed bombers/killers doesn’t mean “police state”, it means “lots of police.”

F/
 
He meant, that one lone guy or the search for him, shut down an ENTIRE large metropolitan area, Boston became a police state, and everyone there simply accepted that it was the right way to go about this. There was no need for the entire city to be on lock-down, that was an over-reaction to a manageable manhunt.
Jihadists are like cancer, they need to be identified and extracted immediately before it spreads and destroys the entire body. I say zero-tolerance in regards to jihadists. 👍
 
Definitely an overreaction. It could also be argued that it made things worse. The guy wasn’t caught until people were allowed outside and somebody saw movement in that backyard. More pairs of eyes able to look for him is better than fewer.
what is your expertise in police manhunts? I mean, professional training, experience, etc. if you were privy to the same info that the cops were, let me know. everyone’s entitled to an opinion, not all opinions are worth having.

and if you were someone in Boston who stayed indoors for a day this hurt you how?

F/
 
He meant, that one lone guy or the search for him, shut down an ENTIRE large metropolitan area, Boston became a police state, and everyone there simply accepted that it was the right way to go about this. There was no need for the entire city to be on lock-down, that was an over-reaction to a manageable manhunt.
I think was the good thing to do because protects the citizens by making them aware of a great danger in their neighbourhood;
 
Exactly. I’m fully expecting to see the argument “we think there’s a terrorist in the area” to be used in the future to violate our civil liberties even further.
 
Definitely an overreaction. It could also be argued that it made things worse. The guy wasn’t caught until people were allowed outside and somebody saw movement in that backyard. More pairs of eyes able to look for him is better than fewer.
I’ve heard one commenter say, who eventually caught the guy?? Was it the trillions we spend for National Security? No, in the end, it was some guy who spotted that this guy was camping out in his own yard, something to think about.

So I hear people saying things sort of like you did.
 
you can remark all you like about the press as you like in my books and fair play to you…

but i have to say that one step to the ku klux klan remark is way off the mark… that is an act of oppressing people…a leftie trick…it was not really a prayerful tongue or heart that spoke or felt this to Elisabeth was it ?

and btw i think that its taking the focus of what is going on away from what is really needed.the main victims and their family,friends and all those who are close to them…are the ones who need the prayers at this moment and for peace.nothing else…imo…
I’m not into playing tricks whether they be leftie, rightie or middly. I had seen yet another interview and it struck me that had one of my relatives committed such an atrocity, I would be beside myself with horror and the last thing I’d want would be a posse of journalists camped on my doorstep or waylaying me on my way home. I posted a one-line comment asking whether the journalistic tactics made anyone else feel uncomfortable. One person said no and I responded giving the reasons for my discomfiture. Elizabeth seemed to take this as meaning that I felt little or no sympathy for the bomb victims or somehow could slice off sympathy for the victims because I felt sympathy for the relatives. I felt then, and still feel that her remarks were uncalled for…to the extent that they insinuated that I was unfeeling towards the bomb victims. Her remarks were OTT and elicited what you seem to think is an OTT response. Perhaps you (and Elizabeth) wouldn’t be so quick to judge if you read things in context.

I was shocked and appalled by what happened in Boston. I was also shocked that a classmate of one of the bombers had recognised him from the FBI photo and when asked by the TV interviewer had he called the police his response was “No”. He went on to say something to the effect that he didn’t want to cause trouble for his friend. This despite an announcement by the police that he was on camera placing the bomb, he had murdered a police officer and, armed and dangerous, he was on the run. Much as I abhor the parents’ claim that their sons were being framed, some small part of me understands a parent’s disbelief that their child would commit such an atrocity and their instinct to protect their child. I cannot understand the classmate not informing the police of the identity of the bomber.

We can (and I have and do) pray for the victims of this senseless violence. Apart from reiterating my sympathy in every post, how do you suggest that I portray my sympathy as equal to yours and Elizabeth’s? Frankly, I find it a bit sick that we are having any kind of discussion about the measure of sympathy for those who lost their lives or limbs.
 
I’ve heard one commenter say, who eventually caught the guy?? Was it the trillions we spend for National Security? No, in the end, it was some guy who spotted that this guy was camping out in his own yard, something to think about.

So I hear people saying things sort of like you did.
the manhunt eventually ran the guy to earth, like it was supposed to do. questioning the efficiency of the manhunt because a citizen dialed in the final tip doesn’t even begin to make sense. the killer was hiding in the boat because he was out of options.

on one hand, its a “police state” because there are too many cops looking for a pair of killers.

but on the other, there weren’t enough cops because a citizen spotted the guy (although the cops made the arrest after yet another gun battle).

what are we griping about?

F/
 
Exactly. I’m fully expecting to see the argument “we think there’s a terrorist in the area” to be used in the future to violate our civil liberties even further.
ok, you’ve expressed your irrational fears about – terrorists or the police – which one is it? what are you planning to do about them?

F/
 
the manhunt eventually ran the guy to earth, like it was supposed to do. questioning the efficiency of the manhunt because a citizen dialed in the final tip doesn’t even begin to make sense. the killer was hiding in the boat because he was out of options.

on one hand, its a “police state” because there are too many cops looking for a pair of killers.

but on the other, there weren’t enough cops because a citizen spotted the guy (although the cops made the arrest after yet another gun battle).

what are we griping about?

F/
Islamic Terrorism in America that was present in Boston which crippled a city which was taken hostage by evil? BTW Four dead not Three you remember that?

“Four Dead” no? How could you possibly forget that in one day?

BTW do you have a law degree are you are assuming he’ll get life? Pretty sure that’s an assumption. But hey, perhaps you know “for sure”?
 
Islamic Terrorism in America that was present in Boston which crippled a city which was taken hostage by evil? BTW Four dead not Three you remember that?

“Four Dead” no? How could you possibly forget that in one day?

BTW do you have a law degree are you are assuming he’ll get life? Pretty sure that’s an assumption. But hey, perhaps you know “for sure”?
what’s the problem with the number of dead? three not enough for you? the killers injured 180 at the Boston marathon, set off at least three big bombs, several pipe bombs, a grenade, and were involved in gun battles.

I practice criminal law, my guess is that the government will settle for knowing why he did it. if they try him he won’t take the stand and they’ll never know for sure. if they accept a plea bargain, he’ll have to tell everything as part of the plea and the prosecutors will have to be satisfied in advance. I explained that its a guess. it is based on my own experience with prosecutors, and murder defendants, taking pleas and what victims and families want, and how judges sentence.

and your opinion is based on what?

F/
 
Right, wrong number.
my guess, if
That’s what it is. “If” they do or don’t take him to trial .
if they accept a plea bargain,?
If again, you mean “if” he is offered a plea bargain.
he’ll have to tell everything as part of the plea and the prosecutors will have to be satisfied in advance.,
No that’s not how it works Mr Attorney. The plea in court is LAST. After all the talk is done and contingent on “if” the state/feds want to take him to trial. He has “no” lawyer. there is NO DEAL.

I believe your confused, Miranda simply means what he does say, cannot be used in court. But your a lawyer you should know that.
I explained that its a guess.
Many times I see, we have it YOU DO NOT KNOW .
it is based on my own experience with prosecutors, and murder defendants, taking pleas and what victims and families want, and how judges sentence?
.

Good thanks for sharing all your above… “guess” and “if” 👍
and your opinion
Radical Islam is a major problem of course.

What’s your thoughts on Radical Islamic Violence in America in relation to Boston and America?
 
One could argue the hard way, a lesson has been learned and the FBI knew of one of these guys already and did nothing. FBI was warned by a foreign government. Let’s not forget that is what Law Enforcement did as well. We are all on the web and we can all make various claims but in many instances, they can not be proven. I respect one’s word, one’s opinion and if someone says so believe it. Let’s hope that such respect would be reciprocated.
 
…
…
No that’s not how it works Mr Attorney. The plea in court is LAST. After all the talk is done and contingent on “if” the state/feds want to take him trial. He has “no” lawyer. there is NO DEAL. …

What’s your thoughts on going Radical Islamic Violence in America in relation to Boston and America?
ya got me. I left my magic see-the-future-glasses in the office.

regarding criminal procedure, I really don’t know what you’re trying to say. if he doesn’t die first, he’ll have a lawyer before he’s formally charged. he’ll plead not guity. in time, his lawyers will make the deal that the government will take and the NG plea will be withdrawn and he’ll plead guilty. if I telescoped the procedure, sorry, I assumed you knew a little about how guilty pleas work; I guess TV and movies aren’t always that clear.

I’m definitely against Radical Islamic Violence in Boston. and you?

F/
 
No Miranda, nothing he states can be used in court, though, there is so much evidence they may not need it. Aside from his brother “felony murder”

He’s charged State and Federal. thus they could choose which venue they prefer. Federal cannot charge him with Conspiracy and give him the death penalty . The State can in which case NONE of what he states will matter. Follow?

No Lawyer. no legal Plea Agreement. What promise is made I have no idea. Likely he will live since he chose life at the boat. Just my view.
 
Suspect 1 was being handcuffed when his brother ran over him??
The Blog
Amazing New Details from the Chase for the Boston Bombers
11:56 AM, Apr 20, 2013 • By DANIEL HALPER
The police chief of the Watertown police department shares amazing new details of the chase for the Boston bombings suspects from Thursday night into Friday evening:
The police chief, Edward Deveau, describes how cops nearly apprehended the older suspect, and were placing handcuffs on him in the middle of the street Thursday night, when the younger suspect came at officers in a carjacked SUV. The cops were able “to dive out of the way,” and the younger suspect then continued to drive directly over his brother and dragging him through the street. That’s how the older suspect died, according to the police chief.
Now that is what I call tragic. And I’m not wanting to see that picture either. I draw the line.
 
He’s charged State and Federal. thus they could choose which venue they prefer. Federal cannot charge him with Conspiracy and give him the .
he hasn’t been charged. you really don’t understand how this works. but that’s ok, the media will explain it to you over the next few months. don’t be surprised when he gets life.

as Catholics, we’re supposed to want this, right?

F/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top