Catholic identity crisis

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaisyNJesus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Just happened to get interested in reading this thread and have two cents to add.

Daisy, there are many different flavors of Catholicism. In any mid-sized city, you can find a variety of parishes with vastly different approaches to “doing” Catholicism, ranging from charismatic through evangelical, and on to what I’d call “high church” Catholicism–the ones that get mightily exercised over issues of liturgical rubrics and “orthodoxy.” You can find Catholic groups focused on prison ministry, on serving the poor, on healing, probably even on speaking in tongues, if that’s of interest. Point being, these days, for good or ill, there are lots of ways to practice Catholicism. And I think many people can go their whole Catholic lives without getting too worked up about, or involved with, Mary and the saints. You can put your emphasis where you want to.

I’ve generally found that all the Catholics I’ve known (and I was a fairly active one for 50 years or so) drift toward the parish or community that is the best match for their stylistic tastes in music and liturgy, their ministry interests, their understanding of what God seems to be asking of them.

That said, I also think you are answering your own question: If your objections to Catholic doctrine and dogma (and even style) are as deep-seated as they sound, it seems to me you’d be happier back in your protestant community.
 
I know the parts of this post weren’t addressed to me, but I think I could help in responding.
I can not understand that it was holy and pious that Therese of Lisieux suffered greatly because she was tormented, gievn lousy food, and lived in a cold cell.
I do not desire to be a great moral theologist or a philosopher that knows every teaching in the Church. I simply wish I had a faith like these evangelical people.
Like Soren Kierkegaard once wrote “The true humility will not be satisfied with the left hand, but will demand the right”. That is the childlike faith that I see in for example Heidi Baker, which is a faith I have not seen much among Catholics. I wish I had, really.
I think you are missing the point about St. Therese. What makes her such a great saint isn’t her physical sufferings, her scruples, her doubts, etc., but that she kept such a childlike faith in the midst of these struggles. To quote that great saint, “It is love alone that counts.”
The more good Catholics ridicule the Pentecostals and say we don’t need what they have, the more hollow I think it sounds. because we do need what they have. We are not yet angels in heaven. The people that called upon Jesus did really call for him to heal them. He did not belittle their prayer.
No good Catholic is acting as a good Catholic by ridiculing another. The Church rejoices in all that is good wherever it is found, inside or outside the Church. Because all good things come from Christ, and from Christ through the Church.
 
Mary always points to Jesus. When the shepherds came to see baby Jesus, Mary and Joseph let them behold their son – thus pointing to Jesus. At the marriage feast in Cana, Mary told the servants, “Do whatever He tells you.”

When she followed her Son to the Cross, Jesus told His mother that John was her new son. And by extension, he gave his Mother to all believers.
Right on sister in Christ:thumbsup:
 
DaisyNJesus
Peace of Christ be yours. We can not give what we don’t possess. Pray as you can, not as you can’t. God can put us into a situation to test our love for Him. We humans get hung up on His gifts and we love them. But while we enjoy His gifts, and perhaps He takes them away (not really, but to us it seems that way) It is only to draw our attention to the real gift of Himself. St.Paul considered all things, and I mean all things as “dung-old expression from the Bible” compared to the knowledge of Jesus Christ. St.Paul called it the pre-eminence of Jesus, that we were created for Him , through Him, and by Him. He is before all things.

Also when we lose our peace with a troubling situation, think of the possibility that it is not from God, but Satan who would very much like to separate you from the whole truth. Remember Satan could not even do that unless God let him So God is always in complete control. Use your Faith in Christ and ask Him to enlighten you in this area of your spiritual life, and do not disregard the love that is shown to you by the posters Where there is love, there is God.
 
It surprises me that your approach to this is to simply suspect brother Christians of lying.
All I can say is that the people who told me about the dead being raised were worthy to be believed. Much more so than those who never do anything but talk.
They are not stupid that they would not know a corpse from a living person.

I have heard such testimonies the last few years from different countries in the world where people who suffer a lot for the sake of the Gospel and preach it (in Africa and China etc.) see huge miracles.

But I have also heard a story like this very close to my home. A Pentecostal father aised his son back to life again - after a deadly accident that had completely destroyed the little boy - through persistent and trusting supplication for about half an hour.

I believe the Western world with its intellectualism and philosophy has made us into sceptics.

The minister Heidi Baker, whom I mentioned earlier, has also seen people raised from the dead. At least five children, who were prayed over by simple African pastors who didn’t know that they were not supposed to pray for such things apparantly. I have met Mrs. Baker and would say she is one of the greatest missionaries alive today because she follows the example of Christ. The word anointing has a clear meaning even when you read her books.

Another testimony I could mention is the famous convert from Islam to Christianity, Gulshan Esther, who wrote her testimony book called “The Torn Veil”. She tells not only about her complete healing from being a cripple after a vision of Jesus Christ, but also how she actually raises her sister back to life. Again there is no reason I would insist on doubting testimonies which are so clearly in line with the Gospels. Jesus told his disciples to do these things, just like he told Peter to step out on the water, which also might sound silly or unprovable for a modern western ear.

Now its amazing to me that you much rather assume that such testimonies are lies, than that you would willingly trust the word of Jesus himself to his disciples:
“Heal the sick, raise up the dead, clean the lepers, cast out demons! You have been given it for free, give it for free”. (Matthew 10: 7-8 )

I think we can learn a great deal about faith from other parts of the Body.

Daisy
I do, too. But shouldn’t one be careful? Jesus himself said there would be others making claims in his name…
Matthew 24…
9“Then they will deliver you to tribulation, and will kill you, and you will be hated by all nations because of My name. 10“At that time many will fall away and will betray one another and hate one another. 11“Many false prophets will arise and will mislead many. 12“Because lawlessness is increased, most people’s love will grow cold. 13“But the one who endures to the end, he will be saved. 14“This gospel of the kingdom shall be preached in the whole world as a testimony to all the nations, and then the end will come.
 
a Catholic is a member of the body of Christ; therefore, a Catholic’s identity is Jesus 🙂 problem solved - live, breathe, and BE HIM, follow Jesus, and you are Catholic
 
Dear sister,

I do read the books from other Christian traditions as well as the Catholic tradition. Why should I not? I have so many books. I liked the saint litterature as well, but I could relate much more readily to the Evangelical Pentecostal testimonies than to the ascetic, somewhat elitist saint litterature about the greatness of suffering, celibacy and morification.
I was very amazed by all this when it was still new to me, but now I do not like to read it much. I feel more inspired by books like “The Hiding Place” by Corrie ten Boom, “The Knife and the Switchblade” by David Wilkerson, “A man called Mr. pentecost” by David duPlessis etc. etc.
I did read a real good book by Catholic sr. Briege McKenna about her healing ministry in the Catholic Church. That was a good book, and it comforted me.

Honestly it was only after I became a Catholic that I encountered all these awesome testimony books from the Evangelical world. It has been a great richness but also created a longing to be with these brothers and sisters that walk in this Kingdom Life, and to learn from them. And as you see it does create some difficulty for me and some conflicting ideas.

I have read extremely much Catholic stuff, I used to live like a hermit almost, and also studied quite a lot of theology, moral theology, catechism, council writings etc. It was amazing and rich and beautiful to get into all that. But when I open the books by the Pentecostals, I say, this is the life of Jesus, and that is what is real. And these people are the ones I want to be like, because they are like Jesus, and I understand what they say and do.

I can not understand that it was holy and pious that Therese of Lisieux suffered greatly because she was tormented, gievn lousy food, and lived in a cold cell.
I do not desire to be a great moral theologist or a philosopher that knows every teaching in the Church. I simply wish I had a faith like these evangelical people.
Like Soren Kierkegaard once wrote “The true humility will not be satisfied with the left hand, but will demand the right”. That is the childlike faith that I see in for example Heidi Baker, which is a faith I have not seen much among Catholics. I wish I had, really.

The more good Catholics ridicule the Pentecostals and say we don’t need what they have, the more hollow I think it sounds. because we do need what they have. We are not yet angels in heaven. The people that called upon Jesus did really call for him to heal them. He did not belittle their prayer.

tell me, are you as a former Baptist never wondering about the language used in some marian devotions, like when Catholics call her their “hope, their life, their salvation” and such?
It seems that some people make good converts like you, and others are always stuck in the culture and faith which they thought they could leave behind.
I know both kinds. I know I am not alone with my struggles.
Can you share more thoughts with me?

Daisy
I was commenting on what kind of Christian religious reading I do and also telling you that I have the common experience of having the “seed” of my Protestant background.
I love Corrie Ten Boom. I was lucky enough to attend one of her talks when I was a teenager. I was extremely inspired. I wish I could be 1/2 as holy as she. My only experience with faith healers was when my mom took us to a Kathryn Kuhlman rally.
I was drawn to the the Catholic Church ever since I could remember. I was received into the Catholic Church when I was 29. (I’m now 53.) I said what I said only because I wish you the best in our Catholic faith.
I’m sorry if I offended you in any way.
 
I was raised in the pentecostal church of god and I have no desire to go back I prefer to stay in the Catholic Church which was founded by Christ.I am a convert to the Catholic faith.
 
I know the parts of this post weren’t addressed to me, but I think I could help in responding.

I think you are missing the point about St. Therese. What makes her such a great saint isn’t her physical sufferings, her scruples, her doubts, etc., but that she kept such a childlike faith in the midst of these struggles. To quote that great saint, “It is love alone that counts.”

No good Catholic is acting as a good Catholic by ridiculing another. The Church rejoices in all that is good wherever it is found, inside or outside the Church. Because all good things come from Christ, and from Christ through the Church.
I know the parts of this post weren’t addressed to me, but I think I could help in responding.

I think you are missing the point about St. Therese. What makes her such a great saint isn’t her physical sufferings, her scruples, her doubts, etc., but that she kept such a childlike faith in the midst of these struggles. To quote that great saint, “It is love alone that counts.”

.
My point is not whether she loved Jesus or not. Of course she did. What I meant was that someone or something had given her the idea that it was most pious to be silent and to suffer at the hands of cruel people who tormented her. Like it would honour God if we suffer at the hands of sadists, instead of just saying: “I need you to turn up the heat in my cell or I will get sick and die.”

I know the Church does not say the canonized saints were sinless at all. However, it does seem that the Church as an institution has promoted also these ideas about illness, asceticism and suffering (everything from stigmata to being suffering a number of illnesses).

I read the book by another saint where it is recorded that she ate someone’s vomit in order to do atonement or mortification.
What this comes down to is that it seems there is a different idea about Jesus and what he actually wants in different churches. What I end up with are testimonies that seem almost unreconcilable.

In the Pentecostal Christianity they focus on what Christ has done and how he has atoned and fulfilled everything and redeemed us, so we don’t have to atone for our sins, which we cannot do anyway and which has already been sufficiently done.

According to the Bible we are called to repent and to serve and love God and our neighbour. But to “make reparations to the heart of Mary” and such things, are ideas which I do not understand where come from. Christ has already atoned for all the sin in the world that has ever been comitted.
Also the idea that people should carry other people illnesses or suffer illness and speak of it as some sort of sign of piety and special gift from God. This is something we see again in the Catholic mystical litterature, which I think is different from what is seen in the Gospel.

It is said Jesus saved us from our sins and bore our sicknesses. This is clearly written. So why do so many Catholics agree that Jesus forgave our sins, but not that he took our sicknesses? Howcome they think they must pay a ransom which has already been paid by suffering for illnesses and sins of others, as though they could adequately do this anyway?

These questions are rather rhetoric. I do not mean to engage in a discussion about all this with you, but to just prove that my points of disagreement go deeper than just being emotionally bored at church.

By the way. I read the book by Therese of Lisieux as well and thought it was good. However, it was one of the books that launched me into a kind of Christianity where there is really much focus on one’s own deeds instead of on what Jesus has done and what he can do through us. This creates scrupolosity and fear in a person, who is preoccupied with own sins, instead of making her or him into a free and zealous evangelist. At least that is my experience.

So childlike faith, Therese, sure had, the faith of a Catholic. Shortly after that I read a book by a Pentecostal person. This person chose to follow Jesus at a very young age, was powerfully baptised in the Holy Spirit as a boy with the signs that follow, was hearing God speak to him and was gloriously led by the Holy Spirit, in ways that make one think of the Acts of the Apostles. In this book there was no glorification of suffering unless it was because of persecution for the Gospel. The childlike faith in that book was something I could relate more to in light of my reading of the Gospels.

Daisy
 
DaisyNJesus
Peace of Christ be yours. We can not give what we don’t possess. Pray as you can, not as you can’t. God can put us into a situation to test our love for Him. We humans get hung up on His gifts and we love them. But while we enjoy His gifts, and perhaps He takes them away (not really, but to us it seems that way) It is only to draw our attention to the real gift of Himself. St.Paul considered all things, and I mean all things as “dung-old expression from the Bible” compared to the knowledge of Jesus Christ. St.Paul called it the pre-eminence of Jesus, that we were created for Him , through Him, and by Him. He is before all things.

Also when we lose our peace with a troubling situation, think of the possibility that it is not from God, but Satan who would very much like to separate you from the whole truth. Remember Satan could not even do that unless God let him So God is always in complete control. Use your Faith in Christ and ask Him to enlighten you in this area of your spiritual life, and do not disregard the love that is shown to you by the posters Where there is love, there is God.
Are you saying I am hung up on his gifts?
What if someone told you you were hung up on the liturgy and you need to focus on Christ and you were to live on some island and never hear the liturgy? or your loved ones pale in the comparison with the Eucharist, so you shall sit in front of the Eucharist and be content without your family?
That would not be sound.
Can I ask you something? Have you ever had a deadly ill person close to you, and be surrounded by unbelievers while you pray with doubt and trembling for their healing?

What I would like is to be part of a community that seeks the Holy Spirit and who carry out the evangelisation the way I find most credible and in harmony with the Gospels. Let us not forget that evangelisation is the core job and purpose of being for the Church. That means us. So when I hear Catholics make light of the ways in which Jesus and the apostles preached the gospel I wonder if this is not rather because we have become too rationalistic and too intellectual.

You need not bring in to this satan. It is funny this subtle manipulation and threatening by people when they encounter a Christian who does not share their ideas. They all say: careful satan is causing the unease and the questions and all that.
But what about the unease I feel about Marian devotion?
The anti-catholics could find every reason to say: of course you feel strange, you are in the wrong place.
I have heard it all.
Seems I am caught between two nails then. The Catholic saying I must repent and pray for enlightenment and the Evangelicals who say I am shamed by a man.made system and of course I lost my peace when I entered that.
I can not really win then can I?
And both sides seem to say they represent Jesus.
In terms of history and theological history the Catholic Church seems credible in its claim to hold authority. But when it comes to example and fruit it seems the Pentecostals, especially those in the third world, are the ones who really live in the Kingdom of God, which Jesus showed us.

You see the difficulty then ?
 
One more thing I would suggest, Daisy. Please read “A Man for Others” – the biography of St. Maximilian Kolbe. St. Maximilian offered his life for a young father at Auschwitz.

You can find this book on Amazon.com. amazon.com/Man-Others-Maximilian-Kolbe-Auschwitz/dp/006067069X

It touched me to the very core of my being.
You did not offend me.
Look I have read so many books, and I also found them quite inspiring. And yes I am quite familiar with the story about Kolbe and of course he was heroic. So was Bonhoeffer and a great many other Catholic and noncatholic saints that died as martyrs during the war.
My point is not that Catholics do not inspire me.
It is more that years after reading all these books, it is the Evangelical books with their simple Christ-centred testimony and- he-has-done-it-all attitudes that I keep going back to, get inspired by and which I feel safe with.

It is like it is almost a genetic thing. A cultural barrier.
When Catholics say: “Mary, refuge of sinners, it has always felt strange to me”. If I am in Christ, do I need to take refuge in a creature? Even on Catholic Answers Forums I see ideas and beliefs spelled out which I do not hold at all. Someone said that God gives all graces through Mary. Not just in the sense that Jesus was born from her flesh, but in the sense that every grace continuously is given through her only. I do not believe that. I can not.

I know I am not the only one to suffer with such thoughts. The difference between me and some people is that I am quite passionate and always feel uneasy when there are unresolved issues.
I am glad for you that your conversion has been more smooth. There is no doubt that it might have been good for me to have waited with becoming fully Catholic. Our RCIA-program was very poor. Many people came into that parish and later stopped attending.

Daisy
 
I was raised in the pentecostal church of god and I have no desire to go back I prefer to stay in the Catholic Church which was founded by Christ.I am a convert to the Catholic faith.
I am happy for you.
My intention is not that people should leave the Catholic Church. On the contrary. You would be surprised by the amount of apologetics I have done the last ten years. I assure you most people would not know about the struggles that go on inside of me.

My estrangement has not ceased in certain areas, however, but maybe even become more felt over the years. Especially as I have grown lonelier in the Catholic parish and heard and seen more what is going on among many of our Pentecostal brothers and sisters.
 
Especially as I have grown lonelier in the Catholic parish and heard and seen more what is going on among many of our Pentecostal brothers and sisters.
This I simply do not understand. This seems very human based. This seems about the sense of joy that you perceive that Pentecostalists feel. The Church is not here to make us feel happy about ourselves, Christ did not die in order that we feel happy in this life. Christ died to save our souls from eternal damnation. In the light of that the ‘buzz’ of joyous gatherings really does pale into insignificance. Mass is the Sacrifice of Calvary happening before our very eyes, it is not a community party.

Would you give up what you know to be true (and from what you have written you do know it, i.e. Christ’s one true Church and the real presence) in exchange for a better ‘experience’ and sense of community (as you seem to regard it) in the Pentecostal Church? Would you set your own emotional (and even spiritual) needs above the Truth that is the Catholic Church? Regardless of your own emotions I really don’t believe that you would.

God Bless,

Brendan
 
Here’s a brief account that explains why St. Maximilian is the Saint of Auschwitz:

Tadeusz Joachimowski, clerk of Block 14A: “In the summer of 1941, most probably on the last day of Juyl, the camp siren announced that there had been an escape. At the evening roll-call of the same day we, ie Block 14A, were formed up in the street between the buildings of Blocks 14 and 17. After some delay we were joined by a group of the Landwirtschafts-Kommando. During the count it was found that three prisoners from this Kommando had escaped: one from our Block and the two others from other Blocks. Lagerfuhrer Fritzsch announced that on account of the escape of the three prisoners, ten prisoners would be picked in reprisal from the blocks in which the fugitives had lived and would be assigned to the Bunker (the underground starvation cell)”

Jan Jakub Zegidewicz takes up the story from there: “After the group of doomed men had already been selected, a prisoner stepped out from the ranks of one of the Blocks. I recognized Fr Kolbe. Owing to my poor knowledge of German I did not understand what they talked about, nor do I remember whether Fr Kolbe spoke directly to Fritzsch. When making his request, Fr Kolbe stood at attention and pointed at a former non-commissioned officer known to me from the camp. It could be inferred from the expression on Fritzsch’s face that he was surprised at Fr Kolbe’s action. As the sign was given, Fr Kolbe joined the ranks of the doomed and the non-commissioned officer left the ranks of the doomed Firzsch had consented to the exchange. A little later, the doomed men were marched off in the direction of Block 13, the death Block.”

The non-commissioned officer was Franciszek Gajowniczek. When the sentence of doom had been pronounced, Gajowniczek had cried out in despair, “Oh, my poor wife, my poor children. I shall never see them again.” It was then that the unexpected had happened, and that from among the ranks of those temporarily reprieved, prisoner 16670 had stepped forward and offered himself in the other man’s place. Then the ten condemned men were led off to the dreaded Bunker, to the airless underground cells were men died slowly without food or water.

Bruno Borgowiec was an eyewitness of those last terrible days, for he was an assistant to the janitor and an interpreter in the underground Bunkers. He tells us what happened: “In the cell of the poor wretches there were daily loud prayers, the rosary and singing, in which prisnoers from neighbouring cells also joined. When no SS men were in the Block, I went to the Bunker to talk to the men and comfort them. Fervent prayers and songs to the Holy Mother resounded in all the corridors of the Bunker. I had the impression I was in a church. Fr Kolbe was leading and the prisoners responded in unison. They were often so deep in prayer that they did not even hear that inspecting SS men had descended to the Bunker; and the voices fell silent only at the loud yelling of their visitors. When the cells were opened the poor wretches cried loudly and begged for a piece of bread and for water, which they did not receive, however. If any of the stronger ones approached the door he was immediately kicked in the stomach by the SS men, so that falling backwards on the cement floor he was instantly killed; or he was shot to death … Fr Kolbe bore up bravely, he did not beg and did not complain but raised the spirits of the others. …Since they had grown very weak, prayers were now only whispered. At every inspection, when almost all the others were now lying on the floor, Fr Kolbe was seen kneeling or standing in the centre as he looked cheerfully in the face of the SS men. Two weeks passed in this way. Meanwhile one after another they died, until only Fr Kolbe was left. This the authorities felt was too long; the cell was needed for new victims. So one day they brought in the head of the sickquarters, a German, a common criminal named Bock, who gave Fr Kolbe an injection of carbolic acid in the vein of his left arm. Fr Kolbe, with a prayer on his lips, himself gave his arm to the executioner. Unable to watch this I left under the pretext of work to be done. Immediately after the SS men with the executioner had left I returned to the cell, where I found Fr Kolbe leaning in a sitting position against the back wall with his eyes open and his head dropping sideways. His face was calm and radiant.”

The heroism of Fr Kolbe went echoing through Auschwiz. In that desert of hatred he had sown love. Mr Jozef Stemler, former director of an important cultural institute in Poland, comments: “In those conditions … in the midst of a brutalization of thought and feeling and words such as had never before been known, man indeed became a ravening wolf in his relations with other men. And into this state of affairs came the heroic self-sacrifice of Fr Maximilian. The atmosphere grew lighter, as this thunderbolt provoked its profound and salutary shock.” Jerzy Bielecki declared that Fr Kolbe’s death was “a shock filled with hope, bringing new life and strength. …It was like a powerful shaft of light in the darkness of the camp.”

catholic-pages.com/saints/st_maximilian.asp
 
My RCIA process was not smooth in all aspects. I really resisted the necessity of the Sacrament of Reconciliation. I did it out of obedience. My first confession was amazing. I brought up sins I had held onto for a long time. And when the priest absolved me, I felt truly free. But first, I had to obey. I’m just speaking for myself and I’m not telling anyone else what to do.
 
My RCIA process was not smooth in all aspects. I really resisted the necessity of the Sacrament of Reconciliation. I did it out of obedience. My first confession was amazing. I brought up sins I had held onto for a long time. And when the priest absolved me, I felt truly free. But first, I had to obey. I’m just speaking for myself and I’m not telling anyone else what to do.
I find the sacraments fantastic. I have always felt hugely blessed by confession, and went to one even before I became Catholic.

I do not know why you bring obedience in to this though. Can you explain?
Are you saying I should pray prayers and such which seem inappropriate to me in order to be obedient?
 
I find the sacraments fantastic. I have always felt hugely blessed by confession, and went to one even before I became Catholic.
That is great! That in itself will keep you firmly within the Church.

As for Fatima, while the vast majority of Catholics accept Fatima, and the Church has firmly approved it, individual Catholics are not compelled actually to accept the apparitions. The Church does not compel individual Catholics to accept any ‘private revelations’ no matter how widespread these revelations have come to be accepted by most Catholics, and regardless of the fact that our Popes also have strong devotions to these. You must accept the compassionate, Immaculate Heart of Mary, but you do not have to accept Fatima. Nor is any Catholic compelled to pray the Rosary. Personally I do accept Fatima (and any ‘priavte revelation’’ that the Church has approved of) and I think the Rosary is a wonderful prayer for protection and battle against evil, but the Church does not compel this.

So if you feel that your unwillingness to accept things like Fatima, the Rosary etc., is a blockage and stumbling block in your being a true Catholic, it is not.

The Catholic Church is not made up of clones who all do the same things, think the same way, and pray the same way. It is not. Perhaps it is the fact that Pentecostalists do tend to pray in the same way and have very a similar spirituality that you feel it ought to be the same in the Catholic Church. It isn’t.

So long as you believe in the Sacraments (as you clearly do) and adhere totally to the teachings of our Church then how you pray is up to you. If you don’t seem to fit in with how the Catholics around you pray, then why should it worry you? We don’t become Catholics because we want to fit in with people.

God Bless,

Brendan
 
This I simply do not understand.** This seems very human based. This seems about the sense of joy that you perceive that Pentecostalists feel.** The Church is not here to make us feel happy about ourselves, Christ did not die in order that we feel happy in this life. Christ died to save our souls from eternal damnation. In the light of that the ‘buzz’ of joyous gatherings really does pale into insignificance. Mass is the Sacrifice of Calvary happening before our very eyes, it is not a community party.

Would you give up what you know to be true (and from what you have written you do know it, i.e. Christ’s one true Church and the real presence) in exchange for a better ‘experience’ and sense of community (as you seem to regard it) in the Pentecostal Church? Would you set your own emotional (and even spiritual) needs above the Truth that is the Catholic Church? Regardless of your own emotions I really don’t believe that you would.

God Bless,

Brendan
You seem you be very focused on the idea that all I want is a pleasurable feeling. You disregard that the tension I experience also has to do with a lack of credibility or inconsistency with what I read in the New Testament and see around me in my actual parish life.

You keep coming back to Pentecostal life being about “party”, “buzz” and “being happy about one self”.

In my experience this is a pattern among many Catholics. They refuse to honour the presence and the actions of Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit in the Pentecostal congegations, and instead keep insisting that Pentecostal church life is all about “feeling happy about one self”.

I know you will be displeased, but it seems to me as narrowminded as the anti-catholic stuff you can hear wherever, where a fundamentalist evangelical paints some image of a churchtradition he has not truly familiarized himself with, and yet insists its all based on the flesh.

Were you ever part of a Pentecostal church, did you read the classics of their tradition, get familiar with their “language”, or see the works of God among them?

We know that Catholicism is not based on the flesh, and that catholics are really seeking God and often experiencing his meaning and light in their lives, both intellectually, through emotion, and mystical experience.
It seems that you deny that the Pentecostal congregations and individuals are God-focused and that Christ leads these people very much, both individually and as congregations. In fact I think that God can very well use congregations to help the individual members and guide them. So when we cut off everything that is congregational in order to focus strictly on liturgy and sacraments or church teaching, we miss something vital.

The people I have met within Pentecostalism were very healthy people. They seemed to have a joy and freedom about them and were not focused on their own sins so much as on the power and goodness of Jesus to overcome everything. I found precisely this extremely inspiring, together with their zeal for evangelisation (not to be mixed up with apologetics). They did not deny pain or suffering in this world, but made it clear that Jesus was and is a prophet and healer because he was and is the messiah who personified and brought the Kingdom of God among us.

You say “the Truth is the Catholic Church”. I say the Truth is Jesus Christ. I would not call the Church the Truth, and I would not worship the Church or go against my conscience in order to follow any institution, no matter how much it claimed to have part in the truth. The Church it self is not the Truth that we are called to preach, Jesus is the Truth, the way and the life. Nothing else should be called the Truth.

Your heavy rhetorics - about the hierarchy of things which you think very important (another Catholic trait) - I suppose is an attempt to make me say with you that I do not need what I found within Pentecostal community. But all I can say is that I do not mind the condescension, when you tell me my views and longings are human based. Indeed they are because I am a human being.
I would also like to be among people and worship God with people who are human and who admit we need to follow his example and the example for Church life found in Scripture, including the charismatic gifts, the zeal for evangelisation, the concrete unity and fellowship, meaningful words (preaching) etc.

And yes, human persons need all these things. They also need healings when they are sick, and not just to be told that God gave them some sickness with which to atone for the sins which Christ already carried up on the cross and saved us from.
I currently know severel people who have cancer. I will try to bring them to the Pentecostals. I really wish I could bring them to my Catholic parish with their human based need for healing.

I thank you for your participation here.

Daisy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top