Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The same question I asked…right before Sideline got into the battle of Padre Pio and the stigmata. I would dearly love an answer though. I don’t think one will be provided, though. For how could a person possibly prove that prayer wasn’t offered up to God on the person’s behalf? but still I would love an answer.
Yup. Not to mention his claim that this happens “about as often”
as to those who do pray for a cure.

Where’s the evidence, Sideline?
 
Considering the lack of evidence provided on this thread for… well everything. I find it funny what delight you take in the fact it takes me a bit of time to research the answer to a complex question.

I mean, it’s not like you guys couldn’t do research it if you were interested yourselves.

It turns out that it is not as frequent as I thought, the rates appear to be 1:60,000 to 1:100,000.

This talks about the placebo effect in general.

Do I know they didn’t pray?

No I don’t. Because almost everyone in North America prays. All I can be sure of, is that people who get prayed for.

The people who I know who had their lives eaten apart by cancer had a number of twenty-four hour prayer vigils in the hopes of helping them out.

If most people who have cancer pray for healing, and no more than 1:60,000 get better on their own, then it would seem the odds of prayer doing anything are pretty bad. Especially, if you could prove that any of the 1:60,000 didn’t pray. But I don’t have the time to check out the prayer lives of thousands of people.
 
I thought Jesus told Satan that you shouldn’t tempt God…

Sounds to me like you want only a miracle in your definition, so that God can prove himself.
 
Do I know they didn’t pray?

No I don’t.
Well, that’s a problem, then, isn’t it? Because your claim is exactly that: people who don’t pray are cured about as often as those who do pray.

Yet you’re saying, "well, I don’t really know if the person who was cured for no reason really didn’t pray. :whacky:
 
Well, that’s a problem, then, isn’t it? Because your claim is exactly that: people who don’t pray are cured about as often as those who do pray.

Yet you’re saying, "well, I don’t really know if the person who was cured for no reason really didn’t pray. :whacky:
This is insane.

I can’t prove that the people who got better from cancer don’t eat bananas. That doesn’t prove that bananas cure cancer.

You don’t think that bananas cure cancer, so you don’t look for a link. You think prayer does, so you do look for a link. You ignore the millions, and millions, and millions of times that prayer does nothing to help people (I know, you are going to ask me to find millions of cases where people prayed and weren’t helped aren’t you?). The half dozen times people get better in unpredictable ways, you credit prayer.

If I claimed that bananas cured cancer, because I met someone who ate an unusually large number of bananas before being miraculously cured from cancer, you ask me to prove it. Would it make any sense at all for me to get you to prove that bananas didn’t have an effect?

You would probably be right in assuming that most people who got better didn’t eat bananas more often, but you couldn’t be sure.

When I point out that people can get better without treatment, you say I can’t prove that they didn’t pray. Well of course I can’t. How could anyone prove that someone didn’t pray? We don’t have the ability to read people’s thoughts. We could never know for certain whether they or someone else was asking a god or higher power for help. When I say that people get better at around the same rates, I am basing that on the fact that no one has found a link between praying and getting better. I can’t prove it, no.

But it shouldn’t be up to me. It should be up to you to produce a link between prayer and cancer remission. You are the one who is claiming that there is an effect.
 
When I point out that people can get better without treatment, you say I can’t prove that they didn’t pray. Well of course I can’t. How could anyone prove that someone didn’t pray? We don’t have the ability to read people’s thoughts. We could never know for certain whether they or someone else was asking a god or higher power for help. When I say that people get better at around the same rates, I am basing that on the fact that no one has found a link between praying and getting better. I can’t prove it, no.
Thank you.
 
So let me understand. Are you saying that my cousin still has cancer and by all rights, according to you, he is dead? I am just fooling myself into thinking that he was cured?
How long did your cousin have cancer?

Sorry if you have already answered that question.
 
This is insane.

I can’t prove that the people who got better from cancer don’t eat bananas. That doesn’t prove that bananas cure cancer.
Umm…if you *made the claim *that people who got better from cancer don’t eat bananas, you’d better be able to back up your claim.

You are very stridently and vociferously making a claim: people who do not pray get cured.

So…where’s your evidence? 🤷
But it shouldn’t be up to me. It should be up to you to produce a link between prayer and cancer remission. You are the one who is claiming that there is an effect.
YOU are making a claim.
 
This is insane.

I can’t prove that the people who got better from cancer don’t eat bananas. That doesn’t prove that bananas cure cancer.

You don’t think that bananas cure cancer, so you don’t look for a link. You think prayer does, so you do look for a link. You ignore the millions, and millions, and millions of times that prayer does nothing to help people (I know, you are going to ask me to find millions of cases where people prayed and weren’t helped aren’t you?). The half dozen times people get better in unpredictable ways, you credit prayer.

If I claimed that bananas cured cancer, because I met someone who ate an unusually large number of bananas before being miraculously cured from cancer, you ask me to prove it. Would it make any sense at all for me to get you to prove that bananas didn’t have an effect?

You would probably be right in assuming that most people who got better didn’t eat bananas more often, but you couldn’t be sure.

When I point out that people can get better without treatment, you say I can’t prove that they didn’t pray. Well of course I can’t. How could anyone prove that someone didn’t pray? We don’t have the ability to read people’s thoughts. We could never know for certain whether they or someone else was asking a god or higher power for help. When I say that people get better at around the same rates, I am basing that on the fact that no one has found a link between praying and getting better. I can’t prove it, no.

But it shouldn’t be up to me. It should be up to you to produce a link between prayer and cancer remission. You are the one who is claiming that there is an effect.
Sideline, we are not making the claim that no one who doesn’t pray gets better. You are making the claim that those who do pray and get better cannot credit it to a miracle. Also, what you have to keep in mind are that most healings occur in the heart, mind and soul of individuals. God has His own reasons for either healing our bodies or not healing our bodies. Prayer is a powerful tool of the Christian. We communicate with Jesus and thank Him, praise Him, and offer our total surrender to Him.
I know of a family who was deeply affected by the suicidal depression of one of it’s members. Nothing was working to help this person. The father, who had been a chain smoker for 48 years told God that he would quit…and offer the suffering of wanting to smoke up to God. And he asked God in return to save his son’s life. The mother did the same with something extremely difficult to give up. They did it for life…not just the 40 days of Lent. That was 14 1/2 years ago. The gun that he had planned on pulling on the police so that they would shoot him dead was never pulled. I know this story very closely. And he should have been dead…but by the actions of God. So miracles come in all shapes and sizes. When a person is at the end of their rope, and can see no light at the end of the tunnel…and then people pray for them…and light appears with answers to the problems, that is a miracle. When one is walking in sin, and he is prayed over…and shortly thereafter he comes to Jesus to be converted…that is a miracle.
You ask, why don’t limbs grow back. Well, there was one story in this thread where it did happen. I have also heard of it in other instances. Why do you have to put conditions on what God has to do in order for you to believe that a miracle is indeed a miracle? He doesn’t take orders from you or anyone else.
 
Please understand this:

Jesus told us that unless we have the faith of a child, we would not enter into the Kingdom of Heaven.

Have you ever noticed that children will believe what you tell them, not requiring the proof in scientific evidence?

That is what Jesus calls us to do. Have the faith of a child. There are none who can fathom the Mind and Actions of the Holy Trinity. We were not created to be able to do so. And sometimes we fail to realize that. We are intelligent beings, and that is a wonderful creation of God. But we are meant to have faith in Him like the faith of a child.

I hope we will turn to Him to recieve such faith.

It takes the faith of a child to believe that God can move mountains…to heal our bodies and our minds.
 
Since when was accepting ancedotal evidence a valid form of debate? Honestly now, if we’re going to do that, I might as well cite “miraculous” anecdotal stories of a myrad of different religions’ believers and claim that they’re all correct.

A miracle by definition is something that happens outside the laws of nature. A limb growing back would fit this description, cancer or some other disease remissing wouldn’t. Just because you don’t know how exactly something happened, doesn’t necessarily mean there is no naturalistic explination for it, especially if it happens with some degree of frequency. This reasoning can be applied to the mechanics of how my television works. Just because I know nothing of the physics or engineering behind it, doesn’t mean Im going to adopt the hypothesis that its somehow God powered.

For those who’ll insist on anecdotal evidence, I present you with a well disorder which is the reason things must be studied in a controlled environment prior to declaring anything en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somatoform_disorder

Consider it the “reverse of a miracle”.
 
Since when was accepting ancedotal evidence a valid form of debate? Honestly now, if we’re going to do that, I might as well cite “miraculous” anecdotal stories of a myrad of different religions’ believers and claim that they’re all correct.

A miracle by definition is something that happens outside the laws of nature. A limb growing back would fit this description, cancer or some other disease remissing wouldn’t. Just because you don’t know how exactly something happened, doesn’t necessarily mean there is no naturalistic explination for it, especially if it happens with some degree of frequency. This reasoning can be applied to the mechanics of how my television works. Just because I know nothing of the physics or engineering behind it, doesn’t mean Im going to adopt the hypothesis that its somehow God powered.

For those who’ll insist on anecdotal evidence, I present you with a well disorder which is the reason things must be studied in a controlled environment prior to declaring anything en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somatoform_disorder

Consider it the “reverse of a miracle”.
I will concede that prayers answered for things that are physical are not necessarily miracles. My cousin having cancer on one day that needed to be taken care of very quickly, and after the prayer and being sprinkled with the Holy Water from the Spring at Lourdes, without recieving medical treatment he was well, is a “Miracle”

The stigmata of St. Francis and Padre Pio are miracles.

So, I concede that others may just be in fact answers to prayers. But it comes down to the same thing. The skeptic would be the same skeptic were we talking about answered prayers or miracles.
 
You would think… since this is the lynch pin of the argument… that there would be some pictures floating around of these perfectly smooth hands. Pictures abound of his hands with the stigmata, but it appears to be impossible to find a picture of him without it.

Why hasn’t somebody snapped a picture of those pristine hands to silence sceptics like myself?
Oh please…like you wouldn’t write that off with a “doctored photo” argument.

Nothing will convince you of anything you’re not willing to believe.
 
I will concede that prayers answered for things that are physical are not necessarily miracles. My cousin having cancer on one day that needed to be taken care of very quickly, and after the prayer and being sprinkled with the Holy Water from the Spring at Lourdes, without recieving medical treatment he was well, is a “Miracle”
As mentioned by a previous posters, cancer remission does happen, although its rare. You could say its an answered prayer if you like, but it wouldnt fit into being classified as a miracle, no more than winning the lottery.
The stigmata of St. Francis and Padre Pio are miracles.
Find me a peer-reviewed study of the examination of either, and I’ll concede that they are miracles.
So, I concede that others may just be in fact answers to prayers. But it comes down to the same thing. The skeptic would be the same skeptic were we talking about answered prayers or miracles.
Yep, just cause the word miracle gets tossed around alot these days.
 
Find me a peer-reviewed study of the examination of either, and I’ll concede that they are miracles.
I suppose you send a letter to vatican asking for this on Padre Pio, they do make quite extensive research on saints with many interviews, analysis, doctors backing them up and so and so…

Saints do not come easy… But i suppose the problem is, when you really start studying miracles you will turn in to a catholic and that might be a bit scary…
 
I suppose you send a letter to vatican asking for this on Padre Pio, they do make quite extensive research on saints with many interviews, analysis, doctors backing them up and so and so…
That’s nice, but I asked for peer-reviewed research. You know, stuff that gets published in the scientific community, not pet articles of certain groups.
Saints do not come easy… But i suppose the problem is, when you really start studying miracles you will turn in to a catholic and that might be a bit scary…
Ironic you should say that as it was precisely the act of studying miracales that led to me to apostize from catholicism lol.
 
As mentioned by a previous posters, cancer remission does happen, although its rare. You could say its an answered prayer if you like, but it wouldnt fit into being classified as a miracle, no more than winning the lottery.

***I am asking for one instance of it. I have never heard of such a thing. And, as I said, if it were to happen, the media would be all over it…because most of the media are anti-Christian. They would love to print or tell the story of a person who, without recieving medical attention for lung, liver, pancreatic, kidney cancer was cured completely without saying prayers to God, or having anyone else say prayers in his stead.

So, you claim that it does happen. When and where and to whom has it happened. You can certainly find proof of miracles in the Catholic Church, through the Vatican. I would like to see the proof for that which you claim.***

Find me a peer-reviewed study of the examination of either, and I’ll concede that they are miracles.

I certainly will find the information you look for…probably by this afternoon, if it is possible for me to work on it today.

Yep, just cause the word miracle gets tossed around alot these days.
Jesus answers my prayers all of the time. It is always with a “Yes, No, or Wait”. I consider that He loves me enough to answer me period is a miracle in itself…seeing as He is God. However, there are what you consider miracles that occur by the Will of Jesus at the request of people praying.
 
That’s nice, but I asked for peer-reviewed research. You know, stuff that gets published in the scientific community, not pet articles of certain groups.

If we have the research from doctors and such, that is indeed peer. Laboratory scientist are not the ones who are going to be studying Padre Pio. There is much scientific evidence…but you are not interested.

And the things that get published in the scientific community change so often that I am not inclined to believe anything in it. What they say they have found evidence of today will be shown by those same scientists to be fallacy tomorrow. That happens very often in what you are calling “peer reviewed research in the scientific community”.

Ironic you should say that as it was precisely the act of studying miracales that led to me to apostize from catholicism lol.
That is very sad. We miss you. And it is a shame, because the studying of miracles in the correct places…like what the vatican has on St. Francis of Assissi and Padre Pio, and so many others, is very well documented and the doctors words on it are just as well documented. Maybe you got upset because the doctor had to accept that they could not explain it. Maybe that is why you left. Maybe you could tell us exactly what miracles or lack there of in the scientific community led you to leave.
 
That is very sad. We miss you. And it is a shame, because the studying of miracles in the correct places…like what the vatican has on St. Francis of Assissi and Padre Pio, and so many others, is very well documented and the doctors words on it are just as well documented. Maybe you got upset because the doctor had to accept that they could not explain it. Maybe that is why you left. Maybe you could tell us exactly what miracles or lack there of in the scientific community led you to leave.
Of course, if you see the Vatican/Church as corrupt, you can’t trust them. And a lot of people see it that way. It’s extremely sad.
 
I don’t suppose that anyone who has seen all of this research on Padre Pio could supply some of it? I’ve been searching this for hours now. I’ve only found one report by a doctor… which I point out earlier… does not support the idea that the wounds are of supernatural origin.

Some elementary questions I have are:

Exactly what doctors saw him, and what tests did they run?

What, if any, were their specialities?

Are their any photographs of his hands after the stigmata stopped to verify there is no scarring?

Were the wounds ever treated? And if so what treatments were done? (Like were his hands bound up in anyway to keep him from inflicting more wounds while the ones he had healed?)

Was he ever brought to an independent facility and observed?

Since you are all experts on the rigorous testing and research done by the Vatican, I assume you can come up with the information more quickly than I can.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top