Catholic practicing Buddhist meditation?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bben15
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But that is the thing: we Christians look inside of us not to find ourselves but God
And there it is in a nutshell … thank you!🙂

And to take it one step further. We “turn inward” so that we can better “turn outward.” The purpose of contemplation, according to St. Teresa, is to produce good works.

So perhaps that’s the context we can understand that Chesterton quote you gave … the true contemplative’s eyes will be intensely alive, open and focused. Such an individual will always be in a state of watching and waiting for the Lord’s coming in the many opportunities we are given to serve Him in all our present moments. We come to know in an experiential way the wisdom of St. John of the Cross: “For God to look or gaze upon is to love.” Our lives become a continuous act of doing precisely that.

The turning inward is where we find our strength and sustenance … so that we can go outward in virtue, perhaps even heroically done.

Love of God and love of neighbor from a mystical understanding.

Dave 🙂
 
Viola Incognita
Are you one of those people? Changing the name does not change the nature of the thing.
Because the term Centering Prayer means different things to different people, as expressed here. The monks and teachers such as Fr Martin Laird, in his book, “Into the Silent Land,” use the term of what the prayer method actually is, “Quiet Prayer.” This is what it was called, long before the term “Centering Prayer,” was ever heard of.
The term Centering Prayer came about on a week-end for religious, which Fr Keating, Fr Pennington and Fr Thomas Merton hosted. They were using the poem of St. John of the Cross’ “Living Flame of Love.”

St. John referred so many times about God being our center, and praying from the center of our soul where God dwells, that people began to use the term “Centering Prayer.” It was still, Prayer of Quiet which was being studied and practiced.

Had you followed the link which was presented earlier, you would learn the origins of Centering Prayer, or Quiet Prayer for which it actually is, comes from St. Johan Cassian and Abba Isaac, mystics of the desert. It has absolutely no origins in Eastern Meditation and the differences in the meditation methods are explained in the link, by Fr Pennington.
And a banned topic by any other name is still a banned topic. So, to get this thread back on the rails… In the OP’s second post on this thread, which some may have missed, he/she brought up a relevant point of discussion to the topic of Catholics practicing Buddhist meditation:
Calling people hypocrites is a violation of the rules and uncharitable, but it’s been allowed in this very thread.
Are there dangers in mind emptying? Why does the Church warn against such practices?
Depends what you mean by emptying the mind. In the teachings of St John of the Cross and modern writers like Fr Keating, blanking the mind is not what is done nor should it be attempted. But letting go of inordinate thoughts which are not of your focus of being in the presence of God. Using the use of a prayer word, like the name of Jesus, or Maranatha, is to quiet our faculties and keep our focus on Jesus Christ. It’s not for blanking the mind or stopping all thinking, which is impossible, but keeping the intention of our will, which is being in God’s presence exchanging love. The transforming grace received from God, is his gift, and it’s only received through love.

FYI, I just started reading “Western Mysticism: Augustine, Gregory, and Bernard on Contemplation and the Contemplative Life,” by Dom Cuthbert Butler .

The introduction gives an account of the debate of the terms of Contemplation, that go back centuries.

I can see why we in this forum can hardly expect to come to an understanding of terms dealing with Contemplative Prayer.

I plan to depart from CAF, for this forum is not conducive for living a life of prayer, but instead, it’s a distraction.

The constant debates about contemplative prayer are a hindrance when turning to prayer and having the debates that what we’re doing is some how evil

Even people who are doing discursive active prayer complain about distractions and this exchanges in this forum are most likely feeding the distraction.

Centered In Christ
Jim
 
I plan to depart from CAF, for this forum is not conducive for living a life of prayer, but instead, it’s a distraction.
Jim, I hope you prayerfully reconsider that. 🙂 There has always been a fear-mongering of interior prayer. As you know, St. Teresa knew that well. It was part and partial of the inquisition of her day. Sadly, that spirit is alive and well … even on these forums. As the saying goes: as it was in the beginning … is now … and ever shall be.

Dave 🙂
 
+JMJ+
Had you followed the link which was presented earlier, you would learn the origins of Centering Prayer, or Quiet Prayer for which it actually is, comes from St. Johan Cassian and Abba Isaac, mystics of the desert. It has absolutely no origins in Eastern Meditation and the differences in the meditation methods are explained in the link, by Fr Pennington.
sigh There is just one objection that I keep on saying here and I have not received any response for it. Why do the proponents of centering prayer NOT emphasize the need for a good life, spiritual reading, and meditation along with contemplation? Why is it that I have not heard ANYTHING from you regarding this?
There has always been a fear-mongering of interior prayer.
For myself, it is not a fear mongering of interior prayer as a fear mongering of imitations of interior prayer. To be able to see and hear God in interior prayer, you must be able to see and hear Him, and recognize Him and His Voice; how can you if your interior is so cluttered and noisy, nor if you do not know Him nor His Voice? That is why interior prayer is (ordinarily) preceded or goes along with asceticism (to clean and silence the self) and meditation (to know Him and His Voice). To go straight to acquired contemplation with no preparation of the life and soul is the height of spiritual pride, like inviting the Lord in a dirty, noisy house.
 
This thread caught my attention, because I am now reading “Growing in Love and Wisdom” by Susan J. Stabile (and I might recommend the OP look for it, if the OP is still interested in Buddhist prayer from a Catholic perspective - despite the numerous well-intentioned cautions posted here.).

The author was raised Catholic, became a Buddhist (for 20 years), and is now Catholic again. She takes several Buddhist meditations which she learned and found fruitful, and adapts them, making them acceptable for Catholic prayer (IMO). She acknowledges the very real differences between the Buddhist and Christian worldview and theology - and also where we might find common ground - throughout this thoughtful book.

Yes, it is probably not for everyone, I suppose, and if you think it will lead you astray (which I sincerely doubt would happen reading this book), then don’t do it. My personal opinion is, just because it might seem novel and different does not necessarily make it bad or dangerous. “Test all things, and hold fast to the good”. Even the revered prayer of the Carmelites and Jesuits might have seemed novel and different when it was first promoted many centuries ago.
 
nuntym
sigh There is just one objection that I keep on saying here and I have not received any response for it. Why do the proponents of centering prayer NOT emphasize the need for a good life, spiritual reading, and meditation along with contemplation? Why is it that I have not heard ANYTHING from you regarding this?
Without a devoted prayer life, living a life of virtues as God desires, is not possible.

God provides the transforming grace which enables us to live life according to his will

Fr Keating wrote much about practicing the Virtues, and how prayer goes along with it.
For myself, it is not a fear mongering of interior prayer as a fear mongering of imitations of interior prayer.
Imitations ? This is where the conversations gets muddled and suggests that you have no experience with interior prayer, otherwise you wouldn’t come up with such statements.
To be able to see and hear God in interior prayer, you must be able to see and hear Him, and recognize Him and His Voice; how can you if your interior is so cluttered and noisy, nor if you do not know Him nor His Voice?
Hence the purpose of slowing down the flow of inordinate thoughts which come into our minds. The purpose of a prayer word, or focus on the presence of God through other means, is to quiet the interior noise in order to hear God.

God’s language is silence, and as St Teresa wrote, God speaks to us best within the depth of our souls. It is there that we understand him best. Not my words, but St Teresa.
That is why interior prayer is (ordinarily) preceded or goes along with asceticism (to clean and silence the self) and meditation (to know Him and His Voice). To go straight to acquired contemplation with no preparation of the life and soul is the height of spiritual pride, like inviting the Lord in a dirty, noisy house.
Quiet Prayer, Centering Prayer or whatever term you want to call it, is not going straight to acquired contemplation. It’s merely the beginning level of being open to contemplation, whether it will be acquired or infused through God’s grace, which one or the other will come in time as a person remains devote in their prayer.

Even the virtues are not gained by an instant decision on your part, but only through spiritual growth which is fed from graces from God.

If you believe you have achieved virtues based on your own initiative, you’ll be deceiving yourself and it’s your own ego doing the feeding, not grace from God.

Centered In Christ
Jim
 
This thread caught my attention, because I am now reading “Growing in Love and Wisdom” by Susan J. Stabile (and I might recommend the OP look for it, if the OP is still interested in Buddhist prayer from a Catholic perspective - despite the numerous well-intentioned cautions posted here.).

The author was raised Catholic, became a Buddhist (for 20 years), and is now Catholic again. She takes several Buddhist meditations which she learned and found fruitful, and adapts them, making them acceptable for Catholic prayer (IMO). She acknowledges the very real differences between the Buddhist and Christian worldview and theology - and also where we might find common ground - throughout this thoughtful book.

Yes, it is probably not for everyone, I suppose, and if you think it will lead you astray (which I sincerely doubt would happen reading this book), then don’t do it. My personal opinion is, just because it might seem novel and different does not necessarily make it bad or dangerous. “Test all things, and hold fast to the good”. Even the revered prayer of the Carmelites and Jesuits might have seemed novel and different when it was first promoted many centuries ago.
I would suggest reading Fr Thomas Keating or Fr Martin Laird. What they teach is according to Catholic Tradition on Contemplative Prayer.

You won’t have to question whether your doing something from outside of Catholic Tradition.

Jim
 
I would suggest reading Fr Thomas Keating or Fr Martin Laird. What they teach is according to Catholic Tradition on Contemplative Prayer.

You won’t have to question whether your doing something from outside of Catholic Tradition.

Jim
Yes, I have read both them too. I would especially recommend the Laird books. The OP had asked specifically about Buddhist prayer, but I have no intention of making waves or being banned, or leading anyone astray with to my humble, misguided opinions!

Do what Jim says.

God bless you!
 
+JMJ+
Without a devoted prayer life, living a life of virtues as God desires, is not possible.

God provides the transforming grace which enables us to live life according to his will

Fr Keating wrote much about practicing the Virtues, and how prayer goes along with it.
What about meditation? What about spiritual reading? Why all these incomplete answers, Jim?
Imitations ? This is where the conversations gets muddled and suggest that you have no experience with interior prayer, otherwise you wouldn’t come up with such statements.
Really? You mean you cannot make mistakes with interior prayer?
Hence the purpose of slowing down the flow of inordinate thoughts which come into our minds. The purpose of a prayer word, or focus on the presence of God through other means, is to quiet the interior noise in order to hear God.

God’s language is silence, and as St Teresa wrote, God speaks to us best within the depth of our souls. It is there that we understand him best. Not my words, but St Teresa.
The problem with that is that acquired contemplation (let alone centering prayer) is insufficient for beginners when it comes to quieting the self, and totally inadequate to know God through it alone. Why do you think St. Teresa of Avila preceded 20+ chapters all devoted to asceticism and meditation in Ways of Perfection before she talked about contemplation?

In fact, read what St. Teresa of Avila wrote about all of this:

You will ask, my daughters, why I am talking to you about virtues when you have more than enough books to teach you about them and when you want me to tell you only about contemplation. My reply is that, if you had asked me about meditation, I could have talked to you about it, and advised you all to practise it, even if you do not possess the virtues. For this is the first step to be taken towards the acquisition of the virtues and the very life of all Christians depends upon their beginning it. No one, however lost a soul he may be, should neglect so great a blessing if God inspires him to make use of it. All this I have already written elsewhere, and so have many others who know what they are writing about, which I certainly do not: God knows that.

Did you read that? Meditation, not contemplation, is the FIRST step towards the virtues! And she also implies here that you have to acquire virtue before you can do contemplation, by beginning with things about virtue when asked to make this book about contemplation.

She goes on:

But contemplation, daughters, is another matter. This is an error which we all make: if a person gets so far as to spend a short time each day in thinking about his sins, as he is bound to do if he is a Christian in anything more than name, people at once call him a great contemplative; and then they expect him to have the rare virtues which a great contemplative is bound to possess; he may even think he has them himself, but he will be quite wrong. In his early stages he did not even know how to set out the chess-board, and thought that, in order to give checkmate, it would be enough to be able to recognize the pieces. But that is impossible, for this King does not allow Himself to be taken except by one who surrenders wholly to Him.

Source

Which is what I have been saying all along: contemplation is the end, the summit; meditation and vocal prayer and the virtues lead to it, not the other way around.

Deal with it.
Quiet Prayer, Centering Prayer or whatever term you want to call it, is not going straight to acquired contemplation. It’s merely the beginning level of being open to contemplation, whether it will be acquired or infused through God’s grace, which one or the other will come in time as a person remains devote in their prayer.
And yet the author of the Cloud of Unknowing specifically discourages this kind of prayer for beginners in prayer!
Even the virtues are not gained by an instant decision on your part, but only through spiritual growth which is fed from graces from God.

If you believe you have achieved virtues based on your own initiative, you’ll be deceiving yourself and it’s your own ego doing the feeding, not grace from God.
LOL back at you then: you then have no experience of the grace of God that comes from the ordinary spirituality taught by Mother Church for you to say that.
 
I’ve been following this thread and am wondering why centering prayer is continuing to be discussed and advocated for when it is explicit in the forum rules that this is a banned topic?
 
By emptying your mind, you get rid of all things, including God, for a while. Since you cleared God out of your head, you cleared the Holy Spirit out of your head. As a result, you have no protection against evil.
Do you remember where you read that?

Have you read the following document? Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church On Some Aspects of Christian Meditation.

The document is only seven sections – Introduction, Christian Prayer in the Light of Revelation, Erroneous Ways of Praying, The Christian Way to Union with God, Questions of Method, Psychological-Corporal Methods, and “I am the Way”. It mentions Buddhist theory. A quick word search found “emptying.” It also mentions Eastern Christian meditation and the Jesus Prayer you mentioned.

May Christ’s peace be with you.
 
I’ve been following this thread and am wondering why centering prayer is continuing to be discussed and advocated for when it is explicit in the forum rules that this is a banned topic?
It should not be.

(And Fr. Keating is part of that movement…one may contact the Catholic Answers apologists with any questions – as noted this is a banned topic.)
 
I would suggest reading Fr Thomas Keating or Fr Martin Laird. What they teach is according to Catholic Tradition on Contemplative Prayer.
You won’t have to question whether your doing something from outside of Catholic Tradition.
I do not really know the second author but the first would be getting into the banned topic of centering prayer.

Since I cannot discuss the topic here – I will leave it at that.
 
It is astonishing to me that the Scriptures clearly call for the death of the “self” in order to be alive in Christ. This worldly “self” which in modern parlance is the ego is the author of most of the chatter in our minds. Why then wouldn’t we want to detach from this chatter? Is the assumption made that simply by declaring oneself Christian, we have shed the ego? Why then all the egocentric behavior from Christians and even Priests? Forget all the terminologies both banned and otherwise, and tell me what is wrong with a discipline that trains one to detach from their ego. I think the only people frightened or angered by this are those who have merely exchanged one false ego for another. Catholic egocentricity is not an aliveness in Christ.
 
The website Roman Catholic Spiritual Direction (rcspiritualdirection.com) has the following introduction (by Dan Burke) to the CDF’s document on Christian Meditation:

“Though a complete understanding of this document requires education in Church history and mystical and ascetic theology – on its face it clearly addresses many current popular teachings on prayer that should be of concern to every Catholic who seriously desires to deepen their understanding of what it means to truly engage with God. This document is a profound summary of true Christ-centered prayer and those false forms of “prayer” that seriously threaten the spiritual well-being of their practitioners. It is also important to note that the errors discussed here were of grave enough concern to trigger a letter to every bishop in every diocese of the Church around the world. It is an important document that any serious pilgrim should take the time to read and seek to understand.”

Read more: rcspiritualdirection.com/blog/2011/11/11/the-vatican-on-christian-meditation-and-centering-prayer#ixzz2X9oiJ7S4
 
The website Roman Catholic Spiritual Direction (rcspiritualdirection.com) has the following introduction (by Dan Burke) to the CDF’s document on Christian Meditation:

“Though a complete understanding of this document requires education in Church history and mystical and ascetic theology – on its face it clearly addresses many current popular teachings on prayer that should be of concern to every Catholic who seriously desires to deepen their understanding of what it means to truly engage with God. This document is a profound summary of true Christ-centered prayer and those false forms of “prayer” that seriously threaten the spiritual well-being of their practitioners. It is also important to note that the errors discussed here were of grave enough concern to trigger a letter to every bishop in every diocese of the Church around the world. It is an important document that any serious pilgrim should take the time to read and seek to understand.”

Read more: rcspiritualdirection.com/blog/2011/11/11/the-vatican-on-christian-meditation-and-centering-prayer#ixzz2X9oiJ7S4
And why should we listen to Dan Burk, a lay covert, over Bishops, Priests and Monks who have dedicated their lives to God, living in monasteries doing contemplative prayer, and have written positively on the subject of Centering Prayer ?

Jim
 
Should have noted: from the Congr. for the Doctrine of the Faith --very important document.
Bookcat -

You post this often … I’m interested in your perspective as there are so many cross currents on this thread that I’m not sure which “theme” this link is meant to address.

The Buddhist aspect is obvious so I don’t need help with that.

But what about CP? Can you point in this document where that’s explicitly addressed? I’m not looking for a discussion as I know that’s banned … just want to know where it’s specifically addressed, rather than where posters might read into that document based on their own personal points of view.

What I’m grappling with in my mind is why there is such a disconnect on these forums on virtually everything related to interior prayer. How one camp in all honesty and sincerity see themselves praying in the manner of posts 19 and 22 (whether they use the term CP or not) and are thus following a very safe and secure path spelled out by the Doctors. And how a second camp looks at those very same words of a Doctor and see borderline heresy if the word CP is attached to it in any way shape or form.

Again, this is just a personal meditation for me … and not meant as a topic of discussion per se. So your pointer on the link would be helpful.

Thanks much,
Dave 🙂

PS - I have only briefly scanned the document so perhaps the answer I’m looking for is right there in black and white. My apologies if that’s the case.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top