Catholic Mysticism

  • Thread starter Thread starter mymamamary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
On Christian Mysticism:

Perhaps you, Tobias, and maybe others may be interested in this site which contains many tapes, now on MP3’s on there. Most of the tapes are about the prayer journey, and reaching union with Christ. There are some on “Interior Castle”, some on St. John of the Cross’ Spiritual Canticle, and many on Centering Prayer. (Not to be confused with eastern, non-Christian centering prayer).

Father Venard Poslusney, O.Carm., now deceased, was a retreat master for priests, nuns, and anyone interested in a deeper prayer life. In my opinion, he explains thoroughly about the topics he knows most about.

advancedchristianity.com/
I had one experience many years ago of centering prayer in a group as a means of praying - I went to sleep… St Therese could fall asleep in the long thanksgiving after Holy Communion, but it was due to human frailty and tiredness not centering prayer.

I dont know much about the technique but we are warned by The Church against it.
catholicculture.org/culture/library/view.cfm?recnum=6892
Dont want to discuss the point, just present what I do know and have experienced. Up to others to research and decide if they wish to do so and decide on their particular direction on the matter.

To locate the Vatican Document on Prayer including Contemplative Prayer and some erroneous forms of same, go to: rcspiritualdirection.com/blog/2011/11/11/the-vatican-on-christian-meditation-and-centering-prayer
 
I had one experience many years ago of centering prayer in a group as a means of praying - I went to sleep… St Therese could fall asleep in the long thanksgiving after Holy Communion, but it was due to human frailty and tiredness not centering prayer.

I dont know much about the technique but we are warned by The Church against it.
catholicculture.org/culture/library/view.cfm?recnum=6892
Dont want to discuss the point, just present what I do know and have experienced. Up to others to research and decide if they wish to do so and decide on their particular direction on the matter.
Please be aware that St. Teresa of Avila refers to “Acquired Contemplation”, (christian “centering”) which is the first part of aspiring to have a deeper prayer life. The term “centering prayer” can be a buzzword for caution due to eastern/pagan types of centering prayer, which focus on the self.

In acquired contemplation", or “active contemplation” (another name for the same thing) we show the Lord that we desire to be in His Presence and love Him, with faith that He loves us back. If God so decides, in our prayer journey, He can then provide “infused contemplation”, which is when he does the work, not us. It is pure gift.

There is a subtle difference to Christian acquired contemplation “centering” which has the Lord as its focus, and pagan centering which has the self as the focus. ( I am totally against the latter).)

The use of the word “centering” can raise red flags, understandably.

I do respect your conscience, but felt the need to explain the above difference.
 
I had one experience many years ago of centering prayer in a group as a means of praying - I went to sleep… St Therese could fall asleep in the long thanksgiving after Holy Communion, but it was due to human frailty and tiredness not centering prayer.

I dont know much about the technique but we are warned by The Church against it.
catholicculture.org/culture/library/view.cfm?recnum=6892
Dont want to discuss the point, just present what I do know and have experienced. Up to others to research and decide if they wish to do so and decide on their particular direction on the matter.

To locate the Vatican Document on Prayer including Contemplative Prayer and some erroneous forms of same, go to: rcspiritualdirection.com/blog/2011/11/11/the-vatican-on-christian-meditation-and-centering-prayer
We are not warned “by the Church” against centering prayer. It is a banned topic on CAF because there is so much confusion about what it is and isn’t. Apparently there is an eastern practice called “centering” but this is not to be confused with “centering prayer,” but it often is. I’m not trying to start a debate, but since it is a banned topic I do not want your assertion that the Church warns us against centering prayer to go unchallenged. The Church warns us against various forms of eastern “mysticism,” but the characterization of centering prayer as being like them is based on false claims and amounts to a straw man argument.

Discussion of centering prayer was banned at the request of one of us who have found great healing in it, and got tired of defending against all the attacks. That should be all that is needed. The anti-cp links are there for those who wish to find fault with it so this post needs no rebuttal.

Alan

Edit: if you want to discuss centering prayer, let me know your email and desired login by PM and I will set you up on a forum I started in 2005 for two main reasons, one of which was for CAF posters to have a place to discuss centering prayer. Now we discuss Richard Rohr, who is just about as controversial but has led many to healing through his teachings on mysticism and non-dualistic thinking. For example I got great benefit from audio CD’s on his book “The Naked Now: Learning to See as the Mystics See.” It’s pretty quiet lately over there so I’d welcome a few newcomers. 🙂 There are also members-only sections so we can discuss things (controversial and/or personal) away from Internet snoops. You can check out the public sections at forums.wordsfree.org Note that we accept all different points of view, and we aren’t all at the same point in our faith journey or agree on everything, but we discuss our varied points of view with respect and encouragement.
 
The pressing need of devoting ourselves to the consideration of the one thing necessary is especially manifest in these days of general chaos and unrest, when so many men and nations, neglecting their true destiny, give themselves up entirely to acquiring earthly possessions, failing to realize how inferior these are to the everlasting riches of the spirit.

And yet St. Augustine’s saying is so clearly true, that 'material goods, unlike those of the spirit, cannot belong wholly and simultaneously to more than one person. The same house, the same land, cannot belong completely to several people at once, nor the same territory to several nations. And herein lies the reason of that unhappy conflict of interests which arises from the feverish quest of these earthly possessions.

On the other hand, as St. Augustine often reminds us, the same spiritual treasure can belong in its entirety to all men, and at the same time to each, without any disturbance of peace between them. Indeed, the more there are to enjoy them in common the more
completely do we possess them. The same truth, the same virtue, the same God, can belong to us all in like manner, and yet none of us embarrasses his fellow-possessors. Such are the inexhaustible riches of the spirit that they can be the property of all and yet
satisfy the desires of each. Indeed, only then do we possess a truth completely when we teach it to others, when we make others share our contemplation; only then do we truly love a virtue when we wish others to love it also; only then do we wholly love God
when we desire to make Him loved by all. Give money away, or spend it, and it is no longer yours. But give God to others, and you possess Him more fully for yourself. We may go even further and say that, if we desired only one soul to be deprived of Him, if we
excluded only one soul – even the soul of one who persecutes and calumniates us – from our own love, then God Himself would be lost to us.

ewtn.com/library/SPIRIT/3WAYS.TXT

Peace
 
Having taken some time to mull this over, it seems that the “communion of the saints” takes care of a lot of my unexplained experiences over the years. I hope I don’t sound like a quack, because I have put a lifetime of effort and cautious concern into this. I’ve done my best to verify that these are real mystical experiences and not just my imagination. I have stepped out in faith following the voice of God countless times in my life, and seen the positive results. I do believe though that these results are personal, and not in a proportion meant to convince anybody else but myself. …And my wife at times, along with the occasions when God has used me to minister to someone else.

My question is: are there, or has there ever been individuals that were once worshiped as pagan gods who are included in the communion of the saints? Because, this seems to be what I have experienced. I have met a number of individuals that identify themselves by the names of known pagan gods, yet seem to be not much different than saints and angels I’ve encountered before.

I can only imagine what people in the past might have done if they had met a saint or an angel. Like build an idol and do all kinds of detestable things to try to gain favors from their new “god”. But does that make the original person evil? What if someone did that with Saint Michael or Mary? I think the original person in heaven would be embarrassed, and the cult would be condemned for idolatry and worshiping of other gods.

I have no interest in justifying the worship or revering of pagan gods. I simply need to make sense of what I’ve encountered. I thought for a while that I must be following Zeus, because He does not seem to be offended by the involvement of other gods in my life. Yet the same would be true for Jehovah, if these beings are not competing gods condemned by the scriptures but simply members in the communion of saints.

The other option of course, is that I am still being tempted with idolatry. I keep waiting for this possibility to play out, and the Jealous God to kick in. And yes, at times He has been jealous, when I’ve started to give in to the temptation and considered replacing Him with one of the others. But I sense no animosity between Him and them. God angry with me when I forgot about Him… sure. but not angry at them.

The last possibility too is that things in the heavens have completely changed. That Christ has indeed conquered all His enemies, and even though these beings were once pagan gods they now happily serve Him.

Got any thoughts that can help me sort this out? Thanks!
 
*The other option of course, is that I am still being tempted with idolatry. I keep waiting for this possibility to play out, and the Jealous God to kick in. And yes, at times He has been jealous, when I’ve started to give in to the temptation and considered replacing Him with one of the others. /I

After giving your question some thought I have actually came up with nothing. Notta, except that whenever you discover the “jealous God kicking in”, we will be here because I suspect you will be needing some prayers.

In the meantime, try to spend some time living outside of your head, you’re overthinking little cricket and your ears are bleeding.*
 
Having taken some time to mull this over, it seems that the “communion of the saints” takes care of a lot of my unexplained experiences over the years. I hope I don’t sound like a quack, because I have put a lifetime of effort and cautious concern into this. I’ve done my best to verify that these are real mystical experiences and not just my imagination. I have stepped out in faith following the voice of God countless times in my life, and seen the positive results. I do believe though that these results are personal, and not in a proportion meant to convince anybody else but myself. …And my wife at times, along with the occasions when God has used me to minister to someone else.

My question is: are there, or has there ever been individuals that were once worshiped as pagan gods who are included in the communion of the saints? Because, this seems to be what I have experienced. I have met a number of individuals that identify themselves by the names of known pagan gods, yet seem to be not much different than saints and angels I’ve encountered before.

I can only imagine what people in the past might have done if they had met a saint or an angel. Like build an idol and do all kinds of detestable things to try to gain favors from their new “god”. But does that make the original person evil? What if someone did that with Saint Michael or Mary? I think the original person in heaven would be embarrassed, and the cult would be condemned for idolatry and worshiping of other gods.

I have no interest in justifying the worship or revering of pagan gods. I simply need to make sense of what I’ve encountered. I thought for a while that I must be following Zeus, because He does not seem to be offended by the involvement of other gods in my life. Yet the same would be true for Jehovah, if these beings are not competing gods condemned by the scriptures but simply members in the communion of saints.

The other option of course, is that I am still being tempted with idolatry. I keep waiting for this possibility to play out, and the Jealous God to kick in. And yes, at times He has been jealous, when I’ve started to give in to the temptation and considered replacing Him with one of the others. But I sense no animosity between Him and them. God angry with me when I forgot about Him… sure. but not angry at them.

The last possibility too is that things in the heavens have completely changed. That Christ has indeed conquered all His enemies, and even though these beings were once pagan gods they now happily serve Him.

Got any thoughts that can help me sort this out? Thanks!
I always understood God’s jealousy to mean that He, the Creator, desires our utmost good (salvation), and so when we are faithless he is “jealous”, because our faithlessness will cause us misery. He loves us infinitely, and his concern is for our good.

God desires us to use our free will to choose Him and His holy will, so we may reach the goal of being forever with Him.
 
My question is: are there, or has there ever been individuals that were once worshiped as pagan gods who are included in the communion of the saints? Because, this seems to be what I have experienced. I have met a number of individuals that identify themselves by the names of known pagan gods, yet seem to be not much different than saints and angels I’ve encountered before.
What are you doing? By what means are you engaged with these?

There is any number of evil creatures out there that will answer your call and tell you anything you want to hear and appear anyway they choose. satan has ever made fools out of those who seek that path. Read the story of John Dee, he prayed, fasted and took every precaution he knew and satan still made a fool of him. At the very start all he found was evil and all he sought were angels. You are surrounded by them, they all stand around you waiting for you to open the door.

I dont know what implementation you have used but your door is open. You need to close it, immediately. Go to a catholic priest today! If he doesn’t believe in demons find another. Your “friends” will take hold of you before you know it, it is a process, and it has begun.

John refered to Pergamum as the seat of satan. Pergamum was the seat of the worship of Zeus.

Again you are in grave danger.

Start praying this now while you are able.

Prayer for Deliverance

My Lord, you are all powerful, you are God, you are Father. We beg you through the intercession and help of the archangels Michael, Raphael and Gabriel, for the deliverance of our brothers and sisters who are enslaved by the evil one. All saints of Heaven, come to our aid.

From anxiety, sadness and obsessions, we beg You. Free us, O Lord.
From hatred, fornication, envy, we beg You, Free us, O Lord.
From thoughts of jealousy, rage, and death, we beg You, Free us, O Lord.
From every thought of suicide and abortion, we beg You, Free us, O Lord.
From every form of sinful sexuality, we beg You, Free us, O Lord.
From every division in our family, and every harmful friendship, we beg You, Free us, O Lord.
From every sort of spell, malefic, witchcraft, and every form of the occult, we beg You,
Free us, O Lord.

Lord, You Who said, “I leave you peace, My peace I give you,” grant that, through the intercession of the Virgin Mary, we may be liberated from every evil spell and enjoy your peace always. In the name of Christ, our Lord. Amen.

and more here victimsoulsofthesacredheart.blogspot.com/2008/01/some-prayers-fr-amorth-exorcist.html
 
I always understood God’s jealousy to mean that He, the Creator, desires our utmost good (salvation), and so when we are faithless he is “jealous”, because our faithlessness will cause us misery. He loves us infinitely, and his concern is for our good.

God desires us to use our free will to choose Him and His holy will, so we may reach the goal of being forever with Him.
That’s a very interesting way to look at God’s jealousy. It’s a lot more in tune with what we know of God’s nature, and less like He suffers from human type flaws. 👍

I keep thinking that if God has indeed given us free will, then it demands a system where free choice is an actual reality. If our only choices are “Love Me, or suffer for eternity in hell”, then we really don’t have much of a choice, do we?

For me to properly choose between the Lord God and others somewhat like Him, then the test requires that there appears to be no strings attached.
 
So, today I remembered Joan of Arc. (Not that I had forgotten her, she’s probably my patron saint if I even have such a thing.) I remembered the latter part of her story, where she was forced to defend herself to religious authorities who were trying to find fault with her. And I realized that there is even more to her life that speaks to me than just the girl who heard voices and tried to follow them.

Question: Is this also an acknowledged part of Catholic Mysticism, where a person sometimes has to stand up for their faith against religious authorities? Is it recognized as “a cross to bare” or “suffering with Christ”? Or are you all too certain that the Church is always right, that there is no room to admit that sometimes men are wrong and insist that the relationship we have with God is profane or defiled?

I guess this would be the reason why I resist the notion of submitting to a spiritual director. I have spent several years now wrestling internally between the doctrines and teachings of Christianity that have been ingrained into me from my earliest childhood, and the faith I have in my very personal relationship with Him.

We touched on some of this earlier, talking about when the disciples had to choose their relationship with Jesus over their offended sense of religion when He taught difficult things to hear. But it seems that now everything taught in church is unquestionably correct, while anything personally experienced is suspect.
…

For those in the Jewish Faith at that time, it would have been a totally overwhelming and outtlandish thing for Jesus to state and so many left following Him. It is understandable to me if I empathize as being a person back in the times of Jesus to suddenly hear him make such a statement and statements, the likes of which had never ever been heard nor hinted at before in the Jewish Faith and they all were practising Jews (Jesus and his Apostles, disciples)as well as many of the people who came to listen to Him.
 
Question: Is this also an acknowledged part of Catholic Mysticism, where a person sometimes has to stand up for their faith against religious authorities? Is it recognized as “a cross to bare” or “suffering with Christ”? Or are you all too certain that the Church is always right, that there is no room to admit that sometimes men are wrong and insist that the relationship we have with God is profane or defiled?

I guess this would be the reason why I resist the notion of submitting to a spiritual director. I have spent several years now wrestling internally between the doctrines and teachings of Christianity that have been ingrained into me from my earliest childhood, and the faith I have in my very personal relationship with Him.
There are several, that have been down the same road as you, that would tell you those you see cannot be trusted. I can tell you as well, myself, there is only evil there. The bible warns us that satan appears as an angel of light. You cannot trust your senses when it comes to the spirit world. We all, even you, have no faculty to control or understand that realm. There is nothing but lions there waiting to devour as soon as your protection is gone. They are not so convenient to show themselves as such, they choose a more subtle path.

There are 4 things in that world. God and His angels, the Latter, satan and his angels, and unclean spirits. You are not master of that realm, they are. satan is the prince of this world, and consequently his world is the first thing you will find. You cannot walk into the place of God by that means.

The strongest point of spiritual direction I can point you to is this, “hostage to the devil”, by Malachi Martin. In particular the chapter “the rooster and the tortoise”. Carl, in that story is on the exact same road as you, and falling for the exact same trap. Carl was deceived, intensely and wholly deceived, and he payed a terrible price for it. All that he was shown, all that he was told were lies, even from the very beginning. All he sought was “true Christianity” and all he found was his true enemy.

Carl was a psychic, gifted with many gifts along that line, including telekinesis. Most of his gifts remained even after exorcism. The gifts themselves are not evil. You have a gift, but it’s not what you think, you don’t know how to use it and satan does. Give your gift to God, surrender it to Him. It is crucially important that you be specific when you do, give it to “Jesus the Christ, son of God, born of the virgin Mary, who was crucified and buried and on the third day He rose from the dead and sits at the right hand of God.” (extracted from the nicene creed)
 
Question: Is this also an acknowledged part of Catholic Mysticism, where a person sometimes has to stand up for their faith against religious authorities? Is it recognized as “a cross to bare” or “suffering with Christ”? Or are you all too certain that the Church is always right, that there is no room to admit that sometimes men are wrong and insist that the relationship we have with God is profane or defiled?
I think there are absolutely such scenarios. Not only that, but those who say they aren’t are often the same ones to complain about what any give priest or bishop teaches or does. For example, if a person has trouble with a priest who seems to be antagonistic toward them, we love to flock around and protect the priest. After all, he is a man of God who has been ordained and who has given his life to the church and how dare we question him? Same priest allows liturgical dancers during Mass, and blam! There goes all the support for that priest. So it isn’t that we can’t second-guess the priests and other church leaders; it that we only second-guess them when it comes to our pet issues – but when we see somebody whose story we’re not buying who has a problem then we tend to cluck about how we should be obedient and how it’s a mortal sin to belittle the priests. There was one thread where a person simply asked whether it was sinful to pray to have a more active priest and that OP was crafted as evil incarnate and disobedient and not supportive of the priest of the Church and how the OP should pray for the priest and not for his replacement. Then the same sort of people will go around and talk about how it’s too bad that the Church doesn’t get rid of certain bishops or for that matter, monks. It seems the friars and monks who try to bring mysticism into mainstream Catholicism are particular targets for this type of attack.
I guess this would be the reason why I resist the notion of submitting to a spiritual director. I have spent several years now wrestling internally between the doctrines and teachings of Christianity that have been ingrained into me from my earliest childhood, and the faith I have in my very personal relationship with Him.
I think the key word here is “submitting.” I don’t “submit” to a spiritual director, I “enlist” him. I had such an amazing SD that it was clear he had wisdom far beyond mine both theologically and psychologically, and that he had things to say that could bring healing. When he told me to do this or that, such as reading Job 38-42 (his first suggestion to me since I was a technical person) or joining his weekly contemplative prayer meetings. I do these things because I am confident that he is leading me, personally, on a path of enlightenment. It’s no different than having a really great piano or voice teacher; they gave me knowledge that could take me far beyond where I was, but that doesn’t mean they are now my boss – in fact they work for me. In the same way, the priests are there FOR US, not so much for the other way around. Yes, we are to support the priests if we believe in the church, but they are my spiritual guides, not my police. I actually think that those who consider the Church as infallible in what she does have a problem with idolatry – but it’s even more complicate because they say she is in one instance that suits them and that she isn’t in another.
We touched on some of this earlier, talking about when the disciples had to choose their relationship with Jesus over their offended sense of religion when He taught difficult things to hear. But it seems that now everything taught in church is unquestionably correct, while anything personally experienced is suspect.
People who think that God’s creation is all about top-down command, like a monarchy, have a problem with the Holy Spirit because if we are to believe the Holy Spirit is actually in our own hearts and speaking through us – as Scripture states – that results in “distributed control.” And bureaucrats, no matter how holy, like to seize and keep central control. The Church must keep control of her teachings and all, so they they do not degenerate with each generation of believers and church authorities. But it is clear to me that the Spirit speak through each and every one of us. The Church is wonderful at getting us to the cross, but from there it is more of a leap of faith to follow Jesus through hell if necessary and into heaven. The paths are narrow because each of us has an individual path, and we will not likely find it if we think of ourselves as lemming who are simply following orders of other human beings. But leaders like lemmings because they are easy to deal with. What happens to people like Fr. Richard Rohr, when he says things that go against the status quo, is that he is vilified out of hand. Yes, he does a few things I think are a bit odd (I know why but they are still odd) but he has much to teach about the spiritual journey and has seen many souls through toward perfection – but since he says things that aren’t mainstream (borderline heretical but maybe not when you look into it) he is written off as dangerous, new age, and all the other adjectives we throw at somebody who doesn’t bow down to the hierarchy.

Thus “the law written in our hearts” becomes subject to inspection and revision from laws that are written on paper. Because we can’t have people making decisions on their own, when We Know Better.

(continued in next post)
 
(continued from last post)

This does not mean I have no respect for the Church or for priesthood. My oldest son will join the seminary in August and he is closer to “traditional” thinking that I am, but he accepts and understands why I raise the issues that I do. And I love my pastor. I see him at least once a week and talk about things that are anywhere from edifying to evil to heretical, and he gives me a proper framework of theology. Funny thing that when I question things that the Church says, more often than not the Church actually has the situation covered by the popular interpretation as spewed by mainstream clergy gives a false impression. So in this way, a person can be condemned as a heretic, when in fact a deeper understanding of theology may show this person is right. It happened all the time to Jesus. They try to stone Him for comparing Himself to God, and of course they were “right” because they “knew” the law:

John 10:30-36
"The Father and I are one.”

The Jews again picked up rocks to stone him.

Jesus answered them, “I have shown you many good works from my Father. For which of these are you trying to stone me?”

The Jews answered him, “We are not stoning you for a good work but for blasphemy. You, a man, are making yourself God.”

Jesus answered them, “Is it not written in your law, ‘I said, “You are gods”’? If it calls them gods to whom the word of God came, and scripture cannot be set aside, can you say that the one whom the Father has consecrated* and sent into the world blasphemes because I said, ‘I am the Son of God’?

So this is how I see it. Incomplete interpretations of the Word of God necessarily result from the desire to support conclusions held in the minds of men who would accuse another of heresy or blasphemy. Times have changed since Jesus walked the earth, but human nature has not. And as you observed, yes the Church is operated by humans.

Alan
 
There are several, that have been down the same road as you, that would tell you those you see cannot be trusted. I can tell you as well, myself, there is only evil there. The bible warns us that satan appears as an angel of light. You cannot trust your senses when it comes to the spirit world. We all, even you, have no faculty to control or understand that realm. There is nothing but lions there waiting to devour as soon as your protection is gone. They are not so convenient to show themselves as such, they choose a more subtle path.

There are 4 things in that world. God and His angels, the Latter, satan and his angels, and unclean spirits. You are not master of that realm, they are. satan is the prince of this world, and consequently his world is the first thing you will find. You cannot walk into the place of God by that means.

The strongest point of spiritual direction I can point you to is this, “hostage to the devil”, by Malachi Martin. In particular the chapter “the rooster and the tortoise”. Carl, in that story is on the exact same road as you, and falling for the exact same trap. Carl was deceived, intensely and wholly deceived, and he payed a terrible price for it. All that he was shown, all that he was told were lies, even from the very beginning. All he sought was “true Christianity” and all he found was his true enemy.

Carl was a psychic, gifted with many gifts along that line, including telekinesis. Most of his gifts remained even after exorcism. The gifts themselves are not evil. You have a gift, but it’s not what you think, you don’t know how to use it and satan does. Give your gift to God, surrender it to Him. It is crucially important that you be specific when you do, give it to “Jesus the Christ, son of God, born of the virgin Mary, who was crucified and buried and on the third day He rose from the dead and sits at the right hand of God.” (extracted from the nicene creed)
What you’re saying sounds a lot like unfounded paranoia. Similar perhaps to what anyone could be led to believe regarding a foreign culture. If we properly vilify any other country, culture, or organization then an uneducated person could conceivably feel as you describe whenever they encounter anyone from there.

Perhaps there is some merit to these types of cautions when talking to people who choose to explore the spiritual realm on their own. However, if a person is led to do so by the Holy Spirit, don’t you think that would make a world of difference? Why shouldn’t we be able to trust God to lead us into all the truth, and protect us from deception?

Col 1:16 For by Him all things were created that are in heaven and that are on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or powers. All things were created through Him and for Him.
 
…

So this is how I see it. Incomplete interpretations of the Word of God necessarily result from the desire to support conclusions held in the minds of men who would accuse another of heresy or blasphemy. Times have changed since Jesus walked the earth, but human nature has not. And as you observed, yes the Church is operated by humans.

Alan
Thank you for your lengthy reply Alan. You have been very helpful. 🙂

It sounds like things are similar in both Protestant and Catholic churches when it comes to this issue. We are left pretty much on our own to find the scriptural justification for anything odd that God asks of us, when it is challenged by someone in authority.
 
Thank you for your lengthy reply Alan. You have been very helpful. 🙂

It sounds like things are similar in both Protestant and Catholic churches when it comes to this issue. We are left pretty much on our own to find the scriptural justification for anything odd that God asks of us, when it is challenged by someone in authority.
Among other things the Church provides an awesome service: it presents the truth regarding God-of His nature and will-dogmatically. From there we, as individuals, are to take that truth and do what we will with it, or allow it to do what it will with us. Whether or not other individuals, including her leaders, themselves benefit much from that truth, or bother to plumb it’s depth with any intensity and grow in the knowledge of God, varies among them. In the end we all answer for what we did with what we were given, and no other being can look inside our souls and judge whether we’ve used it for better or worse-but some seem eager to take that right upon themselves anyway-and pronounce judgments. But God knows-and He’s the only one that counts.
 
What you’re saying sounds a lot like unfounded paranoia. Similar perhaps to what anyone could be led to believe regarding a foreign culture. If we properly vilify any other country, culture, or organization then an uneducated person could conceivably feel as you describe whenever they encounter anyone from there.

Perhaps there is some merit to these types of cautions when talking to people who choose to explore the spiritual realm on their own. However, if a person is led to do so by the Holy Spirit, don’t you think that would make a world of difference? Why shouldn’t we be able to trust God to lead us into all the truth, and protect us from deception?
I’m not paranoid, I’m terrified for you because these are things I know, things many others know.

Now the both are true. I could be ignorant of a new spirituality sent from God, unheading His movements by my lack of education and scruples. Likewise you could be deceived by the same means and completely dismiss the experience and warning of others.

I’m not uneducated on it. For me I burned my hand once and learned, others have burned theirs repeatedly and learned. Their story was told as a warning, a stop sign. To say to them “touch it again it won’t burn this time” won’t convince them. Carl, in the story I mentioned talked with an ancient roman citizen extensively. The spirit showed him many things, in particular he wanted to show him true Christianity. That spirit was not what Carl thought and he payed for it. Could you convince Carl to touch the burner again? Our faculties are the senses, they are not valid in that world. We have no faculty to navigate it.

Would the Holy Spirit lead you to Zeus, when John calls his seat the seat of satan? When God commanded us against idolatry would he then not care about it? Why would the Holy Spirit lead you into something God Himself calls detestable?
Deuteronomy 18:9 When you enter the land the Lord your God is giving you, do not learn to imitate the detestable ways of the nations there. 10 Let no one be found among you who sacrifices their son or daughter in the fire, who practices divination or sorcery, interprets omens, engages in witchcraft, 11 or casts spells, or who is a medium or spiritist or who consults the dead. 12 Anyone who does these things is detestable to the Lord; because of these same detestable practices the Lord your God will drive out those nations before you. 13 You must be blameless before the Lord your God.
Your friends show the signs, they are not who you think they are. If you want to find God, learn about him through His word. He has a purpose for you, and your gift, but you need to find Him through His word. Right now His word stands against what you know.
 
Great post “Semangelof” !

The Doctors of the Church on deeper prayer are extraordinary helps.
 
Saint Seraphim of Sarov

Acquiring the Holy Spirit

(from the Saint’s Conversation with Motovilov)

The true goal of our Christian life consists of acquiring God’s Holy Spirit. Fasting and vigil, prayer, mercy, and every other good deed performed for Christ — are means for acquiring the Holy Spirit of God. Only deeds performed for Christ give us the fruits of the Holy Spirit.

Some say that the foolish virgins lacking enough oil in their lamps is meant to be understood as a lack of good deeds (see Mt. 25:1-12). Such an understanding is not completely correct. How could there have been a lack of good deeds when they, though foolish, are still called virgins? For virginity is the highest virtue, as a state equal to the angels, and could by itself serve in place of all other virtues. I, the wretched, think that they did not have enough of the grace of the All-Holy Spirit of God. These virgins, because of their spiritual injudiciousness, supposed in performing good deeds that it is only necessary to do good works to be a Christian: “We performed a good deed and thus did God’s will.” Whether or not they had received the grace of the Holy Spirit, whether they had attained it, they did not even bother to find out … But, this acquiring of the Holy Spirit is in fact that oil which the foolish virgins lacked. They are called foolish because they forgot about the essential fruit of virtue — the grace of the Holy Spirit — without which there is no salvation for anyone and cannot be. For “through the Holy Spirit every soul is quickened, and through its purification, it is exalted and illumined by the Triune Unity in a Holy mystery.” The Holy Spirit Himself settles in our souls, and this occupation of our souls by Him, the All-Ruling, and this coexistence of our spirit with His One Trinity, is granted only through the diligent acquiring, on our part, of the Holy Spirit, which prepares, in our soul and body, the throne for the coexistence of God the All-Creator with our spirit, by the immutable word of God: “And I will walk among you and will be your God, and ye shall be my people” (Lev. 26:12).

This is the very oil in the lamps of the wise virgins, which burned brightly and steadily; the virgins with these burning lamps could await the Groom coming at midnight, and enter the chamber of joy with him. The foolish ones, seeing their lamps going out, though they went to the market to buy oil, did not manage to return in time, for the doors were already locked. The market is our life; the doors of the bridal chamber — locked and not permitting entrance to the Groom — human death, the virgins wise and foolish, Christian souls; the oil, not deeds, but the grace of the All Holy Spirit of God received through them, transforming from decay to incorruption, from emotional death into spiritual life, from darkness to light, from the manger of our existence, where our passions are tied like beasts and animals, into a church of God, into the all-lighted chamber of eternal joy in Jesus Christ.

Trust me, you can absolutely with Peace-Certitude know the presence of Jesus and the Joy of the Holy Spirit!

Peace
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top