Can the Pope be excommunicated?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mpartyka
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What would the Church do then, if someone became Pope, but while he was Pope, he renounced theCathlic faith for Protestantism? If the Church has no power to excommunicate that pope, then what would happen if that pope made an Ex Cathedra pronouncement that say, Sola Scriptura is no longer a heresy, but a dogma, or the same about OSAS?
Now, how would the Pope “renounce” the Catholic faith? If the Pope attempted to promulgate false doctrine ex cathedra, God would strike him dead. If, however, he decided to submit himself to the teaching of a Protestant pastor, it seems that that would qualify as him officially stepping down as Pope.
 
Theoretically I believe it could be done by the bishops acting in unison and through unanimous consent with sufficient objective data and cause.

Pope Honorious I was anathemized about 40 years posthumously after there was later discovered private letters showing his tacit (silent) support of a heretical teaching for purposes of maintaining unity between two opposing sects.
Actually he said he didn’t know whether there was one or two operators/wills. In these letters it looks like he didn’t seem to think it mattered. He did think that Jesus’ humanity had one will, not two (but I think that was to say Jesus didn’t have the negative tendency to sin that we have in us).

God bless you,
 
it’s hard to tell cause no pope has ever openly taught error.

But there are cases of antipopes~
 
Actually he said he didn’t know whether there was one or two operators/wills. In these letters it looks like he didn’t seem to think it mattered. He did think that Jesus’ humanity had one will, not two (but I think that was to say Jesus didn’t have the negative tendency to sin that we have in us).
This sheds some light on Honorius.

catholic.com/library/Papal_Infallibility.asp

Regarding the topic of this thread, I can’t find my Code of Canon Law right now, but I know it’s here somewhere. . . . And I know I’ve seen this question addressed somewhere, too, but memory fails. For the moment, anyway.
 
Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?
Yes, a Pope can be excommunicated by another Pope. (Don’t laugh, it’s happened.)
 
Well first of all the whole scenario is not plausible. If a pope were so bad that even a large minority of bishops were openly calling for excommunication or speaking out it would mean things were really bad. I think the normal and charitable ecclesial protocol to handle a clearly bad and degrading situation would be for a group of bishops of like concern to charitably come together to approach the cardinals about having a private audience with the pontiff about the state of affairs. In fact I can envision a real scenario here as we often get very aged pontiffs and there is a real possibly for one to develop a mental condition with dementia and alzheimers disease in their old age. In a case such as this I would expect that the cardinals or the pontiffs closest aids would try to gently recommend to the pope that he resign his chair to prevent controversy to The Church.

I can’t see a pope ever letting affairs get so bad that they would not seek to appoint an independent committee of bishops to handle a particular issue or to resign their office if they saw they lacked significant support from the college of bishops. The whole thing is highly unlikely since the cardinals are the ones who elected them in the first place. I could only envision this whole scenario developing in the case of latent mental dementia as a result of age or medical conditions.

James
 
This seems to be a good analysis.

olrl.org/misc/sedevacant_md.shtml

Some astute people have seen the ‘bad popes’ as evidence that the Church will not fail. I think it was Malcolm Muggeridge who said that one of the things that facilitated his conversion was the realization that in spite of the numerous truly bad people who have managed to be elected pope, not one of them ever taught error; he couldn’t account for that, except for the protection of the Holy Spirit. Christ has kept His promise (Mt 16:18) for almost 2,000 years now. I’m happy to say I see no reason to start doubting Him now.
 
I can’t find my Code of Canon Law right now, but I know it’s here somewhere. . . .
Found it! (No idea how it got there!) Can’t say that I find anything really helpful beyond the citations in the Davies article.

I’ve asked a canon law forum whether the pope can be excommunicated, under what circumstances, how it would be done, how a successor would be chosen, and what would the implications be re: Mt 16:18. I invited someone there to visit us, but I’m not expecting a speedy response. I know they’re pretty busy with far less hypothetical issues.

(My speculation is that they’ll say that in a case of clear and indisputable heresy, the pope would have automatically excommunicated himself and the chamberlain would organize a conclave to elect a successor.)
 
I believe a heretical Pope is excommunicated latae sententiae. If he is not public about it, there does not seem to be a problem at all. Infallibility is still invested in the office and no heretical Pope could ever publicly declare anything heretical to be believed by the whole Church.

If the matter were to become public, wouldn’t it be right for the Cardinals to simply convene as if there were no longer a Pope and elect a new one?

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother tdgesq,
Being legally excommunicated and being deposed from the papacy are two different issues. A pope could theoretically incur automatic excommunication by - say - being a formal heretic. No body of the Church would have the legitimate ecclesiastical authority to depose him though.
Excommunication automatically incurs deposition. Every ancient canon of the Church asserts as much. Also, in another thread just recently, it was noted that the Pope during the Council of Trent wrote a bull that repeated the ancient sentences of excommunication/deposition on clerics, even Popes, who have fallen into heresy. The bull had a declaration that its should be in effect for all time.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Dear brother tdgesq,

Excommunication automatically incurs deposition. Every ancient canon of the Church asserts as much.
Could you please provide the sources for that? Thanks.
Also, in another thread just recently, it was noted that the Pope during the Council of Trent wrote a bull that repeated the ancient sentences of excommunication/deposition on clerics, even Popes, who have fallen into heresy. The bull had a declaration that its should be in effect for all time.
I would like to see that bull. I don’t recall ever reading it.

All of the information I have seen on this subject leads me to the conclusion that a pope cannot be validly deposed - deprive the pope of his spiritual office - without his consent. Catholic Answers seems to agree with me on this:
  1. The traditional and continuing law of the Church, expressed repeatedly in papal constitutions ever since the Middle Ages, allows for a heretical or apostate cardinal to participate fully in a papal conclave and even to be elected pope. If he could validly attain the papacy as a heretic or apostate, he could certainly retain it validly, even while remaining in that unhappy spiritual state.
  2. A pope who began his pontificate as an orthodox Catholic but became a formal heretic or apostate during his pontificate would thereby legally incur excommunication. However, even if his heresy or apostasy should become publicly discernible, the absence of any competent authority on earth who could lawfully declare his excommunication would mean that, if he refused to resign and continued to insist on carrying out acts of papal authority, those acts, though illicitly exercised, would still be valid. In other words, he would still be juridically the true pope whom we would have to recognize and obey in all things but sin, even though at the inner level at which grace operates he might well be totally separated from the mystical body of Christ. catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0103fea1.asp
 
The bull had a declaration that its should be in effect for all time.
In light of the article cited in #55, I’ll share the thought that occurred to me as soon as I read the above sentence.

I don’t know this particular bull, but I think it was pretty common centuries ago to put in a statement that the bull is to be in effect ‘in perpetuity.’ (Detractors of the ‘Novus Ordo’ Mass often point out that the official document back in the 16th century said that the Tridentine Mass is to be celebrated ‘in perpetuity’.) I’ve read somewhere that ‘in perpetuity’ means ‘until officially changed.’ That means such a statement especially emphasizes that the order, directive, whatever, must not be disregarded or neglected in any way – unless changed by similarly official means.

Of course, I don’t know whether that’s the case with this particular bull.
 
tdgesq, thanks for digging up the article from catholic.com. I spent some time looking and found nothing.

That seems pretty convincing to me. If I could remove the Davies article from #51, I would. And I think it’s even more impressive now that in nearly 2,000 years no pope has taught error.
 
Could you please provide the sources for that? Thanks.
I don’t have time for research right now. After next Tuesday. Please be patient with me.
I would like to see that bull. I don’t recall ever reading it.
It’s here: forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=4623356&postcount=1

I think you are right regarding the meaning of “in perpetuity.” So I guess the question now is, has there been any decree by the competent authority that has cancelled the contents of the bull (encyclical(?)) mentioned above? If not, then it is still valid, and it states that a Pope falling into heresy no longer possesses the office.

I know Canon law says the Pope cannot be judged by anyone, but that is far from removing the validity of the aforementioned Bull/encyclical.

Blessings,
Marduk
 
Does there exist any set of circumstances under which the Church could excommunicate or otherwise depose the Pope and elect a new one?

–Mike
Typically when one bishop excommunicates another bishop, even if that bishop is the Pope, this simply means that they are no longer in communion with each other. However since you also say “depose the Pope and elect a new one”, that’s a much different matter. Since 1423, under Pope Martin V (1417-1431), the only authority great enough to depose a Pope is the Pope himself. But before that time there were actual cases where popes were deposed by Synod of Bishops in Rome. Benedict IX (1047-1048), for example, served three separate terms as Pope and was deposed two times as well, by the Council of Sutri. After his last deposition this Pope was also “excommunicated” by the Council of Sutri! Here is the chronology of Pope Benedict IX:

John XIX (1024-1032)

Benedict IX (1032-1044, 1st of 3 terms, resigned for financial reward.)

Silvester III (1045, Illegally elected, deposed by the Council of Sutri.)

Benedict IX (1045-1046, 2nd of 3 terms, deposed by the Council of Sutri.)

Gregory VI (1045-1046, Deposed by the Council of Sutri.)

Clement II (1046-1047)

Benedict IX (1047-1048, 3rd of 3 terms, deposed and excommunicated.)

Damasus II (1048)

If you are thinking of another jurisdiction deposing the Pope, I do not think that this is possible, the Latin Church is autocephalous, and as such the only thing that other autocephalous churches can do is break communion.

I hope this helps answer the question!
  • a d r i a n
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top