You’re definitely right about the silliness of the proposals we heard during Obama’s campaign from Catholics that the evils of abortion could be put aside for all the social benefits of the Democratic agenda. It didn’t deliver and abortion is more available than ever. The country has benefited from nothing and just has higher deficits and more financial problems, huge unemployment, and chaos.
But the problem with the “keep government out of everything” philosophy is that some issues need regulation and to be kept in check. Personally I wonder how a little portability and tort reform, as the GOP proposes, will get millions and millions of people covered? I also wonder how portability and tort reform will take care of the way insurance companies find every way to dump or discriminate against people with serious health issues or prior conditions? I also wonder how a little portability and tort reform will keep insurance companies from raising their rates to record levels while they’re still reporting record profits that are obscene and only serve to cause people to drop their insurance and pray to God they don’t get a major illness? Will portability and tort reform keep insurance companies and the health care system honest? If tort reform comes along, will the doctor’s savings from less malpractice insurance translate to savings for the patient? Will the doctor say, “since I’m saving $80,000 this year in malpractice insurance drops, I think I’ll lower my office fees for my customers and give 'em all a discount?!” I don’t think so. It’s human nature that he’ll pocket the profit.
Insurance rates, pharmaceutical prices, health care in general are increasing far faster than the rate of wage increases in America. Some people’s entire paychecks go to health care in marriages. My parents’ income was largely sucked away for medical because they had to insure themselves. It was stifling. Now my dad’s on Tricare, medical from the military (a government program!) and he loves it! Then Medicare will come along, which my grandparents are on and like as well. If they all had to fend for themselves, God help them.
It’s easy for people to trash the post office and other government agencies. Some gov’t programs work, some are a dismal failure like Medical. The post office has taken one mean hit with the advent of the internet and a huge loss in funding from stamp purchases, etc. My wife makes pays all our bills online and we only buy stamps once a year now. Is it government’s fault the post office is in deep doodoo or is it my fault for never buying stamps and the whole program is in crisis?
I find it weird that the Republicans, who fought their hearts out AGAINST social security and medicare, are now the ones so desperately concerned about seniors losing it or part of it from this new health care legislation.
My point is this: The Democrats’ current bill STINKS to high heaven. It’s absurd, too long, doesn’t address the problem, will bankrupt us, will throw our kids into huge hock, and it expands the wrong program, Medical, putting outrageous mandates on states in a time of financial crisis. California, my state, will collapse from these mandates as we’re already in an abyss…The Dems have failed, miserably. But the Republicans have no real solution either. Portability and tort reform are the only songs they sing. They just want to stall it, protect the insurance fat cats and big pharm tycoons, the rich as usual, and hope this blows over. They’re using it as a political card, nothing more. The Dems are in love with abortion and for that they had to give up on single-payer. The Republicans will never do anything about this.
We need a third party, another option, a different perspective, moderate, rational, human approaches, not the Dems condemning Republicans for cutting free-lunch programs and wanting to starve children while the Republicans cry “socialist!” every ten minutes. I’m irritated exceedingly by it ALL! People tell me regarding a third party, “never gonna happen!” and “it isn’t feasible” etc. I really don’t care. I don’t like either option and I’m too much of a realist to buy into Beck, Limbaugh, Schultz, Olbermann, Savage, NPR, or any of it. Both parties have very very un-Christian behavior and ideals just in different directions. The truth lay in the middle. There’s a place for government and in other areas of life no place for it. The truth isn’t simple and it isn’t a quick fix and these ideaologies only compound our problems.
Personally, I believe that ‘social justice’ has been corrupted and used to push an agenda that has nothing to do with the teachings of the church. And it’s used as an excuse to ignore the bigger issues. How many catholics did you hear supporting Obama in the last election because the so-called ‘good’ he was supposed to do was going to outweigh the evil of abortion that he supports. That kind of nonsense is wrapped in the pretense of social justice and I’m pretty tired of it. There’s no reason to use the issues to ignore the hard teachings of the church.
And frankly, most of these ‘social justice’ issues are meant to be addressed individually and/or within the church. People need to be taught the principle of subsidiarity and learn that the church teaches us to NOT rely on the government to fix all our problems but that we are meant to address these areas personally, as part of service to God and fellow men. If people care so much about these issues, they should go out and participate personally to bring about change, not allow the government to do evil in the pretense of doing good.