Christopher Columbus - how can Catholics admire him and name organisations after him?

  • Thread starter Thread starter FiveLinden
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Idk Martin Luther was an antisemitic unstable person whose writings were admired very much by the third Reich, especially Hemrich Himmler.
Columbus brought the one true faith to the Americas. That’s what it comes down too.
 
I believe they were mostly committed by the men under his command, but because he was in command he is responsible whether he gave the order or not. I also don’t think it matters at this point.
 
Maybe not personally. The Spanish did some terrible things. And some good things.
 
I also don’t think it matters at this point.
I disagree with that. I think atrocities matter, whether committed by Hitler, by Pol Pot, or by colonizers of America. I think it is wrong to kill others and steal from them what does not belong to you. And is it not wrong to accept stolen items ? Or is it OK to do so?
 
Well main point, there’s a huge difference between conquering and stealing. The rights of conquest are well established in history.

And yeah, I do personally believe that as time goes on the necessity to continually say “x thing that happened was real bad” goes away. In 100 years no one is going to care about 9-11. There comes a time to move on and let the past die.
 
The rights of conquest are well established in history.
But are these “rights” established in the law of ethical morality? For example, consider all the precious items stolen in the Fourth Crusade and placed in Roman Catholic Churches in the west, such as St. Mark’s for instance.
 
Imperialism was bad? Why? Cross cultural exploration and bringing western values to other nations isn’t a bad thing when the alternative is…well, what it was.
 
Yes, forcibly taking someone else’s land and forcibly imposing your outside culture on another people is wrong. How do you not see thaf? Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you should
 
Feel a little funny having to say this, but killing and stealing are against Christian values.

What’s next? A justification for slavery? I mean, crops and industry came from it…
 
Last edited:
In the year 2318, here on CAF, someone will post a question, Why is Purdue University named after a famed chicken killer? After all, in 300 years, we will probably obtain our food from far different sources today, and looking back in history, raising chickens and then killing them for food will engender horror in the heart of some bleeding heart liberal, who spout his/her revisionist view of history and morality and will bleed all over the Catholic Living forum.
The Knights of Columbus was founded by a priest who, seeing that Catholic widows and children were often left to homelessness and starvation if the father died, founded an organization among New England Catholics, who, in a mostly WASP/Protestant environment were mostly Italian. Father McGivney picked that most famous Italian hero at the time, Christopher Columbus, someone the Italians of his time honored for his courage and foresight in discovering the new world. Someone Catholics at the time could identify with as strong and courageous, while the Protestant majority looked down on them with contempt.
Rewriting history to salve one’s own conscious or assuage one’s feeling of indignation is a pathetic effort to wear ones own morality on ones own sleeve. To savage an organization as morally unfeeling or tone deaf is sad at best. Unfortunately, it is the preferred weapon of the self righteous today.
Oh, and I’m cooking dinner right now and am busy. Would somebody call the Regents at Purdue University and tell them what is coming. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
You know, come to think of it, asking a father to butcher his son is an act of unspeakable barbarism. Don’t you think we should turn our collective backs on someone so vicious and self indulgent. Shouldn’t we revise biblical history to show what a barbaric person like that is, and refrain from honoring such a person? I mean Abraham and Isaac were just a couple of good natured nomads just trying to get by??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top