Conservative Episcopalians

  • Thread starter Thread starter BrushedByAngels
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BrushedByAngels

Guest
For those of you that are conservative, and knowing the current state of the EC, have you any thoughts of leaving your religion or do you love your church and willing to stay through the changes?

Looking forward to hearing your comments as I have family members in the Episcopal Church as well.

Thanks!
 
I left the Episcopal Church about 8 years ago and was extremely gratified in doing so. But I did go back to the parish I left after they went ACNA but didn’t stay because I’m too Catholic…

I do have two dear friends here at CAF who are remaining in their Episcopal parishes because they are very conservative. One of my friends feels the Episcopal parish he’s in is more devout, conservative, and orthodox than the ACNA parish in his town. This can happen. Sometimes even Catholic parishes can be liberal and off-kilter. I’ve visited one of those!

I pray for our Episcopal brethren, that they can get back on course to traditional morality and orthodoxy of doctrine. There still are a lot of good folks in the denomination who are true to their roots and the historic church.
For those of you that are conservative, and knowing the current state of the EC, have you any thoughts of leaving your religion or do you love your church and willing to stay through the changes?

Looking forward to hearing your comments as I have family members in the Episcopal Church as well.

Thanks!
 
I left the Episcopal Church about 8 years ago and was extremely gratified in doing so. But I did go back to the parish I left after they went ACNA but didn’t stay because I’m too Catholic…

I do have two dear friends here at CAF who are remaining in their Episcopal parishes because they are very conservative. One of my friends feels the Episcopal parish he’s in is more devout, conservative, and orthodox than the ACNA parish in his town. This can happen. Sometimes even Catholic parishes can be liberal and off-kilter. I’ve visited one of those!

I pray for our Episcopal brethren, that they can get back on course to traditional morality and orthodoxy of doctrine. There still are a lot of good folks in the denomination who are true to their roots and the historic church.
I should have clarified EC in the USA … a few of my family members stay because they say they do not care if there are actively homosexual clergy – they are there to worship the Lord not care what everyone else is doing.
 
But that argument could be used with anything. My wife and I aren’t having abortions but I sure care about the unborn child killed by others, etc. I’m not impacted by war like Iraq and Afghanistan, but just war theories matter. I think they need to re-examine their priorities…
I should have clarified EC in the USA … a few of my family members stay because they say they do not care if there are actively homosexual clergy – they are there to worship the Lord not care what everyone else is doing.
 
Somehow I never thought that I would consider myself “conservative”, but I suppose that is where I am right now.

I am doing a lot of thinking about the ordinariate. I am inclined toward it, but of course I am not Catholic yet. I hope the ordinariate will prove to be more than a haven for wandering Anglicans. I hope it will serve as a bridge toward greater unity among Christians.

But I have to jump over a few issues that frankly are troubling me.

These are the usual non-Catholic issues, such as the Papacy and the divine bureaucracy in Rome, the Marian doctrines (I really don’t have a problem with them, but I frankly need to understand them better). I am put off by the idea that I have to assent to the nullity of Anglican orders. I don’t like that one bit.

AND FINALLY… why do Catholics always say Aymen instead of Amen. There aren’t any Catholic scholars telling us that Ay-men is the proper pronunciation, are there?
 
I should have clarified EC in the USA … a few of my family members stay because they say they do not care if there are actively homosexual clergy – they are there to worship the Lord not care what everyone else is doing.
Active gay clergy as a reason to leave TEC has always been a puzzle to me. There could be closeted gay clergy in the Catholic Church engaged in homosexual relationships. The only difference in that case would be they are keeping it a secret.
 
Dude, just ONE?!? You are one blest man! 😉
Other than a Lifeteen Mass here and there I wish I could find just one. But for me to find such a place I would have to go to TEC. 🙂 My local Episcopal churches have a variety of services. Ranging from their more traditional Rite 1 and 2. To acoustic guitar which reminds me of the days of Catholic guitar Masses. Except the Episcopalians gather around the altar and pass Communion to each other at their guitar service. To one having a jazz service in their fellowship hall. To the other having a Christian rock band performing at their later Sun morning service. Come as you are they say. Jeans, shorts, and flip flops welcomed. Even at the guitar and jazz services, shorts are welcomed. As one of their rectors told me, no one cares what is on the outside, it’s what is on the inside is that matters.
 
I left the Episcopal Church about 8 years ago and was extremely gratified in doing so. But I did go back to the parish I left after they went ACNA but didn’t stay because I’m too Catholic…

I do have two dear friends here at CAF who are remaining in their Episcopal parishes because they are very conservative. One of my friends feels the Episcopal parish he’s in is more devout, conservative, and orthodox than the ACNA parish in his town. This can happen. Sometimes even Catholic parishes can be liberal and off-kilter. I’ve visited one of those!

I pray for our Episcopal brethren, that they can get back on course to traditional morality and orthodoxy of doctrine. There still are a lot of good folks in the denomination who are true to their roots and the historic church.
And then there are orthodox, traditonalist Anglicans who are not part of the Episcopal Church, or in communion with Canterbury, at all. All sorts of Anglicans around.

GKC

posterus traditus Anglicanus
 
AND FINALLY… why do Catholics always say Aymen instead of Amen. There aren’t any Catholic scholars telling us that Ay-men is the proper pronunciation, are there?
I think when this came up some time ago, we concluded that it was in parishes with a strong Irish background. It certainly isn’t universal.
 
For those of you that are conservative, and knowing the current state of the EC, have you any thoughts of leaving your religion or do you love your church and willing to stay through the changes?

Looking forward to hearing your comments as I have family members in the Episcopal Church as well.

Thanks!
I converted from the EC to the CC in 1992. Never looked back. Have fond memories of my parish growing up, but bcame convinced of the shipwreck that is the EC and the Truth that is the CC.
 
For those of you that are conservative, and knowing the current state of the EC, have you any thoughts of leaving your religion or do you love your church and willing to stay through the changes?

Looking forward to hearing your comments as I have family members in the Episcopal Church as well.

Thanks!
I guess I’m more of a moderate by Episcopalian standards, but no, I’m not leaving. I was born here, and while I’m not happy with our current leadership, they’re not getting rid of me so easily.
 
Very conservative Episcopalian here. I have stayed in TEC because my parish has been faithful and traditional (and is big enough/young enough to sustain itself for the foreseeable future). Twice I’ve tried to at least investigate joining the Catholic Church, but weird work schedules that included lots of travel have made it impossible thus far. 😦 I wish I could just “be Catholic” since I’m with you guys on nearly everything (especially the Sacraments and the importance of the Pope), but the length and awkward meeting times of RCIA have proved impossible thus far. I’ve tried all the “talk to them and see if they’ll work with ya” stuff; no luck yet.

ACNA doesn’t have much of a presence in my state, and the few who are here are basically non-denominational rock concerts with robes. They’re not me. I have little hope that TEC will ever improve. Everything seems like Rome is the way to go; but whenever I’ve visited a Mass, it seems like something has happened to discourage me.

I’m sticking it out through the summer and praying for guidance. I love my parish and the priests there. It’s HARD to make a change this big by yourself when friends and family oppose it. It’s equally hard to feel powerful reverence & devotion in worship at my home church, only to face the “hand-holding folk mass” crew when I visit certain places. 😦 It’s also increasingly hard to read the Church Fathers and tell myself “they were just wrong about the Pope and the Catholic Church.” Pretty sure they were right about far more than I am.

Sigh.
 
Well, naturally, but we’re talking about the Episcopal Church. It’s a given that continuing Anglicans, etc. are more old-school and orthodox…
And then there are orthodox, traditonalist Anglicans who are not part of the Episcopal Church, or in communion with Canterbury, at all. All sorts of Anglicans around.

GKC

posterus traditus Anglicanus
 
Hey, who keeps your cliches and Jimisms alive with the most vigor in this forum?

History is complicated, motley crew, depends on which Anglicans you ask, a lifelong hobby of mine, decree of nullity not a divorce (!!), huh?, oh my, uh-huh, yep, and the like…:o:D
I just like to be remembered.

GKC
 
Active gay clergy as a reason to leave TEC has always been a puzzle to me. There could be closeted gay clergy in the Catholic Church engaged in homosexual relationships. The only difference in that case would be they are keeping it a secret.
Exactly. Thats always the argument in my family. We can always tell when the religion argument is on its way. Unfortunately, its usually at a Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner.:rolleyes: … “whats worse actively gay clergy or priests raping little boys?” that always sends me over the edge.
 
Hey, who keeps your cliches and Jimisms alive with the most vigor in this forum?

History is complicated, motley crew, depends on which Anglicans you ask, a lifelong hobby of mine, decree of nullity not a divorce (!!), huh?, oh my, uh-huh, yep, and the like…:o:D
Again, well done, grasshopper.

GKC
 
… I wish I could just “be Catholic” since I’m with you guys on nearly everything (especially the Sacraments and the importance of the Pope), but the length and awkward meeting times of RCIA have proved impossible thus far. I’ve tried all the “talk to them and see if they’ll work with ya” stuff; no luck yet.

… Everything seems like Rome is the way to go; but whenever I’ve visited a Mass, it seems like something has happened to discourage me.

The trick to comprehending catholicism from the outside is to recognize that the facts don’t always line up with your feelings - just like many other things in life. I don’t WANT to eat broccoli with dinner instead of potato chips, but it’s actually better for me… An awful lot of catholic parishes don’t FEEL like very special places, even during the miracle of the mass. But frankly, that’s precisely WHY we need more good, solid converts! Make your faith decisions based on what facts you’ve come to know to be true, not how you feel after you decide. Come on back, stick out the discouraging times and wind up being a leader. The harvest is plenty, but so are the weeds!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top