Carnivores in God's ceation

  • Thread starter Thread starter redhen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hey Redhen, I just now read all the way through the topic and I think you have some good thoughts on the subject. The issue of pain and suffering in the world is certainly a deep topic not to be taken lightly.

I don’t claim to have all the answers of course, I’m just sharing my own thoughts on the subject here, as a person who’s thought also on the subject of how the righteous God of the Bible can be justified, and has questioned God about it. We both agree that to trust in Him, we must believe in His goodness, and I don’t think we’re too separate save perhaps in our conclusions thus far. Anyway, here are my thoughts:

God created the world, the universe, and mankind completely good. Even Satan was originally good as stated in the book of Ezekiel. God created us all with free will because He didn’t want robots but people who could receive and return His love with love of their own. He wanted beings who could appreciate and praise Him.

Satan was given governance of this world and is called “the prince of this world” in the Bible. In Isaiah 22 we see Eliakim, aka the Holy Spirit (Revelation 3:7 shows He has the key of David, not Peter), was given the powers that apparently once belonged to Satan due to Satan’s disobedience, who as the Holy Spirit is prefigured by Eliakim, is prefigured by Shebna. In the book of Esther, a similar prefiguration appears to occur involving Haman, Esther, and Mordecai, which may be God’s way of historically recreating the history that occurred in Heaven, perhaps before our world ever began!

At any rate, Satan deliberately rebelled against God knowing completely what he was doing and that he was rejecting all goodness, which I believe is why he can never repent. Satan tricked our ancestors into disobeying God also, and with that, sin entered into the world, defiling not only the human race but all creation. Because our ancestors had not done this with complete knowledge like Satan, I believe we were still able to repent and thus God made a way for a remnant of our race to be saved through Jesus the coming Messiah, through whom not only those to come could be saved through trust in God, but also those who had done so in the past!

Through this fall, violence and evil entered the earth. Because the entire world was in rebellion against God, and under Satan’s rule, God also ended up cursing it as spoken of in Genesis so that the once ideal climate conditions became adverse. Plants no longer produced only good things. Death entered the world as the inevitable consequence of rebellion against God, for as a just Judge He can not allow evil to go unpunished.

Jesus is God’s answer to all of this. Through His sacrifice, we can regain eternal life, a right relationship with God, a right heart, mind, and spirit so that our inclination to sin can now be overcome, and a part in God’s coming new Creation which will not include the death, pain, or evil that this world involves.

You see, God could eliminate the diseases and natural disasters from this world. But the real problem would still exist. Our hearts. We are a reason there is evil in this world. Human beings are the cause of murder and genocide, rape and incest, poverty and theft, and numerous other evils.

For God to fix this Creation, He must first fix our hearts. That is why He can’t allow us in His new Creation until we accept Jesus. We’d just mess it up like we’ve messed this one up, and keep making it miserable for ourselves and one another. You see, Jesus is the answer not just because our sins are paid for, but because through Him we are made new people who can enter God’s new creation without messing it up.

The Bible focuses on how our old bodies will be destroyed and with them our sin natures, i.e. our inclinations to sin. But without an eternal commitment to God, which is part of what brings saving faith, we would just fall again like Adam and Eve did.

And Jesus tricked Satan (or at any rate didn’t bother telling Satan what was really going on) so He could enter Hell and gain from the devil the keys of Hell and of death, i.e. power over those realms. Before that, Satan had power over our entire race which apparently was given him by God before his fall, so that when we sinned he gained dominion over us as we each inevitably died. Therefore, Jesus was literally redeeming us from Satan’s power by paying the penalty each of us owed for our sin through His death on the cross.

In the last day when all things will be revealed, God will show forth all the truths about Himself so that all will realize His utter justice, and then will have praise for Him alone, for none but Him is good, even as Jesus said. People then will realize that had they only sought God and His truth, humbling themselves, that He’d have drawn near to them and taught them the paths of life.
 
Hey Redhen, I just now read all the way through the topic and I think you have some good thoughts on the subject. The issue of pain and suffering in the world is certainly a deep topic not to be taken lightly.

I don’t claim to have all the answers of course, I’m just sharing my own thoughts on the subject here, as a person who’s thought also on the subject of how the righteous God of the Bible can be justified, and has questioned God about it. We both agree that to trust in Him, we must believe in His goodness, and I don’t think we’re too separate save perhaps in our conclusions thus far. Anyway, here are my thoughts:

God created the world, the universe, and mankind completely good. Even Satan was originally good as stated in the book of Ezekiel. God created us all with free will because He didn’t want robots but people who could receive and return His love with love of their own. He wanted beings who could appreciate and praise Him.

Satan was given governance of this world and is called “the prince of this world” in the Bible. In Isaiah 22 we see Eliakim, aka the Holy Spirit (Revelation 3:7 shows He has the key of David, not Peter), was given the powers that apparently once belonged to Satan due to Satan’s disobedience, who as the Holy Spirit is prefigured by Eliakim, is prefigured by Shebna. In the book of Esther, a similar prefiguration appears to occur involving Haman, Esther, and Mordecai, which may be God’s way of historically recreating the history that occurred in Heaven, perhaps before our world ever began!

At any rate, Satan deliberately rebelled against God knowing completely what he was doing and that he was rejecting all goodness, which I believe is why he can never repent. Satan tricked our ancestors into disobeying God also, and with that, sin entered into the world, defiling not only the human race but all creation. Because our ancestors had not done this with complete knowledge like Satan, I believe we were still able to repent and thus God made a way for a remnant of our race to be saved through Jesus the coming Messiah, through whom not only those to come could be saved through trust in God, but also those who had done so in the past!

Through this fall, violence and evil entered the earth. Because the entire world was in rebellion against God, and under Satan’s rule, God also ended up cursing it as spoken of in Genesis so that the once ideal climate conditions became adverse. Plants no longer produced only good things. Death entered the world as the inevitable consequence of rebellion against God, for as a just Judge He can not allow evil to go unpunished.

Jesus is God’s answer to all of this. Through His sacrifice, we can regain eternal life, a right relationship with God, a right heart, mind, and spirit so that our inclination to sin can now be overcome, and a part in God’s coming new Creation which will not include the death, pain, or evil that this world involves.

You see, God could eliminate the diseases and natural disasters from this world. But the real problem would still exist. Our hearts. We are a reason there is evil in this world. Human beings are the cause of murder and genocide, rape and incest, poverty and theft, and numerous other evils.

For God to fix this Creation, He must first fix our hearts. That is why He can’t allow us in His new Creation until we accept Jesus. We’d just mess it up like we’ve messed this one up, and keep making it miserable for ourselves and one another. You see, Jesus is the answer not just because our sins are paid for, but because through Him we are made new people who can enter God’s new creation without messing it up.

The Bible focuses on how our old bodies will be destroyed and with them our sin natures, i.e. our inclinations to sin. But without an eternal commitment to God, which is part of what brings saving faith, we would just fall again like Adam and Eve did.

And Jesus tricked Satan (or at any rate didn’t bother telling Satan what was really going on) so He could enter Hell and gain from the devil the keys of Hell and of death, i.e. power over those realms. Before that, Satan had power over our entire race which apparently was given him by God before his fall, so that when we sinned he gained dominion over us as we each inevitably died. Therefore, Jesus was literally redeeming us from Satan’s power by paying the penalty each of us owed for our sin through His death on the cross.

In the last day when all things will be revealed, God will show forth all the truths about Himself so that all will realize His utter justice, and then will have praise for Him alone, for none but Him is good, even as Jesus said. People then will realize that had they only sought God and His truth, humbling themselves, that He’d have drawn near to them and taught them the paths of life.
Excellent! I forgot about satan and the fallen angels. Since they were an “early” creation their influence may have affected the world before Adam’s sin.
 
Maybe but according to the evidence things have been feeding on each other for a long time.
This highlights the allegorical portions of Genesis.
I agree with this, idea.

When Adam and Eve sinned, this fall allowed death and disease to affect humans,

Could it be that, since Satan fell before us humans fell, that death fell upon the animal kingdom before it fell to us? Seems logical, animals don’t have free will. Also, Satan took the form of a serpent showing that he was allowed some control over the animals albeit limited.

God did not create animals to be immortal, He created us to be immortal. He gave us 10 commandments. He didn’t give them to the animal kingdom. Hence, that is why we are people, animals are animals. Lions don’t sit around and ponder, will I eat that antelope today? They eat because they are hungry. They have no realization that the antelope is suffering.

We have free will, we can love God, we can choose to not love him for various reasons. He does not even force us to believe in him. He let’s us love him freely.
 
Then how do you explain carnivorous dinosaurs, long before the evolution of hominids?
Good question. I personally disbelieve the dating theories and consider dinosaurs to have simply been among God’s original creation, made in 6 days. The flood threw off the dating stuff even more, which is inaccurate beyond several thousand years as scientists admit, because of the water erosion. Dinosaurs sunk to the bottom more and thus were covered by heavier sediment levels. Since scientists assume what’s lower is older, they assume those are older than the humans.

I like the book “Reasons Skeptics Should Consider Christianity” by Josh McDowell and Don Stewart as proofs for a young earth. Some proofs I find more convincing are the mixing of fossil deposits from different climate zones as would be expected in a worldwide flood, the very act of fossilization as evidence for a flood since fossilization requires very rapid burial, the preservation of footprints in the fossil record (again requiring rapid covering with a separate material), the state of fossils (in the Green River formation, for example, fossil fish show outlines of the entire fish showing the skin hadn’t rotted at the time and some are pressed flat between band deposits which would’ve taken great pressure from above, each of which bands supposedly took 6.5 million years to deposit), and the lack of transitional forms which Darwin himself admitted would doom his theory but hoped would be found with time (no wings evolved to feet in fossils or half-evolved feathers).

I believe God made animals and humans capable of microevolution or adaptation to their environments so they would be more capable of surviving, but that these minor adaptations did not mean they came from completely different species as evolution teaches. That’s why there are no transitional forms or examples in nature of creatures evolving into completely different forms. They might alter slightly into different subspecies as with Darwin’s finches, but that’s all. The fact that many species when intercourse occurs produce only infertile offspring (such as lions and tigers) I see as evidence that God will not allow such a process to occur.

I believe God made original core species that then altered into subgroup species. Furthermore, how can evolution explain the existence of species it once wrote off as extinct for millions of years like the coelacanth? Or more recently, the newly discovered Laotian Rock Rat turned out to have been a species known only from the fossil record which had been considered extinct for 11 million years.

livescience.com/imageoftheday/siod_060616.html

The term “living fossil” is used for such examples of creatures written off as extinct whose demise turns out to have been greatly exaggerated.

At any rate, those are just my thoughts on the subject.
 
Also, I will admit that while I read a lot of news articles and form my thoughts on how things could work, it’s ultimately the Bible I consider the ultimate authority. I don’t consider myself a scholar, just a Christian who trusts God and forms opinions on things based upon what I consider most certain, and that my personal relationship with God through His Word, the Bible.
 
Hi, Father Mitch Pacwa, on EWTN described that a day for us, is not the same thing as a day for God. We measure our days by the rotation of the earth on it’s axis. God is eternal, the earth was created by Him. A day for Him could be something entirely different

Believing that a T-Rex existed does not go against the teaching of the Church at all.

I unfortunately do not have the link, but he was asked about dinosaurs by a little girl on his program , “Threshold of Hope” I am not sure on the time-frame but I don’t think it was so long ago.

I mentioned this just to point something out…I do not want to start a new discussion.
 
Genesis 1:29 And God said, Behold, I have given you every herb bearing seed, which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree, in the which is the fruit of a tree yielding seed; to you it shall be for meat.
30 And to every beast of the earth, and to every fowl of the air, and to every thing that creepeth upon the earth, wherein there is life, I have given every green herb for meat: and it was so.

Perhaps after the fall of mankind and the world by Adam and Eve’s sin, creatures began hunting one another, but not until after the flood did God condone the eating of animals by human beings.

Genesis 9:3 Every moving thing that liveth shall be meat for you; even as the green herb have I given you all things.
4 But flesh with the life thereof, which is the blood thereof, shall ye not eat.
Hi, this is translated differently in the Latin Vulgate (the Douay-Rheims Bible).
29 And God said: Behold I have given you every herb bearing seed upon the earth, and all trees that have in themselves seed of their own kind, to be your meat: 30 And to all beasts of the earth, and to every fowl of the air, and to all that move upon the earth, and wherein there is life, that they may have to feed upon. And it was so done.
I am not claiming that your translation is incorrect, but their are differences in translation between different bibles.
 
So basically, you’re worshiping a Semitic storm god?
No. I’m worshipping the God of the OT as well as the NT b/c He says He’s the same yesterday, today, and tomorrow. The problem is, our PC society has emasculated God. All throughout the Bible, God is a force to be reckoned with. Why is it that He’s not seen that way anymore? Besides, you quoted what I said out of context. I didn’t say He was only those things. So don’t misquote me to try to twist my words and trip me up, k?
What has you so angry with God, anyway? This doesn’t feel like an unemotional, “I reject this b/c it just doesn’t make sense.” It feels personal. But, that may just be me putting my own experiences onto you b/c you sound like me when I get hurt and angry and start arguing a point. Regardless, I’m praying for you. :gopray2:
 
Greetings my brothers and sisters.

This is why I am a vegan. 🙂

I believe that Genesis 1 is historically accurate where it describes man and beast being given only plants to eat. I believe that the fall brought about a spiritual and physical corruption. And I believe that there will be a historical return to the vegan ideal expressed in Genesis 1 as indicated by Isaiah 11 and other texts, and the universal scope of redemption.

To God our Father be the glory!
 
Greetings my brothers and sisters.

This is why I am a vegan. 🙂

I believe that Genesis 1 is historically accurate where it describes man and beast being given only plants to eat. I believe that the fall brought about a spiritual and physical corruption. And I believe that there will be a historical return to the vegan ideal expressed in Genesis 1 as indicated by Isaiah 11 and other texts, and the universal scope of redemption.

To God our Father be the glory!
Jesus ate the Passover didnt He?
 
Greetings my brothers and sisters.

This is why I am a vegan. 🙂

I believe that Genesis 1 is historically accurate where it describes man and beast being given only plants to eat. I believe that the fall brought about a spiritual and physical corruption. And I believe that there will be a historical return to the vegan ideal expressed in Genesis 1 as indicated by Isaiah 11 and other texts, and the universal scope of redemption.

To God our Father be the glory!
I have pretty much stopped following this thread, but I wanted to add that Gen 9 is clear that God allowed man to eat meat, and as MH pointed out His plan of Salvation revolved around the Passover Lamb, which was eaten.
 
Jesus ate the Passover didnt He?
Hey, MH!

I always thought He did. But maybe He didn’t. 🤷

“Jesus celebrated the Passover without a lamb and without a temple; yet, not without a lamb and not without a temple. He himself was the awaited Lamb, the true Lamb, just as John the Baptist had foretold at the beginning of Jesus’ public ministry: ‘Behold, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!’ (Jn 1:29).” - Benedict XVI, Homily on April 5th, 2007.
 
I have pretty much stopped following this thread, but I wanted to add that Gen 9 is clear that God allowed man to eat meat, and as MH pointed out His plan of Salvation revolved around the Passover Lamb, which was eaten.
I like your name, Catholic Dude.

I think it’s important to note that the relationship existing between man and beast at the time of the flood was far from ideal. I can hear Jesus saying, “It was because of your hardness of heart… but it was not this way from the beginning.” The “fear and the dread of you” falling on the beasts is a very sad departure from the original harmony that existed between us. A harmony to which we shall return (cf. Mk. 1:13)! “Man and beast you save, O LORD!” - Psalm 36:6
 
I like your name, Catholic Dude.

I think it’s important to note that the relationship existing between man and beast at the time of the flood was far from ideal. I can hear Jesus saying, “It was because of your hardness of heart… but it was not this way from the beginning.” The “fear and the dread of you” falling on the beasts is a very sad departure from the original harmony that existed between us. A harmony to which we shall return (cf. Mk. 1:13)! “Man and beast you save, O LORD!” - Psalm 36:6
I like this reasoning, I just wanted to point out God did start allowing meat so it isnt bad in and of itself (nor should it be compared to tolerating divorce) and I dont think there will be a historical return to vegetarianism only (though the Glorified Bodies in Heaven wont require killing animals for food).
 
I like this reasoning, I just wanted to point out God did start allowing meat so it isnt bad in and of itself (nor should it be compared to tolerating divorce) and I dont think there will be a historical return to vegetarianism only (though the Glorified Bodies in Heaven wont require killing animals for food).
Hmmmm… here are some interesting parallels that exist between the Biblical presentation of divorce (D) and the Biblical presentation of eating animals (V) that you might enjoy pondering. Have a blessed evening!

D.1 In the beginning, God created them male and female, and the two shall become one flesh. And God saw that it was very good (cf. Gen 1:27; 1:31; 2:24).
V.1 In the beginning, God made humans and the beasts of the earth vegan. And God saw that it was very good (cf. Gen 1:30-31).

D.2 God permitted divorce (cf. Deut 24:1-4; Matt 19:8).
V.2 God permitted eating animals (cf. Gen 9:3).

D.3 God divorced Israel (cf. Is 50:1, Jer 3:8).
V.3 Jesus ate fish (cf. Luke 24:42).

D.4 Jesus teaches a return to God’s original design for marriage (cf. Matt 19; Mark 10).
V.4 Isaiah shows a future return to God’s original design for veganism (cf. Is 11:6; 65:25).

“They shall not hurt or destroy in all my holy mountain; for the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the LORD as the waters cover the sea” (Isaiah 11:9).
 
Hmmmm… here are some interesting parallels that exist between the Biblical presentation of divorce (D) and the Biblical presentation of eating animals (V) that you might enjoy pondering. Have a blessed evening!

D.1 In the beginning, God created them male and female, and the two shall become one flesh. And God saw that it was very good (cf. Gen 1:27; 1:31; 2:24).
V.1 In the beginning, God made humans and the beasts of the earth vegan. And God saw that it was very good (cf. Gen 1:30-31).

D.2 God permitted divorce (cf. Deut 24:1-4; Matt 19:8).
V.2 God permitted eating animals (cf. Gen 9:3).

D.3 God divorced Israel (cf. Is 50:1, Jer 3:8).
V.3 Jesus ate fish (cf. Luke 24:42).

D.4 Jesus teaches a return to God’s original design for marriage (cf. Matt 19; Mark 10).
V.4 Isaiah shows a future return to God’s original design for veganism (cf. Is 11:6; 65:25).

“They shall not hurt or destroy in all my holy mountain; for the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the LORD as the waters cover the sea” (Isaiah 11:9).
Actually, I disagree about divorce. From what Jesus said, it appears God never gave a commandment allowing divorce, rather, Moses gave it because the Israelites had hardened hearts:

Matthew 19:4 And he answered and said unto them, Have ye not read, that he which made them at the beginning made them male and female,
5 And said, For this cause shall a man leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife: and they twain shall be one flesh?
6 Wherefore they are no more twain, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder.
7 They say unto him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away?
8 He saith unto them, Moses because of the hardness of your hearts suffered you to put away your wives: but from the beginning it was not so.
9 And I say unto you, Whosoever shall put away his wife, except it be for fornication, and shall marry another, committeth adultery: and whoso marrieth her which is put away doth commit adultery.

Just a minor point I suppose, and a bit off-topic perhaps, but I wanted to address it real quick.
 
Actually, I disagree about divorce. From what Jesus said, it appears God never gave a commandment allowing divorce, rather, Moses gave it because the Israelites had hardened hearts:

Just a minor point I suppose, and a bit off-topic perhaps, but I wanted to address it real quick.
Hi Jzyehoshua!

Let me know what you think of this analysis.

Several times Jesus refers to what Moses did. “Moses commanded” the gift to be offered; “Moses allowed you to divorce your wives”; “Moses said, ‘Honor your father and your mother’; and, ‘Whoever reviles father or mother must surely die.’”; “Have you not read in the book of Moses”. Jesus speaks of everything written about Him in “the Law of Moses”, i.e., the Torah, and Jesus asks them, “Has not Moses given you the law?”; Moses gave them circumcision…

We are forced to ask, did not God do all of this?

Now when saying that Moses gave the Jews circumcision, Jesus specifically points out that it was not actually “from Moses, but from the fathers” (John 7:22). We have here an example of Jesus being very precise in His language when referring to what came from whom. He does not do this in the case of divorce. Jesus does not say that Moses allowed them to divorce their wives, but that God did not. I do not believe that He could have said this without breaking the Scriptures, “and Scripture cannot be broken” (John 10:35). Moses was God’s agent, communicating God’s law which was “put in place through angels by an intermediary” (Gal. 3:19). As far as I know, Moses’ commands in Deuteronomy are given in an unbroken discourse from Deuteronomy 10:12 up through the passage on divorce in chapter 24. All of this material is prefaced by and described as “the commandments and statutes of the LORD, which I am commanding you today for your good” (Deut 10:13; cf. 13:18, etc.). Another way of saying it is that God gave these commandments through Moses.

So, one may be tempted to think that Moses - and not God - permitted divorce at the time of Sinai. That God Himself did not make such concessions to the hardness of people’s hearts. Someone may be tempted to see this implied by what Jesus said.

However, what we may think is implied cannot overturn what is explicit: “the commandments and statutes of the LORD” (Deut 10:13). And, as Pius XII wrote, “it is clear how false is a procedure which would attempt to explain what is clear by means of what is obscure. Indeed, the very opposite procedure must be used” (Humani Generis, 21).

May the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you!
 
Well, this has evolved into a vegan thread so I assume there are no more unique answers to the problem of carnivores (and the implied pain, suffering and death accompanying them) in God’s design.

Thanks again to all who replied. I conclude that this is one question (and it’s a BIG one) that will remain a mystery of God.
 
V.1 In the beginning, God made humans and the beasts of the earth vegan. And God saw that it was very good (cf. Gen 1:30-31).
What version of the Bible says that God made the first humans or the first animals vegan?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top