Catholic practicing Buddhist meditation?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bben15
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The website Roman Catholic Spiritual Direction (rcspiritualdirection.com) has the following introduction (by Dan Burke) to the CDF’s document on Christian Meditation:

“Though a complete understanding of this document requires education in Church history and mystical and ascetic theology – on its face it clearly addresses many current popular teachings on prayer that should be of concern to every Catholic who seriously desires to deepen their understanding of what it means to truly engage with God. This document is a profound summary of true Christ-centered prayer and those false forms of “prayer” that seriously threaten the spiritual well-being of their practitioners. It is also important to note that the errors discussed here were of grave enough concern to trigger a letter to every bishop in every diocese of the Church around the world. It is an important document that any serious pilgrim should take the time to read and seek to understand.”

Read more: rcspiritualdirection.com/blog/2011/11/11/the-vatican-on-christian-meditation-and-centering-prayer#ixzz2X9oiJ7S4
And a lay convert is going to know more about contemplative prayer than bishops, abbots and priests, who have dedicated their lives to contemplative prayer and have experience with contemplation ?

I’ve never met a priest or spiritual director, monastic or otherwise, who has told me that Centering Prayer should be avoided. In fact, they understand clearly that it is the opening of oneself to God who dwells within.

How anyone could find this evil is perplexing to them.

Jim
 
Could God reveal mystical truths to a lay person? Sure.

Lay people can even become saints.

I’ve heard plenty of prominent clergy and laity talk about the problems associated with centering prayer and it is notable that the moderators of this forum have asked that centering prayer not be discussed. Each time you do it, you lessen your credibility just by your disobedience to what this forum prescribes as appropriate. If people find that problematic, maybe they need to address their concerns to the moderators instead of flagrantly breaking the rules.
 
Topic thú v? ph?t, mình cung d?nh nói ý ki?n nhung ch?ng bi?t gi?i thÃch th? nÃo
 
I’ve heard plenty of prominent clergy and laity talk about the problems associated with centering prayer and it is notable that the moderators of this forum have asked that centering prayer not be discussed. Each time you do it, you lessen your credibility just by your disobedience to what this forum prescribes as appropriate. If people find that problematic, maybe they need to address their concerns to the moderators instead of flagrantly breaking the rules.
Thank you SeekingHisMercy. We should all be mindful of the rules. And for my own part I realize I have uttered the “name that shall not be named” in a couple of pointed sentences in this thread for the first time in many, many years on these forums. So I thank you for the reminder.

But I will also tell you what is “notable.” The simple fact you interject your personal opinion in the process of shutting down discussion you don’t like (in the name of following the rules, of course) lessens your “credibility” just as surely as those you condemn.

I am done with dishonest conversations.
 
FYI, I was the one who asked the administrators to put a ban on Centering Prayer, years ago.

I did this because it had different meanings to different people, and the majority of information on it here at CAF, was false.

I was afraid people seeking this as a means to developing a deeper prayer life in Christ, would be discouraged and turn away from it.

They banned the topic, while leaving the links to the false articles attacking the method of prayer.

Also, although the subject is suppose to be banned, people who post negative articles and links attacking it, are never removed. Those who post links to articles attacking it, are never removed. So, all that has happened is people responded by posting links to articles written by the men who began to teach this method of prayer outside the monastery, back in the 60’s and 70’s, before the term Centering Prayer was ever used.

Also, calling people names is against forum rules. See post #15. It remains.

So, who’s being uncharitable here ?

Jim
 
  • JMJ +
FYI, I was the one who asked the administrators to put a ban on Centering Prayer, years ago.

I did this because it had different meanings to different people, and the majority of information on it here at CAF, was false.

I was afraid people seeking this as a means to developing a deeper prayer life in Christ, would be discouraged and turn away from it.

They banned the topic, while leaving the links to the false articles attacking the method of prayer.

Also, although the subject is suppose to be banned, people who post negative articles and links attacking it, are never removed. Those who post links to articles attacking it, are never removed. So, all that has happened is people responded by posting links to articles written by the men who began to teach this method of prayer outside the monastery, back in the 60’s and 70’s, before the term Centering Prayer was ever used.

Also, calling people names is against forum rules. See post #15. It remains.
Probably because you ARE inserting CP into discussions that didn’t have it, and probably because the “official” stance of CA on this topic is mainly negative? Have you even READ the articles attached to the ban?!

I tried to respect the ban by not responding to you in that other thread when you mentioned the ban, but what do I find? You mentioning it AGAIN on another thread. I could not ignore that.
So, who’s being uncharitable here ?

Jim
Probably the one who thinks that since he is the one who suggested the rule, he can start discussing the banned topic at his whim.
 
nuntym;
Probably because you ARE inserting CP into discussions that didn’t have it, and probably because the “official” stance of CA on this topic is mainly negative? Have you even READ the articles attached to the ban?!
I only insert truth over false articles and links which are posted. I don’t open threads on the subject, nor do I begin the topic within threads.
I tried to respect the ban by not responding to you in that other thread when you mentioned the ban, but what do I find? You mentioning it AGAIN on another thread. I could not ignore that.
Only responding to the attack against it. I haven’t posted any articles on the subject, as those attacking the prayer method have done.
Probably the one who thinks that since he is the one who suggested the rule, he can start discussing the banned topic at his whim.
Show us a post where I started a thread or posted articles promoting the prayer, since the ban was in place ?

Again, I’ve responded to the attacks only.

Fact is, I know many contemplatives who away from this forum because of not only the misinformation on CP, but on Contemplative Prayer itself.

This forum ends up feeding the distractions for those trying to lead a life of contemplative prayer.

Quite frankly, some people such as yourself, become nasty with name calling, and I have banned myself many times as a result.

Jim
 
At this point, I’ve said all I’m going to say on this subject.

I’m unsubscribing to the thread.

God Bless You All

Centered in Christ Jesus
Jim
 
  • JMJ +
At this point, I’ve said all I’m going to say on this subject.

I’m unsubscribing to the thread.

God Bless You All

Centered in Christ Jesus
Jim
Typical, I was making a reply to the previous post because you ask me to, and then you say you would not even read it. Whatever.

Signing off.
 
nuntym;

Fact is, I know many contemplatives who away from this forum because of not only the misinformation on CP, but on Contemplative Prayer itself.
Someone recently stated that those who have absolutely no experience of true contemplative prayer will never understand it, no matter how many posts/books/articles they quote from. To the true contemplative, these persons are readily and easily spotted; so it is utterly useless to try and use words or language to change their false impressions. Until they experience it, they cannot know what we are talking about, experientially.

End of story. Let them babble.
 
I’ve apologized for posting something inappropriate to this discussion.

Get this straight. I am not a liar.
 
I’m really sorry.
And I am sorry too for my words were uncharacteristically harsh. And, in a way, not even directed to you … rather the “situation” of these forums as to all matters contemplative. I just took a peak at my profile and realized in suprise (?horror? :)) I’ve been here nearly 10 years! So I’ve seen a great many things over that period of time.

Please accept my apology … and wishing you peace in Christ.

Dave 🙂
 
No problem, Dave. Apology accepted. Please keep me in your prayers and know that you’re in mine.

SHM
 
  • JMJ +
Someone recently stated that those who have absolutely no experience of true contemplative prayer will never understand it, no matter how many posts/books/articles they quote from. To the true contemplative, these persons are readily and easily spotted; so it is utterly useless to try and use words or language to change their false impressions. Until they experience it, they cannot know what we are talking about, experientially.

End of story. Let them babble.
sigh And if they missed all the times I have said in other threads that I have recently reached contemplation through the Rosary then I guess they are as blind as they think they are not.

Look, all the things I have said here are the fact that advanced prayer techniques such as the prayer in The Cloud of Unknowing are just that: advanced prayer, not for beginners. The experiences beginners will get from doing such without the preparation of meditation and asceticism or the guidance of a spiritual director will quickly lead to either spiritual pride or disgust with the spiritual life when they see themselves not improving.

I know, I was one of them.

The saints have said it—see what I posted above; priests have said it, including Fr. Thomas Greene and Fr. Jonathan Robinson; theologians have said it.

If you are not one of those who got burned by going directly to advanced types of prayer and not bothering with meditation and asceticism first, then good for you: you have been given a special grace by God. But many others have not been given such grace; they have to go through the ordinary path of sanctity. And it is quite a folly to suggest exceptions to be the rule.
 
I am not sure if I am totally catching what is being discused in this thread but if I am I just wanted to share a few thoughts about some things I have heard or read.

Isn’t the point of meditation and asceticism that we learn to just throw ourselves into God’s hands? I thought I had read some place that St. Theresa of Lisieux wanted to find a quicker way to God than St. John of the Cross had. I beleive it was she who discovered that if she just threw herself into God’s hands it was quicker than going through all the rules and she refered to it as taking the elevator to God.

Does this make sense and can anyone verify or clarify this?

The other point that was made earlier about how there seems to be this fear of looking inside ourselves for God is that if we do not look inside of ourselves and find God then what are we finding in ourselves? We have to look inside and keep looking untill we finally find Him. Other wise we will be all wrapped up in ourselves. That is a pretty miserable and lonely dark place to be. Another thought about finding God inside ourselves is how St. Theresa of Avila describes it as going from chamber to chamber. I believe it was C.S. Lewis in his book called The Last Battle from the Cronicles of Narnia that I believe has helped me start understanding the spiritual journey more clearly. In his book the children go through a door of a barn expecting to find some kind of shelter but when tho go inside they discover that they are in a bigger and more beautiful world than they had just left. I envision each of the chambers that St. Theresa of Avila talks about having a similar effect on us. As we move deeper and find God in each room we then see God out side of us in a bigger and more beautiful way than we had befor. It is like all of creation is bigger and more beautiful than it was befor we entered. it is like we start see everything that God sees the way God sees and how God sees. But if we do not look inside ourselves and find God inside of us we get all wrapped up within ourselfs and can not see how God see but only see how we see. by looking for God inside ourselves we are putting ourselves aside and allowing Him to dwell there instead of ignoring Him and trying to shut Him out.

Anyway just had a minute to share some of my rambling thoughts hope and pray they were not too far out there for what is being discussed here in this thread. Any corrections, clarifications or feed back is most welcome…will take it into consideration and ponder about it some more…
 
I’m not sure there is much point in my saying anything here as you all seem to know one another… not sure I’m welcome… I have not responded to posts directed to me because I feared that if I responded in any way, it would continue to derail the thread, be fuel for an argument and further violate the ban as I understood it.

I am sorry if I offended anyone by anything I have said which was seen as uncharitable. I was unaware of the sensitivities of people here. Or that I was breaking unwritten rules by posting links. (I will continue to post links which I feel will be useful to people. This is not a violation of rules.) It was not my intent to fuel a war in doing so. I am merely trying to be helpful to fellow beginners. I am very sorry that the thread has been so derailed and I apologize if I have contributed to the problem.

Thank you, nuntym. I am a beginner. St. Theresa of Avila is too advanced for me. I am also someone who has been led down wrong paths (not, however, the banned topic!). I don’t want that to happen to other people. There are many people who have questions such as the OP’s. I believe these questions deserve respect and the light of Christ and His Church. If I have blocked His light, I am truly sorry.

May Christ’s peace be with you.
 
+JMJ+

Indeed. In fact, the traditional Catholic remedy to defeat vices is to crowd out the ideas and desires fostered by those sinful habits by the influx of new, holy ideas and desires. For example, watch this classic video of Ven. Fulton J. Sheen starting from the 16th minute mark, but the whole video is frankly very interesting in itself. 👍

But let us go back to the OP. G.K. Chesterton made this observation about the differences between Buddhism and Christianity:

Even when I thought, with most other well-informed, though unscholarly, people, that Buddhism and Christianity were alike, there was one thing about them that always perplexed me; I mean the startling difference in their type of religious art. I do not mean in its technical style of representation, but in the things that it was manifestly meant to represent. No two ideals could be more opposite than a Christian saint in a Gothic cathedral and a Buddhist saint in a Chinese temple. The opposition exists at every point; but perhaps the shortest statement of it is that the Buddhist saint always has his eyes shut, while the Christian saint always has them very wide open. The Buddhist saint has a sleek and harmonious body, but his eyes are heavy and sealed with sleep. The mediaeval saint’s body is wasted to its crazy bones, but his eyes are frightfully alive. There cannot be any real community of spirit between forces that produced symbols so different as that. Granted that both images are extravagances, are perversions of the pure creed, it must be a real divergence which could produce such opposite extravagances. The Buddhist is looking with a peculiar intentness inwards. The Christian is staring with a frantic intentness outwards. If we follow that clue steadily we shall find some interesting things.

Orthodoxy, Chapter 8: The Romance of Orthodoxy

Now it may seem that G.K. Chesterton is wrong about this, because we have read so many recommendations from saints to look inward for God; indeed, Jesus Himself said:

[BIBLEDRB]Luke 17:21[/BIBLEDRB]

But that is the thing: we Christians look inside of us not to find ourselves but God. Indeed, when we are called to look at ourselves, we are often told so so we can distrust ourselves, and therefore we look for the One we can trust that is outside ourselves—indeed, outside of creation!—by looking inside ourselves.
Love this. I really needed to see this. Thank you and God Bless 👍
 
Nuntym, your points are well taken. Of course there’s a time and place for simplified ways of prayer and a natural progression to things. “Readiness” is essential to discernment … and virtue is the fruit of authenticity. Mysticism without asceticism is a sham and a lie. No one denies that. And it has been expressed (in words different than your own) on this thread and many others. My goodness, the very points you make Sirach and I made years ago on the many “debate” threads of the time that led to the ban on this forum.

But there are also no “rules” to this either. St. Teresa herself said in her epilogue to Interior Castle that it would be an act of limiting God to think there are just 7 mansions … when there are many, many more. In fact there’s a “room” for every good hearted soul that seeks Christ … no two of which are likely to be “exactly” the same. So one of the things we try to instill in Carmel is a “balanced” understanding to the issue of progression and that a “linear understanding” … A begets B which begets C … isn’t always the way it happens. In fact, in all my time in Carmel I don’t think I met anyone whose path exactly fit what John and Teresa lay out. In real life there are many twists and turns, straight lines and detours.

Setting all that aside, the real issue you’re seeing expressed by some posters is the frustration that the “issue at hand” isn’t even considered by vocal opponents to be a valid expression of simplified prayer even when through God’s good grace the soul has been led that way. And my experience over nearly a decade of participating and observing every imaginable kind of comment is that the “name that must not be named” deep down really isn’t even the issue at all. Rather it’s just the boogeyman for something else … a deep fear of any type of prayer that smacks of “experience” or intimate relationship. When probed, it is quite clear many self-appointed heretic hunters (not speaking of any one on this thread) have no clue what contemplation is … acquired or otherwise. Yet their one and only mission, in the immortal words of Gandalof the Great, is to continually pound their fist on the table and shout: You … shall … not … pass!!

And this was true in John and Teresa’s day too. The greatest torment Teresa experienced was frightfully poor confessional advice relating to matters as simple as mental prayer … to the infused states such as quiet and union. And to say nothing of more extraordinary matters like raptures, visions, locutions etc. And John’s harshest words were held out for spiritual directors whose sole purpose seemed to be keeping their directees “in their place.” The common denominator for both was the great harm done to souls by those governed by fear and ignorance in the ways of interior prayer. My goodness, John and Teresa desperately WANTED people to progress to simplified ways of prayer and went out of their way to show how one can ready themselves to do so.

Lastly, I neither endorse nor condemn the “name that shall not be named.” But I will defend a good friend who I know from experience has been led by the hand of God through rooms those who are grounded by fear can scarcely imagine. We should all take at face value the “intention” people state for how they practice prayer and recognize that our “words” sometimes fail to do justice to the meaning in their heart. Too many, though, think they know the hearts of posters better than they do themselves … and are obligated to point out their many deficiencies. This, of course, is a fundamental failing of Spirituality 101 … though, of course, they will never see it.

In hindsight I realize this has turned into quite a stream of consciousness rant. Please know THIS IS NOT DIRECTED OR INTENDED TOWARD ANYONE IN PARTICULAR! It is simply the voice of one who has spent too many years trying to ENCOURAGE people toward a deeper, more contemplative relationship with Christ … on a forum that far too often just doesn’t want to hear about it.
 
The link posted by Bookcat and the link posted by Viloa Incognita actually have the same content except one is from Vatican, the other is quoted by Dan Burke referring to the Vatican site. They are the same article.
The Vatican one does not have further link to Centering Prayer but the one from Dan Burke’s site does. If you click “Centering Prayer” right below the heading of “The Vatican on Christian Meditation and Prayer” you will get in here where CP is discussed a little:

rcspiritualdirection.com/blog/2011/05/19/is-there-anything-good-about-centering-prayer
Originally by DBT
But what about CP? Can you point in this document where that’s explicitly addressed? I’m not looking for a discussion as I know that’s banned … just want to know where it’s specificallyaddressed, rather than where posters might read into that document based on their own personal points of view.
Though Dan Burke mentioned there were good things in Centering Prayer for beginners, he emphasized more on St. Teresa of Avila and St. John in Carmelite. He said the following about CP:
Why am I belaboring this point? It is simply because many in the Centering Prayer movement have a severely disordered attachment to movement teachers and practices. When they encounter questioning, instead of responding as my friend did, they typically become hostile or emotionally distraught. This reaction in and of itself reflects a disordered attachment …
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top