Catholic identity crisis

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaisyNJesus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Also, perhaps you have ventured into a lot of deep intellectual thoughts and feel that is not enough. Well of course, it never should be. The famous 20th century Catholic theologian, Hans Von Balthazar coined the term “kneeling theology.” In other words, our theology is meant to inform our relationship with God, not just be an intellectual pursuit.

Yes, there is the danger of “over-intellectualizing the faith,” so to speak. But this happens when we come to believe that our intellects are the only/most important of us as human beings. We have an intellect, but we also have emotions, a body, etc. Jesus, being fully human, addresses us as complete human beings, He too had an intellect- after all, Mary and Joseph lost him at the age of 12 only to find him discussing scripture with the Lawyers and Scribes in the temple. But he also cried when Lazarus died. He ate food and used material things to explain spiritual realities. He experienced sorrow and joy.

Of course, the Church which Jesus established is like him. Yes the Church engages the intellect, because that is part of what makes us human. It also, makes use of material goods (i.e. the sacraments, incense, statues, etc). It heals, but it also recognizes that God does not always take away our suffering. In short, it addresses us as complete human beings, We as the Church simply cannot go in one direction and ignore everything else. You personally might be really attracted to the Charismatic movement. Why not try it out at least?

Finally, perhaps you would appreciate some of the beautiful music and art work Catholicism has produced in the last 2000 years. Sometimes our faith is captured in the beauty of art more precisely than the words of theologians.

God Bless
 
cont…

–He who is the ‘image of the invisible God’ (Col 1:15), is himself the perfect man who has restored in the children of Adam that likeness to God which had been disfigured ever since the first sin. Human nature, by the very fact that is was assumed, not absorbed, in him, has been raised in us also to a dignity beyond compare. For, by his Incarnation, he, the son of God, in a certain way united himself with each man. The redemption of the world-this tremendous mystery of love in which creation is renewed-is, at its deepest root, the fullness of justice in a human Heart-the Heart of the First-born Son-in order that it may become justice in the hearts of many human beings, predestined from eternity in the Firstborn Son to be children of God and called to grace, called to love." (John Paul II, Redemptor Hominis)

Praying to the Saints and Mary

The following is a back and forth between a Catholic and Protestant:

"Protestant: Why do Catholics pray to the saints?

New Apologetics: The Church recognizes that God is not protective of his own glory. In truth, his glory is that we share as fully as logically possible in the life and work of God. He loves us so much that he has decided to give everything to us that can possibly be given.

Saint Therese of Lisieux, Doctor of the Church, writes:

“It is because [God] has so incomprehensible a love for us that he wills to do nothing without us. The Creator of the universe awaits the prayer of a poor little soul to save other souls redeemed like it at the price of all his blood.”

The practice of asking the intercession of the saints is the simple recognition that God’s nature is infinite generosity rather than infinite protection of his own prerogatives. We honor God’s true nature as love when we honor what he has done in the saints and when we ask for their help. He wants each of them and us to have as much glory as he can possibly give.

Consider that even when we pray directly to God, the prayer is always answered through some creature.

“We can never give too great prominence to the Scholastic principle that God never does through Himself what may be achieved through created causality… For any result which does not require actually infinite power, God will sooner create a new spiritual being capable of producing that result than produce it Himself.” (Abbot Anscar Vonier, The Human Soul)

To misunderstand God’s desire that we share in his glory is to misunderstand the gospel. Most Christians have not yet heard the good news.

Protestant: The Bible says “Yours, O LORD, is the greatness and the power and the glory and the victory and the majesty, for all that is in the heavens and in the earth is yours. Yours is the kingdom, O LORD, and you are exalted as head above all.” therefore all glory and honor belongs to God.

New Apologetics: Indeed it does. But the Bible also says that he has given it away. Really, the whole Bible is about God exalting the lowly. Here are just a few quotes:

“And I have given them the glory you gave me, so that they may be one, as we are one, I in them and you in me, that they may be brought to perfection as one, that the world may know that you sent me, and that you loved them even as you loved me.” John 17:22-23

Have you considered that the Father does not love Jesus more than he loves you? Will he therefore keep you down or will he raise you up as high as he possibly can? We and the Bible say the latter:

“I will give the victor the right to sit with me on my throne, as I myself first won the victory and sit with my Father on his throne.” (Revelation 3:21)

You are going to be an equal of Christ by the gift of God. Jesus prays that where he is, you also may be:

“Father, they are your gift to me. I wish that where I am they also may be with me, that they may see my glory that you gave me, because you loved me before the foundation of the world.” John 17:23

And further, justification is not the point… God justifies us so that he can glorify us:

“For those he foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, so that he might be the firstborn among many brothers. And those he predestined he also called; and those he called he also justified; and those he justified he also glorified.” (Romans 8:29-30)

Protestant:

“Paul teaches that we must be dead and for Christ to live in us. Praying to saints is unbiblical for Christs sacrifice and His leading in my life qualifies me as a saint just as much as Paul.”

New Apologetics: You are right that we must die to ourselves and Christ must live in us. But when Christ lives in us, it is CHRIST who lives in us. We therefore take part both in his intercession and in his redemption of the whole world. Your dignity and importance is not that of Saint Paul. Know that you and Saint Paul both share the infinite dignity and importance of God the Son."

-NewApologetics.com

It is easy to see why Catholic pray to the saints when we understand the God is entirely for us. Our God wishes to glory all of us. Jesus says so. Will he keep us down or will he raise us to his own glory? Is God gift or does he keep everything for himself?
 
Dear Daisy,

I want to thank you for bringing up this topic and for expounding your views in a loving way of genuinely trying to get to the bottom of what is troubling you. I see and feel the problems, too. ** I truly believe having the Bible in the vernacular has allowed those not in the church to understand Christ’s teachings.** You are here trying to explain this, and its falling on the same deaf ears that Brother Martin encountered. Martin saw reality and it made him angry. I saw reality and it made me very sad. Because I know this is THE church but its overgrown with weeds and dead brush. You are here sharing some light, the light of Christ’s teachings and they dont get it. I pray that you shine on.
Me too! That is the most important point. Using the words and exampe of Christ and his disciples in the Gospels.
I too believe that the Church historically has the long straw when it comes to claiming authority and there is very much I admire in the Church.But like you, I feel the Church - both as individuals and institution - has complicated matters and gotten caught up in a variety of questions and gone off into being in some ways pharisaic - we have here people being condemned to hell if they miss Sunday Mass or eat meat on fridays. I means seriously!

Yesterday night I read the passage in the Bible where Jesus is accused because his disciples do not wash their hands before they eat. This is a rule, actually a cultic law within the Torah - like our disciplines today. But Jesus excuses his disciples. It is interesting how Jesus says we shall focus on what is inside and not on this outward thing. It is what comes out from within that makes a man unclean, says the Lord.
He was accused of breaking the sabbath rest and such things, working on the sabbath, eating with sinners, giving himself authority as son of God, and doing signs and wonders. The Pharisees and their followers did not like this at all. Jesus was out of their control.
This is interesting because the scribes and pharisees were the priesthood of their day, and they sat on Moses seat and yet they were so wrong they did not recognize the messiah. This always amazed me to think about. God had placed these people into authority, and yet they had turned the faith into a system of hypocrisy, placing burdens on people and treating with suspicion the great things of the Kingdom.

Paul also talks alot in his letters about people should not judge others because of what they eat, or not eat, sabbath days and such.
It troubles me that the church would choose to condemn a person for eating something on a particular day or missing mass for whatever reason.

But these are just more of my problems with the priorities of thought in the Catholic Church. After a while, especially if one is in a dry season, and parish life is also exeedingly dry, one cannot help but gather much guilt on their heads according to the system.
And then, by reading the Gospels, one sees a Spirit of freedom.

I once knew a man who said: All the Catholic young men walk around with red faces like they are ashamed. I think there is some truth to that. We have a a system here where we are given role models that humiliate and efface themselves, who suffer and do not say no to injustice, and who are always occupied by their guilt and sinfulness. Even in the book of saint Faustina it is written she went around smelling like death.
Where is the confidence that be have authority in the Name of Jesus, that we are sons and daughters of the Most High ?

I don’t know.
It is funny how we internalise things we hear and read much off. We get even afraid of thinking for ourselves.
Maybe its my protestant roots, but this just does not seem right to me, in light of what I read in the Gospels. And yes, I would rather like to be with Christians who preach simple Gospel truth, and heal people, than Christians who have a title in the Church and tell me I should do penance and be careful of those that do the things Jesus did.
 
Daisy,

You seem to have a problem with self- inflicted mortifications, especially very severe ones. I assume you are not troubled by ocassional fasting and such types of mortification? The good news is that we don’t have to look for suffering. I don’t have time to find in now, but I remember that Pope Saint John Paul II in his encyclical on suffering said that we shouldn’t go looking for suffering (excluding penances mandated by the Church, such as days of fasting). But the fact remains that suffering is part of life. Of course we should try to reduce and minimize suffering, but some will always remain. So we must deal with it, and God can bring good out of all evil. When we offer up our suffering, we are not trying to earn salvation. All we are trying to do is get closer to Christ. He suffered, and when we suffer, we “offer it up,” meaning we choose to be with him in his suffering. Now we can and should be with him in our joys, but both suffering and pleasent events happen in our lives. And even when we suffer we should not lose our joy (even if we lose our happy feelings) because when we are with Christ, the joy remains. Joy is deeper than mere feelings, and it is a gift from the Holy Spirit.

Now, there are some people who do have a vocation to endure more self inflicted mortification, more sufferings, etc. Look at John the Bapist, for a scriptural example. His vocation was to go out into the dessert and eat bugs and wear camel skin. :eek: That is really intense, but God called him to it. I don’t think he is calling me to it. And perhaps he isn’t calling you to such a vocation either. The Church says that severe mortifications should only be done under the approval and guidance of a spiritual director anyways. However, while these such saints were great and holy people, we don’t have to be exactly like them. Even St. Therese once said that readings some of the lives of the saints “hurt her poor little head” and she found refuge in scripture, where she realized she must just be child-like and trust all to Jesus.

If your home parish is not very welcoming or makes you feel you comfortable, could you try a different one? I moved parishes once because I didn’t feel welcome at mine .

I hope this was somewhat useful to you. God bless.
I do not really disagree with you on any of your points.
John the baptist was a singular person though, he was the Elijah with a unique role in salvation history as the precursor and he was still under the old covenant.

My problem is not that such people have existed. We can also take the example of Abraham. He was a hugely important person in covenant history - father of believers - and was asked by God to sacrifice his son Isac as a test of faith.
Only as part of the UNIQUE story of Abraham who becomes the father of all faithful because of his extreme obedience, bringing in a new covenant within salvation history does this sacrifice make sense.

If normal believers started bringing children to the alter to willingly sacrifice them, we would say they are insane and that they have not understood that Jesus has already been slain as the firstborn of all creation, and that blood sacrifices have no place under the new covenant. We can bring no meaningful sacrifice to add to that which Christ has done, because he is the Lamb who has truly fulfilled it all and ransomed every soul that ever was and will be.

You understand where I am going with this. I see there are times in salvation history where people suffered or made great sacrifices. Sickness was not one of them, I wish to add. The idea that sickness is salvific is something I do not see Biblical evidence for.
Yet in the Church we see normal people who suffer bodily pain and illness who think they are pious and good if they accept and offer up this suffering as an atonement for their sins and sins of others. As though their sins had not been atoned for on the cross.
It is written Jesus bore our sickness and sins up on the cross. The Gospels are quite clear about this too. Not just our sins, but also our sicknesses.

What I see is that people in the Church have no expectation of being healed, our leaders have no expectation that they can heal in the name of Jesus, many of our clever minds are even scandalized at the few who carry out what Christ asked the disciples to do. At the end of the Gospel of Mark it is written:
“Jesus said: Go out in all the world and preach the Gospel … and these signs shall follow those that believe: in my name they shall cast out evil spirits, they shall speak in new togues, they shall lay their hands on the sick and they shall be healed” They went out preaching everywhere and God acted and confirmed the word through the signs that accompanied."

We talk of a new evangelisation, and yet we have become somehow paralysed and passive as a church. I would like to see the Pope, the successor of Peter, going about like Peter and John healing in the streets.

daisy
 
Redemptive Suffering

Many Catholics do not understand Redemptive Suffering either. “Suffering in itself is of no value.” Pope Francis. Through his sufferings he has saved the world. But that is not it. He has united all humans to himself and all human suffering to himself. He has made it that you save the world in Union with him. He has given you this gift so that no part of your life is diminished. He has given you his glory. With that being said, the suffering that we experience are of no value. What is of value is that Jesus suffers WITH us. All the horrors we experience are saving acts of the world. This is how Jesus has conquered all diminshment. This is not to say we should value suffering. ** It is of no value. **** We should search for healing and we know that God does not send us suffering. But the horrors that befall us will never have power over us. This is Redemptive suffering**.
–“The Redeemer suffered in place of man and for man. Every man has his own share in the Redemption. Each one is also called to share in that suffering through which the Redemption was accomplished. He is called to share in that suffering through which all human suffering has also been redeemed. In bringing about the Redemption through suffering, Christ has also raised human suffering to the level of the Redemption.” ( John Paul II, Salvifici Doloris)

"While disease is “a sign of the evil in the world and in man,” Christ’s healings show that “the Kingdom of God is near,” and they serve as “a foretaste of his victory obtained by his death and resurrection.” (Pope Benedict XVI)

Suffering and the lives of the Saints

The truth is we are all one body in Christ** suffering for the salvation of the world.** St. Francis wounds are not any more his wounds then they are yours. We all share Christs wounds equally. We also all share in his glory.
New Apologetics
Thank you very much for these words and quotes, Nate.

They are interesting and they clearly seek to find answers in a world of suffering and confusion.
But I find them rather conflicting.
What I find problematic is the notion that people suffer for the redemption which Christ has already won for us. Only his blood and his suffering as the Son of God could redeem mankind from death, sin and sickness. And this has abundantly been fulfilled by his sacrifice once and for all. He is now seated at the right hand of the Father.

I am not blind to the fact that there is much suffering in the world, and that also Christians suffer illness, even sometimes when they did pray for healing, nor do I deny that the knowlegde of Jesus’ presence with us as we walk through the valleys is comforting. However, I do not believe that Jesus still suffers. He is in the glory and has born everything for us.

You say ;“horror are saving acts of the world” What do you mean by that? and what do you mean by it when you also say that “our suffering has no value”??
Which one is it? Do you yourself understand what you are writing or do you just list a bunch of paradoxes that you read in different books?

I myself find it simpler to rely on the Bible, in particularly the Gospels. We suffer persecution when we are united to Christ and does his deeds and preach the Gospel, because the devil who is very active still, fights against us. There is a real battle. From the evil one comes the suffering and sickness, and the temptation to sin according to the Bible, wherein sickness spirits are being cast out in the Name of Jesus.

The way shown in the New Testament is that Jesus and his disciples heal. I am continuosly struck by the fact that it is repeatedly mentioned that Jesus healed everyone. At no point whatsoever, did he tell even the most pious, that they should suffer and unite their illness-suffering to his suffering.
He speaks of persecution and martyrdom as inevitable and he talks about leaving everything and following him with our crosses, but sickness is nowhere mentioned as redemptive or atonement for other souls.

There is a place where Paul mentions that the one who has suffered in the body has made himself done with sin. (Sorry my translation in direct quote from my mothertongue). But again this passage does not talk about atonement for sins or redemptive suffering due to illness, but probably rather refers to how passions and vanity are reduced when we see how fragile our flesh is.

Again a huge percentage of the Gospel consists of Jesus healing people or raising them from the dead or making wonders with food, or even walking on water.
All these things happen within Pentecostal and Evangelical communities, especially in the mission field and in countries where the Church is persecuted or where Christians have very little theological training but treat the Bible with huge reverence.

From my own admittedly human and limited perspective, it seems that Catholic people have through centuries made layer upon layer of explanations for suffering in the world, and gotten further and further away from the Biblical description of healings and other miracles. It could seem we have lost faith in this possibility and made substitute theories.

Do you understand why I could think this way? Especially in light of the fact that even in Europe, on the continent of scepticism, we see so many healings and miracles at the hands of Pentecostals and other Evangelicals as well, who are inspired by the Bible?

Daisy
 
Why do you think sickness is different from other crosses? Is there a particular sickness you or a loved one has gone through which is agitating you?

When Christ healed the paralytic, he said "Your sins are forgiven. " When the scribes grumbled at him for doing this he said “’… so that you may know that the Son of Man has authority on earth for forgive sins.”’ Then “he said to the paralytic ‘Get up, pick up your pallet, and go home.’” (Mark 2:5, 10-11) Yes Jesus healed people physically, but his real work is healing us from sin. In fact, the story of the paralytic suggests that physical healing was preformed in order to increase faith and spiritual healing.

The Church’s main mission is to heal spiritually, although sometimes physical healings are preformed. (There are miracles. How about all the miraculous healings from the water at Lourdes? All the healings that happen as miracles during the process of beatification and canonization for many saints?) But what’s the point of physical healings without spiritual ones? God gives us health when it beneifts our soul, and permits sickness (a type of suffering) when it benefits our soul as well. I forgot his name, but there was a saint who had the gift of healing, but could not heal a blind girl. When the girl’s mother complained, he said if the girl had vision, she would have commited a moral sin and possibily have lost her soul.

I’ll leave the decisions of who gets healed to God, minimizing suffering when I can and offering the rest up to find union with him. What we as Christians should want most of all is union with God. I always find imense joy in the saints despite their suffering.

God Bless
 
You said: “What I find problematic is the notion that people suffer for the redemption which Christ has already won for us. Only his blood and his suffering as the Son of God could redeem mankind from death, sin and sickness. And this has abundantly been fulfilled by his sacrifice once and for all. He is now seated at the right hand of the Father.”

I reply:I agree that only Christ won the redemption for us. Only God could conquer sin, suffering and death. But he has given us the same victory and the same significance to us. It is his gift to us. The shame of knowing that we wounded perfect love would be to much to bear. This shame is removed when we to are one with the savior of the world. Also all the diminshment we experience would have the power to conquer us if God had not shared the redemption with us.Here are a few quotes:

“With Christ I am nailed to the cross. It is now no longer I that live but Christ Who lives in me” (Gal 2:19-20).

Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, for I fill up what is lacking in the afflictions of Christ." (Col:24).

You said: I am not blind to the fact that there is much suffering in the world, and that also Christians suffer illness, even sometimes when they did pray for healing, nor do I deny that the knowlegde of Jesus’ presence with us as we walk through the valleys is comforting. However, I do not believe that Jesus still suffers. He is in the glory and has born everything for us.

I reply: If he didn’t share the redemption with us, then we could never be saved. The diminshment that we experience would still have the ability to forever diminish us.

“To God, all moments of time are present in their immediacy.” (CCC, 600)

"However, this pain is transubstantiated. It is not mere pain, but redemptive glory. Its meaning is not destruction, but the reversal of all diminishment. Its eternality is tantamount to there never having been such a thing as diminishment…

The same redemptive significance is given to our pain as well. From the standpoint of eternity, we’ve not been diminished, but have always been central to the salvation of all who will be saved." -New Apologetics

He fell to the ground and heard a voice say to him, “Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me?” (Acts 9:4) (Jesus meant this.)

“For the Spirit Himself gives testimony to our spirit that we are the sons of God. And if sons, heirs also; heirs indeed of God and joint heirs with Christ: yet so, if we suffer with Him, that we may be also glorified with Him. The sufferings of this time are not worthy to be compared with the glory to come that shall be revealed in us.” (Rm 8:16-18)”

You said: ;“horror are saving acts of the world” What do you mean by that? and what do you mean by it when you also say that “our suffering has no value”??
Which one is it? Do you yourself understand what you are writing or do you just list a bunch of paradoxes that you read in different books?

I reply: They sounds like paradoxes but they are not. When I say “horror are saving acts of the world” I mean being united to Christ in being in agony with him is what saves the world. When I say “suffering has no value” : I mean in itself it has no value. What is of value is that Jesus suffers WITH US. The union is what is of value not the suffering (in itself).

You said: I myself find it simpler to rely on the Bible, in particularly the Gospels. We suffer persecution when we are united to Christ and does his deeds and preach the Gospel,

I reply:The bible is filled with quotes about Gods gift of the redemption for us. When we are united to Christ we are actually UNITED to him. This includes are suffering. Many Christians suffer in the worse way because they do not know that God has given there suffering the same significance of Christ’s.

“…whereof I Paul am made a minister. Who now rejoice in my sufferings for you and fill up those things that are wanting of the sufferings of Christ, in my flesh, for His body, which is the church:” Colossians 1:23-24

“For as we share abundantly in Christ’s sufferings, so through Christ we share abundantly in comfort too.” 2 Corinthians 1:5

You said: “because the devil who is very active still, fights against us. There is a real battle. From the evil one comes the suffering and sickness, and the temptation to sin according to the Bible, wherein sickness spirits are being cast out in the Name of Jesus.”

I reply: I agree the devil is the real enemy. Although demonic spirits can cause sickness, suffering and death result from sin. Also the demons do not want any one to know that Christ has given the redemption to us and plans to glorify us beyond measure. When this is known all the Christians will return to the Catholic Church.

You said: The way shown in the New Testament is that Jesus and his disciples heal. I am continuosly struck by the fact that it is repeatedly mentioned that Jesus healed everyone. At no point whatsoever, did he tell even the most pious, that they should suffer and unite their illness-suffering to his suffering.
He speaks of persecution and martyrdom as inevitable and he talks about leaving everything and following him with our crosses, but sickness is nowhere mentioned as redemptive or atonement for other souls.

I reply: Yes sickness and suffering are evils. They in themselves are of no value. But all suffering carries the power of the redemption with them. This is how God ultimately strikes down evil. We should seek physical healing at all times.
 
You said: There is a place where Paul mentions that the one who has suffered in the body has made himself done with sin. (Sorry my translation in direct quote from my mothertongue). But again this passage does not talk about atonement for sins or redemptive suffering due to illness, but probably rather refers to how passions and vanity are reduced when we see how fragile our flesh is.

I reply: Are we really part of the body of Christ or is just a thing we say?

You said: Again a huge percentage of the Gospel consists of Jesus healing people or raising them from the dead or making wonders with food, or even walking on water.
All these things happen within Pentecostal and Evangelical communities, especially in the mission field and in countries where the Church is persecuted or where Christians have very little theological training but treat the Bible with huge reverence.

I reply: Yes I agree. They are doing a lot of good things. We were commanded to heal. This happens in the Catholic Church too but I guess not as often. Especially in the Catholic Charismatic movement.

I reply: From my own admittedly human and limited perspective, it seems that Catholic people have through centuries made layer upon layer of explanations for suffering in the world, and gotten further and further away from the Biblical description of healings and other miracles. It could seem we have lost faith in this possibility and made substitute theories.

I reply: There is a lot confusion about suffering, why there still is suffering and many other things. The Catholic Church doesn’t make these mistakes (the actually teaching don’t). Hopefully the confusion will not last for long.

I reply: Do you understand why I could think this way? Especially in light of the fact that even in Europe, on the continent of scepticism, we see so many healings and miracles at the hands of Pentecostals and other Evangelicals as well, who are inspired by the Bible?

I reply: Yes we need to fight the evils of suffering and sickness. Pentecostals take the call for healing seriously. Catholics are confused about suffering and there is a lack in the cause for healing in the Church. God wants all of us to be healed. But when we are suffering we are United to him and partake in his redemption. A healing will not diminsh the redemption for our whole lives are saving acts for the world.

If there is anything you want me to explain then I will be happy to. 🙂
 
God gives us health when it beneifts our soul, and permits sickness (a type of suffering) when it benefits our soul as well.
God opposes all suffering and death with the fullness of his holiness. God does not permit sickness for our benefit. For that would be morally illicit. “The end does not justify the means.” (CCC 1759) Woe to us if God did not oppose evil fully!

You said: I forgot his name, but there was a saint who had the gift of healing, but could not heal a blind girl. When the girl’s mother complained, he said if the girl had vision, she would have commited a moral sin and possibily have lost her soul.

I reply: Not everything said by saints are Catholic teaching. (If this is what happened).

You said: I’ll leave the decisions of who gets healed to God, minimizing suffering when I can and offering the rest up to find union with him. What we as Christians should want most of all is union with God. I always find imense joy in the saints despite their suffering.

I reply: God has made it that ALL your suffering are united to his. The Saints and we are one body in Christ suffering for the salvation of the world. Everything you do and suffer is necessary for all that will be saved.

God Bless
 
Here is a back and forth dialogue between New Apologetics and a suffering Catholic:

Suffering Catholic: “I have cancer. I thanked God for allowing me to suffer because I know he can take this cancer and use it for a greater good. We all have to be willing to carry the Cross.”

New Apologetics: It is important to know that the conclusion that God is perfectly opposed to every instance of human suffering does not contradict what you know from your own prayer about the power of redemptive suffering. Though it appears to be a contradiction, it is really an example of the radical nature of God’s love for us. We explain as follows:
  1. God has willed only life and well-being for us, but the effect of the sin of the world has caused disorder to come into every human experience. God is infinitely opposed to both the sin and the disorder (the suffering and death) that it causes.
  2. To combat the power of sin, suffering, and death, God has taken all of our disorder to himself in Christ to transform its meaning. In Christ, all of the disorder of human history is “transubstantiated” such that all works together for the good.
    It is because God perfectly opposes evil that he has, through the redemption, integrated every evil into a higher order which cannot fail to bring about God’s perfect will. Thus, through redemptive suffering (which is God in union with us), the Kingdom of God has come (and is coming) in Christ.
You do not love suffering, nor are you thankful for it, but you love God, and you know that God is present with you in your suffering. Rightly, you are grateful that God has imbued your suffering with redemptive power, and when it is revealed to you that this power is infinite, and that every good thing that God will give to any creature comes to them precisely through what you have suffered, you will be overwhelmed with gratitude forever. And all others will be forever grateful to you for what you have gone through because they will know that their eternal happiness depends on what the Trinity has done with your life having been exactly what it was. Thus, God has killed death.

Suffering Catholic: “We all have to be willing to carry the Cross. I have been blessed by many gifts from God since I have been fighting through this cancer. During each chemotherapy treatment Jesus has been there with me holding my hand. I couldn’t with stand this without him.”

New Apologetics: This is true. However, we must remember that God does not make the cross. The cross is an implement of torture made to deliver the kind of suffering that mercilessly turns a human being into a piece of meat. The cross is the total violation of everything that God intended for us. Though the cross is unholy, the carrying of the cross is holy. This “carrying of the unholy” has nothing to do with the approval of the torture (or the anguish of chemotherapy) as some kind of good. Rather, it is the refusal to allow the unfairness of the evil that befalls us to diminish our love. By God’s grace, no matter what happens to us, we remain his, and we remain undiminished in love of God and others.

The cross (in itself) is of no value. What is of value is that Jesus has come to make each of our crosses his own. Then, whatever we suffer becomes, though Him, the means of the rescue of all."

-http://newapologetics.com/theodicy-article-and-meaning-of-the-cross
 
St.Paul: I make up in my body what is lacking in the sufferings of Christ. Paul refers to the Mystical Body of Christ, he compares it to the physical body. When one part is infected or ill the rest of the body suffers and comes to its aid. When a member of the Body sins, the whole body is affected, and like the human body The Mystical Body suffers too, and comes to it’s spiritual aid, by prayer,sacrifice, and suffering. Jesus is represented as an immense organism a body which He is the Head, the Holy Spirit it’s soul, and the faithful constitute it’s members (cf Epistles to Corinthians, Colossians, Ephesians, and Romans) St.Paul says we are all one in Christ. Mystical stands for a supernatural reality, not of a physical type. we live in Christ who continues in us His passion and death and resurrection. Also there is the truth that nothing imperfect will enter Heaven (Jesus). The Church regards suffering as a spiritual purification, a purgatory, a refining process of the soul. If we don’t do it here, then we necessarily do it here-after. Christians, true christians always have Hope, not despair, and this grace is given to us in Baptism. All humanity suffers, and it is better to suffer for a good thing, than to suffer for a bad thing. Christians are united to Jesus Christ in all aspects of human life, joy, and suffering. Again Jesus said "What Father is there that does not discipline the son he loves? If our attitude is right, we should kiss the hand that disciplines us. Human nature is adverse to suffering, and one would have to be nuts to desire it, but it is transformed when united to Christ in love, Christ suffers in us, and we in Him, and we long to be free,and we will be, for every crucifixion, there is a resurrection in Christ, our Hope.
 
God opposes all suffering and death with the fullness of his holiness. God does not permit sickness for our benefit. For that would be morally illicit. “The end does not justify the means.” (CCC 1759) Woe to us if God did not oppose evil fully!

You said: I forgot his name, but there was a saint who had the gift of healing, but could not heal a blind girl. When the girl’s mother complained, he said if the girl had vision, she would have commited a moral sin and possibily have lost her soul.

I reply: Not everything said by saints are Catholic teaching. (If this is what happened).
I don’t know if we’re really saying anything different. God is in complete control of the world, meaning, there could not be any suffering unless he permits it. To say otherwise is to contradict God’s omnipotence. Its not that God wills suffering, but he allows the consequences of sin to unfold, and uses that to being a greater good.
“God judged it better to bring good out of evil than suffer no evil to exist.” -St Augustine
.
You said: I’ll leave the decisions of who gets healed to God, minimizing suffering when I can and offering the rest up to find union with him. What we as Christians should want most of all is union with God. I always find imense joy in the saints despite their suffering.
I reply: God has made it that ALL your suffering are united to his. The Saints and we are one body in Christ suffering for the salvation of the world. Everything you do and suffer is necessary for all that will be saved.
What I meant was that sometimes God heals us, and sometimes he does not deliver us from a particular suffering in this life, instead deciding it is better that we endure. In such a situation, we offer it up. If God delivers us from a particular suffering, then we offer it up until it is gone. After that, here is no more of that suffering to offer it up. Thanksgiving would be the proper attitude I’d say.
 
You said:“I don’t know if we’re really saying anything different. God is in complete control of the world, meaning, there could not be any suffering unless he permits it. To say otherwise is to contradict God’s omnipotence. Its not that God wills suffering, but he allows the consequences of sin to unfold, and uses that to being a greater good.
“God judged it better to bring good out of evil than suffer no evil to exist.” -St Augustine”

Yes God does permit it. Permit it means non-intervention. There is a reason he permits it and it doesn’t have to do with “permitting evil so as to bring a greater good out of it.” The reason keeps with God’s omnipotence and keeps with his holiness. If God did permit evil for a greater good, we would be better being atheists. I would like to share the reason if you would like.
 
He is brilliant. I love him.
Why? Do you want to advice me to read something particular that might help me with the problem of “cognitive dissonanz” I experience in certain areas?
I have nothing in particular for you. But one thing that makes him such a great theologian is his clearing up misconceptions of what expiation consists of. In short, everything comes from love.

This is also perhaps relevant:

“So Christ did not come to increase human suffering or to preach resignation to it; he came to give meaning to suffering and to announce its end and defeat.”

vatican.va/liturgical_year/holy-week/2009/documents/holy-week_homily-fr-cantalamessa_20090410_en.html
 
Y
I reply: Are we really part of the body of Christ or is just a thing we say?
**
Dear Nate, and everyone.**
Thanks so much for all your replies.

Nate, You speak about the Body of Christ. It is evident again in the Gospels and Letters that illness among people in the Church was not seen as a good or something that redeemed or saved or atoned for sins of others. What is mentioned a lot however, is the unity as a body in suffering due to to persecution due to faith in Jesus Christ.

I see on this thread a lot of words and quotes, not taken from the Bible, about suffering being redemptive.
I suppose this is all a valid attempt to make meaning out of suffering that takes place in the world due to poverty, illness, and war. As such it is all ight to make these explanations. However, I get uneasy when these theories start seeming like another Gospel, like when people start saying - quite openly on these fora - that we shall atone for our own sins, that illness can save the souls of others if we just “offer it up”.

Its like a new kind of faith - I find - in which we slowly change the image of Christ which is given us in the New Testament. A suffering person said to me: “The Catholic suffering theology has me scared because it seems we can not know which side God is on: if sickness and such are good to him, then we have no way of understanding him, only to fear him”. I found she was right. Futhermore, I did not find a word in the Bible about human sickness saving souls if we offer it up and ask God to unite himself with us. I can rather understand the God shown to me in the Gospels who heals, who is light and there is no darkness in him.

There is a place where suffering becomes a mystery, when even believers do not experience the healing they prayed for. But often we do not pray for healing. Especially as a Church, as parishes, we do not have the expectation and do not pray, hands on and in the name of Jesus, as parishes, for our sick members.
And let us also be honest; many people loose faith alltogether and despair when they suffer.

Someone asked me if I knew someone ill, since I reacted so strongly about all this.
Well of course I do. Don’t we all? I know severel people with cancer. I also know people who have died horrible deaths, where the people next to them came away with a bigger bitterness and disbelief than ever.
Even now I have friends who suffer illness. They are longing for a spiritual touch, but their primary concern is their health - litterally its a matter of physical survival - and I wish I could take them to the Catholic Church. But it is in the Pentecostal church that they experience healings. I am not saying that everyone is healed. But many are, even from really bad stuff like cancer. My whole Christian life started when a close friend told me she had been healed. Jesus is still alive and active, was her firm belief. And it was the opening of faith to me, because I didn’t want more philosophy and humanism. I longed for the God of the Gospels.

Jesus choose the way of healing, in order to attract people, and I reckon, because he could not help himself but had so much pity on the sick people, the family members of the dead etc. We read that clearly in the Gospels. He not only pointed to the Gospel through healing people, he also preached it by healing them. Healing was part of the good news manifested in Christ into the world.

Someone implied healing was only used in order to point to what was much more important, namely the spiritual health.
My question then is simply: why don’t we just do what he showed us? Why don’t we trust his method of evangelisation?

We believe we can preach without the signs confirming. But Jesus himself chose the way of signs and healings. Now we seem to think that nice words are better than following the way that Jesus and the apostles showed us.
I am fairly certain that if we stop talking about a bunch of other theories, raising a few persons in a century to a pidestal while the rest are passive and occupied by their sins and inadequacy, and really start talking about the Gospels and imitating them, seeking God together with fervour and expectation, then the Evangelicals and other Protestants will stop fearing we have gone astray and we can be much more effective and unified in everything essential.

I wont write here anything more.
I am not interested in long discussions based on everything but what we see in the Gospels.
I know a man who is Pentecostal. He and his wife came to pick up their child from daycare. The nanny told them they had to find another daycare because she had gotten cancer and could not work much longer. The Pentecostal couple said: Well we believe in a God that does miracles. Then, right there, they prayed hands on for this lady in the name of Jesus. She was instantly healed, and needless to say, she must have been very open to hear the Good News of salvation.
Thats how simple it can be. And I wish to be with these simple people who can teach me to walk like that in faith, and with such trust in our heavenly Father instead of complicating everything.
And when I say complicating I talk about all the moralism, the devotions and privat apparitions, the huge number of books to read besides the Bible, the emphasis on philosophy and suffering, the division of laity and priesthood and nuns into a- and b teams, etc. All of this is okay, much is good and useful to you. But I feel many things have gone off on a tangent, and we neglect the basics and the actual example over all others.

We don’t all have to be alike. But this is my reasoning, and my reason why I will probably attend both Catholic and Pentecostal services as soon as possible.

Daisy
 
Many years ago, when I observed things going wrong in the Catholic Church with many members, especially with Religious and Clerics I became very upset. I even took a priest to the Airport only to find out he was to rendezvous with a woman to get married in a distant town I searched my soul, and felt driven to do something for the Catholic Faith, to speak out for Christ and the faithful. I once aspired to the priesthood, but it was found that I didn’t the psychological stamina that was required for the African Missionaries. You see my childhood background made that impossible. I made peace with myself, I had to bite the bullet, and it was hard. When I see men treat something so holy and good to be in the service of God, so cheaply, and ungratefully, I felt devastated, and beside myself. I came to realize that God had other plans for me, and I accepted.

I had love for Christ and that never changed, so I felt compelled to do something for Him and the Church so that the world would know the truth of our faith. So I decided to take Christ at His word and act on it in public. I attended a showing of the body of a good man who tried to save the life of a drowning child. In the process he was drowned. His wife and friends were so saddened by the event. I thought this is my chance to show the world the truth of our Faith and shake up the world. I approached the coffin with his body and said “Michael arise in the Name of Jesus” Michael didn’t arise. I was hurt and felt humiliated, but I accepted. I went to a pray meeting that same day to be with God and other faithful. I was met at the entrance of the church by a woman who kept praising me, she didn’t really know me, but she praised me before the community. It soothed my soul, but praise really didn’t mean that much to me, I failed in my mission, it was a bummer! But since then I began to experience a prophetic gift, I wasn’t aware of it at first, but others noticed. The Holy Spirit was really working on me. I grew in the knowledge of Charisms and had some dramatic experiences. The result of which drew me deeper into my faith.
So when I hear from people like DaisyNJesus I know where they are comming from, but I also know where I am comming from. I deliberately follow the Church the best I can in all her teachings, and try my best to reconcile people like DaisyNjesus with the faith, but people make choices according to what they want and believe no matter what one may say. I accept, and when God wants to enlighten them, like many posters, He will enlighten them, I accept. My will is to follow the Spirit, not to lead Him. I would like them to change their opinions to line up with the Church, but the Lord tells us that some will, and some will not. People did it to Him, and He is God, why should we expect any different. Team we know what we desire, and God is pleased with us I know that I can say that with confidence, and that’s what really counts. I must add that I find the majority of Religious and Priest serving God faithfully, and I keep praying for them to remain faithful in God’s service.
 
The Church’s main mission is to heal spiritually, although sometimes physical healings are preformed
This is spot on Flame.

It is also what Jesus did. The church does this through teaching the full truth, and when a person follows these teachings without wavering and in full faith they are removing the evil angels(demons) in the process. Its not about a “physical” healing. Never was and never will be. It is purely spiritual and also invisible. I see these physical healing miracles that sometimes happen as extra blessings and a gift to us for having such deep faith. I speak as a person who experienced personal and constant attacks from such demons in my life. One encounter so grave it brought me to my knees and back to God. My faith had been immense due to the fact that I had such a pronounced experience with a demon and enormous love for Christ saving me from this attack. Spent 3 years withering away failing to win these fights outside of the Catholic church. It wasn’t until I refound the Catholic faith and came to know of how true it is, the immense power of the tools the holy spirit has given the church to teach us to do battle with are the ONLY things that have ever had success in my life in conquering these demons. There is no such thing as too complex or not simple enough when it comes to Christ. As the earthly realm has evolved, so has the Body of Christ. The Holy Spirit continues to unveil more tools and greater insight as we do battle in the 21st century and beyond. Its about spiritual healing. If your blessed some physical may come as a result, but physical healing alone means nothing unless the person is saved spiritually through Christ.
 
We have to remember that the Church is made up of human beings with all that comes with that!
 
One last thing. You are mad at the injustices that Catholics are doing about saying sufferings are good. I am mad about it to. They are (although not purposely) creating all of harm and they are not going out to heal as Christ commanded. We are suffering as a body of Christ and perhaps God has called you to a mission for healing. But through pray we all can be healing instruments to the world. Pray for them and you are doing the right thing in opposing sufferings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top