Commentary: Islam was a religion of love, and the Taj Mahal proves it

  • Thread starter Thread starter CopyBoy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks. There is no right or wrong on understanding scriptural verses unless it is truly glaring.

So it is your understanding and therefore your opinion only, or rather, your interpretation.

I am interested on Islamic teaching on love because it is the point of contention of this thread. As for our personal interpretation of scriptural verses, it do not make a teaching of the religion, as there can be hundreds of different personal understanding of it.

The Quran, like other holy books, do not interpret itself, but its word can be used as teaching by those who are in authority to interpret it. Muslims have to depend on who their authorities are. They can be their imams or other religious scholars or even themselves. That is why there are different interpretation.

ISIS have their own teaching from the same Quran while other sects have their own respectively.
Islam does not have a formal hierarchy or clergy. Leaders are informal, and gain influence through study to become a scholar of Islamic law, called sharia. Anyone with the intelligence and will can become an Islamic scholar. During Midday Mosque services on Fridays, the congregation will choose a well educated person to lead the service, known as an imam (one who leads)
 
I have witnessed Mass Martin.

You didn’t ask for what else.

What exactly are you looking for and I will endeavour to answer your question to the best of my ability.

.
When you claimed that the Church fathers using a verse has nothing to do with the Mass which is a Liturgy, is why I ask you. What is it that you’ve learned it to be? Is it just mere words to make a point? Or something much deeper?

MJ
 
No :confused::confused:

I said “you guys”

Why will you not share your understanding of the scripture when asked Jimmy?

It seems silly…

.
No Servant…you said “are you guys in a secret cult” What’s the “cult” you’re referring to? Is it because Martin and I are Christian …and I said if you followed Jesus and Scripture you’d know. I’ve given you the answer to your question…and its in Scripture if you choose to look for it and believe what Jesus says
 
Dear Reuben

Isn’t God all about love?

.
That is why I would want to know Islam’s teaching on God, on love.

If you ask me, as a Christian, I will tell you that God is love (1 John 4:8). This is Christian teaching, you see. But I do not know Islam’s teaching on it. All that you did, perhaps trying to tell me Islam’s teaching on this subject, was to quote to me some Quran verses, and then you gave me your understanding on them. And then, I have my own understanding on those verses.
40.png
Servant19:
May He grant it on all!
That is a prayer, asking God to grant all of us love. Good. Therefore I would take it as far as love is concerned, one needs to ask God to grant it on us. So is this Islam’s teaching on love, no?
 
That is why I would want to know Islam’s teaching on God, on love.

If you ask me, as a Christian, I will tell you that God is love (1 John 4:8). This is Christian teaching, you see. But I do not know Islam’s teaching on it. All that you did, perhaps trying to tell me Islam’s teaching on this subject, was to quote to me some Quran verses, and then you gave me your understanding on them. And then, I have my own understanding on those verses.
Hi Reuben,

If you look at the nature of God in Islam, the primary nature that is emphasized is the first sentence in each and every Surih of the Quran. The nature of God is termed the “names” or “attributes” of God

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Names_of_God_in_Islam

The first name of God listed is Ar-Rahman meaning “The Exceedingly Compassionate, The Exceedingly Beneficent, The Exceedingly Gracious (to all of humanity and all creatures)

If you are looking specifically for a loving God (using the word LOVE) then name number 47 (listed in that link, in no particular order) is The Loving.

Allah’s nature embraces all these attributes in that link 🙂
That is a prayer, asking God to grant all of us love. Good. Therefore I would take it as far as love is concerned, one needs to ask God to grant it on us. So is this Islam’s teaching on love, no?
Indeed it is a prayer.

The quotes I provided above state that it is to be the prayer of all Muslims to wish God would grant that love onto all Muslims.

You, yourself noted this, when you said “From how I see it, 60:7 says that Allah may grant love and friendship (I am depending on your given translation) between a person and his enemy so that there will be forgiveness.”

🙂

.
 
No Servant…you said “are you guys in a secret cult”
Yes, meaning you and Martin, since he said “Exactly” to your posts. You were joining ranks in this plan of telling me that I don’t follow scripture, but refusing to say how …
What’s the “cult” you’re referring to?
It is called the “Martin and Jimmy cult against telling Servant19 where he is being unscriptural” 😃
Is it because Martin and I are Christian
No 😦

Otherwise I wouldn’t be posting to Reuben and Jeffrey with such high regard in this thread, and so many other Catholics here at CAF 🙂
…and I said if you followed Jesus and Scripture you’d know. I’ve given you the answer to your question…and its in Scripture if you choose to look for it and believe what Jesus says
And I asked you to please help me, as an act of charity, towards where in scripture it tells me who the other “folds” are that Jesus was referring to?

.
 
Yes, meaning you and Martin, since he said “Exactly” to your posts. You were joining ranks in this plan of telling me that I don’t follow scripture, but refusing to say how …
Actually we are two different people individuals. I would suggest you consider charity to us and give us the benefit of the doubt because I trust he’s a practicing Catholic as I am. There is no conspiracy here. Don’t accuse like this Servant.

The trouble is to me if one quotes a verse out of the blue, one has to explain it thoroughly why the verse is being used because it should not be in isolation. So explain why you quote it.
It is called the “Martin and Jimmy cult against telling Servant19 where he is being unscriptural”😃
? :Hmmm:
Otherwise I wouldn’t be posting to Reuben and Jeffrey with such high regard in this thread, and so many other Catholics here at CAF 🙂
Explain this statement. Can you clarify?
And I asked you to please help me, as an act of charity, towards where in scripture it tells me who the other “folds” are that Jesus was referring to?
How do you not understand this “other fold”. You SHOULD know the answer by following the Scripture in order to the point when Jesus says it.

MJ
 
Hi Reuben,

If you look at the nature of God in Islam, the primary nature that is emphasized is the first sentence in each and every Surih of the Quran. The nature of God is termed the “names” or “attributes” of God

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Names_of_God_in_Islam

The first name of God listed is Ar-Rahman meaning “The Exceedingly Compassionate, The Exceedingly Beneficent, The Exceedingly Gracious (to all of humanity and all creatures)

If you are looking specifically for a loving God (using the word LOVE) then name number 47 (listed in that link, in no particular order) is The Loving.

Allah’s nature embraces all these attributes in that link 🙂
Ok. A good try. I agree with the 99 attributes of Allah.

How does Allah love?

And how does this apply to the topic of the thread?

Edit: Servant, I hope you don’t mind, can you define Islam understanding of love?

Servant19 said:
]

Indeed it is a prayer.

The quotes I provided above state that it is to be the prayer of all Muslims to wish God would grant that love onto all Muslims.

You, yourself noted this, when you said “From how I see it, 60:7 says that Allah may grant love and friendship (I am depending on your given translation) between a person and his enemy so that there will be forgiveness.”

🙂

.

Seems quite elitist to me.
 
Ok. A good try. I agree with the 99 attributes of Allah.

How does Allah love?

And how does this apply to the topic of the thread?

Edit: Servant, I hope you don’t mind, can you define Islam understanding of love?
Allah manifests His love through His mercy, His justice and His forgiveness.

He shows His love through His Word which is recorded in the Holy Quran for the salvation of man.

He shows His love by guiding humanity towards His loving embrace and the Path of righteousness and humility.
Seems quite elitist to me.
What is elitist? Asking God to bestow love in your heart so that you may love your enemies?

.
 
Actually we are two different people individuals. I would suggest you consider charity to us and give us the benefit of the doubt because I trust he’s a practicing Catholic as I am. There is no conspiracy here. Don’t accuse like this Servant.

The trouble is to me if one quotes a verse out of the blue, one has to explain it thoroughly why the verse is being used because it should not be in isolation. So explain why you quote it.

? :Hmmm:

Explain this statement. Can you clarify?

How do you not understand this “other fold”. You SHOULD know the answer by following the Scripture in order to the point when Jesus says it.

MJ
Lighten up sunshine, it was a joke hinting that you and Jimmy should show more charity towards those asking sincere questions. 🙂
The “LOL” I put in my post should have been sufficient…

But either way, I shared the verse from the Bible because of the lack of charity shown towards Muslims (who are from another fold) in this thread. Indicating that the love of Allah is not as profound as the love of Jesus is uncharitable and frankly, quite childish.

I do understand what the verse means but I was told that my understanding was incorrect.
If no-one wishes to correct me then I will simply spread this “incorrect” interpretation as far and wide as I can.

Please advise when you have an answer as to which “other folds” Jesus is referring to?
And also why their Beloved is often referred to as a “man in sheeps clothing by underneath is a ravenous wolf”?

.
 
Lighten up sunshine, it was a joke hinting that you and Jimmy should show more charity towards those asking sincere questions. 🙂
The “LOL” I put in my post should have been sufficient…

But either way, I shared the verse from the Bible because of the lack of charity shown towards Muslims (who are from another fold) in this thread. Indicating that the love of Allah is not as profound as the love of Jesus is uncharitable and frankly, quite childish.

I do understand what the verse means but I was told that my understanding was incorrect.
If no-one wishes to correct me then I will simply spread this “incorrect” interpretation as far and wide as I can.

Please advise when you have an answer as to which “other folds” Jesus is referring to?
And also why their Beloved is often referred to as a “man in sheeps clothing by underneath is a ravenous wolf”?

.
The other folds Jesus refers to are not Muslims. Therefore you don’t know.

MJ
 
Servant said Muslims. He’s wrong. So are you willing to learn?

MJ
Always willing to learn Martin, but I do not think Servant is wrong, he has a different Frame of reference than you are using.

I would add all the other Religious Folds as well. In fact I would add all that did not accept Christ as in the end there will be One Fold One Shepherd.

Regards Tony
 
Always willing to learn Martin, but I do not think Servant is wrong, he has a different Frame of reference than you are using.

I would add all the other Religious Folds as well. In fact I would add all that did not accept Christ as in the end there will be One Fold One Shepherd.

Regards Tony
He’s using the SAME words Jesus said. There is no such thing as different frame of reference when exegesis is used.

MJ
 
Very often, deceived by the Evil One, men have become vain in their reasonings, and have exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and served the creature rather than the Creator. Or else, living and dying in this world without God, they are exposed to ultimate despair.
 
Servant said Muslims. He’s wrong. So are you willing to learn?

MJ
Yes please. Teach me so that I cannot question the truth that you utter.
If I question, it is for a sincere quest to understand.
If I understand not, please refrain from condescending and patronising remarks.

Behind these words is a human heart.

.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top