For the record, I’m 99.99% of the time the same way when I listen to all the violent injuries and murders in the local news, or magnify that to all the cities of the United States. Maybe one would call it desensitized…Maybe if the death toll was higher I would been more intrigued and my interest more sustained. I dunno.
And for the record, as Christians we are called upon to become sensitized to our brothers and sisters everywhere, including to complete strangers, and to people with whom we seem on the surface to share little iin come.
Fir the record also, I will admit that I was once just like you – unable to whip up much pathos for the many individual sufferings across the country or across the world – until I myself suffered a significant tragedy, which then transformed me (in that department). Until then, I usually had dificulty “relating” to the events. Personal grief, however, made that possible. I also think that’s true for many people, not just me.
It’s easier for me to reconcile it in my mind if they were people with little to no hope of a “future” for themselves…I understand rage, resentment, and even injustice. But if you’ve got some reasonable hope in a future for yourself, channel all that into “getting back” by acquiring a great and happy future for yourself. What “haters” hate most is to see you happy and doing well. ,That would be my advice to young Muslim men that have been treated poorly or unfairly by Western people. Develop a good life for yourself. Get a good looking wife, drive a BMW, and get a job paying you enough to buy that mansion you want. That’s the best revenge you could ever get if you’re after revenge.
Having read what I have read, I don’t think it has anything to do with economics. I think it has everything to do with identity — personal, ethnic, and national.
The prominent subtexts of the lives of the bombers were two, the first was their Chechnyen identity, experience, and history, relative to Russia, how that became a Cause for their ethnic group overseas, which was then exploited by fundamentalist Muslims aligning themselves with terrorist groups.
The second, The Elephant in the Room, is what too many Americans and too many Catholic Americans find too un-PC to discuss: how immigration itself can become highly problematic for situations such as theirs. In the last week there have already been two articles in the NYT about how the older son despised Americans, was never able to transition to a new culture, and how that restlessness played out. Key to this was the gap in age between the brothers. While the younger one was raised mostly here, the older one was brought to this country
while still forming an identity, especially an identity relative to his ethnic and national loyalties.
It is very myopic of U.S. natives to assume that “everyone wants to come here,” or that everyone will eventualy love it here, let alone that it will be good for them. the assumption is almost always that materialism is as profound a motivation, and as porfound a cure, for whatever ails the immigrant, as Americans assume (usually wrongly) for themselves.
Ethnic, national, and religious ties – and the identities those imply – are more complex and sometimes more determinative – than many Americans, too focused as we are on economics, choose to notice, let alone acknowledge. Again, important article in this weekend’s NYT on this, profiling several other troubled terrorists in this country,and would-be terrorists who were not able to separate from their roots overseas, often despite economic success here.
And the Muslim threat, in relationship to all this, is real. I’m talking, of course, about the extremists, but that goes without saying. Peaceful, mainstream Muslims are not building pressure-cooker bombs; those Moms are home making pressure-cooker meals. The oppotunity for exploitation of young men with vulnerable, still unformed identities, or those who have not made the transition to a comfortable and settled bicultural, bi-national self, is enormous, and until the U.S. wakes up to this, we will continue to be at risk.
Finally, TE, it’s not fair for you to insinuate what you assume the uncle’s motives to be (selfish, saving the family name). The Christian mandate is to make the most generous assumption about him, not the least generous and most suspicious.