Catholic identity crisis

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaisyNJesus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
There are real needs in our Church, especially concerning youth and young adults. We old timers have been subjected to a lot of formality, and ritual. We have been indoctrinated with the truths of our Faith. Life has proven to me and many others that this indoctrination hasn’t necessarily taken root. The world culture has a big influence, plus some have not had a real Christ encounter. There is a great need for Evangelization, There are some areas in Catholic education that were not Christio-centric, even in some Catholic colleges. The Church from time to time needs a spiritual renewal. The Charismatic renewal is a type of spiritual renewal. I have been in it for at least 17 years, was one of the pioneers in my area. I was called to it. I have had many spiritual experiences concerning the Movement, or renewal . They confirmed for me many truths of my Catholic faith. I have seen people come closer to their faith. As a matter of fact I have seen them become leaders. I have seen teenagers come off drugs, and get more involved with the faith. I also have seen some drift away from the faith, because they never had an encounter with God, or the Holy Spirit as they experienced in the Charismatic renewal. I have been with a Bishop who witnessed some of these spiritual events, and priests where involved. Those that drifted away didn’t really have an understanding of their Faith, or weren’t converted in the first place We Catholics have to become like St.Paul when he said “We become all things to all men for the sake of the kingdom” I’m afraid this wasn’t understood, or practice by some. When Paul addressed his followers, and many were converted because they saw healings, and exorcisms, and miracles (charisms to edify, to build the church) he knew that wasn’t all that the faith was about. He told them that he fed them (spiritual )milk (the lighter things of faith) that they were not ready for spiritual meat( the deeper things of faith which dealt with the virtues of Faith, Hope and Love.). Jesus said himself, that you can do all these charismatic things, and still go to hell, if you did not have love St.Paul reinforces the words of Christ.

We must make a distinction between what edifies, and what sanctifies. And of course what sanctifies is of the most importance when it comes to salvation of one’s soul. We need the edifying graces to build the Church, but these graces are of the nature of “milk” to young believers they should lead into more spiritual maturity that comes from “Meat” the real substance of our Faith. Charismatic gifts can produce spiritual delight, as they should, but the real test of faith is to remain faithful, and constant to Jesus even when any delights are not experienced. Spiritual consolations are good, and received from God and we are to be thankful, and we can really need them from time to time and God in His love for us supplies them. We must not stifle the Spirit, He operates where He wills, we need to see what He is doing in the Church. He is the Soul of the Church, and Christ is the Head
 
Charismatic gifts can produce spiritual delight, as they should, but the real test of faith is to remain faithful, and constant to Jesus even when any delights are not experienced.
And that is nub of it all. At its core, Faith is not about feeling good, feeling joyful, feeling sorrowful even. Faith is about remaining faithful, faithful to the teachings of Christ through His Church. How the Church makes us feel is nothing more than a comfort to us. The real test is whether we stick with Christ and His Church when it does not make us feel good.

If as a result of sticking with Christ’s Church we felt lonely, upset, hurt, wounded would we then walk away and look for something else that made us feel better? How did Christ feel on the road to Calvary? Did He walk away?

As you say, charismatic gifts can produce spiritual delights and can help people with their Faith, although I do feel people need to be careful not to indulge in such delights to the point where these delights seem to the point where receiving these gifts seem to be their main focus and identity.

The Church is not there to make us feel good, the Church is there to help save souls from Hell.
 
Of course there is room for you in the Church. However the Church is what the Church is, 2000 years of Truth. Truth is not determined by emotions.

Why not be an evangelical Catholic?

Please stick with us. Find a Catholic evangelical group to attend in addition to Mass, perhaps that might help you develop your particular spiritual charism.

Believe me, I do know how you feel, but from the other end of the spectrum.

However I may consider walking away from my parish church, but I would never walk away from the Church.
Brendan,
I am sure it is not intentional but you do sound a bit patronizing. 😛

You seem to think I am merely bored. Well, my problem goes deeper than that. Firstly it is about what I read in the Gospels, which remain the strongest example for us to follow, and secondly, the experience I have had in my encounter with people and testimonies from certain Evangelical parts of Christ’s body. These I find not only exemplifies New Testament example, they also bear the fruits that Jesus said believers would: love between brothers ( however unimportant you might think that is compared to the Eucharist) Evangelistic/missionary zeal, joy, and the charismatic gifts, including mighty deeds (in the assembly and individually).

Over the last few years I have only grown further away from Marian devotions, prayers to saints and the whole elitist and clericalistic thinking and focus on sinfulness, shame and hierarchies that often accompany such devotions and asceticism. I find that I even take sides with Protestants in discussions on such matters, wondering what odd language Catholics have developed. I have always felt uneasy about especially the Fatima apparitions, which I found to be downright scary and which I could hardly bring in connection with Scripture. So too the extreme suffering of the saints. And then there is the whole suffering theology that Catholics have developed over centuries, so that now even illness is seen as some kind of noble gift, which I find quite contrary to the face value of the Gospel testimonies about Christ. Let us be honest, not once did Jesus tell anyone to “offer up” their illness as though it would save others (except for in the question of persecution), neither did he ask if they were in a state of grace before he healed their bodily afflictions. Yet these ideas are alive within Catholic circles. Within Pentacostalism I have seen people healed from the greatest illnesses, exorcisms carried out by normal lay people etc. I have had to wonder if Catholics developed all these theories about the greatness of suffering because we didn’t have faith, neither as individuals, nor as institution, to pray people healed.

You ask me to compare the crucifix to what might be the focus in a Pentecostal gathering. Well believe it or not, but Christ and the Holy Spirit are the focus in the hearts and minds on the people in a Charismatic Church, as they worship God in unity and zeal (just like we), and I have no doubt that the Lord is present there, as he promised. The first time I had been to a Pentecostal church I felt so drawn to go there again. I felt and still believe that my spirit was drawn by the Spirit. This is not to say that I do not feel the actual, objective presense of Christ in the Eucharist. I do. It is a tangible experience. But you might tell me that is also just a feeling that I cannot trust.😉

I can tell you, if it were not for the Eucharist I would have possibly left the Catholic Church.
You say I can join a Charismatic group within the Church. Firstly I don’t believe that the charismatic part of parish life should be thrown out to a small group. The Bible is clear that the gifts are for the edification of the congregation, not just for a few people in a meeting. But I know no Catholic parish which is charismatic in the sense that the Holy Spirit can act freely and people can get edified like it is written in St. Paul’s letter to the Corinthians. You might say such congregations do not exist anywhere, but they do.

So I could remain, but I would remain estranged. Sometimes I have wept during mass, because we suddenly had to sing some song that I could not sing along with because I didn’t believe in it and felt it to be improper. I have felt a real pressure from Catholic well meaning people, to conform to devotions I cannot see much sense in, the rosary included.

Truly I am very conservative and quite radical - I mean to follow the truth, and I often think the right thing for the very liberal people would be to enter some liberal church community instead of pretending to be what they are not. Because Catholic Church teaching is conservative.
Maybe I should follow my own advice. In my view some liberal Catholics excuse sins that are clearly mentioned in the Bible, or say you can be Catholic even if you don’t believe in half the Creed. I don’t like this kind of pretending we can be all things. Its not fair to those who really are part of the group. But now I find myself out of the honest unity too.

So you see, its not because I am just emotional. Believe me for a long time I sat on a cold stone in the Church and adored Jesus in the sacrament and said I would remain there because it was the truth, even though I felt the indifference, stiffness and coldness of the parish I joined. But I don’t think things are so black and white anymore. Neither do I have such high oppinions of my self, that I think I do not need anyone. In fact I know I do.

What I see around me in the world makes me think there is a side to the Body of Christ, which I find more authentic, more close to what I recognize as truly Christian.
I do not know what to do. I fear I will grow either stronger in my Pentecostal non-catholic convictions, or that I will eventually grow numb and indifferent.
Daisy
 
Of course there is room for you in the Church. However the Church is what the Church is, 2000 years of tradition, 2000 years of Truth. Truth does not depend on how it makes us feel, truth is not determined by emotions, truth simply is.

Why not be an evangelical Catholic?

The Catholic Church is broader than people first think. There are many different charisms within the Church, the Charismatic movement, Opus Dei, Latin Mass Society, Justice and Peace, and much more.

However what we represent is the truth of Christ in its most complete, fullest sense, 2000 years of truth. A continuous tradition of truth going right back to the direct founder of our Church on Earth, Christ Himself.

Mass is not a social gathering where we come primarily to mix and mingle with our friends. Mass is a solemn event, afterall Calvary was a lonely place and it is the sacrifice of Calvary that is the central point of the Mass. Focus on the crucifix above the altar, compare that to what would be the central focus at an evangelical gathering. That perhaps may go some way towards explaining the difference in outward appearance of people during Mass, than at an evangelical gathering.

Please stick with us. Find a Catholic evangelical group to attend in addition to Mass, perhaps that might help you develop your particular spiritual charism.

Believe me, I do know how you feel, but from the other end of the spectrum. Presently I really am struggling myself, but because my parish church seems to becoming less ‘Catholic’ in the traditional sense of the word.

However I may consider walking away from my parish church, but I would never walk away from the Church. Where Peter is There is the Church.
There are real needs in our Church, especially concerning youth and young adults. We old timers have been subjected to a lot of formality, and ritual. We have been indoctrinated with the truths of our Faith. Life has proven to me and many others that this indoctrination hasn’t necessarily taken root. The world culture has a big influence, plus some have not had a real Christ encounter. There is a great need for Evangelization, There are some areas in Catholic education that were not Christio-centric, even in some Catholic colleges. The Church from time to time needs a spiritual renewal. The Charismatic renewal is a type of spiritual renewal. I have been in it for at least 17 years, was one of the pioneers in my area. I was called to it. I have had many spiritual experiences concerning the Movement, or renewal . They confirmed for me many truths of my Catholic faith. I have seen people come closer to their faith. As a matter of fact I have seen them become leaders. I have seen teenagers come off drugs, and get more involved with the faith. I also have seen some drift away from the faith, because they never had an encounter with God, or the Holy Spirit as they experienced in the Charismatic renewal. I have been with a Bishop who witnessed some of these spiritual events, and priests where involved. Those that drifted away didn’t really have an understanding of their Faith, or weren’t converted in the first place We Catholics have to become like St.Paul when he said “We become all things to all men for the sake of the kingdom” I’m afraid this wasn’t understood, or practice by some. **When Paul addressed his followers, and many were converted because they saw healings, and exorcisms, and miracles (charisms to edify, to build the church) he knew that wasn’t all that the faith was about. He told them that he fed them (spiritual )milk (the lighter things of faith) that they were not ready for spiritual meat( the deeper things of faith which dealt with the virtues of Faith, Hope and Love.). ** Jesus said himself, that you can do all these charismatic things, and still go to hell, if you did not have love St.Paul reinforces the words of Christ.

We must make a distinction between what edifies, and what sanctifies. And of course what sanctifies is of the most importance when it comes to salvation of one’s soul. We need the edifying graces to build the Church, but these graces are of the nature of “milk” to young believers they should lead into more spiritual maturity that comes from “Meat” the real substance of our Faith. Charismatic gifts can produce spiritual delight, as they should, but the real test of faith is to remain faithful, and constant to Jesus even when any delights are not experienced. Spiritual consolations are good, and received from God and we are to be thankful, and we can really need them from time to time and God in His love for us supplies them. We must not stifle the Spirit, He operates where He wills, we need to see what He is doing in the Church. He is the Soul of the Church, and Christ is the Head
 
Brendan,
I am sure it is not intentional but you do sound a bit patronizing. 😛
I can assure you I do not intend to patronise you.
You seem to think I am merely bored.
No I do not. But I do think you want to have your cake and eat it. You left a Pentecostalist community to join the one true Church, but now you want to hang onto all the bits you liked about the Pentecostalist community you left as well as the bits that you do like about the Catholic Church.
the experience I have had in my encounter with people and testimonies from certain Evangelical parts of Christ’s body. These I find not only exemplifies New Testament example, they also bear the fruits that Jesus said believers would: love between brothers ( however unimportant you might think that is compared to the Eucharist) Evangelistic/missionary zeal, joy, and the charismatic gifts, including mighty deeds (in the assembly and individually).
The Catholic Church does more charity work on this Earth than any other organisation, let alone any other Church. That is testament to real love of one’s fellow man in a much more meaningful way than beaming smiles and hugs to each other on a Sunday.
Over the last few years I have only grown further away from Marian devotions, prayers to saints and the whole elitist and clericalistic thinking and focus on sinfulness, shame and hierarchies that often accompany such devotions and asceticism.
Elistism and clericalism? What has this got to do with Marian devotions or prayers to the saints? Nothing at all.

And nobody is compelled to pray the Rosary in the Catholic Church. But Mary was the Mother of God so quite rightly deserves pride of place within our Church.

As for focus on sinfulness. We are not guaranteed a place in Heaven simply because of our membership of the Church. Christ spent a large part of His mission focussing on sin. The Church exists to lead mankind top Heaven and this can only be done by us striving to free ourselves from sin.
You ask me to compare the crucifix to what might be the focus in a Pentecostal gathering. Well believe it or not, but Christ and the Holy Spirit are the focus in the hearts and minds on the people in a Charismatic Church, as they worship God in unity and zeal (just like we), and I have no doubt that the Lord is present there, as he promised.
That was not what I meant. The Mass is not simply a gathering of Christians in prayer. The Mass is a reenactment of the Sacrifice of Calvary. The very Eucharist exists as a result of this sacrifice where Christ’s body and blood were shed and were then unified on His Ressurection. The essence of the Mass is a solemn sacrifice. Without Christ’s suffering and execution, there would be no Eucharist, there would be no salvation. We were not redeemed at Pentecost, we were redeemed at Calvary.
The first time I had been to a Pentecostal church I felt so drawn to go there again. I felt and still believe that my spirit was drawn by the Spirit. This is not to say that I do not feel the actual, objective presense of Christ in the Eucharist. I do.
Martin Luther no doubt felt drawn by the Holy Spirit when he split from the Church. The Church is like a roadmap, sometimes we might feel as if we are going in the right direction, but we must then consult the teachings of the Church to check whether what we felt was indeed the right direction. If what we do is not in line with Church teachings then we must conclude that what we felt was wrong or incorrectly interpreted by ourselves. You feel the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist, then surely that is enough to convince you that it is in His Church, the one true Church, that you should trust?
I can tell you, if it were not for the Eucharist I would have possibly left the Catholic Church.
And that in itself ought to be proof enough for you to trust the Church in which Christ resides in physical form?
You say I can join a Charismatic group within the Church. Firstly I don’t believe that the charismatic part of parish life should be thrown out to a small group.
So you feel that the whole of the rest of the Church ought to follow a charismatic path, simply because you believe that is the right direction?
Maybe I should follow my own advice. In my view some liberal Catholics excuse sins that are clearly mentioned in the Bible, or say you can be Catholic even if you don’t believe in half the Creed.
You are free to chose sin, but with that comes the wages of sin.

I honestly think that you need to learn to love the Church. Would you marry a man, and then try to change him into something he is not. Do you love him, or are you in love with an image of him that you want to create, but one that does not yet exist? Should the Church be moulded in your image of what the Church should be like, or should you love the Church as she is and conform yourself to Her?

Whatever your doubts, hang onto the fact that Christ resides in physical form in the Catholic Church. Why does that not happen in the Pentecostalist community you are so fond of?

And do join a Catholic charismatic group, as that would seem to suit your own personal spiritual charism. Ours is a broad Church as far as spiritual charisma are concerned. Myself, I would never wish to join a charismatic group, as that is not my spirituality, but you will find that the Church is very accommodating.

Whatever happens, whatever your doubts, do not leave us, please!

God Bless,

Brendan
 
DaisyNJesus:
Anytime people are involved no matter Catholic, Protestant or Pentecostal you are going to find imperfection, scandal and corruption, it is inevitable. Mankind is in spiritual bondage until Jesus Christ save us, we inherited this condition due the sin of Adam. I know you must be familiar with this truth of faith. The whole mission of Jesus was to take our corrupt state and transform it to an "incorruptible state- a state of sanctifying grace, some call it “Amazing Grace” a sharing in the divine life of God To do this the Father leads into an encounter with His Son. An encounter of the first kind, is one where we turn form sin and turn to Christ, something wonderful causes us to do this. It is an “Enlightenment” a gift from God. But how many had a personal encounter with Jesus and heard Him say “I love you” He does this, He did it to me. No human voice, just in my soul by communicating through my understanding, and giving me a "spiritual experience " to confirm it. Jesus said “Ask anything of the Father in my Name and He will give it to you” How deep is your faith.

Acts 10: 9-49 When Cornelius received his vision of an angel, the angel said "Cornelius the lord has answered your prayers…send for the man from Joppa Simon called Peter. Peter came with his company and he and Peter exchanged their experiences about the vision of “The Sheets containing different animals…” Peter said "I see that God shows no partiality,rather in every nation whoever fears Him and acts uprightly is acceptable to Him. Then Peter shares the “Good News” Jesus is the Son of God, and how He went about doing good performing miracles, and how He was crucified, but rose from the dead. While Peter was speaking the “Good News” the Holy Spirit fell upon Cornelius and company, and those with Peter were astounded by what they saw. For they could hear them speaking in tongues, and glorifying the Lord. Then Peter responded “Can anyone with-hold water for baptizing these people, who have received the Holy Spirit even as we have?” He ordered them to be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ

The reason I referred to this passage of the Gospel is that I know this is one of the major beliefs, if not the major belief of the Pentecostals. for their belief in the gift of tongues and other Pentecostal gifts. You will have to notice that all of this happened because of the "Good News being preached by Peter and it culminated in the Baptism of Cornelius and party. By the Charisms of the Holy Spirit they were led into becoming members of the Christian Church led by Peter who Jesus assigned to lead His Church. When Jesus asked Peter "Who do you say I am, and Peter answer “Thou art the Christ, the Son of God” and Jesus said “this is not of your self, but because of the Holy Spirit given to you by my Father” Peter’s Faith in Jesus, and he represented that faith, was to become that rock upon which Jesus will build His Church, Jesus is the Rock, and Peter represented that Rock. It was Peter who ordered their Baptism. this also shows the meaning and significance of the Charismatic gifts, to build and edify, but it is the Baptism that sanctifies,and Peter was put in charge. The Charisms are incomplete in their use if they do not lead a sanctifying life, a life in Christ. So where does the truth direct one?
 
I feel that its almost like a culture… and I cannot understand the Catholic culture which to me seems to stress the intellectual ( like the scripes instead of the way Jesus was)
Catholicism stresses both intellecutal life AND spiritual life.

You need both.

If you refute intellectual endeavors then you turn like thos crackpots who believe the Earth is 6000 years old… then maybe take a science class and lose all their faith thinking Christinity is irrational, while only THEIR Christianity was irrational.

Also you cannot be only an intellectual or your spiritual life will be extremely dry.

I do not know at your local Church, but most priests I know, in their sermons, are not teaching high theology, but give more down to eath spiritual advice in light of the gospel.
to stress the suffering instead of all the healings that Jesus showed us in his Gospels,
That’s a misconception. We celebrate BOTH his suffering and his resurrection. We need to understand both.

Looking at Jesus’ suffering helps us dealing with our suffering: God has suffered like us, hence He relates to us.

Looking at Jesus’ Resurrection gives us the hope for the new life that awaits us.
to stress Mary and the Saints when it comes to prayers, instead of trusting Jesus, the Father and the Holy Spirit and growing in their personal Love and power,
The Church DOES stress God in his prayers. Do you EVER go to Mass? Do you LISTEN? All the prayers are to God the Father through Jesus Christ with the power of the Holy Spirit!

Even the prayer to saints, where we ask their help, ultimately go to the Father through Jesus.

It’s a protestant bias to think we favor the saints above God… a bias based on ignorance.
and to stress the elitist clericalism, which for me seems very odd, when I think of the powerful testimonies from ordinary folkes within the other churches…
There is no elitist clericalism. Sure I admit maybe SOME do fall into clericalis, but priests are SERVANTS and MINISTERS. “Minister” in the sense of administrator, those who are trusted by God to dispense the sacraments.

Remember that Jesus gave tha APOSTOLES this duty, not just any guy who went around.

This however does NOT and shoud not stop people from performing good things, pray and halp the Church.
**
The Church is a community. Everyone must do his part, not only priests. People who afoten accuse the Church of clericalism are the first who refuse to do an humble, but necessary, job… and that is sinful pride, not justice**
people who even raise people from the dead, and who dont talk about holy orders, mortifications etc.
I would really like to see that…

In any case many people in the CATHOLC CHURCH, which we venerate as saints, DID do many miracles, even sometimes raise people from the dead

. She is a clearly a mystic, she had a vision where she was getting married to Jesus, yet she is a wife and a mother of two, a missionary in Africa who sees visions, hears from Jesus so much, and who have prayed for soo many people so that they got healed even from AIDS. People even get raised from the dead in her ministry…
How is that possible? How can a Pentecostal who probably lives in the deadly sin of contraception hear so much from Jesus and do such a splendid Work for him?
You ASSUME she is a mystic. Also all NUNS in the Catholic Church are, in sense, married to Jesus, one could say.

I could write and invent visions of Jesus and claim to be a mystic. This would not make me so.

The Church has always been the first skeptic regaring people who claimed to have mystical visions, miracles, etc… Such skepticism is an healty skepticism, it does not exclude that miracles and visions are possible, yet it does not gullibly believe any old wives’ tale!

Now I have nothing against Ms. Baker, who seems a very good person and Christian, mind you, but I would take what she says with a pinch of salt.

I do not doubt she is doing good work and I am happy she helps and converts people, but before crying miracle I would go beyond just trusting the mystics’ word.

INDEED the Church takes her time to investigate miracles and mystics
Indeed I feel the Catholic suffering-“saint image” of Christ in the middleages, and the one that is shown me through people like Heidi Haker are two different views of God.
Not all saints are people who suffered greatly, Some did, some didn’t.

All had their hardships, and I am sure, Ms. Baker had too!

To note that even saits who suffered gretly, like St. Francis of Assisi, also were HAPPY people, trusting in God.
I ask myself, when Heidi Baker hears so much from Jesus, which is truly also evident from the fruits in her life, then why does he not call her to join the catholic Church? She is more an example than any catholic I have met, and Jesus does not tell her she needs the Eucharist… I ask myself why?
You assume A PRIORI, Baker is some sort of saint and miracle worker, but there have been criticism from the protestant world:

talk2action.org/story/2012/5/7/6228/64684/Front_Page/Christianity_Today_Should_Retract_or_Correct_Cover_Article_on_New_Apostolic_Leader_Heidi_Baker

So be careful.
 
ALSO

1- you ignore all the Catholics throughout history and now are nystics and even have performed miracles, as if Baker is the only one who ever did it.

2- you assume Bakers message is correct, but some of her statements are very very shady, theologically speaking.
HEre you need REASON: If a person claims to be a mystic, but makes statements that theologically contraddict the gospel… then there must be something wrong… either that or Jesus make mistakes!

3- You see to ignore completely all the movements within the Catholic Church: such as the Catholic Charismatic Renewal (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Charismatic_Renewal)forfor) example

4- What is Christianity for you? Some sort of joyride with fancy special effects or an encounter with God?
The Eucharist is a true encounter with God and whose who truly learn to appreciate it turn to true mystics… and indeed there is a whole great deal of mysticism around the Eucharist

5- Also the Catholic Church has a HUGE tradition of Mysticism (see en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_mysticism)

You just have to open the door and look for it.
 
You say:
For me, I have this principle: The church is to be represented by the best Catholics. Now when I read the stories about saints I often feel estranged. The theology of suffering and atonement (self inflicted suffering also) it seems so unlike the spirit of the Gospels, and how I see what Jesus did and said. Jesus told us to imitate him and do what he did. When I read the saints now, I see a lot of strange things that I do not see in the Gospels.
I met good Catholics. And I admire many of them, but mostly in the human strength they show when they make big sacrifices etc, even in areas where I think its not reasonable to do so. I admire these people for their intellect and honesty and conviction that what they believe is right.
The Church is ALL the Catholics… good or bad.
sented by the best Catholics. Now when I read the stories about saints I often feel estranged. The theology of suffering and atonement (self inflicted suffering also) it seems so unlike the spirit of the Gospels, and how I see what Jesus did and said
that’s very ODD, since Jesus more than once talked about atonement, how about he had to suffer, and how people should pray and fast and also be penitent for their sins. The Church however does reject hedonism, ie pleasure for pleasure’s sake.

Thsi does not mean there is no room for joy. Jesus invites both, and so does the Church. It seems to me you are fixated to only look at the negative and never at the positive.

There is a time for atonement and penitence and a time for joy and celebration, like there is a time of Lent and a time of Easter in the Lithurgy.
But on the other hand, I find them to be often clericalistic, elitist in their thinking, dry intellectualists, with a faith which is surely deep but which is lacking outward manifestations like joy, fellowship, healings etc…
Sometimes I must even think of the Scribes and Pharisees. They had all the authority but they lay burdens on the shoulders of others. When Jesus came he said: The people were poor and unedified like sheep without shepherds.
Funny how you say they are “Good Catholics” ad “Adimre them” and then curse them to be hypocrits and stuck up snobs like the Pharesees.

I think you ought to do a “self-check”!!! There is something wrong here!

Just because someone is intellectually active, it does not mean he is like a pharisee.

The Pharisees (or the ones Jesus accuses in any case) had only an external faith, just doing things because it was in the rules of Judaism and expected with extreme zeal everybody ought to be like them.

Just becuase people believe in order, and indeed also Holy Orders, and know their faith and use reason, it does not mean they are like the Pharisees.

If they are good Catohlics they are not.

Also being a Christian does NOT mean be all “happy clappy” like in some Pentecostal Churches, which, in my opinion, it borders on the ridiculous!

I see also a kind of social control, even on CAF, which I do not like. Its menacing. The funny thing is I used to be like that also. Someone would utter some doubt on Church teaching and I would say: “Should you be Catholic, do you really belong here?” The immensity of the spiritual pride! And that is what I see even on this thread.
I think itòs a bit infatile to think Jesus had not his moral judgments and that he was some sort of a hippy.

Jesus himself spoke some very harsh words, sometimes.

Read the Gospel
from Matthew 5:
21 “You have heard that it was said to those of ancient times, ‘You shall not murder’; and ‘whoever murders shall be liable to judgment.’ 22 But I say to you that if you are angry with a brother or sister,[a] you will be liable to judgment; and if you insult** a brother or sister,[c] you will be liable to the council; and if you say, ‘You fool,’ you will be liable to the hell[d] of fire. 23 So when you are offering your gift at the altar, if you remember that your brother or sister[e] has something against you,**
Or Matthew 22:
.
9 Go ye therefore into the highways; and as many as you shall find, call to the marriage.
10 And his servants going forth into the ways, gathered together all that they found, both bad and good: and the marriage was filled with guests.
11 And the king went in to see the guests: and he saw there a man who had not on a wedding garment.
12 And he saith to him: Friend, how camest thou in hither not having a wedding garment? But he was silent.
13 Then the king said to the waiters: Bind his hands and feet, and cast him into the exterior darkness: there shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth.
14 For many are called, but few are chosen.

Jesus was definitively not the “Happy Hippy” some picture him to be, but he also was firsm and sometimes harsh.

Funny, also, how you say first we a Catholics are moralists and then lament we do not preach about damining people to hell enough…

ALSO:

If you are so unhappy in your current parish, CHANGE PARISH.

Not all priests are good preachers, not all parrishes are the same. There are some bad priests and bad parrishes around.

You are judging ALL CATHOLICS only by looking at the FEW around you.
 
DaisyNJesus:
Anytime people are involved no matter Catholic, Protestant or Pentecostal you are going to find imperfection, scandal and corruption, it is inevitable. Mankind is in spiritual bondage until Jesus Christ save us, we inherited this condition due the sin of Adam. I know you must be familiar with this truth of faith. The whole mission of Jesus was to take our corrupt state and transform it to an "incorruptible state- a state of sanctifying grace, some call it “Amazing Grace” a sharing in the divine life of God To do this the Father leads into an encounter with His Son. An encounter of the first kind, is one where we turn form sin and turn to Christ, something wonderful causes us to do this. It is an “Enlightenment” a gift from God. But how many had a personal encounter with Jesus and heard Him say “I love you” He does this, He did it to me. No human voice, just in my soul by communicating through my understanding, and giving me a "spiritual experience " to confirm it. Jesus said “Ask anything of the Father in my Name and He will give it to you” How deep is your faith.

Acts 10: 9-49 When Cornelius received his vision of an angel, the angel said "Cornelius the lord has answered your prayers…send for the man from Joppa Simon called Peter. Peter came with his company and he and Peter exchanged their experiences about the vision of “The Sheets containing different animals…” Peter said "I see that God shows no partiality,rather in every nation whoever fears Him and acts uprightly is acceptable to Him. Then Peter shares the “Good News” Jesus is the Son of God, and how He went about doing good performing miracles, and how He was crucified, but rose from the dead. While Peter was speaking the “Good News” the Holy Spirit fell upon Cornelius and company, and those with Peter were astounded by what they saw. For they could hear them speaking in tongues, and glorifying the Lord. Then Peter responded “Can anyone with-hold water for baptizing these people, who have received the Holy Spirit even as we have?” He ordered them to be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ

The reason I referred to this passage of the Gospel is that I know this is one of the major beliefs, if not the major belief of the Pentecostals. for their belief in the gift of tongues and other Pentecostal gifts. You will have to notice that all of this happened because of the "Good News being preached by Peter
Ynotzap.

That is all fine and good. I do not deny that Peter was an apostle and even the leader among them. My problem is that I do not see the connection between much Catholic spirituality today and that which I see in the New Testament. That makes me anxious. Do you understand?

It is interesting. In the Cornelius-story you see a whole household being baptized in the Holy Spirit with the signs that accompany this. Could you imagine what would happen if Pope Francis went visiting a house and they all started praying in tongues. The scandal it would cause if he walked the streets and started healing the sick, like Peter and John did in fact do after the resurrection.
The very fact that this is unthinkable and even ridiculed as an outrageous idea, is one of the reasons why I feel estranged from many otherwise very clever and good Catholics.

Other reasons are these trends that I see, also on Catholic Answer Forums. Catholics who suffer illness and they offer it up instead of praying for health because they think this is pious; Catholics who sit and pray 3-4 rosaries a day in order to earn something from God, whereas my Pentecostal friends (non priests) just lay hands on people even afflicted with cancer and they get healed; Catholics who believe in odd apparitions and stories from mystics and yet scorn the simple Christian in other churches who simply go and evangelize and actually do the things Jesus told us to do.
It’s almost like the Gospels are not interesting enough and challenging enough, so many Catholics choose to talk about saving all the poverty problems in the world, world peace, philosophy and morality instead of doing that which Jesus told us to do: preach the Gospel, heal the sick, dispel the demons from the possessed etc.

Paul tells us how to form our congregational life. He says; when you come together, one person will bring this gift and another will bring that. The very strong and effective gift of prophesy was worthy to be strived for - which anyone can understand that has actually experienced it -. It is also written that if there are ill people in the congregation the elders shall pray for him and he shall be healed. All this is being at least partly ignored or even looked down upon, while we see as much illness in our communities as ever, and what we preach is often not hope of deliverance but rather dry intellectual consent to moral truths.

It seems easy to exult the suffering instead of praying together for healing as a community – a real prayer together over a really sick person. Even our leaders do not expect healings, let us be honest. Try to just look at the responses I get here. It is assumed that I am childish in my faith, that all I want is comfort of feeling good, that Christ himself opposes my ideas, that I am preposterous for even suggesting that I am not edified in a Church that offers me the Eucharist etc.

But when I read the Bible I wonder at the way the Bible is being read by Catholic people, and the ways it is not being read. That is my problem. I do not know if it can be solved. But I am so tired of feeling guilty that things do not make sense to me, and of getting told I am fighting Jesus, because for Catholics “Jesus” is almost synonomous to “Church”.

I do not think it makes much sense.

Daisy
 
I can assure you I do not intend to patronise you.
…
Brendan
Dear Brendan.

Thank you for your reply which was kind and serious.

About having the cake and eating it. Firstly I want to say, I did not leave the Pentecostal Church in order to join Catholicism. I only encountered the Pentecostal church a couple of years after joining the RRC. You are right that I hang onto things that I experienced there. I can not deny that, neither do I want to, because what I experienced was helpful and good, and humbled me as a Catholic. You know of course that I can not abandon that which I believe to be true.

Brendan, I believe a variety of things that do not all match well together. For instance I am positively sure that demons were cast out and cancer was healed etc. by lay people and leaders in the Pentecostal church, and the Holy Spirit was present and welcomed among them so that he could do these things in the congregation. It was a firmly christocentric assembly, where the Bible was central. I have heard people speak real languages in tongues, I have heard prophesy, words of knowledge, seen a community vibrant in the service of the Holy Spirit, and I have had to compare it to Catholic community life where people were bored, young people left the church, preaching was seen as unimportant, community was seen as unimportant, miracles seen as suspicious, odd devotions and practices were widespread – like exulting of suffering caused by illness, and the belief that saints could better obtain blessings for us, or that Mary would hold back the wrathful arm of God etc, all things I can not accept.

You say clericalism has nothing to do with excessive devotion to Mary. You are right. My point was to sum up shortly all the tendencies that I do not agree with or can not understand. Now clericalism has been warned against from the highest places in the Church, but it is still very active everywhere especially among ardent Catholics.
My problems with Marian devotion are of course more problematic, since I am constantly told I am wrong, and I also can not avoid it: In my neck of the woods, every mass is preceded by a Rosary and Marian songs are sung at mass. I cannot feel a unity with a Catholic who stands next to me and sings: Mary is my salvation, Mary, my grace, mary my life etc. This is so strange to me. I can not understand that Catholics are surprised that the Protestants think we worship Mary, when we find such expressions in our songs and litanies.

Do you really think its nice to sit in a congregation that prays like this, and among friends who want to admonish you and pressure you to do what your whole being cannot agree to? What am I to do?

You say the Catholic Church is the biggest charitable ornanization in the world. Now I find this saying very nice, but also very abstract. In Europe at least the vast majority of people hired by Catholic organizations to do relief work etc. are not practicing Catholics. I know people who are atheists who work at Catholic hospitals. I think your statement is as vague as when one Catholic stands up and says the church has the fullness of faith. How do we even measure such a thing? What does it even mean?

A bunch of the poorest of the poor, filthy, sick, molested children etc. encounter the ministry of Heidi Baker. They get food, shelter, the good news of salvation, many get healed emotionally, and physically, moslems get healed and are ready to hear the Gospels because of this etc. In the real world, Heidi Baker and her ministry and their pastors - who also raise the dead and make exorcisms – because they were never told they were not supposed to – these are the real church to real people at a real moment of need. These people are putting their life on the line. It is not about "free hugs and smiles” on Sundays.

You are right that we are redeemed at Calvary. But Jesus also said: Its right for me that I go so that the Holy Spirit can come. I have a feeling that many people in the Catholic Church do not focus on the Holy Spirit and what is written about him and his works. It seems they think that Mary leads them to Christ, instead of the Holy Spirit. Yet he is the one who does it, according to the Word.

You find it preposterous that I think the whole church should be more or less charismatic in its spirituality. As a person who does not feel comfortable within this way, you feel uncomfortable at the suggestion. Well, welcome to how I feel in the church about a lot of things. Maybe you can relate now.

You ask, why does the Eucharist – real presence of Christ not happen in the Pentecostal community. Well, we both know the reasons for that. We also both know, that because of the Eucharist I am likely to stay although I feel unedified in many ways. But why don’t you answer me too; why do the Evangelicals preach so well, evangelise with much more success, why do they see so many healings and miracles, why do they have so much joy and such good and strong communities? If they are wrong and we are right, then why is that? And don’t tell me these things are details.

Your words about me choosing sin and about marrying a man and then seeking to change him were uncalled for and you just took the discussion down to a level we didn’t have to go to. What if I told you your convictions were sinful? All that is just rethorics. You talk as though faith is something one simply chooses. But the problem arises when one feels pressured to consent to something which makes no sense to one’s mind and heart. I hope you do not do that, Brendan, because Jesus knows your thoughts and he knows mine. I do not wish hypocrisy and fear upon anyone, Catholic or non-Catholic.

I hope you understand.
 
ALSO

1- you ignore all the Catholics throughout history and now are nystics and even have performed miracles, as if Baker is the only one who ever did it.

2- you assume Bakers message is correct, but some of her statements are very very shady, theologically speaking.
HEre you need REASON: If a person claims to be a mystic, but makes statements that theologically contraddict the gospel… then there must be something wrong… either that or Jesus make mistakes!

3- You see to ignore completely all the movements within the Catholic Church: such as the Catholic Charismatic Renewal (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_Charismatic_Renewal)forfor) example

4- What is Christianity for you? Some sort of joyride with fancy special effects or an encounter with God?
The Eucharist is a true encounter with God and whose who truly learn to appreciate it turn to true mystics… and indeed there is a whole great deal of mysticism around the Eucharist

5- Also the Catholic Church has a HUGE tradition of Mysticism (see en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_mysticism)

You just have to open the door and look for it.
With all respect. I can not enter into a dialog which would be meaningful and fruitful on the basis of the posts you have written. Thank you for your time though, and I did read your oppinions.
Blessings,
Daisy
 
Daisy NJesus:

I shared my Charismatic experiences with the Forum, but for some reason, and I can imagine the reasons they were deleted. Their authenticity may have been one, and if they were posted it would invite a lot of questionable experiences that would need a lot of discernment. Satan is always active in so many ways. But I can truly say that I experienced the Charism of the Church, and God verified it for me, and others, Priests, Nuns and college students, charismatic prayer groups. I made my experiences known to Bishops, and I can name names of people who witnesses some of these events. But even in Charismatic prayer groups I could discern Satan’s works. So no group is perfect and without fault and even sin. You say you don’t understand many things, neither do I, and I think many others will agree that they don’t either. Trust in Jesus to see us through in spite of all the obstacles. We learn that when things seem to be going all wrong, we must be doing something right, because the devil never tires, or quits, but his does suffer defeat before he even tries, he is condemned to try knowing it is all futile. Right now you are going through a spiritual trial, one of doubt, one of questions, one of even disillusionment. The Charismatic gifts Faith, discernment, prophecy,and tongues were granted to me, I don’t control them, only when the Holy Spirit moves me to use them, and they are most powerful when I emphasize the truths of my Catholic Faith. This was the reason I as a lay apostle joined the Charismatic renewal, to keep those involved on the path of truth, found in our faith, and God empowered me. I had to learn a lot about humility, and those that apposed my witness were humbled themselves. I had no control over this. This even included clergy, Most of the prophesy involved becoming God’s mouth piece concerning spiritual problems in the Church and with youth. We Catholics are being exposed to our own priesthood, but never to supercede the Ordained Priesthood of the Church We can hear confessions, we hear many on the forum from youths that really need spiritual help, we council, but we can,t absolve, Jesus gave that to the Ordained Priest. We can lay hands and pray and seek healing, according to God’s will. We don’t command God. We can perform simple exorcisms, but not possessions, the Church forbids it because people can get hurt. It is true that there is not a whole lot of freedom, but a cautious freedom it the use of the Charisms in the Church. There is a strong awareness that when we have spiritual manifestations, the devil is good at imitating the Holy Spirit, and without discernment, this becomes dangerous. I have been deceived and almost causes a possible family problem. The devil actually took control of my voice and imitated Tongues, if it wasn’t for discernment I would have be deceived again. I do have the real tongues, and I was led to use it when I felt incapable of worshiping God with ordinary prayer, but I use my own language most of the times. I admit formal prayer can get very dry, and my mind is all over the place. Tongues lets me rise to a higher level of concentration, it was spiritually verified for me, so I have no doubt to its validity. So you see, the Charisms can be experienced in the Church, and outside the Church. You can not bottle the Spirit, He moves where He wills, we have to learn to move with Him. Turn to the Holy Spirit, especially when you receive Christ in Holy Communion, He is there with Jesus, and His Father and ask Him to solve you spiritual problem, with Him there is peace of mind and soul, if you remain disturbed it is not the work of God. Trust Jesus.
 
People need to be listened to, not yelled at or dictated to. I have been guilty of both, and I still struggle with my own bloviating.

In life as in online.

I hope Daisy returns, but if not, God bless.
 
Daisy,

I think you focus too much on all the non-essentials, on all the bits around the core.

Go to exposition of the Eucharist and sit in silence in the physical presence of Our Lord and you will know why you should never leave the Church.

To me you seem to be more concerned with all the ‘frills’ around the edges.

I love praying the rosary, but nobody is required to. If people pray the rosary before Mass, you are under no obligation to join them. That is a separate, personal devotion, and not all Catholics pray the Rosary anyway.

You talk about miracles and healing at Pentecostalist churches, there are thousands of miracles that have occurred at Lourdes. Those miracles may not include a lot of dramatic hands in the air and praises, but these miracles occur nevertheless, through the intercession of Our Lady.

You may feel uncomfortable about miracles happening through the intercession of Our Lady, but why do you not feel uncomfortable about miracles happening through some minister in a shirt and tie?

Seriously, go to Eucharistic adoration and sit silently for an hour in the presence of Our Lord. All the stuff round the edges, all the joyous feeling of laying on of hands, all the community camaradre, etc. doesn’t matter any more.
 
Daisy,

I think you focus too much on all the non-essentials, on all the bits around the core.

Go to exposition of the Eucharist and sit in silence in the physical presence of Our Lord and you will know why you should never leave the Church.

To me you seem to be more concerned with all the ‘frills’ around the edges.

I love praying the rosary, but nobody is required to. If people pray the rosary before Mass, you are under no obligation to join them. That is a separate, personal devotion, and not all Catholics pray the Rosary anyway.

You talk about miracles and healing at Pentecostalist churches, there are thousands of miracles that have occurred at Lourdes. Those miracles may not include a lot of dramatic hands in the air and praises, but these miracles occur nevertheless, through the intercession of Our Lady.

You may feel uncomfortable about miracles happening through the intercession of Our Lady, but why do you not feel uncomfortable about miracles happening through some minister in a shirt and tie?

Seriously, go to Eucharistic adoration and sit silently for an hour in the presence of Our Lord. All the stuff round the edges, all the joyous feeling of laying on of hands, all the community camaradre, etc. doesn’t matter any more.
Sir, I do not believe healing, prophesy, love between brothers etc. are non-essential frills. Go to a sick person and say that their healing is a “frill”. And I bet you can not find one single Christian who wouldn’t secretly desire a word of prophesy - there are so many people who feel that God does not even see them.
How can I experience a unity with you, when you say my needs are frills? I do not find it wise when people are being told they need nothing but the Eucharist.

I do not wish to go to Lourdes, nor to Fatima. I am even free to reject these private apparitions. I do not wish to practice a Christianity where it is believed that Mary can and would obtain miracles for us more easily than Christ.
Marian appartions - and especially the way they are dealt with by numbers of Catholics - is something I can not understand and which makes me very uneasy. Especially when people do what you just did: refer me to Lourdes, or the Rosary, or some prayers to angels or saints, as though I shared your spirituality.

In theory I am allowed to care little about all these things as a Catholic, but in reality I am put under pressure from almost every Catholic, who tells me I should do this or that devotion and who makes me feel that I am not a good Catholic if I do not wish to.
 
People need to be listened to, not yelled at or dictated to. I have been guilty of both, and I still struggle with my own bloviating.

In life as in online.

I hope Daisy returns, but if not, God bless.
Sailor,

I am here. Please let me hear your thoughts.

Daisy
 
Daisy NJesus:

I shared my Charismatic experiences with the Forum, but for some reason, and I can imagine the reasons they were deleted. Their authenticity may have been one, and if they were posted it would invite a lot of questionable experiences that would need a lot of discernment. Satan is always active in so many ways. But I can truly say that I experienced the Charism of the Church, and God verified it for me, and others, Priests, Nuns and college students, charismatic prayer groups. I made my experiences known to Bishops, and I can name names of people who witnesses some of these events. But even in Charismatic prayer groups I could discern Satan’s works. So no group is perfect and without fault and even sin. You say you don’t understand many things, neither do I, and I think many others will agree that they don’t either. Trust in Jesus to see us through in spite of all the obstacles. We learn that when things seem to be going all wrong, we must be doing something right, because the devil never tires, or quits, but his does suffer defeat before he even tries, he is condemned to try knowing it is all futile. Right now you are going through a spiritual trial, one of doubt, one of questions, one of even disillusionment. The Charismatic gifts Faith, discernment, prophecy,and tongues were granted to me, I don’t control them, only when the Holy Spirit moves me to use them, and they are most powerful when I emphasize the truths of my Catholic Faith. This was the reason I as a lay apostle joined the Charismatic renewal, to keep those involved on the path of truth, found in our faith, and God empowered me. I had to learn a lot about humility, and those that apposed my witness were humbled themselves. I had no control over this. This even included clergy, Most of the prophesy involved becoming God’s mouth piece concerning spiritual problems in the Church and with youth. We Catholics are being exposed to our own priesthood, but never to supercede the Ordained Priesthood of the Church We can hear confessions, we hear many on the forum from youths that really need spiritual help, we council, but we can,t absolve, Jesus gave that to the Ordained Priest. We can lay hands and pray and seek healing, according to God’s will. We don’t command God. We can perform simple exorcisms, but not possessions, the Church forbids it because people can get hurt. It is true that there is not a whole lot of freedom, but a cautious freedom it the use of the Charisms in the Church. There is a strong awareness that when we have spiritual manifestations, the devil is good at imitating the Holy Spirit, and without discernment, this becomes dangerous. I have been deceived and almost causes a possible family problem. The devil actually took control of my voice and imitated Tongues, if it wasn’t for discernment I would have be deceived again. I do have the real tongues, and I was led to use it when I felt incapable of worshiping God with ordinary prayer, but I use my own language most of the times. I admit formal prayer can get very dry, and my mind is all over the place. Tongues lets me rise to a higher level of concentration, it was spiritually verified for me, so I have no doubt to its validity. So you see, the Charisms can be experienced in the Church, and outside the Church. You can not bottle the Spirit, He moves where He wills, we have to learn to move with Him. Turn to the Holy Spirit, especially when you receive Christ in Holy Communion, He is there with Jesus, and His Father and ask Him to solve you spiritual problem, with Him there is peace of mind and soul, if you remain disturbed it is not the work of God. Trust Jesus.
Hello,
thank you for your second reply.
I really agree with you on everything you say.
I do not know if your posts were deleted intentionally. What I do feel is that many conservative Catholics are quite anti-charismatic. It seems that our very church structure has a way of shudding out the miraculous from congregational life. The intellectual and dry theological approach has won out.
Just see how we are supposed to win back the lapsed Catholics. We are advised to educate our selves in apologetics, instead of finally getting trained in preaching the Gospel and inviting the Spirit to confirm through signs, as is so clearly written in the New Testament that he will do.

I have felt the turbulenz on and off for the last severel years. I can sit and pray and feel joyful and at peace, but I will always again be confronted with the things that I find so puzzling. Like when I come to a Catholic Church and people would be mixed up with private revelations - I guess because they long for the supernatural and do not experience it in the church, they look for all these odd but exciting writings - or when I come to Church and the priest suddenly talks about Mary in ways I cannot follow at all, or songs and litanies are sung, which just make me want to run far away.

I know, I can just keep walking and feel like the odd one out.
I would like to know, however, are there any real Charismatic and Catholic congregations around that look anything like the one described in the letter to the Corinthians?

Daisy
 
I do not wish to practice a Christianity where it is believed that Mary can and would obtain miracles for us more easily than Christ.
Yet you are OK with miracles that occur as a result of a Pentecostal lay minister laying on hands?

And Mary does not cause these miracles herself, she intervenes for us. In effect she prays for us to Our Lord (her son) who then acts. It sometimes seems to me that many protestants seem to have no issue with asking a living person to pray to Our Lord for them, but take issue when the saints are asked to do likewise. They seem to have no issue accepting miracles that seem to occur through the intercession modern day evangelical pastors and charismatic lay-people, but seem to take issue when miracles occur through the intercession of the saints.

Yes other things are important, but compared to the enormity of what is the Eucharist they do pale into mere tools. The Holy sacrifice at Calvary is the very centre of our Faith and it dwarfs everything else in our Faith, in Christianity, in the whole world. How can everything else in our Faith and in this world not pale into insignificance compared to the very physical presence of Our Lord in the Eucharist?

The Eucharist IS the source and summit of all Christian life, not community, not charismatic gifts, not even scripture, but the Eucharist.
 
Yet you are OK with miracles that occur as a result of a Pentecostal lay minister laying on hands?

And Mary does not cause these miracles herself, she intervenes for us. In effect she prays for us to Our Lord (her son) who then acts. It sometimes seems to me that many protestants seem to have no issue with asking a living person to pray to Our Lord for them, but take issue when the saints are asked to do likewise. They seem to have no issue accepting miracles that seem to occur through the intercession modern day evangelical pastors and charismatic lay-people, but seem to take issue when miracles occur through the intercession of the saints.

Yes other things are important, but compared to the enormity of what is the Eucharist they do pale into mere tools. The Holy sacrifice at Calvary is the very centre of our Faith and it dwarfs everything else in our Faith, in Christianity, in the whole world. How can everything else in our Faith and in this world not pale into insignificance compared to the very physical presence of Our Lord in the Eucharist?

The Eucharist IS the source and summit of all Christian life, not community, not charismatic gifts, not even scripture, but the Eucharist.
Brendan, we have been told in Scripture to pray for the sick people, and that these signs will follow “those who believe”; they will lay hands on the sick and they will get healed etc.

I have no problem that the Catholics who wish to, choose to ask Mary for intercession.
My problem comes when you are trying to tell me that this is something I have to do in order to be somehow in good standing with the Lord.
Whether you like it or not, the proof from Scripture that saints who had already passed on were asked to pray for us in the earliest church, is very weak if not completely absent.

I think there is a difference between asking saints on earth and saints in heaven to pray for us, but that is not the point.
As I said, I have no problem with saying: please pray for me too, Mary.

What I do find very troubling is when people start hoping to obtain more mercy and help from a creature than from Jesus.
Or when words are used in devotions which sound like something directed at lesser deities. When people say: “Mary my salvation”, or “Mary my hope”, I get very uneasy, whatever long explanations are given afterwards in order to explain that it was all a matter of poetry and family-affection.

Believe it or not Brendan, but I used to have no problem with Marian devotion after my conversion to Catholicism. Only after I started really asking myself about these expressions and all these Marian apparitions that I felt were quite odd in light of the Gospel, did I have to distance myself.
But then I immediately ran into this subtle pressure to conform against my judgement and my conscience in obedience to the Church.

I do not have a problem with miracles performed by saints who have passed on, just like I have no problem with the next door Pentecostal guy laying on hands and healing some agnostic from cancer with full faith in Christ. It seems rather that a lot of Catholics have trouble with accepting that normal lay Christians have the same Holy Spirit and can do great things in the name of Jesus, because Jesus is not a “respecter of persons”.

A kind of A and B group is being formed in the head of many Catholics, especially among people who read saint litterature and who feel like they are never good enough. They start to focus on their own lack of virtue and therefore lack of the power of Holy Spirit and faith, instead of simply focusing on the promises of Christ, which many Pentecostal people do, which makes God able to act through them.

A very pious Priest once told me that we shall not say: “which is more important, the inspired Word of God or the Eucharist. Both are essential and equal”.
You think that because of the Eucharist everything else is of little importance. I think precisely because of what we believe about the Eucharist all the other things become hugely important too. How do you think that a place where there is no joy, preaching, community, no power of the Spirit, can convince people that we have the true Presence of Christ more than all the others?

Daisy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top