Viola Incognita
Are you one of those people? Changing the name does not change the nature of the thing.
Because the term Centering Prayer means different things to different people, as expressed here. The monks and teachers such as Fr Martin Laird, in his book, “Into the Silent Land,” use the term of what the prayer method actually is, “Quiet Prayer.” This is what it was called, long before the term “Centering Prayer,” was ever heard of.
The term Centering Prayer came about on a week-end for religious, which Fr Keating, Fr Pennington and Fr Thomas Merton hosted. They were using the poem of St. John of the Cross’ “Living Flame of Love.”
St. John referred so many times about God being our center, and praying from the center of our soul where God dwells, that people began to use the term “Centering Prayer.” It was still, Prayer of Quiet which was being studied and practiced.
Had you followed the link which was presented earlier, you would learn the origins of Centering Prayer, or Quiet Prayer for which it actually is, comes from St. Johan Cassian and Abba Isaac, mystics of the desert. It has absolutely no origins in Eastern Meditation and the differences in the meditation methods are explained in the link, by Fr Pennington.
And a banned topic by any other name is still a banned topic. So, to get this thread back on the rails… In the OP’s second post on this thread, which some may have missed, he/she brought up a relevant point of discussion to the topic of Catholics practicing Buddhist meditation:
Calling people hypocrites is a violation of the rules and uncharitable, but it’s been allowed in this very thread.
Are there dangers in mind emptying? Why does the Church warn against such practices?
Depends what you mean by emptying the mind. In the teachings of St John of the Cross and modern writers like Fr Keating, blanking the mind is not what is done nor should it be attempted. But letting go of inordinate thoughts which are not of your focus of being in the presence of God. Using the use of a prayer word, like the name of Jesus, or Maranatha, is to quiet our faculties and keep our focus on Jesus Christ. It’s not for blanking the mind or stopping all thinking, which is impossible, but keeping the intention of our will, which is being in God’s presence exchanging love. The transforming grace received from God, is his gift, and it’s only received through love.
FYI, I just started reading “Western Mysticism: Augustine, Gregory, and Bernard on Contemplation and the Contemplative Life,” by Dom Cuthbert Butler .
The introduction gives an account of the debate of the terms of Contemplation, that go back centuries.
I can see why we in this forum can hardly expect to come to an understanding of terms dealing with Contemplative Prayer.
I plan to depart from CAF, for this forum is not conducive for living a life of prayer, but instead, it’s a distraction.
The constant debates about contemplative prayer are a hindrance when turning to prayer and having the debates that what we’re doing is some how evil
Even people who are doing discursive active prayer complain about distractions and this exchanges in this forum are most likely feeding the distraction.
Centered In Christ
Jim