I believe that, for practicing Catholics, Romney was the only one we could have voted for had one decided to vote. Now, it is true that both Romney and Obama supported the intrinsic evil of abortion to varying degrees, but I have not heard a convincing case made that Obama would have done more than Romney to limit the intrinsic evil of abortion. In fact, the Democrat Party now actively supports as part of its platform two sins that cry to Heaven for vengeance: abortion on demand and homosexual marriage.
I believe the U.S. Bishops should have come right out and said, by name, which of the two candidates would have done the most to limit the intrinsic evil of abortion (doing so would not have been a case of the Bishops campaigning but rather a case of them concretely applying the Truth to a specific moral dilemna). Instead, their statements left the resolution of this dilemna up to the subjective judgement of individual consciences.
Now, as to the future of the Republican Party, I think Pat Buchanan (who endorsed Mitt Romney by the way) just took a cold, hard look at the future in latest article “Is the GOP Headed for the Boneyard?” (
buchanan.org/blog/is-the-gop-headed-for-the-boneyard-5347).
Now, as to your mention of the economy and Mitt Romney, I don’t think even a Mitt Romney win would have done anything in that regard. As Ron Paul recently said (
rt.com/usa/news/paul-fiscal-cliff-obama-364/):
“We’re so far gone. We’re over the cliff. We cannot get enough people in Congress in the next 5 to 10 years who will do the wise things. We have to prepare for having already fallen off the fiscal cliff."
“They’re just looking for the truth,” said the congressman. “They say, ‘Well, all we need is a little compromise.’ Well nobody expects that because they do not admit the truth, and the truth is that we are broke. How do you compromise? The only way you can compromise is if you agree on what to cut. People do not want anything cut. They want all the bailouts to come. They want the Fed to keep printing money. They do not believe we have gone off the cliff or are close to going off the cliff.”
I believe that there are really a few things keeping the U.S. economy afloat right now in spite of our obscene debt: the fact that we can print money out of thin air, the fact that the Dollar is the world reserve curreny, and the fact that our endless “war on terror” has kept at least one sector of the economy growing. But that may all be about to change and even Obama might not be able to stop what comes next.