Can I raise this child if I'm not the father?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Thomasbelby27
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree with this. I don’t think they owe the one-night-stand man anything at all. The OP is going to be the child’s father, and even the law presumes that he is. Tracking down the guy helps absolutely no one–not the child, not the OP, and not his wife. I don’t believe there is any moral duty toward this man.
It’s not about owing the one-night-stand man anything, it’s about trying to consider the feelings of the child. I disagree that it won’t help the child at all to try and find out more about the man’s background. And yes, he might just refuse to acknowledge the possibility, etc, but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t try.

I think I would feel very strange going through life not knowing where half of me came from…but that’s just me.
 
It seems I haven’t posted here in so long my original account is gone. However this thread pulled me back.

I am frankly amazed at the number of blasphemous answers here. To the com mentors that have referenced St Joseph and Mary May God judge you for speaking as you do.

St Joseph was not cheated and Mary did not have a one night stand. To even imply that is to betray the faith and sully the name of both of these saints. The OP has -nothing- to do with Mary or Joseph. Please stop calling what is good evil.

There has also been a stunning lack of Bible centered advise. People have been preaching feel good rather than truth.

To those who claim the child is innocent and therefore no harm can befall it have you forgotten Deut 23:2?
“2 A bastard shall not enter into the congregation of the Lord; even to his tenth generation shall he not enter into the congregation of the Lord.”

While it is true the child is not formally at fault the OPs wife’s perversion has created an unholy thing that only God can put right. She became “one flesh” with a man that was not her husband. The false allusions to Joseph and Mary are understandable given that such behavior is nowhere treated as acceptable in Scripture or Tradition. The devil after all has to find some foothold for his argument.

The closest we have is actually Hosea who marries a whore and who names his children “not pitied” and “not my people”. Let that sink in a moment.

My advice is this:
  1. Your wife lied to not just you but God. Do not be so cavalier about forgiveness. A woman who betrays the virtue of her sex for a one night stand has likely done so in the past and will likely do so in the future. Again meditate on Hosea and Gomer. It is possible to love those you do not trust but you need not trust them again.
  2. Our society doesn’t like talking about bastards, even the supposedly religious, because it removes the responsibility of licentiousness. If you raise him be aware that your wife’s behavior has marked him for all time. Working through that can be difficult but rewarding.
  3. Adopting the child does not mean you must accept back your wife. She made her decisions and is responsible for them. Note I am -not- arguing for remarriage. You will if you chose this path forgo sexual relations. It is survivable. If you don’t think it is you may have to go back to your wife.
  4. Stop acting like a little girl. It is your job to defend and provide for the family. That is not a " fault". Your wife betrayed you and her faith. Stop acting like you did. It cheapens any forgiveness you might give and makes you look like a joke. God made men manly and your posts here are anything but. Jesus did not raise up the prostitute and tell everyone it was his fault he said, “sin no more”. Try acting more like Jesus and less like a dishrag. The next time you catch yourself apologizing for working hard tell yourself to man up.
 
Look at the different responses that are given if it is a man at fault for the same situation, LOL. Completely opposite of what they are advising here.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=873039

“Hon, first of all, do NOT accept his attempts to blame you for his sin!”

“I can only agree that he has to take full responsibility for his failure of loyalty trust and his vows.”

"Please do not allow your husband to guilt you into thinking you were somehow responsible for him committing this sin. The blame is ALL on him, NOT YOU. "

“If you took the child it would be a reminder of your husbands unfaithfulness to his marriage vows every time you looked at the child innocent as the child is, best bet is to get your husband to step up to the plate instead of trying the oldest trick in the book blaming someone else for his failings and lust”

“Don’t let anyone force you take a baby that is not yours”

“Cheating makes me livid. My husband knows that if he cheats, I’m gone (or he is dead because I’m a deadly shot).”

“Let’s say she let’s her husband bully her into taking the child in, and she finds she simply can’t treat him/her the same as the other children”

“Have you considered the possibility of an STD? You should get tested”
 
Just like me I don’t think they are being disrespectful, they are trying to wake the person up to reality.

I was not suggesting that I knew more about Thomasbelby27’s wife or family, it is ultimately his decision, he asked for advice and I am trying to be honest with how I respond.

It is simply a fact that cheating spouses generally have a habit of that type of behavior. And for women, when they cheat it is usually because they have already left the relationship and are not attracted to their husband any longer, it is a quite severe situation. More than the OP realizes.
 
Thomas: A number of posters have said it is important to track down the biological father. May I offer yet another differing opinion?

Your wife became pregnant due to a (sorry for the slang) “one-night stand”. For you two to spend a lot of time to track down a man who may likely be totally shocked and disappointed that this ever happened seems to be, possibly, a waste of energy. With all that you are going through, how much energy to you have to spare? Your wife’s guilt feelings would be dredged up all over again. I could almost guarantee that the biological father is not going to respond with a whole bunch of loving, financial, or emotional support. He’s going to be wishing you two are just a figment of his imagination and would quietly go away. He may a family of his own to deal with, or even multiple families.

You may think its necessary to track him down “for the medical history” or some such, but realize that many, many people did not have their family tree and medical histories in their lifetimes and they got along OK. And if you are think that the bio-dad has “rights” that need to be dealt with, you are overthinking this.

Don’t mean to be discouraging…just hoping you are concentrating on the more important issues: you and your wife’s relationship healing, her maternal health, and general adjustment to becoming parents.
I have to reiterate the opinion to locate the birthfather; not out of duty to him (although, it can be argued that there is a duty), but out of a duty to the child. True, many people do not have their medical history, but does that make it right? Especially when the opportunity is available for that biological history to be available with just a little effort?

You might think I’ve gotten along ok without my medical history, but you’d be an outsider looking in, and you’d be wrong. I don’t discuss how much it hurts, even just a little bit, when I have to tell my doctor ‘no medical history’…when my kids are being tested for possible deadly diseases, and again say, no medical history, because of my adoption. When I’m in the hospital with major heart malfunction, and saying, ‘no medical history’. Just because it happens and people think it’s not a big deal, doesn’t mean that they are right.

And it’s possible that he has other children; what if one of them, or I, had a life or death issue that could be solved by a biological member of the ‘other’ family. I’d have grave guilt if I could have saved someone’s life, but couldn’t, since we didn’t know each other at the time, but found out later.

It’s not about having another ‘daddy’ in the picture, or even different siblings.

“Sorry baby B; we loved you so much we wanted to keep you, even though we could have found your birthfather, but chose not to; we didn’t care about your medical future, nor your children, our grandchildren’s medical future, because it was uncomfortable for us to face him. Our short term uncomfortableness trumps your biological/medical needs of a lifetime.”

On another note, this gentleman has chosen at this time, to be the baby’s father. What happens down the line may or may not have happened with or without this child. I’m appalled and saddened at those of you calling him names, questioning his manhood, simply because you couldn’t do what he is doing. He is doing what is right in HIS eyes, and what he believes is right in God’s eyes. You might want to take a look at yourselves and why this bothers YOU so much. Are you jealous of his strength? Have you made a different decision and now regret it? So you’re taking it out on a stranger who is reaching out on the internet for support? He has been remarkably patient, kind to all the responses here, even the hateful ones. I don’t know what I’d do in that situation, and I pray I am never put to the test.

OP, there may be a point that this would be wise to leave this thread, if at any time you feel it is drawing you down, influencing you negatively, and quits helping you get through this. God bless and keep both you and your wife, and the child, during the difficult times ahead.
 
Look at the different responses that are given if it is a man at fault for the same situation, LOL. Completely opposite of what they are advising here.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=873039

“Hon, first of all, do NOT accept his attempts to blame you for his sin!”

“I can only agree that he has to take full responsibility for his failure of loyalty trust and his vows.”

"Please do not allow your husband to guilt you into thinking you were somehow responsible for him committing this sin. The blame is ALL on him, NOT YOU. "

“If you took the child it would be a reminder of your husbands unfaithfulness to his marriage vows every time you looked at the child innocent as the child is, best bet is to get your husband to step up to the plate instead of trying the oldest trick in the book blaming someone else for his failings and lust”

“Don’t let anyone force you take a baby that is not yours”

“Cheating makes me livid. My husband knows that if he cheats, I’m gone (or he is dead because I’m a deadly shot).”

“Let’s say she let’s her husband bully her into taking the child in, and she finds she simply can’t treat him/her the same as the other children”

“Have you considered the possibility of an STD? You should get tested”
All of these are rather appropriate responses. The problem is they weren’t applied here. You are also right Holly that the wife has likely checked out of this marriage. Even the OP makes this clear. She didn’t go to the bar because she wanted to hang out, she went alone so that she could get drunk and reduce her responsibility when she picked up a guy. This is problematic on so many levels since it shows premeditation.

She -chose- to cheat in the OP. This was not a mistake. This was not random. She did not go out with the girls and wake up pregnant. She wanted a kid and she went out and made one God and husband be damned. This is what makes it so serious.
 
To those who claim the child is innocent and therefore no harm can befall it have you forgotten Deut 23:2?
“2 A bastard shall not enter into the congregation of the Lord; even to his tenth generation shall he not enter into the congregation of the Lord.”
I believe that the Bible is wrong on this point. In our neighborhood, there is a family with several children. One of them is a beautiful young girl who is obviously of mixed race. No one even gives this a second thought and everyone that I know only speaks well of her. She is completely accepted just as she is and no one is forbidding her anything on account of her parentage.
 
If St Joseph’s wife had done what the OP’s wife has done, St Joseph would have divorced her. Interesting comparison.
 
An innocent child is an “unholy thing,” marked for all time? A man who, like God, forgives a transgression against him is a “little girl?” And that’s considered an insulting term?

Once again an answer on CAF leaves me wondering why I would want to share a religion with people who feel like this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top