Climate Change News 2

  • Thread starter Thread starter Theo520
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have this strange idea: why not let a free people make their own choices and decisions.
Sure We could build all of our utilities, transportation systems, waster management, public services, military, etc. that way.
 
40.png
JonNC:
I have this strange idea: why not let a free people make their own choices and decisions.
Sure We could build all of our utilities, transportation systems, waster management, public services, military, etc. that way.
You can, depending on where you live. Don’t get me wrong, I think solar on a private home is a marvelous idea. It can save money and reduce dependence on utilities and government, all of which are good things.
My objection is to the authoritarian nature of dictating that people do it. This is not about health or safety.
 
40.png
JonNC:
clean burning
That presuppose a particular definition of “clean”.
A definition of clean which means safe for the environment and the living organisms within it.

And solar panels, as good as they might be, present their own risks.


http://www.wfsb.com/story/28886201/experts-warn-about-potential-dangers-of-solar-panels


But my issue is freedom to choose. We are supposed to be a free society. It seems to me it should be my choice on having solar panels on my roof
 
Last edited:
But my issue is freedom to choose. We are supposed to be a free society.
I think with many places that you live there are going to be building codes on aspects of construction, efficiency, and æsthetics. This looks like just one more aspect of it.
 
40.png
JonNC:
But my issue is freedom to choose. We are supposed to be a free society.
I think with many places that you live there are going to be building codes on aspects of construction, efficiency, and æsthetics. This looks like just one more aspect of it.
Maybe they exist in some areas , but I’ve never seen a building code that dictated one’s source of heat and electricity. Has anyone been told they have to use natural gas or electric heat? Or a requirement to use oil heat or have a wood burning system?
 
But my issue is freedom to choose. We are supposed to be a free society. It seems to me it should be my choice on having solar panels on my roof
Not good for the roof.

Too expensive if I have to pay myself.

We have tree branches come down a lot.
 
Don’t get me wrong, I think solar on a private home is a marvelous idea. It can save money and reduce dependence on utilities and government, all of which are good things.
My objection is to the authoritarian nature of dictating that people do it. This is not about health or safety.
“Authoritarian” is not a bad word when the people have freely chosen to grant that authority. In our nation we have a mechanism for people re-evaluate that authority periodically. If the exercise of that authority is not in general accord with the people granting that authority, that authority will be removed and given to someone else in due course.
 
“Authoritarian” is not a bad word when the people have freely chosen to grant that authority. In our nation we have a mechanism for people re-evaluate that authority periodically. If the exercise of that authority is not in general accord with the people granting that authority, that authority will be removed and given to someone else in due course.
Authoritarianism, once entrenched, is harder to eradicate than kudzu, Asian carp, and killer bees combined.

D
 
Last edited:
40.png
JonNC:
Don’t get me wrong, I think solar on a private home is a marvelous idea. It can save money and reduce dependence on utilities and government, all of which are good things.
My objection is to the authoritarian nature of dictating that people do it. This is not about health or safety.
“Authoritarian” is not a bad word when the people have freely chosen to grant that authority. In our nation we have a mechanism for people re-evaluate that authority periodically. If the exercise of that authority is not in general accord with the people granting that authority, that authority will be removed and given to someone else in due course.
That would be fine if that was what authoritarian meant.
ADJECTIVE
favoring complete obedience or subjection to authority as opposed to individual freedom: authoritarian principles; authoritarian attitudes.
2.
of or relating to a governmental or political system, principle, or practice in which individual freedom is held as completely subordinate to the power or authority of the state, centered either in one person or a small group that is not constitutionally accountable to the people.
3.
exercising complete or almost complete control over the will of another or of others: an authoritarian parent.

I see absolutely nothing good in that.
But as for authority, sure , and I grant that the state (as opposed to the general government) in this capacity, has authority to pass these laws, assuming the California constitution allows it. That doesn’t make it right, and it certainly represents an exercising of a strict imposition of government rule over individual freedom, which is why a refer to it as authoritarian.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
40.png
JonNC:
Don’t get me wrong, I think solar on a private home is a marvelous idea. It can save money and reduce dependence on utilities and government, all of which are good things.
My objection is to the authoritarian nature of dictating that people do it. This is not about health or safety.
“Authoritarian” is not a bad word when the people have freely chosen to grant that authority. In our nation we have a mechanism for people re-evaluate that authority periodically. If the exercise of that authority is not in general accord with the people granting that authority, that authority will be removed and given to someone else in due course.
That would be fine if that was what authoritarian meant.
ADJECTIVE
favoring complete obedience or subjection to authority as opposed to individual freedom: authoritarian principles; authoritarian attitudes.
2.
of or relating to a governmental or political system, principle, or practice in which individual freedom is held as completely subordinate to the power or authority of the state, centered either in one person or a small group that is not constitutionally accountable to the people.
3.
exercising complete or almost complete control over the will of another or of others: an authoritarian parent.

I see absolutely nothing good in that.
But as for authority, sure , and I grant that the state (as opposed to the general government) in this capacity, has authority to pass these laws, assuming the California constitution allows it. That doesn’t make it right, and it certainly represents an exercising of a strict imposition of government rule over individual freedom, which is why a refer to it as authoritarian.
In that case I disagree with your characterization of the way government is handling climate change as “authoritarian.” It is more like what you describe as “authority.”
 
In that case I disagree with your characterization of the way government is handling climate change as “authoritarian.” It is more like what you describe as “authority.”
We’ll have to disagree. With other sources of energy available, people should be free to make market decisions. There is no reason for government to dictate which type a person uses.
 
Last edited:
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
In that case I disagree with your characterization of the way government is handling climate change as “authoritarian.” It is more like what you describe as “authority.”
We’ll have to disagree. With other sources of energy available, people should be free to make market decisions. There is no reason for government to dictate which type a person uses.
There is when those decisions affect the common good, as most scientists agree they do.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
There is when those decisions affect the common good, as most scientists agree they do.
Using natural gas or electric heat has little to no environmental effect. And solar has its own environmental impacts.
For what it’s worth, on this specific question I think mandating solar on new home construction is ill-advised on purely practical grounds of cost-effectiveness. It is an appropriate question for government to decide. I just think they decided wrongly in this case.
 
Low-carbon energy transition requires more renewables than previously thought

The transition to a low-carbon energy society will require more renewable energy sources than previously thought if current levels of energy consumption per capita and lifestyles are to be maintained. This is one of the main conclusions of a study recently published in Nature Energy by Lewis King and Jeroen van den Bergh of the Institute of Science and Environmental Technology of the Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona (ICTA-UAB).

Following the Paris Agreement, several global energy transition scenarios have been presented. While these tend to be analysed in terms of gross energy, the authors of the study consider the need to calculate energy requirements by distinguishing between gross (total energy yielded) and net energy (gross energy minus the energy used to produce it). Relevant in this context is the notion of ‘Energy Return on Investment’ (EROI), which represents the amount of useful energy yielded for each unit of energy (name removed by moderator)ut in the process of obtaining that energy. The lower an energy source’s EROI, the more energy (name removed by moderator)ut is required to produce a given energy output, resulting in less net energy available for consumption. According to researchers, coal and hydroelectricity have high EROIs, while nuclear energy, oil and gas have medium EROIs, and solar and wind power are characterized by medium to low EROIs.
…
 
Last edited:
What I learnt through those who know best( not me…),
is that for alternative energy to have a real impact environmentally,has to be extended,not individual only.
To my dismay…cause I thought our small contributions counted … Not that they don t but it isn t enough.
In this sense,what Leaf is saying about authority makes sense . Someone chosen by the people has to coordinate efforts.
One may agree or not with the chosen direction,but it is elected authorities.
Personally,we are slowly replacing stuff by solar panels. Bills here have skyrocketed as well for gas and electricity,and we may start small and see how the hybrid works.
We have wind powered water for us and cattle,but this how it is here in the countryside. Not in town.
I live abroad btw
That is why I am reading this thread also.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top