B
Br.Rich_SFO
Guest
No.Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?
–Mike
No.Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?
–Mike
Now, how would the Pope “renounce” the Catholic faith? If the Pope attempted to promulgate false doctrine ex cathedra, God would strike him dead. If, however, he decided to submit himself to the teaching of a Protestant pastor, it seems that that would qualify as him officially stepping down as Pope.What would the Church do then, if someone became Pope, but while he was Pope, he renounced theCathlic faith for Protestantism? If the Church has no power to excommunicate that pope, then what would happen if that pope made an Ex Cathedra pronouncement that say, Sola Scriptura is no longer a heresy, but a dogma, or the same about OSAS?
Actually he said he didn’t know whether there was one or two operators/wills. In these letters it looks like he didn’t seem to think it mattered. He did think that Jesus’ humanity had one will, not two (but I think that was to say Jesus didn’t have the negative tendency to sin that we have in us).Theoretically I believe it could be done by the bishops acting in unison and through unanimous consent with sufficient objective data and cause.
Pope Honorious I was anathemized about 40 years posthumously after there was later discovered private letters showing his tacit (silent) support of a heretical teaching for purposes of maintaining unity between two opposing sects.
This sheds some light on Honorius.Actually he said he didn’t know whether there was one or two operators/wills. In these letters it looks like he didn’t seem to think it mattered. He did think that Jesus’ humanity had one will, not two (but I think that was to say Jesus didn’t have the negative tendency to sin that we have in us).
Yes, a Pope can be excommunicated by another Pope. (Don’t laugh, it’s happened.)Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?
When and who? How could you have two, sitting, legitimate popes?Yes, a Pope can be excommunicated by another Pope. (Don’t laugh, it’s happened.)
Well, of course, when you have multiple Popes you are in a situation where legitimacy is a matter of serious debate.When and who? How could you have two, sitting, legitimate popes?
In that case, wouldn’t you have one pope and two men, excommunicating each other?Well, of course, when you have multiple Popes you are in a situation where legitimacy is a matter of serious debate.
The most notorious example was the Papal Schism:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Schism
Three popes each excommunicating the other two. Yikes!
In the eyes of God, perhaps. But human affairs tend to be messier.In that case, wouldn’t you have one pope and two men, excommunicating each other?
Found it! (No idea how it got there!) Can’t say that I find anything really helpful beyond the citations in the Davies article.I can’t find my Code of Canon Law right now, but I know it’s here somewhere. . . .
Excommunication automatically incurs deposition. Every ancient canon of the Church asserts as much. Also, in another thread just recently, it was noted that the Pope during the Council of Trent wrote a bull that repeated the ancient sentences of excommunication/deposition on clerics, even Popes, who have fallen into heresy. The bull had a declaration that its should be in effect for all time.Being legally excommunicated and being deposed from the papacy are two different issues. A pope could theoretically incur automatic excommunication by - say - being a formal heretic. No body of the Church would have the legitimate ecclesiastical authority to depose him though.
Could you please provide the sources for that? Thanks.Dear brother tdgesq,
Excommunication automatically incurs deposition. Every ancient canon of the Church asserts as much.
I would like to see that bull. I don’t recall ever reading it.Also, in another thread just recently, it was noted that the Pope during the Council of Trent wrote a bull that repeated the ancient sentences of excommunication/deposition on clerics, even Popes, who have fallen into heresy. The bull had a declaration that its should be in effect for all time.
In light of the article cited in #55, I’ll share the thought that occurred to me as soon as I read the above sentence.The bull had a declaration that its should be in effect for all time.
I don’t have time for research right now. After next Tuesday. Please be patient with me.Could you please provide the sources for that? Thanks.
It’s here: forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=4623356&postcount=1I would like to see that bull. I don’t recall ever reading it.
Typically when one bishop excommunicates another bishop, even if that bishop is the Pope, this simply means that they are no longer in communion with each other. However since you also say “depose the Pope and elect a new one”, that’s a much different matter. Since 1423, under Pope Martin V (1417-1431), the only authority great enough to depose a Pope is the Pope himself. But before that time there were actual cases where popes were deposed by Synod of Bishops in Rome. Benedict IX (1047-1048), for example, served three separate terms as Pope and was deposed two times as well, by the Council of Sutri. After his last deposition this Pope was also “excommunicated” by the Council of Sutri! Here is the chronology of Pope Benedict IX:Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?
–Mike