Boston bomber killed

  • Thread starter Thread starter latin_rite
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I was listening to the police scanner that night, and heard the report from the officers at the scene. He was taken to Beth Israel because the explosive device on his person went off. This was confirmed again when officers were warned to take precautions that suspect number 2 might also be wearing an explosive device.
I heard this also. And the first Doctor stated he had shrapnel and GSWs on his torso. He didn’t mention tire tracks. 🤷
 
I heard this also. And the first Doctor stated he had shrapnel and GSWs on his torso. He didn’t mention tire tracks. 🤷
You also remember they stripped a guy of his clothes, because they thought he might be suspect number 2. This was to check for the explosive device. That guy was later released. He was just in the wrong place at the wrong time. Everyone I know has been joking that he will forever be known as “nekkid guy”. :rotfl:
 
You also remember they stripped a guy of his clothes, because they thought he might be suspect number 2. This was to check for the explosive device. That guy was later released. He was just in the wrong place at the wrong time. Everyone I know has been joking that he will forever be known as “nekkid guy”. :rotfl:
:bigyikes:
 
I was listening to the police scanner that night…
you’re still lucky then. many agencies have gone over to digital encrypted, so the average citizen can’t listen in anymore. no more nights of the “prostitute chasers channel”. you’re still on VHF?

F/
 
you’re still lucky then. many agencies have gone over to digital encrypted, so the average citizen can’t listen in anymore. no more nights of the “prostitute chasers channel”. you’re still on VHF?

F/
I used Broadcastify.

broadcastify.com/listen/feed/6254

At one point over 80,000 people were listening. Many people have been getting together to monitor broadcasts and take notes. Often they compare notes after the event to see if the news is being reported accurately. We knew what was going on hours before CNN first reported it on air, and alerted one another as each news station mentioned it on the television.

Other people use Tune In:
tunein.com/radio/Boston-Police-Fire-and-EMS-Scanner-s146109/
 
I used Broadcastify.

broadcastify.com/listen/feed/6254

At one point over 80,000 people were listening. Many people have been getting together to monitor broadcasts and take notes. Often they compare notes after the event to see if the news is being reported accurately. We knew what was going on hours before CNN first reported it on air, and alerted one another as each news station mentioned it on the television.

Other people use Tune In:
tunein.com/radio/Boston-Police-Fire-and-EMS-Scanner-s146109/
CNN’s status, what little it still had, took a serious thumping during this. I don’t think they got a single thing right in the first day…all in the pursuit of being first with the big scoop.
 
I used Broadcastify.

broadcastify.com/listen/feed/6254

At one point over 80,000 people were listening. Many people have been getting together to monitor broadcasts and take notes. Often they compare notes after the event to see if the news is being reported accurately. We knew what was going on hours before CNN first reported it on air, and alerted one another as each news station mentioned it on the television.

Other people use Tune In:
tunein.com/radio/Boston-Police-Fire-and-EMS-Scanner-s146109/
Broadcastify is very good but they pulled the Boston area police feeds during the search. Some guy in Boston had his own scanner and set up a feed of it that had 3 million viewers on at one point.
 
CNN’s status, what little it still had, took a serious thumping during this. I don’t think they got a single thing right in the first day…all in the pursuit of being first with the big scoop.
They were pretty bad. They were reporting “More explosions heard in Watertown!” when the police used flashbangs (which they even said they were going to do over the scanner). It was hopefully a wake up call for the public about sensationalist journalism.
 
Broadcastify is very good but they pulled the Boston area police feeds during the search. Some guy in Boston had his own scanner and set up a feed of it that had 3 million viewers on at one point.
That’s why it’s essential to have multiple resources and use social networks to communicate with others who are also listening. Fortunately, the feed wasn’t pulled until after I went to bed. 👍
 
I was shocked and appalled by what happened in Boston.
I was neither. I watched the news with interest that afternoon though. I don’t know if that makes me a spectator or not. The only one I honestly recall having any feelings for when I was first watching and listening to the news was the little boy. I thought that was awfully tragic.

I’m sure it was and is tragic for all the other few victims killed and those maimed or injured but I did not immediately feel anything for them. I see no reason to pretend about it either.

For the record, I’m 99.99% of the time the same way when I listen to all the violent injuries and murders in the local news, or magnify that to all the cities of the United States. Maybe one would call it desensitized.
I was also shocked that a classmate of one of the bombers had recognised him from the FBI photo and when asked by the TV interviewer had he called the police his response was “No”. He went on to say something to the effect that he didn’t want to cause trouble for his friend. This despite an announcement by the police that he was on camera placing the bomb, he had murdered a police officer and, armed and dangerous, he was on the run.
Now this does not shock me. The first I’m hearing of it is now. I haven’t been following much of the Boston case on the news. I quickly lost interest after a while. Maybe if the death toll was higher I would been more intrigued and my interest more sustained. I dunno.

I know some people don’t like to “drop dimes” or “snitch” on people especially if they are distrustful of the law or government. But I wasn’t in the mind of this guy, so, I can’t say exactly what his concerns, fears, or doubts were about making a call to identify his friend. Maybe he though, “What if my friend is innocent and I put him through pain and years in prison for something he didn’t do?”
Much as I abhor the parents’ claim that their sons were being framed, some small part of me understands a parent’s disbelief that their child would commit such an atrocity and their instinct to protect their child. I cannot understand the classmate not informing the police of the identity of the bomber.
I don’t know why you abhor this. Maybe we are cut from different street corners? I felt absolutely nothing about hearing the father doubt his sons could actually do this. I was most sympathetic and empathetic to the aunt of the young men. She seemed very honest, level headed, and authentic. She did not say for 100% her nephews were innocent, she just said it’s hard for her to imagine her nephews would do this, and that she doubts it, but if they did do it and the evidence is there, let her take all that in and then allow her natural and resulting emotions to be expressed. That’s basically what she said.

I really didn’t care for the uncle’s belittling of his nephews though. He was primarily concerned with the family name and how this would effect him and his family. I’m not sure there is much that could get me to disown or publicly belittle my nephews. I love my nephews more than all the combined citizens of the United States, Canada, and Mexico. The whole city of Boston would have to go up in flames, every tower in New York City would have to come crumbling down before I disown my nephews. That’s how much I love mine.
We can (and I have and do) pray for the victims of this senseless violence. Apart from reiterating my sympathy in every post, how do you suggest that I portray my sympathy as equal to yours and Elizabeth’s? Frankly, I find it a bit sick that we are having any kind of discussion about the measure of sympathy for those who lost their lives or limbs.
The death of the little boy bothers me most. That and this 19 year old kid about to lose his life. He’ll do life in prison. And for what? I don’t understand why he and his brother did this. It would make more sense to me if they had nothing.

I don’t really feel anything for his older brother. Although I was intrigued that he was a boxer. I felt some slight connection to him since I did a little training in boxing. He seemed to have a whole life ahead of him. He wasn’t n ugly looking dude either. And younger brother had his whole life ahead of him too. I honestly don’t get these people with a good amount going for them, advanced and doctoral degrees, doing mass assaults and/or mass killings.

It’s easier for me to reconcile it in my mind if they were people with little to no hope of a “future” for themselves.

I understand rage, resentment, and even injustice. But if you’ve got some reasonable hope in a future for yourself, channel all that into “getting back” by acquiring a great and happy future for yourself. What “haters” hate most is to see you happy and doing well.

That would be my advice to young Muslim men that have been treated poorly or unfairly by Western people. Develop a good life for yourself. Get a good looking wife, drive a BMW, and get a job paying you enough to buy that mansion you want. That’s the best revenge you could ever get if you’re after revenge.

But back to the little boy. I’m sure he’s in heaven now. So, my sad feelings for them are due more to my human weakness, because if what I and many believe about heaven is true, he has gained his eternal reward and happiness, embraced and now protected by God and the Holy Mother. It is his parents and loved ones on earth who will now carry the greater burden of the tragic lose of his life. And losing a child (to life in prison, death, or abduction) has to be one of the greatest sorrows on earth.
 
I’m shocked at our human capacity to inflict evil and I hope I will never be desensitised to it. I felt profound sadness for all those people plunged from joy to terror in minutes, changing forever the lives of those bereaved and injured. I know the awful desperation of trying to find out whether a loved one is a victim and my heart goes out to all those who were in Boston on that terrible day. I couldn’t drag myself away from the TV as the entire tragedy unfolded. I actually fell asleep waiting to see if the bomber would surrender.

I suppose our own life’s experiences influence how we react to any given set of circumstance. The bombers’ relatives may have had very negative experiences at the hands of the Russian authorities, but I don’t know how they could transfer that negativity to the law enforcement agencies of a country that had given them asylum. (Incidentally, I have never heard of people who had been granted asylum going back and forth between their adopted country and the country they had fled). It makes no sense for him to continue lashing out against the US and I don’t see how he could expect it to help his son. I suppose trauma makes people irrational.

Do you think you would be so staunch in your defence of your nephews if you were an immigrant in the country where they had caused such mayhem and you were terrified of being linked to the atrocity? Much as you love your nephews, do you love them enough to jeopardise your own family’s wellbeing? (I’m assuming the uncles have children of their own).

The aunt in Canada could afford to adopt a different stance from a safe distance. I got the distinct impression that they all knew there was something amiss with the two young men although maybe not to the extent that they were terrorists. I still can’t figure out how the journalists got to her so quickly. Maybe she contacted them…but why would she do that? I’m sure she said that she had been a lawyer, and I imagine a lawyer’s instincts would be to wait until she had all the facts before saying anything.

Another innocent victim of this terrible act is the child of the older bomber. Imaging growing up with the knowledge that your father was the most hated man in town. Everyone is saying that he was the chief culprit, but the younger brother was cold hearted enough to go partying after committing murder.

I don’t know how the little boy’s family will ever recover from this. As if grief wasn’t enough, they have serious injuries to contend with. God help them.

I hope that the bomber is not executed because (a) I believe that capital punishment is about vengeance rather than justice; (b) he’s young enough to learn that what he did was evil and to repent; and (c) because it could turn him into a martyr for some twisted cause.
 
For the record, I’m 99.99% of the time the same way when I listen to all the violent injuries and murders in the local news, or magnify that to all the cities of the United States. Maybe one would call it desensitized…Maybe if the death toll was higher I would been more intrigued and my interest more sustained. I dunno.
And for the record, as Christians we are called upon to become sensitized to our brothers and sisters everywhere, including to complete strangers, and to people with whom we seem on the surface to share little iin come.

Fir the record also, I will admit that I was once just like you – unable to whip up much pathos for the many individual sufferings across the country or across the world – until I myself suffered a significant tragedy, which then transformed me (in that department). Until then, I usually had dificulty “relating” to the events. Personal grief, however, made that possible. I also think that’s true for many people, not just me.
It’s easier for me to reconcile it in my mind if they were people with little to no hope of a “future” for themselves…I understand rage, resentment, and even injustice. But if you’ve got some reasonable hope in a future for yourself, channel all that into “getting back” by acquiring a great and happy future for yourself. What “haters” hate most is to see you happy and doing well. ,That would be my advice to young Muslim men that have been treated poorly or unfairly by Western people. Develop a good life for yourself. Get a good looking wife, drive a BMW, and get a job paying you enough to buy that mansion you want. That’s the best revenge you could ever get if you’re after revenge.
Having read what I have read, I don’t think it has anything to do with economics. I think it has everything to do with identity — personal, ethnic, and national.

The prominent subtexts of the lives of the bombers were two, the first was their Chechnyen identity, experience, and history, relative to Russia, how that became a Cause for their ethnic group overseas, which was then exploited by fundamentalist Muslims aligning themselves with terrorist groups.

The second, The Elephant in the Room, is what too many Americans and too many Catholic Americans find too un-PC to discuss: how immigration itself can become highly problematic for situations such as theirs. In the last week there have already been two articles in the NYT about how the older son despised Americans, was never able to transition to a new culture, and how that restlessness played out. Key to this was the gap in age between the brothers. While the younger one was raised mostly here, the older one was brought to this country while still forming an identity, especially an identity relative to his ethnic and national loyalties.

It is very myopic of U.S. natives to assume that “everyone wants to come here,” or that everyone will eventualy love it here, let alone that it will be good for them. the assumption is almost always that materialism is as profound a motivation, and as porfound a cure, for whatever ails the immigrant, as Americans assume (usually wrongly) for themselves.

Ethnic, national, and religious ties – and the identities those imply – are more complex and sometimes more determinative – than many Americans, too focused as we are on economics, choose to notice, let alone acknowledge. Again, important article in this weekend’s NYT on this, profiling several other troubled terrorists in this country,and would-be terrorists who were not able to separate from their roots overseas, often despite economic success here.

And the Muslim threat, in relationship to all this, is real. I’m talking, of course, about the extremists, but that goes without saying. Peaceful, mainstream Muslims are not building pressure-cooker bombs; those Moms are home making pressure-cooker meals. The oppotunity for exploitation of young men with vulnerable, still unformed identities, or those who have not made the transition to a comfortable and settled bicultural, bi-national self, is enormous, and until the U.S. wakes up to this, we will continue to be at risk.

Finally, TE, it’s not fair for you to insinuate what you assume the uncle’s motives to be (selfish, saving the family name). The Christian mandate is to make the most generous assumption about him, not the least generous and most suspicious.
 
That would be my advice to young Muslim men that have been treated poorly or unfairly by Western people. Develop a good life for yourself. Get a good looking wife, drive a BMW, and get a job paying you enough to buy that mansion you want. That’s the best revenge you could ever get if you’re after revenge.
That’s not what drives ideologues, especially Muslims who believe that Islam demands everything of them, including death. It’s their hatred for all things Western that drives them. Adopting our lifestyle means WE have won, not Allah. In the Middle East, the terrorist organizations will pay the family of a martyr which gives them the means to survive (unemployment and poverty are real problems) AND raises their status. Hard not to respond to that pull. The ones who come here, to America, tend NOT to assimilate.
 
That’s not what drives ideologues, especially Muslims who believe that Islam demands everything of them, including death. It’s their hatred for all things Western that drives them. Adopting our lifestyle means WE have won, not Allah. In the Middle East, the terrorist organizations will pay the family of a martyr which gives them the means to survive (unemployment and poverty are real problems) AND raises their status. Hard not to respond to that pull. The ones who come here, to America, tend NOT to assimilate.

Robert Pape offers a counter-view

Code:
Pape's strong conclusion is that religious fundamentalism is NOT the source of suicide bombings or terrorism. "What nearly all suicide terrorist attacks have in common is a specific secular and strategic goal: to compel modern democracies to withdraw military forces from territory that the terrorists consider to be their homeland." This is true in Sri Lanka, it is true in the Middle East (where many terrorist groups consider themselves secular rather than religious) and, yes, in Iraq, where former Baathist supporters of Saddam Hussein may use Islam as a cover and even a recruiting tool, but are motivated by clear political objectives: the pressure the US to leave Iraq so that the way will be clear for their own return to power. Worldwide, the struggle is about power and politics, not religion.
So it’s a counter view, this doesn’t change the fact that it seems when these things happen they will often cry out “Allahu Akbar”.
 

Robert Pape offers a counter-view


So it’s a counter view, this doesn’t change the fact that it seems when these things happen they will often cry out “Allahu Akbar”.
There are many motives for terrorism, and we will never know all of them. The terrorists themselves may not even be conscious of all of their motivations. I just pointed out that in some cases, it is a matter of taking care of their families and raising their own and their family’s status with their own martyred death. That’s something we Westerners have a hard time understanding, but as a young Arab male, that’s a career path. Our sons and daughters go to graduate school and apply for corporate jobs; their sons and daughters strap on suicide vests and go to Allah in a blaze of glory.
 
I don’t know about a counter view, perhaps part of the larger picture. Sharia Law as practiced in areas such as Egypt, Iran and so forth is diametrically opposed to US thinking.
 
There are many motives for terrorism, and we will never know all of them. The terrorists themselves may not even be conscious of all of their motivations. I just pointed out that in some cases, it is a matter of taking care of their families and raising their own and their family’s status with their own martyred death. That’s something we Westerners have a hard time understanding, but as a young Arab male, that’s a career path. Our sons and daughters go to graduate school and apply for corporate jobs; their sons and daughters strap on suicide vests and go to Allah in a blaze of glory.
That’s a bit of a broadbrush stroke, you have some suicide bombers, 9/11 that were Saudis, you have had Palestinians do it in the past but now it is Arab males. Also, those in Afghanistan and Pakistan would not be Arabs.

Which brings us to the point that the most extreme Islamic regime in the world, at least along with Iran is probably Saudi Arabia. And who supports them? Uncle Sam.
 
I don’t know about a counter view, perhaps part of the larger picture. Sharia Law as practiced in areas such as Egypt, Iran and so forth is diametrically opposed to US thinking.
Yes, it is just part of a larger view and I doubt very much that there’s a one size fits all solution to it.

When I see the US pumping money into countries like Pakistan, I wonder are they just throwing money down the drain. I suppose they are doing whatever it takes to protect American interests abroad but maybe the money would be better spent on taking care of things at home. There’s another thread on here about an incident at a New York subway station. Such disaffected youngsters (in Britain they are described as the underclass) are meat and drink to terrorist organisations.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top