I always ask for the same thing–pierced earrings (fishhook preferred), candles (and I specify the three scents that I can tolerate) and towels.
The only jewelry I wear other than my wedding ring is earrings (although I have stopped wearing small ones and posts after losing two different ones pulling off my mask–I can HEAR large earring when they fall off). I love quirkly earrings that express my interests or that are holiday-related–right now, I’m wearing turkey earrings about the size of a quarter!
I use candles almost everyday, so I appreciate having a large supply!
And I HATE ratty, threadbare towels–and that’s the way our towels look after a year or two of use. So I LOVE getting new, soft, plush towels and relegating the ratty ones down to the basement pile of “scrubbing towels.”
I also love anything associated with ice skating, and uranium glass for my collection.
One other thing–EVERY year for the past ten years, my kids have gotten me a goofy Jesus item because when they were little, I would draw Jesus for them in stories, and my Jesus drawings were…not really good, and He always wore a blue sash. When I drew Jesus as a Baby in the manger, it really looked like a carrot (swaddling clothes), and my daughter swears that this has scarred her for life. So one year they (and my son-in-law, too) stayed up very late to craft a “Nutcracker Jesus” for me. Ever since then, they have found the most ridiculous Jesus gifts–last year, it was a refrigerator display of “What Would Jesus Wear?” At the moment, I have Him dressed in a dashiki and khakis.
I also like food gifts, unfortunately.