B
balboa
Guest
Just happened to get interested in reading this thread and have two cents to add.
Daisy, there are many different flavors of Catholicism. In any mid-sized city, you can find a variety of parishes with vastly different approaches to “doing” Catholicism, ranging from charismatic through evangelical, and on to what I’d call “high church” Catholicism–the ones that get mightily exercised over issues of liturgical rubrics and “orthodoxy.” You can find Catholic groups focused on prison ministry, on serving the poor, on healing, probably even on speaking in tongues, if that’s of interest. Point being, these days, for good or ill, there are lots of ways to practice Catholicism. And I think many people can go their whole Catholic lives without getting too worked up about, or involved with, Mary and the saints. You can put your emphasis where you want to.
I’ve generally found that all the Catholics I’ve known (and I was a fairly active one for 50 years or so) drift toward the parish or community that is the best match for their stylistic tastes in music and liturgy, their ministry interests, their understanding of what God seems to be asking of them.
That said, I also think you are answering your own question: If your objections to Catholic doctrine and dogma (and even style) are as deep-seated as they sound, it seems to me you’d be happier back in your protestant community.
Daisy, there are many different flavors of Catholicism. In any mid-sized city, you can find a variety of parishes with vastly different approaches to “doing” Catholicism, ranging from charismatic through evangelical, and on to what I’d call “high church” Catholicism–the ones that get mightily exercised over issues of liturgical rubrics and “orthodoxy.” You can find Catholic groups focused on prison ministry, on serving the poor, on healing, probably even on speaking in tongues, if that’s of interest. Point being, these days, for good or ill, there are lots of ways to practice Catholicism. And I think many people can go their whole Catholic lives without getting too worked up about, or involved with, Mary and the saints. You can put your emphasis where you want to.
I’ve generally found that all the Catholics I’ve known (and I was a fairly active one for 50 years or so) drift toward the parish or community that is the best match for their stylistic tastes in music and liturgy, their ministry interests, their understanding of what God seems to be asking of them.
That said, I also think you are answering your own question: If your objections to Catholic doctrine and dogma (and even style) are as deep-seated as they sound, it seems to me you’d be happier back in your protestant community.